Work Text:
Hawkins, Indiana has been through a lot in the past five years. A missing kid coming back after he was presumed dead, the new state-of-the-art mall to be created, only for it to be shut down after a month due to the Russians using it as a front, and the killer, an inhuman monster trying to bridge time travel in an alternate dimension to Earth. If you can think of something, chances are it has probably happened in Hawkins, but ten times worse.
But through every disaster, one thing in Hawkins never wavered: Enzo’s.
The little Italian restaurant had been opened by Giuseppe and Maria Ruzzo as an homage to Maria’s father, Vincenzo. They shortened the name to Enzo’s, and the rest was history. Warm, familiar, and always lit by the glow of good food and better company, Enzo’s became a haven for anyone who walked through its doors.
Maria and Giuseppe knew everyone who walked through their doors and every quirk that came with their orders. They knew that police chief Jim Hopper liked extra sauce on his pasta, while his girlfriend Joyce Byers liked the cheese on her chicken parm to be burnt to a crisp. The duo also knew all the town gossip, whether they knew it or not. The biggest news of the year was that Jim Hopper was finally going to propose to Joyce after taking her on their first date three years prior. Maria might have been eavesdropping on Joyce’s son, Jonathan, when he told his girlfriend, Nancy, the news.
Maria nearly dropped the bread basket mid-delivery to a table when she heard it. Jonathan wasn’t loud by any means. He was a quiet kid, had always been during his time eating at the restaurant whether with the Byers or just Nancy. Though, Maria noted, he was always a little more animated when it was just Nancy. Jonathan leaned in closer to Nancy, a voice low trying not to tell the entire restaurant but Maria who had hearing sharper than kitchen knives did not miss a single word.
“This Saturday night,” Jonathan whispered, glancing around as if the pictures on the walls might be bugged. “He’s doing it then. Told Will and me this morning. He’s got the ring and everything. Hop even pulled me aside and asked if I’d come separately to get photos of it happening.”
Nancy’s eyes grew wide and full of excitement. “Jonathan, you know that I’m coming with you, right? No one is going to question if I’m with you when he pops the question. Just say that you’re on a date with me if anyone asks.”
Jonathan sighed, but there wasn’t a hint of real protest behind it. “Yeah, yeah, I figured,” he said, rubbing the back of his neck. “Just don’t get too excited when you see them walk in, I have no idea what part of the dinner he is asking her. If Hop sees us before it happens, he might chicken out and I don’t want to be the reason it doesn’t happen.”
Nancy smirked. “Jonathan, honey, I love you—but if you think Hopper isn’t going to ask your mother to marry him after everything they’ve been through, you’re batshit insane.”
“I know Nance, I just don’t want to cause him extra stress, which is why I’m going to tell them that I’m going to pick you up at your house and take some amazing photos of you, then take you for a quick dinner at Enzo’s before I take you back to my house for the rest of the night on Saturday. And if we run into my mom and Hopper while here, we’ll just say it’s a coincidence,” Jonathan quipped back.
Nancy raised an eyebrow, pretending to look offended. “Oh, so I’m just bait now? A distraction dinner date?”
Jonathan chuckled, the sound soft but warm. “You’re not bait. You’re moral support. And the only person I know who can keep me from overthinking myself into a fucking coma about this. It’s why I love you, Nancy Wheeler.”
Nancy leaned across the table, brushing his hand with hers. “Jonathan Byers, if anyone overthinks themselves into a coma, it’s going to be you. But I’ll be there. And I’m excited. Your mom deserves this more than anyone.”
Maria, who had been pretending to wipe down a spotless counter, felt her heart melt. Young love, a proposal in the works, and a Saturday night that was shaping up to be a dream. Enzo’s hadn’t been this exciting since the mayor passed out in the marinara ten years ago.
She forced herself to keep walking, chin high, expression neutral, as if she hadn’t just heard the next chapter in the Byers-Hopper saga. But the moment she pushed through the swinging kitchen doors, she grabbed Giuseppe’s arm.
“Giuseppe! You are never going to believe the news I just heard coming from Jonathan Byers of all fucking people. Hopper is proposing to Joyce. He’s got a ring and everything,” Maria practically shrieked in joy to Giuseppe.
Giuseppe didn’t look up from the dough he was shaping. “Maria, amore, I know. You told me this morning.”
“No,” she insisted, gripping his forearm. “THIS is new. They’re coming here Saturday. Jonathan will be taking photos. Nancy will be there distracting slash giving Jonathan moral support. Maria Ruzzo will be overseeing romantic ambiance.” She pressed a hand dramatically to her chest. “This is destiny.”
“It’s dinner,” Giuseppe corrected. “With sauce. And meatballs.”
Maria waved a dismissive hand. “You wouldn’t understand. You’re just a man. This has to be important for Joyce after the shitshow Lonnie put her through.”
Outside the kitchen doors, Jonathan and Nancy began gathering their belongings. Nancy shrugged on her coat while Jonathan tucked his camera bag under his arm—the same one he carried everywhere, patched up with duct tape and old stickers.
“You want to come over after dinner tonight?” Nancy asked softly. “We can practice angles. You know—surprise engagement photography techniques?”
Jonathan smiled. “Yeah. I’d like that.”
As they walked out, the bell above the door chimed. Maria darted to peek around the corner, watching them disappear down the sidewalk, their heads leaned close together, laughing about something only the two of them understood.
When she stepped back inside, she found Giuseppe staring at her knowingly.
“What?” she asked.
“You’re going to rearrange the whole restaurant for this, aren’t you?”
“Absolutely. This has to be perfect.”
“I knew it.”
Maria was already pulling out her notebook. “We need soft lighting. Maybe the red tablecloths. And the candles, not the tiny ones, the tall ones. Oh! And the garlic knots shaped like hearts—”
“No,” Giuseppe said.
“Yes,” Maria insisted.
“No,” he repeated. “We tried those once. They looked like deflated footballs.”
Maria paused. “Fine. But we are getting fresh flowers. Do not ruin this for them, Giuseppe. I want this to be the best proposal the town of Hawkins has seen. No bullshit, and I mean that.”
Giuseppe sighed knowingly. “Fine.”
Before they could continue arguing lovingly about décor, the front bell chimed again. This time, it was Joyce with windblown hair, a stack of envelopes clutched in her arms, and her purse sliding off her shoulder like she sprinted all the way from Melvald’s.
“Maria,” Joyce said breathlessly. “Do you have a minute?”
Maria straightened immediately. “For you? Always. What’s wrong?”
Joyce huffed, dropping her mail on the counter. “Is Hopper acting strange when he comes in here? Because at home he’s been—” she made a vague circular motion with her hands—“like this. Quiet. Fidgety. Checking his pockets like he’s hiding contraband.”
Maria blinked innocently. “Contraband? What are you talking about contraband?”
“I don’t know! Tools? Receipts? Snacks he doesn’t want me to know about?” Joyce let out a frustrated groan. “He’s planning something. And usually when Jim plans something, it’s because he broke something else.”
Maria forced a calm smile even as her insides fizzed like soda. “Joyce, take a breath. Jim’s fine.”
“Are you sure?”
“Positive.” She patted Joyce’s hand. “If he’s acting strange, it’s probably… a good reason. A very good reason.”
Joyce squinted. “You know something.”
Maria froze. “What? Me? No. Know something? About what?” She waved a hand too fast. “I know nothing.”
Giuseppe snorted from the kitchen, overhearing the girl's conversation.
Joyce’s suspicious expression softened into a tired smile. “Okay. I’ll trust you. I just… I want to believe it’s something good.”
“It is,” Maria promised, squeezing her hand. “I can guarantee it is.”
Joyce nodded slowly, gathering her mail again. “Alright. I’m holding you to that, Maria.”
As she left the restaurant, the bell chimed again, and the door clicked shut behind her.
Maria let out the world’s largest sigh of relief.
Giuseppe leaned on the counter. “You’re going to implode before Saturday.”
Maria pointed at him. “No. I am going to make magic before Saturday. Absolute magic.”
And she meant it.
Because if Jim Hopper was going to propose at Enzo’s, Maria Ruzzo was going to make sure it was the most perfect, unforgettable proposal Hawkins had ever seen—no Russians, no conspiracies, no emergencies.
Just love, pasta, and maybe those heart-shaped garlic knots.
Even if they looked like deflated footballs.
Two days had passed while Maria got everything ready for Hopper’s proposal. She managed to find a vintage bottle of wine that she got from her parents as a wedding gift to Giuseppe and wanted to give it to the happy couple during their meal. She also picked the perfect spot to reserve for the two of them, just in the back enough for a private moment but also near the middle where Jonathan would be sitting with Nancy while it happened.
By Saturday afternoon, Enzo’s looked like Maria had single-handedly taken on the role of wedding planner, set designer, and emotional support chef. Candles flickered on every table, their light softened by the sheer cream curtains Maria had hung, and fresh bouquets of roses, daisies, and lavender added splashes of color to each corner. Heart-shaped garlic knots topped the bread baskets—slightly more heart than deflated football, thanks to Giuseppe’s careful shaping and her relentless supervision. Soft Italian jazz hummed through the speakers, mingling with the gentle clatter of dishes as the last few lunch patrons trickled out.
The bell over the door chimed as Jonathan and Nancy stepped inside, bringing in a swirl of cold air and the faint smell of snow. Jonathan looked like he was trying to fold himself into his camera bag, while Nancy strode in confidently, cheeks pink from the cold and excitement.
“You look like a kid at Christmas,” Nancy brushed a bit of snow from her hair, and Jonathan caught himself staring a second too long before looking away.
Not now, he reminded himself. Focus on the photos, not her smile.
“I’m trying to be invisible,” Jonathan muttered, gripping his camera bag straps. “But it’s impossible. I’m basically a neon sign that says I’m here for the proposal, although I think someone already got the memo that he’s doing it tonight.”
Nancy laughed softly. “You’re doing fine. Remember—just relax and get the shots. I’ll be happy to be a distraction anytime you need it.”
Before Jonathan could answer, Maria spotted them.
And smiled like a cat who had just found two unattended, nervous mice.
“Ah! The lovebirds have arrived!” she declared, sweeping toward them with her arms wide open, kissing each of them on the cheek, like family would. “Jonathan! Nancy! You’re early. Early is good. Early means prepared. Early means romance!”
Jonathan froze. “Maria, please.”
“We’re here for dinner,” Nancy said, barely containing her smile.
“Dinner!” Maria echoed dramatically. “Yes. Food. Nourishment. Cover story.” She wiggled her eyebrows. “Mamma mia, perfection.”
Jonathan closed his eyes. “Oh my God.”
Maria leaned in, stage-whispering loud enough for Giuseppe to hear in the back, “You two look adorable. Very subtle. Totally inconspicuous. No one will ever suspect you’re here to secretly photograph an engagement.”
Jonathan’s head snapped up. “Maria!”
“What? You think Hopper can hear me from here? He’s probably at home checking his pockets like he lost his lungs and practicing his speech.”
Nancy nudged him, laughing. “See? Maria gets it.”
“Of course I get it,” Maria said proudly, hand over her heart. “If love were an Olympic sport, I would have three gold medals, a Wheaties box, and my own parade.”
Jonathan groaned. “Why did we come early again?”
“Because you love me,” Nancy said sweetly while giving him a quick kiss. “And because you carry the camera.”
Maria gasped. “Speaking of love—any spontaneous engagement plans of your own? I still have the candles and heart-shaped garlic knots ready!”
“Maria,” Jonathan choked, “we talked about this.”
“Yes, yes, ‘someday.’ I know.” She waved it off. “But look at you two! Coordinated outfits. Matching excitement levels. You’re glowing.” She squinted. “Or maybe that’s just the lighting I personally spent hours perfecting for this momentous occasion in Enzo’s history.”
“Mostly the lighting,” Nancy said with a grin.
Maria clapped her hands lightly and gestured toward the back. “Come, I’ve saved you guys the best vantage point. And don’t touch the flowers—especially the lilies. Giuseppe and I had a negotiation over those.”
Jonathan nodded solemnly, as if preparing for a battle. Nancy rolled her eyes but followed him. Together they slid into the booth Maria had chosen—the perfect line of sight to the table she had decorated for Hopper and Joyce: lace runner, tall vase with a single red rose, and the vintage wine bottle glinting softly in the candlelight.
Maria lingered, rearranging napkins that were already perfect, her eyes darting toward Jonathan every three seconds.
Finally, she leaned over their booth, lowering her voice like she was about to reveal state secrets.
“So,” she said, “how freaked out is Hopper right now? Scale of one to ‘sweating through his suit and questioning every life choice he’s ever made’?”
Jonathan let out a small laugh. “Definitely the second one. He’s pacing. Checking his pockets. Muttering. It’s… intense. He told me right before I left to pick up Nancy that my mom ‘deserves something good. something… stable’ and I agree. I know my dad was a piece of shit, she deserves this more than anyone.”
Maria pressed both hands dramatically to her heart. “Perfectly nervous! Romantic chaos! He cares. This is how you know.”
Nancy snickered. “You’re enjoying this way too much.”
“I’m professionally enjoying it,” Maria corrected. “Someone has to keep Hopper from imploding before the magic moment.”
Jonathan leaned back, smiling now. “If anyone can calm him down, it’s you.”
“Exactly.” Maria winked. “I’ll even whisper encouragement if he needs it. Maybe a little Italian pep talk over the pasta. They’ll survive. And Enzo’s will witness the perfect proposal!”
Jonathan shook his head, amused. “Maria, you’re insane… but in a good way.”
Maria patted his shoulder. “Good. Because by the end of tonight, Hopper is going to be a married man, Jonathan. And Enzo’s will be famous—not for monsters, not for mall closures, but for love.”
Jonathan’s shoulders relaxed. “He’s lucky to have you helping.”
Maria’s smile softened. “Of course he is. Now—what time are they supposed to be coming for dinner?”
Jonathan checked his watch again, though he’d already done so three times since they’d sat down. “They’re supposed to be here around seven,” he said. “Joyce said they were running some errands first, so… we’ve got time.”
Maria inhaled sharply. “Time is good. Time means preparation. Time means romance.” Then her eyes narrowed. “Time also means I will fluff the table again.”
“You’ve fluffed it twice already,” Nancy pointed out, amused.
“Yes, and now I will fluff it a third time. Don’t ask questions, you don’t want answers to Ms. Wheeler,” Maria declared, marching away with dangerous determination.
Giuseppe emerged from the kitchen just long enough to mutter, “If she fluffs that table again, the table will disappear,” before returning to the safety of his garlic knots in the kitchen.
Jonathan exhaled long and slow, settling more into the booth. The restaurant was still fairly empty—only a couple finishing coffee in the corner—and the soft lights made everything look warm and intimate.
“So,” Nancy said, nudging him playfully, “since we’re officially ‘on a date,’ Mr. Byers, what are you ordering? And don’t say you’re too nervous to eat.”
Jonathan lifted a shoulder. “Okay, but I’m too nervous to eat.”
“Wrong answer.” She handed him a menu. “Pick something.”
He chuckled and obeyed, scanning options he’d known for years. “Uh… maybe the chicken piccata. I want something hearty but not too messy to eat, you know?”
Nancy nodded approvingly. “Good. And I’ll get the ravioli. That way we can switch halfway so I get the better dish.”
Jonathan laughed. “You always do that.”
“It’s part of my charm.”
Maria swooped back in suddenly—because of course she did—eyes wide with expectation. “Are my two favorite fake daters ready to order?”
Nancy raised an eyebrow. “Fake daters?”
“Yes, fake!” Maria whispered conspiratorially. “You are here on a romantic outing. For distraction. For cover story. For ambiance.” She winked. “I approve of the commitment to the bit.”
Jonathan slid the menus toward her. “We’ll take the chicken piccata and the ravioli.”
“I knew it,” Maria said proudly. “The romance dishes.”
“Maria, I’ve been coming here for as long as I can remember, what the fuck are you talking about when you say ‘there are romance dishes’?” Jonathan asked weakly.
“There are now,” Maria declared, sweeping away.
Once she disappeared, Nancy leaned her chin on her hand, studying him with warm eyes. “You okay?”
“Yes,” Jonathan said immediately. Then, reflexively, “No.”
Nancy reached across the table and took his hand. “Jonathan, you’re allowed to be nervous. This is huge.”
“I know. I’m just… excited for her. And terrified I’ll screw up the photos.”
“You won’t.”
“You don’t know that.”
“Yes, I do,” she said simply. “Because when it matters, you always show up. You always get it right. You always have.”
Jonathan’s breath caught a little at the sincerity in her voice.
“…thank you,” he said softly.
“You’re welcome.” She squeezed his fingers. “Now relax. Eat some carbs. Pretend you’re on a date with me.”
“That part isn’t hard,” he laughed softly before he could stop himself.
Nancy’s eyebrows lifted, a slow smile spreading. “Oh? Smooth, Byers.”
He turned red immediately. “I didn’t mean—well, I did mean—but not—”
Nancy leaned over the table and kissed him quickly. “Stop talking. Just make it through the rest of this and I promise you tonight will be all worthwhile.”
He did.
Their food arrived not long after, Maria placing the plates gently as if they were fragile evidence in a police investigation. “There,” she whispered. “Eat. Flirt. Look natural. I will be timing everything until seven.”
As Maria glided away, Jonathan shook his head. “She’s really into this.”
“Understatement,” Nancy murmured, adding cheese and red pepper flakes to her ravioli.
For the next half hour, they slipped into an easy rhythm—talking, laughing, sharing bites of each other’s meals just like a real date.
“You always do that,” Jonathan said when she took half his chicken piccata.
Nancy nudged him. “You like it. It’s our thing.”
Jonathan paused. “Yeah… it is.”
Something in his tone softened, and Nancy looked up, her cheeks warming.
Even if this was supposed to be a cover for the photos, the moment felt real. Comfortable. Familiar. Good.
At 6:55, Jonathan checked his watch again. His heart jumped. “Okay. Five minutes.”
Nancy brushed her hand over his knee under the table. “We’re ready.”
At exactly 7:02, the front bell chimed—bright and unmistakable.
Maria froze mid-step.
Jonathan straightened so fast he nearly hit the wall.
Nancy whispered, “Showtime.”
The door swung open.
Joyce stepped in first, bundled in her coat, hair windblown, cheeks flushed. She was talking about the cold, the line at Melvald’s, something about a missing coupon.
Behind her stood Hopper.
In a navy suit.
With a tie that looked like it had been tied, untied, and re-tied about eight times.
And the expression of a man walking bravely to his doom.
Jonathan whispered, “Oh my God, he really wore the suit.”
Nancy grinned. “Maria is going to detonate.”
And that’s precisely when Maria let out a dramatic gasp loud enough to echo off the Italian jazz playing overhead.
But improbably—miraculously—she didn’t run to them.
She smoothed her apron, inhaled deeply, and walked toward the entrance as though hosting a royal event.
“Joyce! Jim!” she greeted brightly. “Welcome to Enzo’s on this incredibly normal, not-at-all-special Saturday evening!”
Joyce blinked. “Um… thanks?”
Hopper cleared his throat, then immediately checked his inner jacket pocket again. He tugged at his collar again, very nervous to everyone but Joyce, not wanting to ruin the moment.
Jonathan whispered, “He’s gonna tear a hole in that suit.”
Nancy murmured, “If he hasn’t already.”
Maria guided them to the table she’d been fussing over all afternoon. “Your usual spot,” she said, a little too brightly.
As Joyce sat, Hopper pulled out her chair, and she kissed his cheek—sending his face instantly pink.
Across the room, Jonathan lifted his camera discreetly, testing angles.
Nancy rested her head gently on his shoulder. “This is going to be perfect.”
Maria returned to their booth, breathless, glowing, vibrating with romantic adrenaline.
“Okay,” she whispered. “They’re here. They’re seated. The lighting is perfect. My soul is not, but everything else is ready.”
Jonathan steadied his camera. “Now we wait.”
Maria clasped her hands together as Hopper reached across the table and took Joyce’s hand.
“Tonight,” she whispered, “Hawkins becomes a town of love again.”
Maria—who had been vibrating in place like a hummingbird on espresso—waited exactly six minutes before deciding she could not, would not, should not let Hopper and Joyce simply sit there without food.
“No,” she whispered to herself, grabbing two plates from the pass window. “They need comfort food. They need tradition. They need… their usual.”
Giuseppe watched her stacking parmesan on Joyce’s chicken parm with the intensity of a jeweler inspecting diamonds. “Maria,” he warned, “don’t smother it—”
“She likes it burnt to a crisp,” Maria shot back. “I am giving her love, Giuseppe.”
“And Hopper?”
“Extra sauce. He is a simple man. He also has bigger fish to fry right now, the least I can do is make sure he eats something that he likes.”
Giuseppe muttered something about “too much sauce being a crime,” but Maria ignored him and strutted toward the table, plates in hand, heart hammering dramatically.
Jonathan swallowed hard, camera quietly clicking into position.
Nancy whispered, “Okay, here we go…”
Maria arrived with the flourish of a stage actress making her grand entrance.
“Dinner is served!” she announced softly—but still somehow loud enough that Jonathan winced. “Joyce, your chicken parm exactly how you like it. Hopper, your pasta with enough sauce to drown in, romantic, is it not?”
Hopper stared at the mountain of red sauce. “Uh… yeah. Looks great.”
Joyce smiled warmly. “Thanks, Maria. This looks amazing.”
“You’re welcome,” Maria said, her eyes shining suspiciously bright. “Enjoy, my loves.”
She glided away only far enough to not be in the conversation but absolutely still in earshot.
Joyce cut a piece of her chicken, humming with satisfaction. “Oh, Maria never fails. Honestly, I think she’s the only one in town who knows how to burn cheese correctly.”
Hopper nodded absently.
But he wasn’t eating.
He wasn’t touching the bread.
He wasn’t even pretending to look at the menu.
He was staring at Joyce’s hands.
And then the pockets of his suit.
And then Joyce.
Nancy grabbed Jonathan’s arm signaling to him, It’s happening.
Jonathan raised his camera discreetly, heart pounding.
Joyce seemed to realize Hopper was unusually quiet. “Jim?” she asked gently. “You okay?”
He cleared his throat.
“Oh, boy,” Nancy mouthed.
Hopper pushed his plate aside a little—not rudely, just enough to create space between them. His leg bounced under the table. He swallowed once, twice, three times.
Finally, he reached into his jacket pocket—but froze, as if the world had narrowed to this one impossible moment. His hands trembled, heart hammering against his ribs. Joyce tilted her head, concern mixing with curiosity. “Jim? What are you doing?”
Across the room, Maria gripped the counter like she might pass out.
Hopper inhaled deeply. His voice came out rough, low, tentative.
“Joyce… I, uh… I’ve been thinking. A lot.”
Joyce blinked, confused but listening.
Hopper tried again. “About us. About everything we’ve been through.” He laughed nervously. “And, uh… that’s a damn long list.”
Joyce smiled softly. “It is.”
“And through all of it,” he continued, eyes locked on hers, “you—somehow—kept us going. You kept me going. When I was stuck in Russia… when the kids were in danger… when this town felt like it was falling apart… you were always the one thing that felt steady. The one thing that felt right.”
Joyce’s breath caught.
Nancy squeezed Jonathan’s wrist so hard he nearly dropped the camera.
Hopper’s voice cracked, but he pushed forward.
“And after everything—everything we survived, everything we lost, everything we fought for—I realized something.” He reached into his pocket again. This time, his hand came out holding the small velvet box.
Joyce’s eyes widened.
Maria choked on her own gasp.
Jonathan began snapping photos softly, tears burning in his own eyes.
Hopper took a shaky breath. “I realized… I want the rest of my life to be with you. The quiet parts. The loud parts. The scary stuff. The boring stuff. All of it. I want to do it all with you, Joyce. You’re my home, Joyce. You always have been.”
Joyce’s hand flew to her mouth.
Hopper opened the box.
The ring caught the candlelight.
And Hopper whispered, voice trembling but certain:
“Joyce Byers, will you make me the happiest man alive and will you marry me?”
The entire restaurant seemed to stop breathing.
Maria pressed her hands to her heart, whispering prayers in Italian.
Nancy was crying silently.
Jonathan didn’t even realize his own eyes were wet.
Joyce stared at Hopper—at this man who had been her friend, her partner in chaos, her anchor—and her entire expression softened into one full of love, relief, and something long overdue.
She exhaled, tears glistening and spilling freely. Her eyes searched his face—every line, every tremble, every ounce of love he’d risked to be here. “Oh, Jim…” she whispered, voice cracking.
For a split second, Hopper’s face shifted. Fear. The kind that came from a lifetime of losing things he loved.
But then—
Joyce nodded.
Then nodded again, stronger this time, laughing through her tears.
“Yes,” she breathed. “Yes, of course I’ll marry you.”
Hopper blinked, stunned.
Nancy clapped a hand over her mouth to stop herself from squealing.
Maria did not bother to restrain herself—she let out a triumphant, operatic “MAMMA MIA!” so loud it rattled the tall candle next to Jonathan.
Hopper surged forward, relief breaking across his face like sunlight, and he stood, pulling Joyce into his arms. She wrapped her arms around his neck, burying her face against him as she laughed and cried at the same time.
“I thought—” Hopper choked out, voice shaking. “I thought you’d say no.”
Joyce pulled back just far enough to cup his cheeks. “Jim Hopper, I have loved you for years. Years. You could’ve asked me in a grocery store aisle with a plastic ring, and the answer would still be yes.”
He laughed—one of those rare, soft Hopper laughs—and rested his forehead against hers.
Jonathan snapped photos rapidly, breath tight, hands steady despite how emotional he suddenly was. Each picture was perfect—Joyce’s smile, Hopper’s trembling hands, the moment their foreheads leaned together.
Nancy leaned against him, tears spilling freely. “You’re getting all of this, right?”
“Every second,” Jonathan whispered.
Jonathan lowered his camera, feeling a rush of relief and joy. Nancy leaned against him, a soft smile on her lips. “We made it through another emotional rollercoaster,” she murmured.
He laughed softly, squeezing her hand. “Yeah… but tonight was worth it. Seeing them happy—it’s enough to fill the entire year.”
Across the room, Maria bolted straight to the kitchen to scream into a dish towel, then sprinted back out just in time to witness Hopper sliding the ring onto Joyce’s finger.
She gasped again. Loudly. Dramatically.
“HOPPER!” she cried, pointing at his hand. “You picked a good ring! I am so proud of you!”
Hopper, face red but beaming, shook his head. “Jesus, Maria…”
Joyce held up her hand, admiring the ring—simple, elegant, perfect. “Jim… it’s beautiful.”
“I wanted something classic,” Hopper murmured. “Didn’t want anything too fancy. Just something you’d like.”
“I love it,” she said, pulling him in for another kiss. “I love you.”
Maria practically dissolved grabbing Giuseppe’s arm. “Giuseppe! They’re engaged! Look! LOOK! It’s happening in our restaurant! Our Enzo’s!”
Giuseppe took one look at the couple embracing in the candlelight, then at Maria’s tear-streaked face, and sighed in affectionate resignation. “I will get the champagne.”
“You will,” Maria ordered, wiping her eyes. “You absolutely will.”
Joyce and Hopper finally sat back down—though Hopper didn’t let go of her hand for even a moment.
“Honey,” Joyce whispered teasingly, “you’re shaking.”
“I’m… relieved,” he admitted, exhaling long and hard. “And maybe still terrified.”
“Of what?”
“That you’ll wake up tomorrow and realize you could do better,” he muttered.
Joyce snorted. “Jim, you idiot. You’re it. You’ve been it for a long time.”
He smiled warmly, his thumb brushing her knuckles.
Meanwhile, Maria swept back to Jonathan and Nancy’s booth, eyes wide, hands clasped to her chest.
“It happened,” she whispered reverently. “My soul has ascended.”
“You okay there?” Nancy asked gently.
“No,” Maria said breathlessly. “I am dying in the most beautiful way.”
Jonathan lowered his camera, visibly moved. “That was… perfect.”
Maria pressed a hand to his cheek. “Jonathan, you captured magic. Your mother is going to frame these photos until the end of time.”
He laughed, blinking away tears.
“Yeah,” he said softly. “She will.”
Maria sniffed loudly, then suddenly spun on her heel. “Giuseppe! WHERE IS THE CHAMPAGNE?!”
“Here,” Giuseppe answered, walking out with a chilled bottle and four glasses—two for the couple, two for Nancy and Jonathan and whoever else Maria inevitably decided should celebrate.
Jonathan and Nancy watched as the bottle popped, Hopper nearly spilled his champagne, Joyce laughed harder than she had in years, and Maria toasted the entire restaurant as though she were presenting an award at the Oscars.
“To love!” she declared. “To hope! To surviving monsters and Russians and small-town nonsense! But mostly—TO JIM AND JOYCE!”
The restaurant erupted in gentle applause.
Hopper kissed Joyce’s temple.
Jonathan took one more picture—this one of pure happiness.
Nancy leaned into him, sighing. “Told you this would be worth it.”
“It really was,” he whispered.
Across the room, Hopper looked over and spotted Jonathan and Nancy for the first time that night.
His expression softened into something warm. Grateful. Proud.
He raised his glass slightly.
Jonathan raised his glass back.
And Nancy smiled, knowing that—finally—after everything—
The Byers and Hopper families had something good. Something joyful. Something beautiful.
Something worth celebrating.
The applause of the restaurant’s soft chatter faded into a warm buzz, settling over Enzo’s like a soft blanket. Hopper and Joyce were leaning close, fingers laced, whispering and laughing like teenagers instead of two adults who had clawed their way through hell to reach this moment.
But then Joyce looked up. Her eyes landed on Jonathan. Everything in her expression softened. She squeezed Hopper’s hand, whispered something quick, and then stood, making her way across the restaurant with that familiar mix of determination and shaking emotion that only Joyce Byers could pull off.
Nancy nudged Jonathan gently. “Brace for impact.”
Jonathan barely had time to set his camera down before Joyce launched herself at him. She wrapped him in a hug so tight he wheezed.
“Jonathan Byers,” she said, voice thick with tears and joy, “you knew. You knew and you didn’t say a word.”
Jonathan hugged her back just as tightly. “I promised him. And… I wanted it to be perfect for you.”
“Oh honey,” Joyce whispered, pulling back to cup his face in both hands. “It was perfect. More than perfect.” She pressed a kiss to his forehead. “Thank you.”
Jonathan blushed, ducking his head, unable to hide his smile. “I’m happy for you, Mom.”
Joyce’s gaze shifted to Nancy, and without hesitation, she pulled her into the hug too.
“Nancy Wheeler,” Joyce said dramatically, “thank you for keeping my son alive these past seven years.”
Nancy laughed. “Me? Hopper’s the one who almost had a panic attack.”
Joyce grinned. “Oh, trust me, I know. You should’ve seen him at home. I thought he swallowed the ring at one point.”
Jonathan choked out a laugh. “Explains the pocket checking.”
“Oh, speaking of pockets,” Joyce said, suddenly remembering. “He almost lost the ring this morning.”
“WHAT?!” Jonathan and Nancy said in unison.
Joyce threw up her hands. “He left it on the bathroom counter. The bathroom counter! El saw it first!”
Nancy slapped a hand over her mouth, trying not to cackle.
Jonathan shook his head in disbelief. “He… what? How? Why?”
“Hopper,” Joyce said simply. Fair enough.
Before anyone could say more, Maria descended upon them like a confetti cannon with legs. She swooped in between Jonathan and Joyce, grabbing both of their cheeks with her hands.
“My angels!” she cried, shaking their faces lightly. “The photos! The reactions! The ROMANCE! I am deceased. I am a ghost haunting this restaurant with LOVE!”
“Maria—” Joyce laughed, wiping tears from her eyes.
“No, no, no, don’t speak,” Maria insisted, pressing a finger to Joyce’s lips. “I have waited YEARS for this moment. YEARS. I have prayed to every Italian saint—St. Anthony, St. Rita, Frank Sinatra—everyone!”
“Maria,” Joyce repeated, gently pulling her hand away, “Frank Sinatra was not—”
“Shh,” Maria said again, deadly serious. “In my house, he is holy.”
Nancy bent over, laughing so hard she had tears forming at the corners of her eyes. Jonathan looked like he was questioning reality.
Maria turned on him next. “And YOU!” she said, pointing at him with both hands. “You captured the kiss, yes? The tears? The shaky hands? The NOSE WRINKLE Joyce does when she’s happy?!”
Jonathan blinked. “I—uh—yeah. All of it.”
Maria pressed a hand to his cheek. “Jonathan, amore,” she said, plucking his camera from his lap with pickpocket precision. “This moment belongs in history. I will capture it properly.”
Jonathan opened his mouth to protest, but Nancy just laughed, nudging him. “Let her. It’ll be memorable.”
Maria jabbed a few buttons, muttering Italian under her breath—half incantation, half instruction. “Smile… sì… Jonathan, less panic, more pride… Nancy, dazzle… Joyce, glow like the sun… Hopper, stop fidgeting with your napkin, it’s ruining the symmetry!”
The four of them leaned together, awkward grins giving way to genuine smiles. Maria clapped her hands dramatically after the click.
“Perfetto! Bellissimo! Magnifico! This—this is the moment future generations will envy!” she declared, holding up the camera triumphantly. “I have captured the soul of happiness itself.”
Jonathan groaned, but couldn’t hide his grin. Nancy elbowed him, whispering, “See? You’re in good hands.”
Joyce and Hopper exchanged amused glances, shaking their heads at Maria’s uncontainable energy.
“Well,” Joyce said softly, “thank you, Maria… for everything.”
Maria waved a hand as if to dismiss the praise. “Nonsense! I am merely doing my duty as the world’s greatest Italian, protector of romance, and curator of heart-shaped garlic knots.”
With a satisfied nod, she handed the camera back to Jonathan. “Now, young people, run along. Go home. I shall handle the cleanup, the candles, and the emotional aura. Hopper, Joyce, you dine in peace! No interruptions! Except maybe Giuseppe bringing tiramisu… that is allowed.”
Jonathan and Nancy gathered their coats, exchanging grins as they moved toward the door.
“Thanks again, Maria,” Nancy said warmly.
“Grazie, Grazie!” Maria said, twirling dramatically. “Go! Enjoy your evening knowing the world’s happiness has been perfectly documented!”
Jonathan waved sheepishly, and Nancy laughed as they slipped out into the snowy evening.
The bell chimed behind them, leaving Hopper and Joyce alone at their table.
Maria hovered for just a moment, peeking over the counter with a satisfied smile. Then, finally, she leaned back, hands on her hips.
“Finally,” she muttered to Giuseppe, “love can eat in peace.”
Giuseppe shook his head, smiling. “And I thought I was dramatic.”
Maria winked. “No, amore. I am dramatic. But in the right way.”
And with that, she disappeared into the kitchen, leaving the restaurant bathed in candlelight, soft jazz, and the warm, unhurried hum of love finally settled.
Jonathan lingered near the doorway, camera in hand. He hadn’t planned to take another shot, but the scene was too perfect to resist—the soft candlelight highlighting Joyce’s smile, Hopper’s eyes crinkling with happiness, the quiet laughter between them. He crouched slightly, careful to stay unseen, and snapped a single photo.
“Got it,” he whispered to himself, a small, satisfied grin tugging at his lips. “For the memories.”
Nancy peeked over his shoulder, smirking. “You’re hopeless. But fine… at least the house is still yours for the night.”
Jonathan chuckled softly. “Ah, that’s where you’re wrong, Nancy. The house is ours for tonight—we’re on a date, after all.”
Nancy’s eyes twinkled, and she looped her arm through his. “Oh? Just the two of us… no one to bother us?” Her voice was low, teasing. “I hope you’ve got plans to make it… interesting.”
Jonathan’s cheeks flushed, but he grinned. “Yeah… definitely interesting.”
Nancy leaned closer, brushing her hand lightly along his arm. “Good. Because I plan on making sure this date is… memorable.”
Jonathan laughed, feeling a rush of warmth. Then, without thinking, he leaned in and pressed a quick, soft kiss to her lips. Nancy grinned against his, pulling him slightly closer before breaking away, a spark of mischief in her eyes.
Jonathan’s heart raced, but he couldn’t stop smiling. “Right… memorable. Got it.”
Nancy gave him a playful nudge. “Then let’s get back to your place before we freeze out here. Private date, remember?”
Jonathan squeezed her hand, still grinning. “Lead the way, Miss Wheeler.”
Back at the table, Giuseppe quietly appeared with a tray, placing two perfect slices of tiramisu in front of them, each adorned with a small chocolate heart.
“Dessert,” he announced softly, bowing slightly. “For the newly engaged. From Enzo’s, with amore.”
Joyce’s eyes sparkled as she looked at Hopper. “You know, we can finally eat dessert without anyone yelling at us or taking pictures.”
Hopper chuckled, picking up his fork. “Yeah… just the two of us. Kind of nice, actually.”
They dug in, laughing softly and stealing bites from each other’s plates, savoring the quiet intimacy after the whirlwind of the evening.
Maria, somewhere in the kitchen, hummed a soft Italian tune, satisfied that the world’s happiness had been properly captured—and, more importantly, properly celebrated.
The warm glow of candlelight, soft jazz, and lingering scents of garlic knots and tiramisu wrapped Enzo’s in the kind of magic only love, pasta, and a little Italian flair could create—perfectly ordinary yet extraordinary, just like Hawkins at its best.