Actions

Work Header

What if

Summary:

When the villagers call it luck, Belle learns very quickly what they really mean is silence.
In another version of the tale, she marries Gaston — not out of love, but out of pressure, fear, and the promise that her father will be “safe.” The house is big, the walls are beautiful, and every room feels like it’s closing in.

Rules replace freedom. Gossip replaces truth. And Belle discovers that surviving in Gaston’s world means becoming quieter, sharper, and far more careful than any story ever warned her she’d need to be.

This is a darker “what if” — the paths the fairy tale never follows, and the costs it never counts.

Chapter 1: What If Belle Married Gaston

Chapter Text

They said she was lucky.

They said it the way people say things to keep themselves from thinking too hard.

Lucky girl.
Lucky house.
Lucky future.

Belle stood in the church doorway after the ceremony and felt nothing but a thin, cold line running down the center of her chest, as if someone had quietly opened her and removed something essential.

Gaston’s hand wrapped around hers like a clasped gauntlet.

“Smile,” he murmured through his perfect teeth. “It makes people comfortable.”

She smiled.

He squeezed harder when she didn’t do it fast enough.

The house was bigger than anything Belle had ever lived in.

That didn’t make it less of a cage.

Every room smelled faintly of polish and gunpowder, of antlers that had been ripped from skulls and mounted like reminders. Gaston’s boots clicked hard on the floors. He owned the space the way he owned everything: loudly, possessively, without doubt.

The first rule came on the second day.

“No books at the table.”

She nodded.

The second rule came the next.

“Don’t contradict me in front of people.”

She nodded again.

By the end of the week there was no need to speak rules aloud. He expected obedience the way other men expected air. And when something displeased him — her silence, her tone, the way she stared out the window too long — his hand would land on the table with a dull, patient thud.

A warning.

He never needed to hit her.

He was cleverer than that.

He learned which threats frightened her most: Maurice’s health. The villagers’ gossip. A quiet hint that accidents happen to wandering old men in winter.

So Belle learned not to wander.

She learned that survival was a language spoken softly.

The bookshop closed.

She stood in front of the door for a long time while the townspeople walked past, careful not to meet her eyes.

Gaston appeared with a smile that was all teeth.

“Not much use for books now,” he said cheerfully. “You’ve got a home to run. A husband to look after. Real duties.”

“You bought the building,” she said quietly.

The smile didn’t falter.

“It was a bad influence.”

Belle went home and took her books — the last, hidden few — and burned them in the stove because suddenly she understood:

If he found them, he would not destroy the pages.

He would destroy her father.

The flames licked up the margins as if eating her voice.

She did not cry.

Crying was the one thing Gaston could not abide. It made him feel small. And no one made Gaston feel small.

He loved to talk about himself in the evenings.

About hunts.
About admiration.
About how the world worked.

“Some people just aren’t meant to think,” he said once, swirling his drink. “Thinking ruins them. Makes them unhappy. You’re unhappy because you think too much.”

Belle stared at the portraits on the wall rather than at him. The eyes in the paintings seemed to follow her with a kind of dull horror.

“I’m unhappy,” she said, “because I’m not free.”

He laughed.

“Freedom is for men.”

He said it lightly, as if it were a weather report.

Later, in their room, he kissed her like claiming territory. His hands were careful — always careful — but the ownership in them was colder than any bruise.

Afterward, when he slept, she lay awake and counted the cracks in the ceiling, memorizing them like constellations. As long as she could count, she was still herself.

Names.
Numbers.
Thoughts.

Smuggled contraband.

The village changed around her.

People watched Belle differently — not with curiosity anymore, but with fear disguised as politeness. Women looked at her hands and spoke in hushed voices about obedience, about patience, about not provoking things best left alone.

They pretended not to notice the way Gaston’s presence silenced rooms.

Maurice stopped visiting at night because someone — Belle never learned who — whispered that old men shouldn’t travel after dark. Bad roads. Broken wheels. Wolves.

Once, he tried to take her home with him.

Gaston walked into the workshop the next day and put a hand on Maurice’s shoulder.

Such a gentle hand.

Such a soft voice.

“Your inventions are dangerous, friend. I’d hate to hear you got hurt.”

Maurice nodded, terrified and smiling.

Belle never tried to leave again.

Winter arrived hard.

Snow crusted the fields. The trees snapped in the wind. Gaston hunted constantly, as if killing was the only warmth available. He came home smelling of blood and frost, exhilarated.

Belle kept the house spotless.

She spoke less.

She watched more.

Gaston noticed the quiet.

“You’re colder than the weather,” he said one night, almost offended. “You used to have opinions.”

She met his gaze for the first time in weeks.

“You killed them.”

For a heartbeat, something ugly flickered in his face — not guilt. Never guilt.

Annoyance.

He set his glass down with surgical care.

“I gave you safety,” he said. “I gave you a name. I gave your father protection. That’s more than most women ever get.”

“If this is safety,” Belle murmured, “why does it feel like drowning?”

He stepped closer.

She did not step back.

They stood there in the dim light, the house around them so quiet it might as well have belonged to ghosts.

Finally he said, almost softly:

“Because you don’t know how to be grateful.”

Rumors began, eventually.

Not about Gaston.

About Belle.

Cold. Difficult. Arrogant. Ungrateful.

People are eager to believe anything that keeps their heroes intact.

Belle walked through the square, chin level, spine straight, carrying whatever remained of herself like a fragile ember cupped in her hands. She did not help in the ways she once dreamed — there were no lessons whispered at the well, no books passed hand to hand in secret.

But sometimes, she would meet another woman’s eyes — one bent under the weight of her husband’s voice or her father’s rage — and in that quiet look, something wordless passed between them:

I see you.

You are not crazy.

This is cruel.

It wasn’t rebellion.

It was witness.

And in a world that worshipped Gaston, that was dangerous enough.

Years later, the house still smelled of trophies and polish.

Maurice walked with a cane.

The villagers told stories about the good marriage, the strong husband, the quiet wife. Children grew up thinking this was what happiness looked like.

Belle woke every morning before Gaston and stood at the window as the sun cut the sky open like a wound.

Sometimes, just before waking, she dreamed of a castle she had never seen — of roses and snow, of a voice that spoke gently to her mind instead of shouting at her life. The dream always ended before she reached the door.

She did not know what it meant.

She only knew that when she opened her eyes, the house felt smaller than ever.

Gaston stirred.

“Coffee,” he said, still half-asleep, as if she were another piece of furniture that moved when commanded.

Belle turned from the window.

She went to the kitchen.

And as the kettle began to scream, she imagined — not escape, not miracles, not curses breaking —

Only silence.

A silence deep enough and long enough that no one’s voice could ever fill it again.

She stood there and let the water boil over, listening to the metal rattle, until Gaston called her name like a warning.

Then she turned off the flame.

And the house went quiet.