Chapter Text
Y/n’s Pov
Today the boys were filming a car video and I was going to be in it, Nick and I came up with a little funny, harmless prank to pull. Obviously Nick’s gay, everyone knows that, so the prank was to straight up makeout in the back seat. We wanted to see how long it took for Chris and Matt to notice and get their reactions on camera. We practice on how we were going to execute this, minus the making out part, we just did quick little pecks instead, and figured it all out. All of us had gotten into the car and drove to the place where we were going to film so it was time to put our plan into action.
We started off the video normally but when Chris went off on some off-topic, random tangent about food and colors being associated, we did it. Me and Nick both put our fingers over our lips as if we were shushing the fans before turning to each other. Nick grabbed my jaw, guiding me toward his lips as I had one hand on the side of his face and the other in his hair as our lips met. The angle was a bit awkward but we made it work, licking and biting each other’s lips and tongues while his brothers conversed in the front.
It took a couple of minutes for Matt to realize we weren’t talking, causing him to turn around and nearly scream. This made Chris look back as well and yell, “ What the fuck are you doing!” causing me and Nick to pull apart. “Nothing, what are you doing?” I asked back casually, as if I wasn’t just making out with his gay brother. “I- but you- what!?” Matt said confused, trying to put the pieces together. “Okay, off camera, what the actual fuck was that?” Chris asked more calmly this time, “It was nothing” I replied with a shrug, getting weird looks from both brothers.
“It was just a joke but oh my god your reactions were priceless!” Nick said while we both started laughing. “It was fucking weird is what is was” Chris complained, “Awe does Chrissy want a kiss too?” I joked, obnoxiously puckering my lips. “Matty wants a kiss!” Matt joked while Chris just shook his head in disappointment. We continued the video, going back to filming our original idea of insane would you rather questions.
Not gonna lie, I was pretty turned on from that kiss because obviously Nicks hot as fuck, like yea he’s my gay best friend and all but I’m not blind to his attractiveness. Also because we were full on making out for like a solid 4 minutes and he was sucking on my tongue, licking across the roof of my mouth and biting my lip. For obvious reasons, nobody was going to find out I was turned on, well until Chris and Matt started talking about something completely random again.
Nicks pov
It was really weird that I was turned on from making out with Y/n, I mean obviously she’s gorgeous but I’m only attracted to men. I was extremely hard, but thankfully you couldn’t tell though because my pants cover it. Chris and Matt were rambling on and I knew I was going cut some of it out, so I told to Y/n what she did to me. “God, you made me so fucking hard, feel my cock” I whispered while grabbing her hand, bringing it towards my cock.
I made her feel how hard I was over my pants, Y/n let out a quiet gasp and I was pleasantly surprised by what came out of her mouth after. “You turned me on too Nicky” she whispered back shyly, “You’re such a good kisser too” I added before placing a small kiss behind her ear. This made Y/n/n shudder before we started interacting with the video again. After about another 20 minutes or so, we were done filming but Chris was hungry and wanted to go to Taco Bell, which is all the way across town in the opposite direction of our house.
As Matt started driving to Taco Bell, I put my hand on Y/n’s thigh, this wasn’t anything unusual as I’ve done it before when we’re driving, but this time I did something a little different. Usually my hand is down closer to her knee, however, this time I put it closer to her pussy. I started leaving light, feathery touch on her inner thigh, ever so often grazing against her clit. I was glad Y/n/n wore a biker shorts because of the thin material, making it easier for me to tease her.
Y/n’s pov
Nick’s light touches on my clit were driving me crazy, I could practically feel my wetness soaking my panties. I decided if Nick gonna tease me, it was only fair for me to tease him as well. I undid the button of his shorts and started palming his cock over his boxers, the heat and hardness of his cock was so sexy to me. Nick stopped teasing my clit and was now just tightly gripping onto my thigh while trying not to moan.
He looked at me with his lip between his teeth and widened eyes, resulting in me smirking at his before moving my hand fully into his boxers. Nick was big, very long and girthy, I honestly wasn’t expecting to be so turned on just by the way his cock felt in my hand. He let out a small whimper when I started slowly jerking him off, running my thumb across his slit and biting my lip at the amount of precum that was leaking out of it.
“Your cock is so wet and hard Nicky” I whispered into his ear, “Stop fucking teasing me, Chris is gonna see what you’re doing!” he whispered back in a panic. “I’m going to keep rubbing your cock, I’ll do it over your boxers but I’m not stopping” I, yet again, whispered. Nick was lowkey squirming in his seat and couldn’t help but let out little whimpers as I slowly jerked him off through his boxers. Ever so often, I would press down on or rub his tip, until we got to Taco Bell, then we both stopped all touching as Nick had to order Chris’ food.
On the way back home, my touches continued, still moving slowly but applying more pressure and being a bit rougher. With my free hand I pulled Nicks hair a bit before kissing up the side of his neck and quietly spoke in a seductive tone. “You like this don’t you? I bet you want to cum so badly, I know your close Nick, but you’ll have to wait” I said as his hips bucked up and his breath hitched.
Nick’s pov
I should’ve known teasing Y/n would have consequences, but I wasn’t expecting her to full on jerk off my bare cock like that. I knew there was no way I’d be able to last or stay quiet so I told her to stop, but Y/n had other plans. She started palming me through my boxers, teasing my sensitive tip and overall just feeling up my cock. I was getting really close when we pulled up to Taco Bell and she quickly rebuttoned my pants and halted all touching until after we ordered and got out of the drive-thru.
I was a bit shocked when she resumed her movements on my edged dick, while I focused on not cumming. Y/n was being a bit rougher than before but was still going pretty slow but it was enough to make me squirm and have whimpers fall past my lips. I almost fucking lost it when she pulled my hair and licked up the side of my neck before whispering something dirty in my ear while squeezing my cock.
It took all my my strength not to cum, I tightly closed my eyes and unintentionally bucked my hips up as she did that. I let out a louder whimper than intended but luckily my brothers didn’t hear as my breath hitched and I accidentally creamed in my boxers. Y/n/n pulled away and went to go rebutton my shorts again but I had to slap her had away, scared I’d fully cum if her hands got close to my dick again.
I was honestly a bit embarrassed, when Y/n asked, “Are you okay Nicky? Did I hurt you or something?” because I was being quite and my eyes were tightly shut. I opened my eyes to be met with her beautiful, yet concerned, face that caused me to heavily blush. “I-I’m fine, you didn’t hurt me, but you did make me cream in my boxers a bit” I said while looking her body up and down. “That pretty hot” she replied back while biting her lip and looking directly into my eyes with her big y/e/c ones.
Y/n’s pov
The fact that Nick creamed himself because of my touching, was so fucking hot to me. From my perspective, I got my gay best friend, who’s never had any interest in females, hard and made him almost cum in his pants, it makes me feel sexy as fuck. We pulled into the driveway and Nick was the first one out of the car, running up to his room so his brothers didn’t see how unbearably hard he was.
“What’s kids issue?” Matt asked me, “I don’t know, he said something about having to piss like a racehorse” I lied, using a phrase my dad says sometimes. “Seems about right” Chris replies as he went into his bedroom as Matt and I continued up the stairs. “You wanna sleep in my room tonight or Nick?” he asked with a smile, see the thing is that Matt kinda has a thing for me, he’s pretty much had a little crush on me since 7th grade.
I let him down gently, saying that I promised Nick I’d sleep in his room this time since I did, in fact, sleep in Matt’s room last week. “Lame! goodnight, you’re sleeping in my room tomorrow by the way” Matt pouted, giving me a hug before going to his room while I went up to Nick’s room. “Took you fucking long enough!” Nick complained, as he pulled me towards his bed, already having discarded his short and shoes.
Nick looked so desperate and it was really turning me on, I know it’s wrong but I cant help it. I took off my shoes, shorts and top, leave me in a regular black bra and panties before climbing onto Nick’s lap, already knowing what he wanted. Nick slid his shirt off before gripping my jaw and pulling me towards him so we could makeout again. The kiss was fast paced, rough and messy, before I knew it, Nick flipped me over onto my back. “Can I fuck you?” he asked out of breath, and even though I should’ve say no, I said yes instead.
“Please Nick” I begged breathlessly, in an instant my bra and panties were removed along with Nicks boxers. He went to grab a condom and even though I said he didn’t need it, he wanted it so I let him use it. He pushed his cock in and it was a little bit of a stretch but not too much, “You’re so tight” he grunted, pounding into me without letting me adjust. It was a little painful at first but then it started to feel good, really good actually. “Fuck Nick, you’re doing it so good” I quietly moaned, not wanting his brothers to hear us.
Nick wasn’t gonna last long, I knew that going into this, but he was continuously abusing my g-spot. Along with choking me and rubbing my clit, I knew I wasn’t going to last long either as I seas already feeling close. “Are you gonna cum Y/n/n?” he asked, moving faster, “Y-Yea, I’m so close” “Me too” he rasped. Within the next few minutes, we were both cumming. Even though it was now around 4:00am, Nick wasted no time before helping me up and dragging us into the shower, during which he got hard again.
“Suck me off, yea?” he asked nonchalantly and I agreed, giving him head before we both got out. While we were getting dressed, he was unusually quiet, I just shrugged it off though. I went back into the bathroom to pee and brush my teeth but when I came back out, my world got flipped upside down. Nick was standing there panicking a backpack, making me confused, “What are you doing?” I laughed, but that laughter quickly stopped. He started putting my things back into my bag before harshly shoving it at me.
I was beyond confused, it’s not like I was expecting Nick to be all lovey dovey and start a relationship with me or anything, but I wasn’t expecting him to be so cold. “The sex was good but it was a mistake and I regret it. It shouldn’t have happened, I’m gay and feel no attraction towards you, I was just horny. Now I’m leaving so get the hell out of my room and go sleep on the couch or go home, I don’t really give a shit what you do at this point” Nick spat at me.
He shoved me out of his room, grabbing his stuff and leaving in the process. I was obviously really upset so I just sat on the couch, not wanting to wake Chris or Matt up as I softly cried. I didn’t think that this would happen after sleeping with Nick, I just thought we’d laugh it off and it would be done with. Apparently I was wrong, I was just a quick fuck for him to cum. I think I might’ve just lost my best friend. I cried for roughly 30 minutes before trying to fall asleep on the couch, but I couldn’t and it was now almost 5:00am.
I definitely had tried tears on my face but I didn’t really care, I didn’t want to be alone, I just couldn’t sleep and I was cold. I got up and walked over to Matt’s room, quietly opening and closing his door before carefully climbing over him. I got under the covers next to him to him and slowly drifted off to sleep, sadness completely taking over my body.