Work Text:
Living with your older brother, Nick, had its fair share of ups and downs. The ups being that the two of you were quite close and that you had a place to live, rent-free. The downs, his friends. You didn’t dislike his friends as there was nothing unlikeable about them. The problem was that maybe you loved them too much. One of these friends was Johnathan and for the past three months, the two of you had a secret relationship. It was quite easy to hide as he lived alone so you would go over there lots. You’d just lie about where you were going to throw off suspicion.
It started as a friends-with-benefits situation. Nick had Tanner and John for their bi-weekly Overwatch meetup. You’d decided to join them, not to play, but to watch. You did play video games, but first-person shooters weren’t your thing. You preferred games like Minecraft or Elder Scrolls, but you still decided to hang out with them. They didn’t mind as they enjoyed your company, and you the same. They didn’t treat you like Nick’s little sister, but more so as a friend. Schlatt, however, saw you as something more.
Tanner and Nick were playing split screen, while you and Schlatt were sitting quite close. It caught you quite off guard when he placed his hand on your knee and whispered in your ear, asking to be friends with benefits. Quite flustered, you whispered a yes and a smirk formed on his face as he moved his hand up to be placed on your inner thigh. It stayed for about ten minutes before Nick wanted a break and asked Schlatt to take his place. He pulled his hand away quite quickly and took the controller.
Feeling quite hot, you told the boys that you were gonna head upstairs and do your own thing.
You heard a knock on your bedroom door and looked over at the time. It was slightly past 1:00 in the morning, but as you furrowed your brows, you reluctantly said, “It’s open.” The door slowly creaked open and it was Schlatt.
“Can I come in?” He asked.
Gently biting your lip, you nodded. “What’s up?” You quietly said.
“Nothing really. The boys fell asleep, and I’m quite bored. I didn’t wake you did I?”
“No, I was just listening to music.”
“Can I listen?”
“Sure.” You took out your right earbud and gave it to Schlatt as he sat next to you on your bed.
“Oh my God
She took me to the sky
Oh my God
She showed me all the stars ”
The lyrics sang as you hummed along. Schlatt asked what the song was and instead of telling him, you showed him your phone. He nodded, “(G)I-DLE? Never heard of them.”
“It’s KPOP,” you said with a nervous giggle.
“KPOP?” He teased you before for a little while before the two of you decided to just sit in silence.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
He blatantly said that nobody had to know. You promised and for those three months, you’ve been keeping him as an oath. It was difficult not to tell anyone as you had major feelings for him. That was until you were in LA for Mogul Money with Schlatt and Hasan.
Blaire, one of your closest friends was visiting you in your hotel room. The two of you were laughing over a story about Ludwig when your phone pinged. It was a Snap from Schlatt. Expecting it to be nothing, you opened it, with your blonde friend. What the two of you saw blew Blaire away. He was in the bathroom of his personal hotel room. He was sitting on the side of the tub, the bright white lights shining a glare making it almost difficult to see. But that didn’t mean that the two of you couldn’t figure out what it was. It was a dick pic. In shock, you just responded with a message saying that you were busy at the moment. With her mouth gaping wide Blaire asked, “What was that?”
“It’s not what it looks like.”
“What it looks like is that John sent you a picture of his dick.”
“Okay, it is what it looks like.”
“Spill.”
You then explained to her what was going on between you and him. When it happened, how it happened. You even told her that it was supposed to be a secret, and as you were filled with remorse for saying something, you begged her to keep her mouth shut. You then let out a deep sigh and gave her another secret to keep; that you have more than just sexual feelings toward him. That you wanted an actual relationship, but you were scared that he doesn’t feel the same. As she pulled you in for a hug, she promised to take both secrets to her grave.
“You’re gonna be okay. Now go kick some Mogul ass. I’ll take you”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Despite absolutely wiping the floor with Schlatt and Hasan, you were quite frantic. Your mutton chop fuck buddy was constantly making sexual innuendos guided towards you, that you were surprised nobody noticed. Or maybe they did. You couldn’t really tell. Either way, you were on your way to winning a generous amount of cash. Question after question, you were blowing your competition out of the water. When it was time to play Quick Money, you and Schlatt had the two highest scores. You won and as you were celebrating, Schlatt gave you side hug, his hand awfully low and his mouth in your ear offering to have a different kind of celebration in his hotel room afterwards. You nodded as Lud was saying his final goodbyes and letting the viewers know when the next Mogul Money was.
The second you entered Schlatt’s hotel room, you guys couldn’t keep your hands off of each other. Your back against the wall, hands in his hair, and a core pressed so hard against his left knee it started to ache, in a painful way. His hand were roaming up and down your sides as he sucked and bit hard on your neck.
“John,” you let out with a shaky breath.
“Yes baby girl?”
“Fuck me harder than you ever have before.”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The next morning you were lying naked under his covers. Alone. The rising sun peeking through the poorly closed curtains, illuminating the room in a beautiful orange tone.
Luckily, it wouldn’t last long as you would hear the click of the door handle and see Schlatt turn around the corner. You didn’t need to ask where he went as you saw him place the McDonald’s bag on the dresser. He got breakfast. For the both of you. He proceeded to take his shoes off and grab the bag to sit next to you on the bed. He got both of you guys bacon and egg McGriddles. As you were eating, you rested your head on his shoulder and softly, you spoke for the first time that morning.
“John?”
“What’s up?”
“I don’t want this,” you gestured towards your naked body and his fully clothed one, “anymore”
“Oh,” he seemed genuinely hurt. Were you really just a sex thing to him?
“Not like that. I like what’s between us, but I want something more.”
“Like a relationship?”
You just nodded in response.
“How about when we get home, I’ll take you out on a real date and we can slow down on the fucking and see if we can work out. Sound good?”
You smiled and nodded a response again. God, you couldn’t wait until you got back home to Texas.