Work Text:
Having Amber and Jesse Gemstone host their own couples counseling sessions with members of the congregation was, without a doubt, a choice. A bold one. A loud one. The kind of idea that could only have come from Jesse himself, pumped full of misguided confidence and just enough charisma to make it happen. Amber, ever the supportive wife and co-star in the Gemstone pageant of piety, went along with it, because what was image, if not everything?
Backstage, Amber was in her element. She stood under the vanity lights, dusting a soft pink blush across her cheeks with a practiced hand. Her hair had been curled into bouncing perfection, big, southern, and glossy, the kind of curls that didn’t move when she nodded. She clipped on a pair of gold earrings that shimmered in the light like halos. Her Bible sat closed on the dressing table, untouched, while the script for the session, half sermon, half reality show monologue, lay in her lap. She glanced down at it, mouthing Jesse’s lines as she adjusted the neckline of her dress.
Jesse strutted in, adjusting the cuffs on his flashy, rhinestone-studded suit. He looked like a televangelist Elvis impersonator, and he knew it. “You ready, baby?” he asked, offering his arm.
“Born ready,” Amber smiled, slipping her arm through his.
They made their entrance to applause, emerging from behind a velvet curtain to a lit-up stage that had been decorated to look like a cozy living room, two oversized pastel chairs, a rug that looked expensive but wasn’t, and a fake fireplace with battery-operated flames. Jesse gave a practiced wave, flashing his teeth, while Amber did a demure hand-on-heart gesture like a First Lady at a prayer breakfast.
The crowd was packed with married couples from the congregation, most of them holding hands a little tighter than usual, clearly hoping to find some sort of holy blueprint in the Gemstones’ not-so-humble example.
“Thank y’all,” Jesse boomed into the mic, leading Amber to their seats. “It’s such a blessing to be able to share a lil’ piece of what God’s done for us in our marriage. And let me tell you, it’s a lot. Like, a whole miracle.”
They sat down, Jesse leaning back like he owned the room, Amber crossing her legs and smiling sweetly.
“We get asked all the time,” Jesse said, shifting into his stage voice, “How don’t you guys argue? How do y’all stay so in sync, so peaceful?”
He looked at Amber with a grin.
“Well,” he said, “a little bash to the head fixes it right up!”
Laughter rippled through the congregation. Jesse chuckled louder, clearly pleased with himself.
Amber tilted her head toward the crowd. “Now don’t go home and actually hit each other, y’all,” she said with a laugh that sounded almost rehearsed. “It’s just a figure of speech. We believe in prayer... and therapy. And maybe a little wine and a long walk around the property.”
The audience chuckled again.
From the front row, Sister Rhonda raised a hand. “So what do you do when you do fight? Like really fight?”
Jesse leaned forward, clasping his hands. “That’s a great question. First off, we don’t fight. We... discuss passionately.”
Amber nodded. “There was this one time,” she said, her voice honeyed, “Jesse bought a brand-new bass boat without telling me. Full package. Speakers. Neon lights. Whole thing looked like a floating nightclub.”
“It was for ministry,” Jesse interrupted. “I told you, babe, I was gonna start a men’s outreach.”
Amber turned to him with a raised eyebrow. “You took it to the lake three times and baptized nobody.”
More laughter. Jesse held up his hands. “Okay, okay. But we talked it out. I apologized. I repented. And then I bought her a new SUV and all was forgiven.”
Amber grinned. “See? That’s the Lord at work right there. Forgiveness. And a good warranty.”
They carried on like that, passing stories back and forth, some exaggerated, some suspiciously convenient, each one reinforcing the fantasy of the perfect couple with a perfect God-blessed life. Jesse played the part of the flawed-but-redeemed husband, and Amber, the patient and prayerful wife who always pulled him back from the edge.
Behind their words, though, was a crackle of something else. A performance with enough truth to make it land, but not so much that it would ever get real. They weren’t just hosting counseling sessions. They were doing brand management. Holy PR.