Work Text:
I Hope You Settle Down
The paperwork still exists, somewhere. It always will. Peter doesn’t look at it every day like he used to, in part because the overwhelming waves of grief have subsided to a gentle undercurrent and in part because he has every page memorized. A death certificate filed under the right name, signed by the right hands, stamped and tucked away in the right filing cabinet. That’s how the world knows Neal Caffrey now: finished, buried, and wrapped up neatly in black ink. Peter knows better. There are things that don’t add up, no matter how clean the paperwork looks.
The storage unit is one of them. A small, unremarkable space rented under a name that wouldn’t last ten minutes under scrutiny. Peter doesn’t call it proof. Proof is loud. Proof demands action, follow-up, and consequences. This is quieter than that. This is a suspicion he lives with, the way you live with a scar that doesn’t hurt anymore, but you can still feel the roughness in your skin. Something healed wrong, maybe. Something unfinished. He files it away where he’s learned to put impossible things. Right next to the memory of Neal standing in interrogation rooms like they were parlors. Right next to the rubber band ball stowed in his bottom desk drawer. Right next to the way running was a language Neal spoke more fluently than hope.
Peter finds a strange solace in knowing that no one is looking for Neal anymore. Not with warrants, not with grudges, not with guns. That was the point, he supposed, after all. To stop the chase. To let the past finally lose interest.
Peter had believed, once, in systems. In steps, and processes, and time served equaling freedom. He had believed that if Neal did everything right, if he complied, if he waited, if he proved himself again and again, there would eventually be a door that stayed open. Neal’s commutation hearings had disabused him of that notion. Death by a thousand technicalities. Watching the proceedings stretch and stall and sour, Peter began to understand that Neal’s past wasn’t something the system intended to forgive. It was leverage. It was a permanent condition. A retractable leash that the FBI could shorten at will. No matter how many cases Neal solved, no matter how much good he did, the finish line kept moving. Freedom dangled just out of reach, close enough to be cruel. Peter started to see the pattern for what it was: motion without progress. A hamster wheel disguised as redemption. Neal kept running, because that’s what he did. Stopping had never been an option anyone offered him in good faith.
That was the part that made Peter angry, though he rarely let himself name it. The way choice, redemption even, had always been an illusion; the way the world seemed invested in keeping him useful but never unburdened. How even now that Neal is free, it came with conditions. There’s no ankle tracker anymore, no threat of going back to prison, but there’s no going home either.
Peter thinks of how tired Neal was near the end. Not physically, Neal had always carried himself like someone immune to exhaustion, but something deeper, heavier. A fatigue that came from always anticipating the next knock on the door. From being captive and hunted in equal measure. By the time it ended, or by the time it was supposed to have ended, Peter had already stopped believing that Neal would ever be allowed to simply exist. Not without permission. Not without supervision. Not without owing someone something. So, if Neal is alive, and Peter believes this the way he believes in gravity, quiet and constant, then his death is the closest he’ll ever come to freedom and salvation.
Peter doesn’t try to reach across the gap between the living and the dead. He knows better than that, too. Contact would be a kind of violence; to acknowledge Neal is alive would be to pull him back into the very machinery that never stopped grinding him down. Love, Peter has learned, sometimes looks like restraint. So he stays on his side of the line. He lets the world believe what it needs to believe. He lets the ink dry and the file gather dust. He carries the frustration like a private debt, unpaid and unpayable.
If Peter allows himself one selfish hope for Neal, it’s not for greatness or reinvention. It’s for smallness. For routine. For days that don’t require aliases and exit plans. For Neal to wake up somewhere and decide, without careful calculation, that he can stay there. He hopes Neal chooses a quiet life not because he’s afraid, but because he’s earned rest. Running shouldn’t be a full-time job forever. Across the divide, Peter imagines Neal somewhere unremarkable. Somewhere boring. Somewhere safe. He imagines days that don’t feel borrowed. A life that doesn’t require contingency plans.
He hopes most of all that Neal settles down, not into obscurity, not into fear, but into stillness. He hopes he settles into a place where no one is counting his steps, a place where running is no longer the cost of being alive. Across the great divide, Peter imagines Neal finally standing still.
I Hope You Marry Rich
Mozzie has always known that death is more of a suggestion than a rule. A strong recommendation, maybe. A social contract everyone agrees not to question too closely. People disappear all the time. They reinvent. They shed old aliases and don new ones like tailored suits. Neal’s just done it more thoroughly than most.
Still, there’s something sacred about the finality of it, the way the world has accepted the lie so eagerly. A closed casket, a clean narrative, a collective agreement to stop asking questions. Proof that if you sell the story well enough, everyone buys it. Mozzie finds comfort in that. Comfort, and a certain professional pride. The con held. That matters.
Neal was never built for poverty of any kind. Not financial, not emotional, not aesthetic. He starved visibly in ugly spaces, in cheap wine, in conversations that didn’t sparkle. He could tolerate scarcity, but it always cost him something. Mozzie saw that early on the way Neal gravitated toward beauty like it was oxygen. Fine suits, clean lines, art that said something worth hearing. His crimes were curated, even his mistakes had taste.
Mozzie had spent enough time in close proximity to wager that beyond all the charm and glamor, Neal’s real vice was romance. Neal wanted love the way some people want absolution. Fully, ruinously. He pretended he didn’t, of course. Neal cloaked his desire in irony, in charm, in exits he swore he’d take before things got messy. Mozzie knew better. Mozzie knows Neal is a romantic. It’s his fatal flaw. He believes in big gestures, in once-in-a-lifetime connections, in the idea that love can be both an anchor and an escape hatch. It was his most exploitable weakness, and Mozzie guarded it like a state secret. Mozzie hopes the next version of Neal’s life lets him indulge that without consequences.
If Mozzie were the type to wish on stars, and he isn’t (stars are notoriously unreliable), he’d wish Neal abundance. Not just money, though he doesn’t kid himself, money solves a lot of problems and creates a very comfortable buffer between you and catastrophe. Money buys time. Money buys silence. Money buys the luxury of not needing to explain yourself. More than that though, Mozzie would wish Neal someone who understands the artifice. Someone who knows the man they’re loving is a construction and loves him anyway. Someone who can spot a forgery at twenty paces and choose the original. Someone rich enough (financially, emotionally, existentially) to let Neal be complicated without turning him into a project.
Marriage, Mozzie thinks, is just another kind of con. Two people agreeing to believe in the same future long enough to make it real. Assets pooled. Stories aligned. Alibis shared. When it works, it’s unbeatable. When it doesn’t, it’s catastrophic. Neal always did like high-risk ventures. He hopes Neal marries rich not out of greed, but out of adoration. Sure, he wishes Neal a love fiscally wealthy enough that no one asks questions. Financially endowed enough that there’s always a lawyer on retainer and a vacation home to disappear into. Affluent enough that running becomes optional. That’s the dream, isn’t it? Not freedom (Mozzie’s lived too long to believe in that) but safety. A soft place to land that isn’t contingent on staying useful.
Beyond economic stability and against his own beliefs with regards to the merits (or demerits) of romance, Mozzie hopes Neal catches his white whale. That Neal finds a love for the ages he doesn’t have to hide parts of himself from. That someone looks at him like he hung the stars and moon, the way Mozzie has seen Neal look at his loves like they’re the sun and everything ought to revolve around them. Intimacy was always Neal’s greatest sacrifice in this life, and Mozzie hopes he finds it in abundance in his next one.
Across the line that separates the dead from the living, Mozzie imagines Neal somewhere expensive and warm, laughing too loudly at a joke that isn’t that funny. He imagines him surrounded by art he didn’t steal and people who don’t need him to perform to find worth in him.
Mozzie doesn’t delude himself into thinking this ending fixes everything. The past has a long memory, and consequences have a way of accruing interest. But wealth, real value, turns emergencies into inconveniences. Neal deserves that much, at least. He deserves the chance to love loudly and permanently too, as much as Mozzie begrudges his romantic endeavors.
If you’re going to die, Mozzie thinks, you might as well come back to life rich in all the ways that count.
I Hope You’re Scared Of Only Ordinary Shit
Being dead is quieter than Neal expected.
Not peaceful, or restful exactly, but quiet in the way a room feels after the door finally closes. No footsteps in the hall. No voices arguing over his fate. No one watching, waiting to catch the moment he slips and proves them right. The names that used to live rent-free in his head, men who collected debts in blood and leverage, men who turned grudges into lifelong hobbies, have lost their teeth. They can’t reach him now. That was the bargain. That was the cost. He chose the grave because it was the only move that didn’t put a target on someone else’s back. He had to be the end of the line.
Death was the only exit that didn’t loop back on itself. Neal understands that now with a clarity that feels almost cruel. There was no version of his life where he walked away clean, no door he could close without someone reopening it behind him. Prison, partnership, parole, every path led back to the same place, the same watchful eyes, the same conditional mercy. So, he chose the one thing the system couldn’t revise or renegotiate. But as he was learning, escape isn’t the same as freedom. Freedom would mean he could come and go as he pleased, associate with whom he pleased, but Neal has none of that. He is unsupervised and unpursued, but also unanchored. He can never go back. Being dead cut the leash, but it also cut the map.
Beyond that, fear doesn’t evaporate just because the threat technically does. It lingers in the ordinary moments. In silence that stretches too long. In waking up without an exit plan already half-formed. In the strange vulnerability of not needing to run anymore. Neal has always understood danger; he has always been able to read it, predict it, and outmaneuver it, but respite is unfamiliar terrain. Life after death asks him to trust that nothing is coming for him next. It’s an interlude that offers no puzzle to solve, no opponent to anticipate. It simply waits. Neal has never trusted anything that waits.
He is less afraid of ghosts than he is of stillness. He’s less afraid of men who wanted him dead than of the possibility that, stripped of the chase, he might finally have to confront who he is without it. The prodigy. The con. The criminal. The asset. The problem to be managed. For years, those labels were both prison and permission. They explained everything. They justified the surveillance, the ankle monitor, the endless conditional freedom. He could tell himself it wasn’t personal; it was procedural. A system doing what systems do. But systems don’t let go. They don’t forget. They just find new language for control.
Neal remembers what it felt like to live on borrowed trust. To have his usefulness measured and recalculated. To know that no matter how many cases he closed, how many lives he saved, there would always be a clause, a caveat, a contingency. Freedom, dangled just far enough away to keep him compliant, but close enough to feel attainable. He wonders sometimes if that was the cruelest part. Not the prison, not the chase, but the way hope itself was weaponized. How staying meant never being done.
On the far side of the divide, Neal feels the weight of everyone he left behind moving forward without him. At least no one was paying for Neal’s past with their future. Peter had his faith in order and Mozzie had his faith in cleverness. He hopes quietly, cautiously, that the world stays convinced he’s gone. He hopes the story ends cleanly enough that no one goes digging. No one gets curious. No one decides to prove something. Beneath that, deeper and more fragile, is a hope he barely lets himself name.
He hopes that someday he won’t flinch at the sound of his own phone ringing. That he won’t catalogue every room for exits out of habit. That he can walk into a place and not immediately calculate how long it would take to disappear from it. That he won’t spend the rest of his life looking over his shoulder. He hopes that the man he becomes here won’t need to be brilliant just to be safe. That ordinariness won’t feel like a trap. Maybe one day, he’ll be scared of the normal things, like skin cancer. Maybe the fear will finally recalibrate and no longer about who’s coming for him, but about what it would mean to stop running from himself.
For now, being dead is enough.