Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of All’s Fair In Love And War
Stats:
Published:
2026-04-04
Updated:
2026-04-04
Words:
4,453
Chapters:
1/?
Comments:
16
Kudos:
10
Bookmarks:
5
Hits:
132

ludus and philia

Summary:

Damian has some pretty big plans for the year. He, ambitious 15 year old he is, wants to juggle becoming hall president with several other extracurriculars. And, like any normal son, learn more about his father through almost any means necessary: searching through school archives, obsessively pouring over books, listening to cassette tapes, and the like.

Which is great in Anya’s opinion! I mean, Strix has been pretty slow. Plan A, B, and C all are all technically complete? Technically is the key word because none of them have yielded world peace. But some real progress could be made this year!

Well… except for the fact that Becky is attempting to enforce an ultimatum: confess or move on. Damian, naturally, decides she’s full of it. Perhaps angering the best friend of your crush isn’t so wise, especially when you already have so much on your plate.

Shoot for the stars, Damian Desmond, because you’ll land among them! Or… burn out. Whichever comes first!

OR

Watch Damian as he navigates politics (Becky), politics (school) and even more politics (historical)!

Notes:

The naming scheme for this fic series is based off words for love. I originally got this idea because of C.S. Lewis's "The Four Loves" but in the end, I couldn't neatly pair the four loves to books for this series. And to be honest, the series had expanded beyond the original plan so there were too many books to match with just 4. I liked the idea of naming books after words for love so I went to find the "other Greek words for love" because I remembered hearing about more than 4. It sounds like there was only 4 words for love in Greek. I THINK (tis but a guess!) the rest come from The Color Wheel Theory of Love by John Alan Lee, which incorporates several other Greek and Latin words to describe types of love. I am not necessarily using every definition from John Alan Lee's theory because the theory doesn't even include philia which comes is one of the original Greek words for love. Plenty of people seem to break John Alan Lee's wheel down and just include it in list for Greek words for love which made it fair game for me in my opinion.

Now. Ludus and Philia. What do they mean?

Ludus: Means "game, sport, or play" or "school"
This is typically associated with puppy love, early stages of romance, and low commitment to non official relationships. It's very playful, teasing, and generally lighthearted.

Philia: Means friendship
I don't really have to explain this one so I'll take this time to say that friendship is a huge part of this fic. In many ways, it is a friendship fic just as much as it is a ship fic. You'll see what I mean over the course of the book. I will also go ahead and say that if you do not have a strong love for Ewen and Emile by the end of the book, I have failed my job. (I think if you're reading this fic you'll already have that strong love for Anya, Damian and Becky.)

How fitting I FINALLY get around to posting the beginning of a fic series themed around love on Easter- a day celebrating the resurrection of Christ who was and is the manifestation of God's love (1 John 4:9-10).

Perhaps less fitting is the fact that this series opens with two characters fighting LOL. Or maybe it's very fitting because have you seen humanity? LOL

Anyway. Thank you for deciding to read this fic! Happy Easter. Or not, if you're reading this at a later date- in which case, happy normal day!

Chapter 1: Ultimatum

Summary:

Becky attempts to have a serious talk, er, interrogation, with Damian about his behavior for the past ten years. He is uncooperative so it quickly devolves into chaos. Oh, and Wiesel’s there too.

Notes:

SHOUT OUT TO MY BETA READER CRAFTIDORE BTW 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️ he rocks! He doesn't have an Ao3 account right now but he will in 15 days. Everyone applaud because this man does not have social media. He’s making one just to interact with this fic. The sacrifices made by beta readers everyone. 👏👏👏

The formatting in this chapter might be mid because I did the last minute formatting myself. 💀 I didn’t get a second opinion on them. So. Oops. Shouldn’t be too big of a deal, this chapter is not nearly as experimental in formatting as some of the other chapters. Shout out to Craftidore again for agreeing to help me with that. I have the coolest beta reader and I will not accept any arguments on why not at this time. Or any time really

If there are any other mistakes this chapter, that’s (probably) my fault because I ALSO did some last minute edits and said “THIS IS GETTING POSTED TODAY.” Because I said that exact thing. Several other times. For weeks. But this time I finally meant it!!

The first chapter was going to be 12k+ words before my beta, Craftidore, told me to split the chapter up. It’s funny because I was originally against this scene alone being the first chapter. I had considered it and decided it against it until Craftidore encouraged me to split it. This could’ve been out way earlier sighhh…

OH WELL! We’re here now, aren’t we gang? Please enjoy this chapter.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Everyone has a secret side they don't show to other people. Not to friends. Not to lovers. Not even to family. 

"I've been expecting you, Desmond," came a voice from a jet black office chair. 

They hide who they are behind lies and painted smiles.

"What do you want, Blackbell?" 

The jet black chair swiveled around, revealing Becky stroking her dog, Wiesel, in her lap. "I don't know, what do you want?" She asked with a mocking sweetness. 

And thus Eden Academy maintains its thin veneer of peace.

"What's that supposed to mean?" Damian raised his brow. "I want a lot of things." He shrugged. "You'll have to be more specific," he sneered, matching her faux smile with his own. 

"Evasive as ever," Becky scoffed. "You know what I'm talking about.  It's why you're here."

Damian shifted uncomfortably before plastering his smile back on. "I have no idea what you're talking about." He tapped his chin with a finger. "I'm here to enjoy the company of my peers and celebrate the beginning of a new school year." 

Becky crouched and let Wiesel down from her lap.  "Oh, I'm sure you just want to enjoy the company of your classmates. More like 'a classmate,' singular," Becky remarked, staring Damian straight in the eyes. "Namely, Anya?"

Damian froze. He side-eyed Becky.  "You never answered my question."

"You never answered mine." Becky shrugged.

"See, the thing is, I asked first."

"Yes, well, you're in my house." She smiled as she leaned towards him, her chin resting on her folded hands.

Right. Getting kicked out before he could even talk to Anya would be less than ideal. It would be best if he could avoid upsetting her. He scanned the room, taking in the grimy brick walls and muddied tiled floor. "Nice place you've got here," he scoffed.

Becky ignored the comment. "Why don't you sit?"

"No thanks." 

"Sit."

"Nah. Don't feel like it."

"Sit. Down." She narrowed her eyes. "Or I'm throwing you out." 

Damian yielded and plopped down into the cool, steel chair across from her.

"Wonderful. Let's begin."

FWEEEEET!

Wiesel pattered over with a binder in her mouth.

"Of course your dog is in on it too." Damian rolled his eyes.

Becky snatched the binder. "Wheezy, ignore this horrible man."

Wiesel nodded once in reply before hopping down and scurrying off to the corner of the room. She re-emerged from the shadows, dragging an office chair with her teeth. She paused, then barked. Becky nodded once. Wiesel hopped up onto her hind legs and shoved the chair forward. It shot across the floor until Becky grabbed it by an armrest. Wiesel trotted back over.

Damian blinked.

"Who's a good girl? You are! Yes! You are!" Becky cooed, cradling and petting Wiesel in her arms. Becky turned to Damian and gave him a dirty look. "Never insult my baby girl again. She's more capable than you'll ever be." 

Becky spun the chair around, revealing a vibrant pink dog bed in the seat. She kissed Wiesel gently, then placed the dog onto the chair.

Damian opened his mouth again but Becky raised an open palm. "That wasn't an invitation to speak." Becky opened the binder. "You have quite the track record."

"I'm a Desmond. Of course I do." Damian smirked, leaning back in his chair.

"That's not what I meant."

"I guessed not, but quite frankly, I don't care!" Damian chuckled.

"How do you feel about Anya?"

"I could care less," Damian replied coolly.

"So you admit you care some."

Damian's face suddenly lit up crimson. The front legs on his chair slammed back onto the ground. He glared at Becky. "I did not!"

"So you deny it." Becky frowned. "Okay, let's try this again."

"No one likes you, Blackbell," Damian grumbled.

"Demonstrably untrue." Becky examined her nails, then her eyes flicked up to meet his. "Anya likes me."

Damian kicked her under the table. "Oops. My leg slipped!"

"You're sitting down!"

"I am aware." Damian grinned. "I'm just... soooooo clumsy," Damian posited, smiling into his hand.

Becky sighed. "Well, I tried to be civil but I am ultimately loyal to Anya, not morality."

"What." Damian sat upright.

"I am a loyal friend." Becky's voice quavered. "I'm sorry Desmond," she said, looking down at the table.

Damian squinted at her suspiciously. "Why are you apologizing?"

"'Cause I'll interrogate you like the SSS!" Becky declared, grinning and giving him a double thumbs up.

"Pardon?" Damian blinked as if seeing better would change what he heard.

Becky clicked on the desk lamp, blinding him. He immediately recoiled and hissed. "Ow! Do you have to shine that in my face?" He rubbed his eyes. "I don't have to tell you anything!" 

Becky turned the lamp away, temporarily restoring his vision. Becky was glaring at him, gripping the binder and a pen. "Evasive," Becky concluded, scribbling in her binder. "Probably malicious intentions."

"WHAT? NO! I DON'T HAVE MALICIOUS INTENTIONS!" Damian shouted. "But. Like. It's just I'm 100% benevolent all the time! HAHAHA." Damian laughed awkwardly and loudly. "I don't have intentions with her! At all." 

Becky made a loud incorrect buzzer sound. "Yeah... your tsundere act isn't endearing anymore."

Damian's hands fell to his sides. "What is a tsundere?" 

"What are you, a cave dweller?" Becky laughed. "Oh, you're serious. Geez, you live under a rock."

"Those are insults, not an answer to my question. Or are you too dumb to recognize the difference?"

"Read a dictionary! ANYWAY!" Becky waved a hand. Then she directed the light right back into his eyes.

"Could you quit it?! It hurts!" He hissed. 

Becky slid him a compact mirror. "Aw, do you not want to see what a hot mess you are?" 

"I can't see at all!" Damian seethed, shielding his eyes with his hands to glare at Becky.

"Oh? You can't?" Becky tilted the mirror to reflect the light back into his eyes.

"AGGGGHHH!" Damian shrieked, slapping his hands over his face. "STOP!"

"Your behavior is unacceptable. And so are those eye bags..." Becky clicked her tongue disapprovingly. "The shadows under your eyes extend to your very soul." She shook her head.

"NOT how shadows work," Damian snarled.

"Yes, but it is how metaphors work, Desmond!" Becky nodded condescendingly. Wiesel barked and pawed at Becky. "Fine, fine, I won't shine the light in his eyes. You're right, it's counterproductive. He should be seeing the light metaphorically not literally…" She sighed, slumping into her hand. 

Why was Becky being so mean to him? Why was the dog being so nice to him? Was there mercy in this world? Wiesel pawed Damian gently, staring into Damian's soul with big puppy dog eyes.

No. It had to be a trap. Becky corrupts everything she touches, even dogs.

Wiesel barked.

"Well, that didn't work!" Becky clapped her hands together. "Back to torture methods!" she declared with a cheery smile.

"What."

Becky blew her whistle. FWEET! And again. FWEET! FWEEEEET!

Damian's jaw dropped. "You're joking."

FWEET! "Nope!" FWEET!

Damian winced, hands zipping to protect his ears. "Would you quit it?!"

That only made the whistles louder. FWEET! Wiesel began to howl along. FWEET!

"SHUT UP!" Damian demanded. Becky shook her head.

FWEET! Becky clicked the table lamp off. FWEET! She tugged on a pull chain to a hanging, overhead light. FWEET! Becky tugged again and the overhead light turned off. FWEET! FWEET! FWEET! FWEET! FWEET! On. Off. On. Off. Then on.

Damian cringed. "IF I WAS AN EPILEPTIC, YOU WOULD'VE GIVEN ME A SEIZURE BY NOW!"

The whistle dropped from Becky's lips momentarily. Becky scooted her chair back and forth, generating an ear-splitting screeching sound. "THING IS, I KNOW YOU'RE NOT ONE, SO IT'S FAIR GAME!"

"YOU'RE THE WORST!" Damian shouted. His glare flickered in and out with the overhead lamp.

"GOOD! MAYBE YOU'LL SELF-REFLECT!"

 FWEET! FWEET! FWEET! On. Off. On. With a SCREEEECH, Becky pushed herself away from the table. FWEET!

"Whew, I can finally see again." Damian smiled, grateful for even the slightest reprieve in this cacophony of annoyances.

FWEET! Becky pulled a balloon from under her chair and slingshotted it at Damian's face. FWEET!

Damian smacked it off, only to find Becky standing back in front of him. She snatched the balloon. FWEET! Becky rubbed the balloon against Damian's hair while Damian batted at her hands. FWWWEEEEEET!

Damian covered his ears once more, recoiling. "I HATE YOU!" He snarled. FWEET! Becky mockingly fluttered her eyelashes at him. "NO ONE LIKES YOU!" She rolled her eyes. FWEET!

One of Becky's hands zipped back up to the overhead lamp. FWEET! Off. Damian's eyelids snapped shut. FWEET! On. "WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS?!" FWEET! Off. His hair tingled at the gathering static electricity. fwwWEEEEEEET! On.

And suddenly, silence. Well, except for the overhead lamp's faint buzzing. Damian's eyes fluttered open and his hands pried themselves off his ears. How annoying. Damian leaned back in his chair, inhaling deeply.

"Take a guess why."

"Why what?"

"Why I'm doing this."

The front legs of Damian's chair slammed back onto the ground. "If you want me to play guessing games with you," Damian said, propping an elbow onto the table, "maybe you should do that before you piss me off." He rubbed his temples.

Becky crept forward and slapped his arm with the balloon.

Damian looked up at her. "What?"

She blinked. "Hold on."

"Holding..." Damian said blankly, staring into space.

"Thanks." Becky whacked his arm with the balloon again.

"What... what are you doing?" Damian asked.

Becky huffed. "Currently? Failing." She pinched the bridge of her nose. "Okay! One more time!" She tapped Damian's arm with the balloon.

"Seriously, what are you doooo...ingg..." Damian's voice trailed off, his open palms curling in on themselves. "Oh." Damian glanced down at the balloon then back up at Becky. "Ooooh." He pointed a finger at her. "You're," he concluded triumphantly,  "trying to shock me."

"No!" Becky blurted out, hiding the balloon behind her back. "I mean, yes!" She slapped her forehead. "I mean-" She cut herself off and stared at the floor.

Damian laughed, smacking the table with his fist. "Ooh, that's rich. Probably richer than our families' wealth combined."

Becky flushed, knuckles whitening around the knot of the balloon. "It isn't that funny."

Damian smoothed his hair back down. "It's okay Blackbell. It definitely is that funny." He smirked, locking eyes with her.

Becky's shoulders sagged. "Can you just... take it and shock yourself please?" She extended the balloon out to him.

Damian snorted. He slapped a hand over his mouth. He stared at the balloon. He snickered. He looked away, then back again. His eyes darted up to meet Becky's. "You're serious. I cannot believe you're serious."

"That's not an answer to my question!" Becky stomped.

Damian coughed to hide another laugh. "Sure. I'll shock myself. Give me the balloon." His straight face faltered and he cracked a smile.

"Great!" Becky cheered.

"Are you going to say thank you too?" His eyes followed the balloon as she approached.

"I don't see why not. Thank you." Becky handed him the balloon.

"And thank you... FOR BEING SO DUMB!" Damian cackled, lunging forward and shocking her with the balloon.

"OW! You traitor!" Becky gasped, jumping back.

"I'm not a traitor if we're on different sides. That's the fault of the scenario you created."

"You are so untrustworthy! I don't know why anyone trusts you with ANYTHING!" Becky retorted.

Damian's lips curled up into a smile against his best efforts. "Becky, it seems you've forgotten that you asked me to shock myself. Do you realize how stupid it was to hand me a weapon when you've been messing with me?"

"A balloon isn't a weapon." Becky muttered.

"Whatever you say." Damian rolled his eyes. "I do intend to fulfill my promise. I still refuse to use my hair to charge it though."

"Because of Anya?" Becky crossed her arms.

"So I still have the balloon." Damian grinned. "Get over here." He said, teeth slightly gritted but voice still eerily sweet. "We'll use your hair."

"You're going to shock me again!"

"Because of your comment about Anya and your accusation, yeah, I might." Damian laughed, waving the balloon around mindlessly. "That's a risk you have to be willing to take."

"Seriously?! I'm not letting you shock me again!" Becky glared.

"Hurry up and get over it." Damian yawned. "Please."

Becky didn't budge.

Damian sighed. "Whatever. I'll do it myself." He rolled up his sleeve and rubbed the balloon against his arm, recharging it with static electricity. "Done. Would you like to do the honors?"

"I would. Thank you." Becky smiled.

Damian jabbed the balloon at Becky as she approached. She jumped backwards. "YOU SAID YOU WOULDN'T!"

"I didn't agree not to spook you though." Damian snickered. "Okay, seriously, you can have it." Damian said. He extended the balloon to her. "I'm a man of my word. Besides, it's 0 to 1 right now: that's unbalanced. I like to think of myself as a champion of equality."

"'Champion of equality' and it's just you fulfilling your promise," Becky muttered.

"It really isn't that big of a deal. You mess with me, I mess with you. Simple. Fair."

I hate that he has a point. "Ugh." Becky eyed the balloon warily.

"I cannot spend the entire evening coaxing you into retrieving the balloon. I have other things to do. Important things." Such as talking to Anya.

"Like, talk to Anya?"

"See, comments like that are why we're in this situation in the first place!" Damian snapped. "Just get over here and take the balloon!"

"Ugh! Fine!" Becky stormed over and snatched the balloon from his hand. "You're the worst." She tapped Damian with the balloon.

"Ouch.” He winced slightly at the shock. "You overreacted. This whole thing is so stupid."

"It's not stupid! She doesn't have any siblings to protect her from dirt bags like you!"

He laughed. "I don't have any siblings—"

"You have Demetrius," Becky interjected.

"I wasn't finished!" Damian objected. "I don't have any siblings who would do that kind of thing either," he said, shrugging. "If Demetrius did, it would be..."

Weird. It would be weird. Speaking of weird, why was he suddenly holding a glass of grapefruit juice? Why were his hands so... small? And why was he wearing a white suit?

The people around him—which he realized were all girls—were equally small. They weren't just small, they were young. He shivered. Was he getting hit on by a bunch of first graders?

Oh. OH NO. HE WAS BACK AT THE DANCE FROM THE FIRST GRADE.

Maybe it wasn't so bad. He caught Anya's emerald eyes through the gap in the crowd. His face contorted and warmed. It was disgusting! He was tiny and vulnerable! Where were Emile and Ewen when he needed them?!

His head frantically darted around the room. His eyes landed on them right as they were knocked to the floor by a streak of black and red. An Imperial Scholar? Damian suddenly met wide eyes with pin-prick pupils. DEMETRIUS DESMOND the Imperial Scholar?!

Damian gasped, his hands shot up to his mouth. He was dewy-eyed. His chest swelled with something dangerous: hope. Demetrius had come to save him! Or not.

*Because then Demetrius did the unthinkable, the unforgettable, the unforgivable. With a firm shoulder pat, Demetrius declared the horribly familiar words of Ewen and Emile all those years ago. "Form a single line, ladies."

Damian's blood went cold and his face paled. "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!" His sobbing caught in his throat. "I can't do this, not again." Damian sniffled into his hands. He blinked away his tears, the dingy ballroom flickering into a dimly lit room with a metal table. Oh wait, that part was real.

Becky's eyes widened. Apparently, his scream had been real too. "Are you okay?" she enquired, brows furrowed with concern.

Damian panted like he was recovering from a waterboarding. His eyes stung. "Um... yeah... I'm okay." His hand slid off his forehead. "My throat is kind of dry though." He croaked.

Becky shifted uncomfortably, wringing her hands. "Do you want some water?"  Becky asked awkwardly.

"That would be nice, thanks. It would also be nice if you would refrain from mentally replacing my brother with doppelgängers in the future."

"I can do that. Both of those things."

Silence.

"Soooo, do you have to tell a servant or?"

"Nope."

Damian pinched his lips together, gesturing to the mirror by a filing cabinet. "That's two way, isn't it?"

"Noooooo," she mumbled.

"Oh cool, so you just have wiretaps in here somewhere?" He joked, crossing his arms behind his head.

"Yup!" Becky chirped.

"Wait, what?" Damian locked eyes with Becky. She's serious!

CRASH! He hopped to his feet. "Are you joking? Becky!" He SLAMMED his hands on the table and glared at her face, now only inches away.

CREEEEAAKK! Damian whipped his head back around. 

A servant stood in the doorway, holding a silver tray with two cups of water balanced upon it.  "You're in Ms. Blackbell's personal space," he droned.

Talk about bad timing. Damian put his hands in the air and took a step back. 

"Ms Blackbell, you promised there'd be no funny business. I'm afraid I'll have to—"

"No!" Becky whined, stamping her foot. "I'm sorry! He didn't mean it! Right Damian?"

"Uh, I'm confused about what's happening here." Damian raised a hand.

Becky yanked his hand down. "My dad is super protective. You're the opposite sex." She whisper-shouted.

"Oh, you don't say? YEAH, DUH SHERLOCK," Damian retorted. Then his eyes lit up with understanding. "Oh. Ooooooh," Damian said, wrinkling up his nose. "Would he really think?" Damian whispered back. 

"He'd say 'all men are wolves' and he'd be right because that's what you are, you—"

"AHEM. The conspiratorial whispering isn't helping your case Ms. Blackbell."

"NO! IT'S NOT LIKE THAT!" Becky shrieked. "I'll- I'll punch him in the face! As proof!"

Damian gasped. "What?! I didn't agree to that! Not if I punch you first!"

The servant eyed the two warily.  "Ms. Blackbell, you promised me there would be no violence." 

No violence? Damian and Becky share a look. Somehow, by some miracle, they'd managed to evade an earlier interruption.

Becky stepped forward, eyeing Damian one last time before she spoke. "No! He was only in my personal space because he was trying to scare me! He hasn't hurt me in any physical capacity at all tonight! I haven't hurt him in any physical capacity at all tonight!"

Becky elbowed Damian. Play along.

Why would I save you from being grounded? Damian narrowed his eyes at her. Then his eyes widened. Right. Your dad. Military industrial complex. Would he shoot me?! Becky! Is that what you're implying?!

Becky gave no facial expression in response.

"Is this true, Mr. Desmond?" The servant asked.

Damian blinked. My motives? Pure instinct. Probably not an acceptable answer. "Uh." He side-eyed Becky who nodded furiously. "...yes? Yes! She was being really rude so iiiiIII... got defensive! I'm sorry for the confusion. I got in her personal space because she's done nothing but insult me all night." Damian said with a gritted smile, giving Becky a stink eye.

"See! It's only verbal violence!" Becky clapped. "Please don't shut it down! I worked so hard on putting all of this together!" Becky whined. "It really isn't violent!"

"No, it definitely is. Just against my eardrums. You sound like nails on a chalkboard." Damian coughed into a fist.

Becky whipped her head towards him. Becky kicked him in the shin. Damian hissed, then he glared at her.  Don't risk our lie with jokes, is what her scowl seemed to say.

The servant nodded slowly and solemnly. "Yes. I understand Ms. Blackbell." The servant lifted the tray to them. "Water?"

"Oh! Thank you! I nearly forgot."

"Thanks for the water," he muttered weakly as he took his glass.

The servant bowed his head and then left. 

"This is all your fault." Becky huffed the moment the servant left. 

Damian rolled his eyes. "Because this whole thing, whatever," he said as he gestured around, "this thing is, was my idea. Sureeeee. Whatever helps you sleep at night." He took a sip of his water.

"I'm going to spit in your cup," Becky threatened. 

"Then I won't drink it. What are you, 6?" Damian laughed.

"That's rich coming from you! You're a grown man!"

"I'm 15. That is hardly a grown man, Blackbell."

"That was my blunder." Becky conceded. "You can hardly be called human, let alone a man." Becky scowled. Damian opened his mouth to object but Becky's manicured hand shot up in front of his face. "Don't try and deny it, Desmond.  You know I've known for years." 

"You never stop!" Damian groaned.

"Don't worry, that's about to change."

Damian straightened in his seat. "Oh? Go on."

"Wow, you really hate me, don't you?"

"Why of course!"  Damian grinned. He rested his chin on his folded hands. Then with mocking innocence, he batted his eyelashes at her. 

"I hate you more," Becky giggled. Her girlish grin faded, giving way to a stone face glare. "I really do. You have zero shame—"

"Only because I have nothing to be ashamed of," Damian flashed her a smug, self-satisfied grin. 

Becky stared. "And that's why you always hide behind excuses when it comes to Anya. Because you're just so fearless and unabashed."

Damian's face fell. He glared.

"Yeah… I don't think any amount of 'tactics' explains your behavior." Becky rose from the table and snatched his glass of water. "You don't deserve this by the way," she said, shaking the glass side-to-side slightly.

Damian rolled his eyes, slumping back in his chair. He wasn't going to argue. He wasn't that dehydrated, at least not yet. He did tend to get weirdly sweaty around Anya. "Whatever."

Becky promptly poured out Damian's water, into a potted plant, while making direct eye contact. "You know, most people change during a decade," Becky said coolly, examining the plant's leaves as if it was the most interesting thing in the world. 

"Oh really? You wouldn't know anything about that, would you? You're as petty as ever. So petty, in fact, that you backpedaled on an act of charity in little over a minute." 

"Did I hear someone projecting?" 

"Playing dumb only ruins your credibility." 

"I don't need credibility with you."

Damian shrugged. "Well, maybe if you want me to listen to you." 

Becky laughed coldly. "Please, you wouldn't listen either way. You lie to me despite how painfully obvious your feelings for Anya are. Everyone can see it! People wouldn't have half the certainty they do if it wasn't true! People aren't that dumb."

Damian sucked a breath in between his teeth. "Oooh… Blackbell… that's argumentum ad populum. And perhaps… faulty generalization? Who is included in 'everyone'? You?" Damian laughed. "Two possible fallacies… you're really great at arguing, Blackbell."

Blackbell pinched the bridge of her nose. "Look. It's been ten years. You have two choices: man up and confess or move on!" 

"Now why would I participate in your false dilemma? That's another fallacy." Damian grinned. 

"Real love requires courage and sacrifice, Damian." She hissed. 

"Just to clarify," he raised a hand, "you are trying to make logical arguments, yes?" 

"Duh!"

"Wonderful! Reification fallacy. Love cannot require anything from me. Love is an emotion, not a person." 

"Sure, sure. But I am a person capable of setting requirements." Becky glared. "And I refuse to let Anya have anything but the best. You don't even meet the bare minimum. No one who's serious about someone else behaves the way you do."

Damian folded his hands and leaned in. "Appeal to purity." 

"I'm sure you can find it in your heart to tell her because if you don't, I will make your life a living hell until you commit to a choice. How's that for an argument?" 

"Congratulations. A formally valid argument." Damian said, staring blankly at her.

Becky sighed in relief.

Damian snickered, a smile creeping into his face. "Except it's still informally invalid! Argumentum ad baculum."

Becky groaned into her hands. "I hate you."

"Ad hominem."

"That wasn't an argument idiot!"

"You said you were trying to make logical arguments. I took you at your word." Damian shrugged innocently.

"You know that's not what I meant!"

"I'm not a mindreader. You're not a mindreader. Let's not kid ourselves that you know what you're talking about."

"Are you ever going to listen to me?"

"Nope!" 

"Why did I even try? Why do I even bother?" 

"I don't know. Why do you try? My guess is that you want to be a bother. If that's your goal, then congratulations! This certainly was an inconvenience!" 

Becky put her face in her hands. "Please get out."

"Now why would I do that? I'm finally having fun!"

Becky made a shooing motion with her hand. "Please… just… get out." She croaked.

"Well," Damian failed to suppress a smile, "because you're so confident that I have feelings for Anya, I'll humor you." He tucked a strand of hair behind his ear. "And… talk to her." He giggled in a way too genuine to be mockery. Then he lurched forward. Eyes dead serious. Hands clenching the table. And beaming like a child on his birthday. "Soooooo," his fingers tapped on the table excitedly, "where is she?"

Becky sighed and looked up at him. "She's not even here." 

Damian froze. "What?"

"You heard me."

"Total waste of my time." Damian tucked his chair back under the table with a very gentle SLAM! "Good night to you!" Damian stomped over to the door, mumbling further complaints to himself.

"AHA!" Becky's head snapped up. "I thought you wanted to spend time with all of your classmates!"

Damian whirled back towards her. "Shut. Up." He shook a finger at her. "You're the worst." He snarled. He laughed, cold and contemptuous.  His body shook with barely concealed anger. "No one likes you!" He shouted. 

"Anya does." Becky sniffed.

"Well!" Damian clapped his hands together. "I'm the one who's currently here." He hissed through gritted teeth. "And I hate you!" His eye twitched.

"I miss her." Becky said sadly. 

"Me too." Damian murmured, temporarily deflating.

"What was that…?" Becky asked wearily.

"NO ONE LIKES YOU!" Damian snapped, spinning around on his heel. His wave looked more like a karate chop. "GOODBYE!" He flung the door open. 

"Bye." Becky scowled.

"GOODBYE!" Damian shouted from the door frame.

"You already said that." 

"I WANT THE LAST WORD!" Damian's shaking hand clamped down on the doorknob. "FAREWELL!" 

SLAM! 

Wiesel barked.

"I know right?" Becky rolled her eyes. "Can you believe that guy?"

Wiesel barked again.

"Me neither." Becky shook her head. "Me neither."

Notes:

One of my (and my beta’s apparently) favorite things about fics is author’s notes so you can expect to hear from me almost every chapter. I don’t want to commit to EVERY chapter in case I feel it ruins the tone of a chapter because. I definitely have some sadder endings coming.

NOTE FROM MY BETA?!?! NOT CLICKBAIT?!

BR/N: Salutations readers, I'm the beta reader for this fic. I've really enjoyed working on it so far! However, I'm having a little bit of a hard time convincing edenflowers that I think she's a good writer after I've torn apart whatever she's written looking for improvements. So, if you guys could do me a HUGE favor and post lots of compliments about her writing in the comments, I'd be super appreciative!

OKAY BETA NOTE OVER!!!! I’m leaving his note exactly as is because I’m not the SSS. I’m not gonna censor my beta *applause track.sfx* I know guys, I’m so awesome. I will admit it is mildly embarrassing how HARD I procrastinated reviewing the notes. But the chapter is DONE! I AM VICTORIOUS. I feel significantly better about the chapter now. I used to think this chapter was easily one of the weaker jokes (I have a lot of funny ones me thinks) but I think it came out really well in the end.

Still, compliments are helpful. I procrastinate. Horribly. It’ll be better now that I am perceived and thus accountable to an audience to post things. But I am still a procrastinator through and through. SO PLEASE. I BEG YOU. PEER PRESSURE ME WITH INTEREST INTO WORKING. THIS IS A GENUINE PLEA. YOU’RE ALLOWED TO BE ANNOYING ABOUT ASKING WHEN THE NEXT CHAPTER COMES OUT. I really don’t want to go months on end without posting anything.

Anyway. You should comment telling my beta to lock in and finish reading the rest of the manga and watch the rest of the anime. Because I will show my beta the comments until he gets his own account. I’m pretty sure he can read them either way because this fic isn’t exclusive to registered users only. Craftidore, if you’re reading this, hi. Lock in. Do the homework I’ve assigned you.

Okay now I wanna talk chapter!!!

Also, I have no idea if I got the fallacies right. I think maybe I did, but if I didn’t, I don’t think it matters. Damian was being annoying and obnoxious on purpose. He’s already lied about his feelings towards Anya here so misrepresenting Becky’s argument to annoy her sounds about right. I feel like Damian would understand fallacies really well though, and I do not, so if there are debaters in the audience, please comment good resources for making me understand fallacies please and thank you 🫶

And I’m sorry to any Demetrius fans for what I did. 😔 I hope you know it could’ve been worse if I had a higher cringe tolerance. There are many jokes like that to come: I know what I have to do but I don’t know if I have the strength to do it. Encouragement helps! If you think something was particularly funny, it helps to know that my sense of humor actually lands and isn’t just utter nonsense. At least, not unfunny nonsense?

Anyway. *kicks feet and giggles* Whaddya think?? Did you like it? What was your favorite part or joke? I love hearing from people. (Again: I encourage peer pressure to release another chapter as soon as possible.)

Series this work belongs to: