Work Text:
Lucy was a smart girl, but quiet even though she was super popular with everyone except the football star named Natsu. For some reason they hated each other. One day in class, before Professor Makarov came in the room, Natsu took Lucy's lucky pen (necklace, bracelet, something her mom gave her.) the blackmailed her into being his pretend girlfriend. She had to say yes because what was stolen meant a lot to her. It was the last gift from her mom she ever got. Her dad was a butthole to her as well.
At first everything was meh, but then Lucy and Natsu developed real feelings while going on fake dates. Natsu then asked her to the Enchantment Under The Sea dance that the school had (because all cliche high school stories need Enchantment Under the Sea!) and she said yes, because she thought Natsu was still an unfeeling jerk who had custody of her pen/bracelet/necklace/whatever. During the slow dance, Natsu confessed he actually did like her, like, a lot. He gave her back her thing and she blushed and they kissed and became the high school 'it couple' for the rest of their lives. They got married, had three kids, and died of old age. Wow, this is much shorter than my last one. Let me add some stuff.
"Omg! Natsu and Lucy are super cute together, right?" Levy said to Erza and Wendy when they saw the two kiss.
"Extremely," Erza agreed.
"Adorable!" Wendy added.
Jellal then walked over and asked Erza for a dance, which she blushed as red as her hair and agreed. Gajeel kinda just grabbed Levy and dragged her to the dance floor. Romeo brought Wendy some punch and they talked. All the while, Juvia and Gray were in Gray's Maserati getting it on. But only because Juvia got him a tad too drunk on her father's booze stash. Otherwise he wouldn't be doing that stuff with her because Gray is a gentleman and would never do that to a lady. Maybe accidentally grope her boobs, but again. Accidentally.