Chapter Text
Months had passed as I slowly began to sink back into my usual life. A good portion of my memories returned and while I still had the occasional memory popping in here and there, it wasn’t as much a problem as it used to be. I fell back into my old ways with everyone and it became more common for us to hang out together, rather than just hide with Marco and Historia.
Armin and I’s relationship progressed pretty quickly at the beginning, skipping many of the stages first time couples had. Instead, falling back into how we acted in our past lives. Well, minus a few certain things.
I was currently sitting in my room watching a movie with my cute blond boyfriend. We had the entire house to ourselves, my parents deciding it was a wise decision to leave us alone for the weekend. I was laying on my stomach, spread out on my bed. Armin was laying the opposite way, sitting up right. He currently had my foot in his hand, massaging it for me. His wonderful handiwork making every moment of it total bliss.
I was too busy paying attention to the movie playing to care what Armin was doing behind me. I could faintly feel movement behind me, but I ignored it. Well, I ignored it up until Armin flipped me over and pinned me under him. I stared up at him with wide eyes, my focus entirely on him now.
He was looking down at me with a smirk on his face. He leaned down and started planting kisses on my neck, leaving nips in between kisses. I let out soft, breathless moans, which made Armin chuckle as he continued to kiss me. He caught me off guard by biting my neck, then beginning to suck. It hurt so much but felt so good at the same time, I was squirmin under him, more soft moans dripping from my mouth.
Armin pulled away after he felt he had done a good enough job on the hickey. He stared down at it, wiping his saliva from my neck. As he pushed pressure on to it, I pulled away, feeling the pain of it. Armin’s eyes were locked on my form, admiring how I looked all flustered for him.
“You look good marked up like that. Maybe I should leave some more.” His voice said, dripping with dominance.
My eyes were hazy with lust as I stared back at him, all I wanted was to feel his hands on my body. I wanted him to keep touching me, but he was just staring down at me. He knew exactly what I wanted but was makin me wait for it.
Armin moved from pinning me under him to sitting up on the bed. He began trailing his fingers lightly down my torso, strategically moving between my breast down my stomach to just above my core. I bucked my hips up in anticipation, wanting nothin more than to feel some kind of pressure.
Even though this was the first time we were having sex in our new lives, I had been reliving our past conquests for months now and I found myself more than ready to submit to him again. I found myself yearning for him ever since I had fully accepted my memories and the past couple months of playing it safe while having been amazing, had made you more than just needy for this kind of action,
It felt as if the two of you had been doing this sort of thing for months now. As if we both weren’t complete virgins now. But enough monlouging, let’s get back to the action.
Armin kept his hands just above my core, rubbing circles right above it. I was staring into his blue eyes pleading with him to do something more, letting out a little whimper here and there. He just shot another smirk my way and slowly moved his fingers onto my clothes core, but his touches were faint. It felt as if he was as light as a feather with his touches, neglecting to give me the pressure I seeked.
“Babe, please. I need more.” I whined out, my face turning red in embarrassment for having to beg.
“What do you need more of?” His demandin voice asked, as he trailed even more feather like touches.
“Touch me h-harder.” It was embarrassing having to admit what I wanted, but I recalled our past lives sexcapades and how much he loved when I did.
Almost immediately I felt Armin press his fingers harder against me, rubbing them up and down my pussy. I couldn’t help but grind back against his hand, excited to finally get what I needed. However, the clothing that separated his fingers from my core was starting to irritate me, with holding some of that pressure I wanted.
I reached down and grabbed hold of his hand, guiding it away from my core and to the top of my shorts, pushing the tips of his fingers under the band. He knew exactly what I wanted and didn’t waste time stripping the article of clothing off of me. I was left in just my panties, which were becoming more damp by the second, and my shirt. Armin decided not to stop with the shorts, reaching his hands to my shirt and pulling it over my head. The coldness from the room caused me to shiver a bit.
Armin was staring down at me again, trailing both his hands down the curve of my body, before stopping at my hip and gripping it. He pulled my body close to his, wrapping my legs around his torso so my pussy was against his hardened dick. He leaned himself down over me, capturing my lips in a heated kiss. His hands continued to wander over my body, poking and prodding different areas. We were grinding both out cores against each other, searching for the friction we both needed.
It was all so much, I was unable to hold back my moans, which were soft and muffled by Armins mouth on mine. I tangled my hands into his blond locks, tugging at it when he ground his hips harsher than usual into me.
The room was getting much hotter, making it nearly unbearable for us. Armin pulled away from me, pulling his shirt off and beginning to unbutton his jeans. He didn’t pull them off just yet, knowing how badly I wanted them off already. I sat up a bit, staring longingly at his jeans, hoping my not so subtle clue got to him. Armin just laughed me off, teasingly palming his length through his jeans.
“If you want it, come and get it.” He teased.
I felt my face grow flushed at his demand, but nonetheless crawled over to him. I tugged his jeans off and discarded the off the edge of the bed. As I stared down at his erection, noticing the way the precum marked his briefs, I started to feel nervous. Up until this moment I had felt as if this was normal, like I had done it many times before. Sure, in my past life I had done this with Armin, but now? I hadn’t even been with another man. The thought of seeing a penis was making me nervous.
Armin obviously noticed my nervousness, his face softened and he moved closer to me. “Are you okay? We don’t have to do this if you aren’t comfortable.” He worried, his soft voice breaking me from my thoughts.
“I… um…” I cast my gaze onto his face, finding comfort in his blue eyes. “I’m just kind of nervous. This is my first time doing something like this…“ I trailed off, awkwardly covering my chest up.
“Oh.” Armins soft voice said, taken slightly aback by my admission.
“H-Have you done this with anybody else?”
Armins face went red at my question, his eyes widening in shock. He didn’t respond, making me prod him even further.
“A-Armin, have you?” I realized how rude my question may have come out, immediately waving my hands in front of me. “I won’t be angry if you have, I-I’m just curious.” My words awkwardly stumbled out, my facing heat in up in embarrassment.
“I…um… kinda…” he mumbled, avoiding eye contact with me.
My jaw dropped a bit, surprised to here that my cute armin had sex in this life.
“Y-You aren’t angry with me are you?” Armin worries, my silence making him nervous.
“No!!” I exclaimed, a little to loud. “I’m just surprised. I didn’t expect you to have…” Armin released a sigh of relief, glad he hadn’t upset me in any way.
“Do you feel comfortable doing this then? We can stop if you want to.”
I shook my head vehemently, protesting the idea of stopping. “No, I want to keep going!! Just let me collect my thoughts for a minute.” Armin nodded his head, placing a hand on my thigh.
I took some deep breaths, building up my courage to keep going. After a minute I was fine, letting Armin know by dropping my arms from my chest and run my hand down his chest. He immediately got right back into it, shimmying out of his briefs and freeing his cock from its cage.
It sprung up quickly, precum smeared from the tip. His cock had gone limp ever so slightly, but as I brought a hand to touch it it grew harder under my touch. His cock was just as I had remembered, he was just above average and curved ever so slightly. Oh that curve, I remembered just how well that curve hit just the right spots inside me.
I rubbed my thumb over he blunt tip of it, spreading the precum over it. I brought my hand to the base, stroking it for a second to test the waters. Armin released a strangled breath, finding the friction to be amazing. I took this as a sign to continue, stroking it slowly. After a few seconds, armin swatted my hand away, catching me by surprise.
He pushed me back onto the bed, he reached his hand to my panties, pulling them off of my body. His hands forced my legs open, giving him an up close view of my pussy.
He suddenly brought to fingers to my mouth, waiting for me to open it. I didn’t quite catch the memo and awkwardly stared back at him, raising one of my eyebrows at him.
“Suck on them for me, I want you to get them nice and wet for me.” He demanded. I slowly nodded my head, opening my mouth wide for him and sticking my tongue out. He slide them inside, letting me suck on them till they were what he felt was good enough.
He pulled them and brought them to my pussy. He spread my lower lips open, sticking his forefinger into me. I tensed up as he slide it in, squirming under him. Armin soothingly rubbed my thigh with his other hand, helping me to calm down. Once he had fully pushed it in it took a few seconds for me to feel comfortable enough for him to continue.
I bucked my hips upward, letting out a whine as a sign for him to continue. He took the hint and began moving his finger in and out, starting off slow before speedin up. I let out soft moans, chanting Armins name as if it was a prayer. Armin stopped his movements and pulled his finger out, before shoving it back in, however this time with a second finger added. I let out a loud moan, feeling the pressure of being stretched both enjoyable and painful. However, the pain subsided quickly as he picked up his pace. I bucked my hips up to meet his pumps, enjoying the way his fingers prepped my pussy for him.
He felt that I was more than ready after another minute of fingering, pulling his fingers out of me and wiping them on my bed. I laid on the bed, my heavy breathing and hazy eyes makin me feel like a mess at the moment. I felt armin tap my thigh, making me look up at him weakly.
“Flip over. Hands and knees.” His orders were short and sweet, but I could feel my pussy clench in need.
I did exactly as he wanted, presenting myself to him. He fumbled around for a few seconds behind me, pulling his bag from off the ground. I watched from the side, observing what he was doing. I noticed him pull out a condom and lube from his bag, before dropping it to the ground again. Before he had a chance to open the small packet I stopped him.
“W-Wait, you don’t have to. I’m on the pill.” I stuttered out.
Armins face flushed a soft pink, but threw the condom on the ground. He opened the bottle of lube, pouring a small amount on his hand before slathering it around my hole. I shuddered at the coldness of it, moving away from his hand instinctively. Armin couldn’t help but snicker at the sight. He poured more of the lube onto his hand and rubbed it over his length, stroking it while he did.
I moaned at the sight, wanting nothing more than to have him in me already. Luckily I didn’t need to wait much longer. He placed both of his hands onto my hips, aligning his cock with my pussy. I tensed for a moment when I felt his blunt tip press against me. Armin removed one of his hands from my hips and used it t help himself push into me. He slid into me slowly, taking his time as to not hurt me.
I clenched my eyes closed, everything inside me tensing as he slid in. The uncomfortable burn inside of me causing me to whimper out in pain.
Armin used his other hand on my hip to rub soft circles into it. His soft voice behind me attempted to get me to calm down. “Come on, babe. Just a little further and it’ll be in. Just relax for me, baby.”
I nodded my head vehemently, trying to take my mind off of the pain. I began untensing my entire body for him, arching my back as I relaxed. As he finished pushing the last of his dick into me, I let out a relieved moan as I adjusted to his size. I could feel him pulsating inside me, the grip on my hips he had was tight as he became overwhelmed with my initial tightness. We both sat there, taking a few seconds for us both to become comfortable.
“Armin… please, move.” I begged.
I didn’t get a response from him, only the feeling of him rocking back before pushing himself right back into me. My hands reached out to grab the blanket on the bed, needing something to hold onto as Armin continued his thrusts. It didn’t take long for him to start pounding into me, causing my moans to increase in volume as I got closer to my end.
I heard him release his own moans as he continued, his ragged breathing and deep moans making me feel ten times better. In the spur of the moment, I decided to push myself back onto his cock, meeting his thrust perfectly. Both of us released loud moans, with armin cursing under his breath. I continued to do this, becoming overcome with pleasure. My thrusts became erratic not soon after, as my end came closer than I anticipated. Armin senses this and ceased my thrusts, stopping my hips from moving.
I was moaning wantonly, not caring how loud I was. Then I felt it. Armin thrust his cock deep in me, hitting that one spot in me that made me see stars. I clenched tightly around him, my moan cracking from pleasure. He knew immediately what he had done and continued to pound that spot, making me drool as I was overwhelmed by the feeling.
“You like that? Tell me how much you love this.” Armins raspy voice spoke. The low tone of it sending another wave of pleasure through me.
I lifted my face from the mattress, attempting to form a coherent sentence while Armin continued. “Soooo… good, feels am-AHHzing. Ahh, armin.” Not the most clear sentence, but it got the point across.
Armin must’ve liked the response he got, forcing my hips back onto his cock to meet his thrusts. I was seeing white as I found myself close to reaching my end. Armin must’ve sensed this and began thrusting even faster into me.
He hit that special spot in me again, pushing me over the edge. I cried out in pleasure, my climax making my entire body tingle all over. It took a couple seconds for me to come down from my high, calling face down onto the mattress. Armin slide his length out of me, tapping me on my ass. I grunted in response, weak and tired from my orgasm.
“Oh come on, we aren’t done yet. Onto your back now, sweetheart.”
I nodded my head slowly, moving my body around so I was facing him. My face was flushed red as I was panting out, still recovering. I saw Armin kneeling over me, jerking his dick off as he stared down at me. My cum and the lube still present on it making it easier for him to stroke himself. Armin moved his body to be close to mine, straddling my hips.
He used his free hand to move some of my hair out of my face, stroking my cheek afterwards. I smiled softly up at him, enjoying watching him get off.
“Now, when I say so, I want you to close your eyes for me. I don’t want any of this to get in there.” I nodded my head, understanding what he wanted.
Armin leaned down and caught my lips in his, our messy lip lock helping further him to his end. It didn’t take long for him to reach his end after that. Pulling away from me, armin instructed me to close my eyes which I did immediately, afraid of the burnin pain if I didn’t.
Even though I couldn’t see it, I felt wet hot streams of his cum hit my face. Armin releasing a strangled breath as he hit his climax. I stayed there for a bit, afraid to get cum in my eye. I waited till Armin calmed down, feeling his finger swiping cum off my eyelids so I could see. Slowly I opened my eyes, staring up into Armins bright blue ones.
He smiled down at me softly, which I happily returned. It was obvious both of us felt tired, but the feeling of our now sweaty body combined with my now cum soaked face made me want to shower as soon as possible.
I pulled him down, pressing a tender kiss against his lips. “Why don’t we get cleaned up now?” I asked, my voice weak from our previous activities.
Armin, moving his now messy hair from his face, chuckled at my request, nodding his head in agreement. “That sounds really nice right now actually.”
He helped me to my feet, leading my tired form out of my room and down the hall, into my parents master bedroom and into their huge bathroom. He knew exactly what I wanted.
Armin sat me on the toilet seat, using a towel to wipe the rest of his semen from my face. He gave me a minute to myself as I used the toilet, getting all the bacteria and shit out of me. After I finished he kindly prepared the bathtub for us, waiting for the water to heat up before letting me slide in. He slid behind me, leaning my body against his as the water from the tub surrounded us. I leaned my head against his shoulder, curling up against his form as I relaxed. He pressed a kiss to the temple of my eye before helping me get cleaned off.
As I laid in his arms, I swore I had died and gone to heaven at some point, feeling more comfortable in his arms than anywhere else. I looked up into his eyes and pressed a quick kiss to his cheek.
“I love you so much, Armin. I’m so glad I’m with you again.” I told him sweetly, staring into his eyes lovingly.
Armin smiled down at me, running his finngers through my hair.
“I love you too, (Y/n). I promise I won’t ever let you go again.”