Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of A Different Fate
Collections:
Collections
Stats:
Published:
2018-06-23
Completed:
2018-07-24
Words:
107,781
Chapters:
50/50
Comments:
79
Kudos:
268
Bookmarks:
75
Hits:
13,846

In Sunshine or Shadow

Summary:

What if Harry and his friends had never gone to the Department of Mysteries in The Order of the Phoenix? Perhaps things would have turned out a bit differently. This is the story of what might have happened if Harry had taken a different course of action.

Notes:

***Notes from 2024***

How's it going, everyone? Just wanted to say a few things about this very old story before you start reading it. I wrote it between 8 and 10 years ago, when I was still developing my skill as a writer and published it on fanfiction.net. Some of my readers have followed me from over there, but not for this story (as far as I know).

I had very different opinions about various Harry Potter characters and the world in general. Basically, this story is unpolished and I no longer like the plot. I don't like the way I wrote characters or even my OCs. If I wrote a Fix-It Sirius Survives set in Year 5 (the premise of this story) today, it would be VERY different. I understand the mixed reviews.

Many fic writers have gone back and rewritten parts or all of their early works and WIPs. But if I rewrote A Different Fate, I would change so much that the only thing it would have in common with the first version is the premise. I can't even promise the pairings would be the same. Basically, I've decided that I cannot fix this story and will be leaving it as is. I apologize for not being able to give it my best, even though I do think this was my best at the time I first wrote it.

I do have an ongoing Harry Potter series called "Before the Thunder" that has received a more positive reception. Once that is finished, I am not sure when or if I will return to writing Harry Potter fics. Maybe I will make a second attempt at the Sirius Survives in Year 5 premise, or I may come back with a totally different story. But I am done with A Different Fate. It helped me to hone my skill and improve significantly, and I am leaving it in the past where it belongs.

To clarify, I will read and respond to comments left on this story, mainly because I receive email notifs about any comment on any of my works, but I won't interact with this story beyond that.

If you choose to read this story, and judge it for yourself, I appreciate it. If you decide to look elsewhere, I understand, and I will shamelessly plug my other fic, Before the Thunder (and if you're coming to this story from BTT... please lower your expectations significantly).

Also, please don't go in the comments and tell me it's not that bad of a story. I know that objectively I did some great stuff here. I also know I could've have done a much better job of it, and I'm okay admitting it.

That's about it, I suppose. Read or don't, it's up to you. The rest of this A/N is what I wrote initially six-ish years ago when I first transferred this to AO3 from Fanfic. Hope everyone's 2024 is going well and continues to. Bye.

***Back to 2018 Cici***

Hullo, everyone! This is a Sirius Survives story, beginning around the end of Order of the Phoenix. I am a huge Padfoot fan, and I can't bear to kill him off in fanfics.

This story is from my fanfiction.net account. It received mostly positive reviews. However, many readers had a problem with the inclusion of LGBTQ characters. Some were very rude about it. I hope the Ao3 community is more open-minded.

This story has no connections to my other Harry Potter series, Before The Thunder. While there are some similarities, the plots and concepts are very, very different.

Special thanks to Leahcar260, my beta reader and author of McGonagall's Girl.

****Additional Update - Leahcar260 is now Monoceros260 <3****

Chapter 1: A Turn of Events

Chapter Text

"Harry, will you just listen to me?"

Harry sighed and finally turned to look at his bushy-haired friend. Her dark eyes were fierce.

"Sirius is in trouble, Hermione." He said as he led the way back to the school. Ron, Ginny, Luna, and Neville joined them in the Entrance Hall.

"And there are a half-dozen people in this school with the ability to contact him." Hermione countered.

"And who do you suppose is actually going to believe me and see about him, eh? Dumbledore and McGonagall, maybe, but they're both gone."

"This is different, Harry. Besides, I think someone's already contacted Grimmauld Place."

The others stopped.

"Who? We haven't told anybody." Ron said.

"Yes, we have." Hermione said. "Remember 'He's got padfoot at the place where it's hidden'? You know, Snape isn't dim. I saw recognition in his eyes, like he knew what Harry meant. He knows who Padfoot is."

"She's got a point." Ginny agreed. "And the only way we'll know is if we find Snape."

"He's probably down in his dungeon." Ron said.

Harry had to agree with them. Snape did seem to have understood the message. But there was still one problem.

"Why would Snape care if Sirius is in danger, though? They hate each other." He argued as they headed down the stairs to the dungeon.

"Because Sirius knows quite a bit about the Order." Ginny said.

"Because Dumbledore'd be angry if he didn't." Ron said.

"Because it's not just about Sirius. It's about the whole wizarding world. Whatever their protecting is powerful enough for Voldemort to want it." Hermione said.

Neville and Luna said nothing, but Harry assumed they didn't completely understand what was going on.

As they neared Snape's office, they heard faint voices, but could not make out what they were saying.

"Who's he talking to?" Harry whispered.

"Let's find out." Hermione pushed Harry forward and they entered through the open door.

"Harry!" Cried a familiar voice, the owner of which proceeded to tackle Harry in a great bear hug.

"Sirius! You're alright?" Harry managed to say.

"'Course I am." Sirius assured him. He then stepped out of the way and they noticed the other two occupants of the room: Remus and Snape, the latter looking rather chagrined about his company.

"But what are you doing here?"

"Snape said you gave him a coded message after trying to use Umbridge's office to floo me." Sirius said. "Lucky you did, too. Dumbledore's led a team of Order members to the Department of Mysteries to protect the weapon."

"But what is the weapon?" Harry asked.

Sirius eyed him for a moment. "I have a feeling Dumbledore will be telling you all about it after this."

"So what do we do now?" Ron asked. "Wait and see what happens?"

"Well, I believe you lot have some explaining to do." Remus told them. "Professor Snape only told us what he knew, and that wasn't much. Let's go upstairs and find Professor McGonagall. She's just returned."

"Where was she, anyway?" Ron asked.

Everyone except for Snape went back upstairs to find Minerva McGonagall waiting for them in the Entrance Hall. She looked concerned but not particularly surprised, as though she'd already been briefed on what was happening.

"I've woken the other teachers. Everyone's on alert and standing guard around the school. With the exception of our High Inquisitor, however. I hope you six have a particularly good tale to explain her whereabouts, otherwise I'm going to have to take House points." The Deputy Headmistress said.

As always, it was impossible to tell whether she was joking or not. Either way, she led them to her office, where they each told their part in the night's events, tea and biscuits provided. Sirius, Remus, and McGonagall seemed to find Umbridge's fate quite amusing.

"Flitwick and I will retrieve her in the morning." She said with very little care.

Finally, Hermione explained why they went to see Snape and their arrival there ended the story.

Nobody spoke for a few minutes after, all of them turning the events over in their heads.

"I'd give him clothes, but he knows too much. Maybe he'll keel over if I scare him enough." Sirius said darkly.

"But Sirius!" Hermione cried. "Kreacher is-"

"Don't worry, Hermione." Remus interrupted. "Sirius will do nothing of the sort to Kreacher. He will, however, be ordering him to never leave Grimmauld Place unless he is specifically given a destination to go to."

Sirius crossed his arms but nodded. Hermione gave him a small glare, which he ignored.

At that moment, a light appeared in the window. A patronus flowed through the glass as though it weren't even there.

It spoke only six words in Moody's voice. "Battle over. Order won. None dead."

"Typical Mad-Eye. He's a man of few words." Sirius noted.

"A rather bothersome trait." McGonagall said. "If it weren't for my duties to the school I would go to the Ministry myself and find out what exactly happened."

"Voldemort tried to get the weapon, didn't he?" Harry asked, ignoring Ron's flinch at the name. "In the Department of Mysteries."

McGonagall raised an eyebrow. "The battle did indeed take place in the Department of Mysteries, according to the message I received from Kingsley Shacklebolt. With the Death Eaters on the move, I had the teachers and faculty take up posts around the school, just in case they decided to attack the school."

"I suppose all we can do now is wait for someone to give us more information." Sirius said, sounding rather mature.

"If the battle is already over, then the Order must have had prior knowledge of the attack." Hermione surmised.

"Not to my knowledge." McGonagall told her. Sirius and Remus shook their heads.

"Maybe Dumbledore knew, and he just didn't tell anyone." Harry suggested.

"Wouldn't be the first time." Sirius agreed, receiving sharp looks from both McGonagall and Remus.

"Professor," Harry said. "Where were you today?"

Professor McGonagall looked for a moment as though she wouldn't answer him.

"I was at an Order meeting. I deeply regret leaving the school with Dumbledore gone. It is a mistake I shall not make again."

At that moment, a bright light poured into the window once more, and they watched as a jack rabbit patronus hopped through the glass.

"Tonks." They heard Remus say.

"Meet in Dumbledore's office in five. Bring Wolf, Dog, Scar, and friends." Tonks' voice said.

"Gee, I wonder who Scar is." Ron said sarcastically, nudging Harry, who self-consciously rubbed his scar. It was tingling a bit.

"Who did she expect to be listening in on that?" Sirius asked. "And she really needs to come up with better names."