Work Text:
On a cold night in 2002, Steve was sleeping on Jimmy's couch. He had gotten evicted. Again. And there was no room in Jimmy's bed for them to cuddle 😢.
Steve was shivering, and the city noises were so loud, but despite this he was able to fall asleep.
When he woke up, he got up and yawned. Instead of finding cold flooring under his feet, there were joyous pink clouds. This place looks like some shit out of a little girls show. He thought to himself. He straightened his clothes a little and started to wander around.
This world was weird. The temperature was just perfect, and it felt like the orange-pink skies were singing to him in a familiar melody. A rhythm he's never heard, yet he knew every note.
He kept walking, trying to find someone else in this kiddish wonderland. Through the mild sunlight, he finally saw something other than the beautiful hills of clouds. Houses. And roads. And things that were familiar to him in the city. He ran towards this town, wanting to ask someone where the fuck he was.
The first person he locked eyes with.. Was himself. Except an altered version. He recognized his face. This was one of the looks he had in the 90s. Beautiful magenta pigtails, a warm, black sweater that had little crosses on the end. He looked down to see the other similarities. This was weird.. Instead of the long skirt he had worn, this other wordly Steve had a short, white one on, paired with a pair of knee high socks with girly bows on them.
Steve was caught up with admiring the differences between them until the other Steve spoke. "Hey, bud, what ya staring at?" He was a bit spooked at first, quickly returning his eyes to the others face. It was at this moment he noticed the MAJOR difference between them. Ears on the top of his head. Pony ears. And a horn between them. Steve gestured to his head, looking a bit puzzled. "Why do you have.. Horse ears?? I-im not a f-f-f-furry-" He stammered on his words, out of breath from running. Horse Steve looked decently confused. "Why don't you have ears? Everyone here is either a pony, Pegasus, or an alicorn. Unless you're the next ruler, like myself, who has both a horn and wings!" Steve backed up a little, putting space between himself and alternate him. He was gonna be.. A king in an alternate universe?
He shook his head to clear his thoughts and circled back to the main thing on his mind. "Where am i?" He asked with a clear, confident voice. He didn't wanna embarrass himself even more in front of an important government figure. Horse Steve smiled, pleased with the switch in subject. "You're in Hysteria!" He couldn't have heard that right... Right?! He looked around and rubbed his eyes, as if that would make everything disappear. "Hysteria..?" He mumbled under his breath.
Horse Steve grabbed his hand. "Let me show you around!" He turned and pulled Steve along with him as he skipped through the town. Steve noticed the bright colored horse tail on the other Steve's ass. He focused a bit too much on that area, noticing that another difference between them was the beautiful glutes horse Steve had.. Must be from prancing around all day!
He was physically shook out of his thoughts as horse Steve turned him around. "This is Jimmy, lynz, and kitty! They're my bandmates!" That was another one of the things they had in common. He waved at the horse versions of his friends with varying features, taking note of how they looked to see if there was anything else he could spot that was different.
Before any of them notices, Steve was already being dragged to another part of the land. Everyone else he was introduced to also held important parts in his life, his friends, neighbors,.. Everything was eerily the same.
After about an hour of the tour of Hysteria, Horse Steve pulled Steve back to the place his bandmates were. Leaving him to go talk to his friends. Everyone in the town was staring at him. He was wack compared to everyone here. No ears, no tail, and he looked very disheveled.
Kitty, who was more off to the side, leaned over to Steve and yanked him to where horse Steve was. "How are you two so alike? Are you twins??" Kitty, Lynz, and Jimmy were in both Steves faces, dazzled by how similar they were. Their dirty, DIRTY, hands slid around on their flesh. Getting close to the sensitive areas of their faces, the eyes, mouth, nose.. Steve was getting very overwhelmed. He pushed everyone away, taking a huge breath after getting his own personal space. "Leave me alone! I don't even know you!" Horse Steve grabbed Steve's hand. "Leave US alone! Come on, lets go somewhere more private."
He led his counterpart to his castle. Very fancy place, the complete opposite of the apartment Steve had gotten evicted out of. Horse Steve dragged him to his room, locking the door behind them. The bed was big and soft, it only took a look to figure that out. Horse Steve flopped onto it and patted the spot beside him, a half smug, half horny look on his face. Steve was kinda uncomfortable with this. He backed up into a corner and stood awkwardly. "Why are we in your room?-" Horse Steve chuckled, as if the question was stupid. "Because I wanna see just how similar we are, handsome." Handsome? HIM??? HIMSELF THOUGHT HE WAS HANDSOME?!?! Blush spread across Steve's face, and blood flowed elsewhere as well. "Pffttt- well I won't turn down an opportunity to have sex with someone so hot."
Steve sat next to Horse Steve, looking him up and down as he undressed. They took off their shirts in sync, both of them getting harder as they eyed up each others bodies. Only in their boxers now, Steve rolled over to be next to the horse version of himself, bodies pressed together. He didn't think his already phat ass could get even bigger, but horse Steve proved him wrong.
Horse Steve was about to lean in for a kiss, when he suddenly got his butt squeezed, and a whinny escaped from his lips. Steve giggled, he'd never imagine himself... Making such noises. But it sounded great. He reached his hand further and circled a finger around his hole, teasing him through his underwear. "Got any lube?" He pressed his finger down harder and faster. "Yes!" Horse Steve whined, pleasure starting to course through his body. "Second drawer of my night stand!" He huffed out, starting to slide down his boxers. Steve flipped over and opened the drawer, quickly finding the lube. He also saw a condom, but,, he wanted to do this rawww.
He turned back to his counterpart and squirted the lube onto his fingers, licking his lips as he did. Horse Steve presented his ass in the air, lifted his tail, and pissed. Steve froze in shock. Did he seriously just pee?? Horse Steve blowed, wiggling his butt a little. "Waht are you doing??" Steve spread apart his cheeks and stuck his middle finger into his asshole. "Uhhh why'd you just piss" Horse Steve squealed, feeling himself tighten around the finger. "I'm ready to mate!" Steve didn't quite understand, but he didn't need to to take pleasure in the neighs that were coming from his horse self.
Steve stuck another finger in, almost done preparing him for his dih. After a minute of scissoring motions, he pulled his fingers out and wiped them off on his boxers. He pulled off his underwear and watched as his hard cock was dripping a bit of precum. He squeezed the bottle of lube again, getting it all over his hand. He spread the liquid all over his shaft, getting it nice and slippery.
Horse Steve flipped over and compared their dicks to each others, same length, girth, tip color, balls.. Steve thought he oughta try something with their dihs being so close to each other. He wrapped his fingers around both of their cocks, stroking his hand up and down. He pumped his hand quicker, getting whines and whimpers out of both of them. Steve kept going until they were both close to cumming, so he pulled his hand away. They weren't done just yet.
Horse Steve climbed on top of Steve, leaning down and kissing him. He nickered as he ran his hands through his counterparts short, blonde hair, positioning himself to be more in line with his cock. Steve pulled back and looked into horse Steve's eyes, letting his hands slip onto his waist. His fingers made their way back to the others cheeks and spread them, bucking his hips up and thrusting his dick in. Horse Steve pulled on Steve's hair as he was fucked, he never imagined this is what it felt like when he had sex with others. Just as he thought it couldn't feel better, Steve hit his g-spot. Steve's tip hit it again and again, and they cummed at the same time. Steve got a load of semen in his face, and what better to do than wipe it off his face? He licked it off his face the most he could. Damn. His cum tasted great.
After the clean up of their breeding, the Steve's just cuddled together in the freshly sheeted bed. It was smooth, soft, and silky. The bed sucked Steve in, and the soft, familiar humming of his counterpart lulled him to sleep.
When Steve awoke, he found himself himself in Jimmy's bed, his head in Jimmy's lap as he was humming to Steve. "Jimmy?" He mumbled as he sat up, stretching his arms out. Jimmy looked down at him and smiled. "Good fucking morning. You must've had a good fucking sleep, didnt ya? You got a whole fucking load of cum in your pants!" Steve started blushing, looking in his pants to see just how much he came. He glanced back up at Jimmy with a smirk. "Wanna take a shower together?"
THE END ✨ thanks fur readin