Chapter Text
Jennifer had always been one to garner attention everywhere she went. So to everyone else at school, she seemed normal. She was the head bitch in charge, acting as she usually would, but something seemed strange to you.
Then there was Needy, who had been acting completely different recently. She had always clung to Jennifer before, but it was different now; They always had a hand on each other. Whether they were holding hands, hugging, or even just linked by pinkies. Something was off, but you had no idea what could've happened.
You tried to let it go. It was none of your business. That was, until your brother stormed down the hallway, wiping angry tears with his sleeve.
Everyone at their lockers just stood watching the boy. You sighed, shutting your locker, and trudging after him. You could feel the eyes on you as followed your brother out of the school.
" Chip, slow down. What was all that about?" You jogged to catch up to your brother. He turned abruptly, and you could see just how bad he really looked.
" Needy just fucking dumped me because that fucking crazy bitch finally sunk her claws into her"
Oh, that definitely explains the new-found closeness between Jennifer and Needy.
" Maybe she's just gay."
He made extravagant gestures with his hands," No, there is something going on. Y/n, I swear after that fire she changed. She's more like Jennifer than ever before. Needy wouldn't just dump me like that"
He had a point: Jennifer had never been fond of your brother yet Needy always chose to be with him. What was different now?
" Maybe they just finally confessed their feelings to each other, dude. Everyone knows that they had some underlying sexual tension… even you"
He scoffed," Just because they had tension means that they'd act on it. I'm telling you Y/n, I know Needy. Even if she did have some weird girl crush on Jennifer, she wouldn't have made a move because Jennifer scares her."
" Look, I didn't come out here to listen to your conspiracy theories about the two. I came out here to make sure you were alright, and you seem fine to me so…"
You were going to leave Chip alone in the parking lot, but you stopped in your tracks when you saw Jennifer and Needy standing on the steps outside of the school. They were both staring at you and your brother. It gave you an unsettling feeling.
" See, that's fucking weird, isn't"
You shoved his shoulder," Shut up and get the car, we're going home."
You tossed him the keys, and he went to pull the car around. You looked back at the school and almost choked on air when you saw the blonde and brunette were still staring at you.
You stared back at them before awkwardly waving at the pair. They stared at you a second longer, and you could see Jennifer licking her lips. They both gave you a wink, and you could see them giggling before they re-entered the school.
You didn't have much of a relationship with Jennifer, or Needy for that matter. Needy was just your brother's girlfriend, and Jennifer was just a girl you knew only by her reputation. So what just happened was pretty strange.
When Chip finally pulled the car up, you shoved him into the passenger's seat and drove home.
-In School-
" Who was that girl, Needy?"
" Y/n, she's Chip's sister"
" Do you like her?" Jennifer's hand crawls all the way up into the blonde's hair.
Needy closes her eyes at the contact," She's Chip's sister Jen"
Jennifer tugs on Needy's hair a bit," I asked if you liked"
Needy deflects again," Do you like her?"
Jen bites her lip," I think she could be one of us"
Needy frowns, taking a step back from Jennifer. She was going to share her opinion, but the bell rang for class," I gotta go, Jen"
Needy tried to rush off, but Jen grabbed her arm and dragged her into the janitor's closet.
" Talk to me baby, what's the problem?"
Jen was looking directly into Needy's eyes. She left any room she could between them, letting Needy have control of their intimacy level.
Since they both got turned Jen had become way nicer to Needy. She wanted to let her know that they were equals now and that Needy's feelings were just as important as hers.
Needy rests her head in the crook on Jen's neck," I like it when it's just us. If we add someone else then… then maybe you won't-"
Jennifer lifts Needy's head off of her shoulder," I'll always need you and you'll always be important to me. No matter what, Needy. We don't have to add Y/n, it was only a suggestion"
Needy leans forward and places a kiss on Jennifer's lips," If you want her we can have her"
Jennifer smiles against Needy's lips," Are you sure?"
" Positive"
Since they would've already been late Jennifer and Needy spent the class period in the closet. It's not hard to imagine how they passed the time.
-Your Place-
" Fuck," you heard your brother yell from the kitchen.
You reluctantly get off of the couch to see what the issue is," What now?"
" Needy's coming after school to get her things"
You roll your eyes," Just tell her no"
" She didn't ask. She just said ' Coming to get my shit after school'," he impersonates her at the end of the sentence.
" Well then let her come get it? I don't what you want me to say here"
He throws his head back," She literally just broke up with me hours ago. I don't want to see her and-"
He goes on and you tune him out. You think that eventually he'll shut up, but he doesn't. When you were seconds away from putting him in a choke hold, you threw the car keys at him.
" Just shut and go. I'll give Needy her stuff, ok?"
He was going to protest, but you cut him off," School ended 5 minutes ago, better hurry"
Chip glances at you before he runs out of the door," Thanks for this"
He doesn't wait for your reply before slamming the door behind him.
It hadn't been five minutes later when your doorbell rang. When you open it, you're surprised to see Needy and Jennifer standing on your porch.
You find yourself in yet another staring match with the pair before clearing your throat," Chip left, but I'm sure you know where everything is"
Needy let out a scoff as you let them into the house, " Of course he's not here"
" Well, you did break up with him to be with your hot popular cheerleader friend so, it's obvious why he doesn't want to see you"
" Thank you," Jennifer speaks up, eyeing the length of your body.
" For what?"
Her gaze locks on your eyes," Well you said I'm hot didn't you"
That was enough to make you a little flustered. You could feel sweat start to form at the base of your neck.
Needy had already started traveling up the stairs. Since you were still unresponsive to her comment, Jennifer decided to follow Needy.
You decided to follow them, just in case they decided they wanted to trash the room or something. Walking up the stairs, you had the perfect view of Jennifer's ass. You tried hard not to stare, but it was proving to be a hard task.
It wasn't big, but it had a nice shape, and it definitely jiggled a little with each step she took.
It wasn't until she turned around with a smirk on her face that you stopped watching her ass.
" See something you like Y/n"
The color drained from your face as she continued walking up the steps without another word.
When you got to his room, Needy was looking for her things while Jennifer was sitting comfortably on his desk.
" Y/n can you get that sweater off the top shelf in the closet, I can’t reach it."
Your eyes landed on the baby blue sweater that obviously belonged to Needy. You fully went into your brother's room and grabbed the sweater for Needy.
When you handed it to her, you heard the bedroom door close and lock. Jennifer had locked you in the room with her and Needy.
" Why'd you lock the door?"
" Sit down Y/n," Needy shoved you onto your brother's bed and straddled your waist.
You tried to struggle out of her grasp, but she was surprisingly stronger than you thought she should be.
" Get off of me"
Jennifer laughed," I think she looks good on top of you. What do you think Needy?"
The blonde throws her back with Laughter," I think she looks good under me"
You struggle me," Knock it off Needy, you literally used to fuck my brother"
She took her glasses off and put hair in a ponytail," I did, but something tells me you could do a better job"
This was wrong, and you knew that, but a part of you is curious as to what the actual fuck is going on.
" What do you want from me?"
Jennifer lies down on the bed next to you and Needy. She turns on her side so that she's making eye contact with you.
" Do you know about the murders Y/n?"
" You mean the animal attacks?"
Jennifer has a smile on her face," I called them what they were, but if animal attacks help you sleep at night, be my guest"
You looked between the two girls," You killed them"
Needy giggles on top of you," Thank god you're smarter than your brother"
Jennifer uses her finger to trace your arms that are held in place by Needy," You see, Y/n, Needy and I have stumbled onto something quite unfortunate."
" Speak for yourself, Jen. I love it"
" Would you just get to the point, please?" You spoke out of turn, earning a slap in the face from Jennifer.
You held back a grunt as their laughter echoed around you.
" We're possessed by demons and demons get hungry, Y/n. They have to eat"
" Well if you're planning on feasting on me, I'd reconsider"
Jennifer starts," We weren't going to eat you"
" Just turn you into one of us"
You laughed," Well I'm afraid you can't do that either"
" And why not?"
You pushed Needy off you with ease and within an instant you were at the locked door.
" I already am one"