Work Text:
Two years later, Robby still did not trust happiness on its own.
That was probably the simplest way to put it.
Not because things were bad. That was the problem. Things were good. Obscenely, offensively good. Good in ways that still occasionally made something old and feral in his nervous system sit up and look around for structural damage.
Jack had moved in the same day they got back from Calgary.
Not metaphorically. Not in the romantic sense where somebody left a toothbrush and a sweater and then somehow never really departed again. No. Jack had walked into Robby’s house, dropped his duffel by the bedroom door, made one disgusted comment about the state of the coffee situation, and then behaved as though he had always lived there and Robby was simply late to the understanding. He’d called a moving company the same night and 48 hours later his espresso machine was in the kitchen, his books were in the living room shelves, and the spare bedroom that had once been Jack’s unspoken space, had given into entropy and become his home gym.
Robby had been too tired, too wrecked, too relieved, and frankly too horny to put up anything resembling resistance.
Not that resistance would have done much.
Jack, once he had decided something was happening, tended to treat dissent as either decorative or evidence of temporary confusion.
The six weeks after they got home had passed in a blur of therapy appointments, grocery runs, sleeping like men recovering from war, and leaving the bedroom only when starvation or scheduling forced the matter. It had been, Robby would later admit only under duress, the best six weeks of his life.
Even the therapy had been useful, though useful in the way chemotherapy was useful if chemotherapy occasionally wore good shoes and looked at you over the rim of its glasses and asked why, exactly, you thought self-loathing counted as moral seriousness.
Jack’s therapist, now unfortunately also Robby’s therapist, remained evil.
Not in the fraudulent, manipulative sense. In the much worse sense of being deeply competent and offensively hard to lie to. He had once reduced Robby to tears in under eleven minutes by asking one calm question about the difference between guilt and a god-complex. Another time he had let Jack and Robby spend fifteen full minutes circling an argument about emotional labor before quietly observing that they were both, in completely different ways, trying to earn the right to be loved retroactively. Robby had once stormed out in a fury after the therapist tried to ask him about his mother and had been led back in fifteen minutes later, sheepishly, by Jack who was not having it.
Evil.
Still, Robby had stayed.
He was still staying.
Therapy had not cured him because therapy was not magic. What it had done was make him significantly less likely to interpret every instance of stability as either a clerical error or an elaborate prelude to catastrophe.
Only less likely, though.
Not immune.
Which was why, on a bright Thursday morning in late spring, when Jack said, “Get dressed. We’re going out,” Robby’s entire soul narrowed its eyes.
He looked up from where he was sitting at the kitchen island with coffee, laptop, and three tabs open on a grant application he had been pretending to work on for the last forty minutes.
“What.”
Jack did not look up from the espresso machine, which was making the soft, superior sounds of a device that knew exactly how much it had cost.
“We’re going out,” he repeated.
“That is not answer.”
“It’s the one you’re getting. Now put on something that you can be seen in outside the house,” he said it like he was insulting Robby’s outfit, but the way he was eying him in his threadbare shirt and ancient sweatpants made it seem more like he just didn’t want anyone else seeing him that way.
Robby stared at him.
Two years in, Jack in the kitchen still had the power to make him feel vaguely ambushed by domesticity. He was wearing jeans, a navy Henley, and the reading glasses he refused to admit made him hotter. His hair had gone a little more silver at the temples since the road trip. His leg was bothering him a little, Robby could tell by the angle of his stance, but not enough to slow him down. Nothing ever slowed him down when he was in one of these moods. Calm. Focused. Disturbingly unhurried.
Administrative, Robby thought with dread.
Jack turned, set a demitasse cup on the counter, and looked at him over the machine with an expression that immediately made every alarm bell in Robby’s body start clanging.
No.
Absolutely not.
“That face,” Robby said.
Jack blinked. “This is just my face.”
“No,” Robby said, already getting to his feet. “That is your ‘I’ve made a decision for both of us and I’m just waiting you out until you give in’ face.”
Jack took a sip of espresso.
“That’s not a real category of facial expression.”
“It is in this relationship.”
Jack’s mouth twitched.
Robby pointed at him.
“That expression has preceded every bureaucratic event of the last two years of our lives. Your change of address forms. Filing paperwork on our relationship that nearly gave Gloria a heart attack. Mortgage refinancing. Insurance appeal. The time you reorganized my filing cabinet because you claimed my tax records looked like they’d been filed by a raccoon. You do not get to make that face and then act like I’m being dramatic.”
Jack leaned one hip against the counter.
“You are being dramatic.”
“I am being observant.”
“Still dramatic.”
Robby narrowed his eyes.
They had, in fact, reached a place in their relationship where this level of suspicion was both normal and healthy. That was what therapy had bought them, among other things. Not the absence of anxiety, but better pattern recognition. He knew Jack’s tells now. The specific calm that meant he had made a decision three days ago and was only just now allowing the rest of the world to catch up.
“Where are we going,” Robby said.
“To run an errand.”
“And you need me to run this errand with you?”
“It’s the kind of administrative errand you are required for.”
Robby actually recoiled.
“There,” he said. “There it is. That phrase has never once meant anything good in my life.”
Jack gave him a patient look.
“It’s not bad.”
“Jack.”
Jack set the cup down.
Robby crossed his arms.
The kitchen was bright with late morning light, and outside the window the street looked offensively normal. Someone was walking a dog. A car alarm went off two blocks over and then stopped. Pittsburgh continued to exist like it had not once nearly failed to keep them both alive.
Jack said, “You need to stop reacting to simple logistics like they’re an assassination attempt.”
Robby laughed once.
“You absolutely do not get to say ‘simple logistics’ in that tone when you are clearly planning something.”
Jack’s expression did not change.
That was worse.
That was so much worse.
Because if he were up to ordinary nonsense, he would have looked more guilty. More smug. This was something else. Something bone-deep and already settled.
Robby put his coffee down carefully.
“Tell me now.”
“No.”
“Jack.”
“No.”
“You cannot just make decisions and then drag me into them like some kind of very handsome authoritarian.”
Jack considered that.
“Very handsome?”
“That is not the point.”
“It’s still nice to hear.”
Robby made a sound of profound disgust.
He should have known then. He would later blame the espresso, the weather, the fact that Jack had spent the previous night ruining him slowly enough that higher reasoning had not fully returned. Whatever the cause, he did not know until they were already in the car.
Jack drove. Of course he drove. He always drove in situations where he expected resistance. Not because he was controlling. Because he believed, with all the confidence of a man who had once hijacked Robby’s life back from the edge one protein bar at a time, that he was better at steering through crisis.
He was often right.
That did not improve Robby’s mood.
Downtown Pittsburgh slid up around them in familiar blocks. Office buildings. Glass. Traffic. Pedestrians moving with lunch-break urgency. Jack parked in a garage with the kind of confidence that made Robby’s stomach drop.
“Jack,” he said slowly, as they got out of the car.
Jack locked it and adjusted his jacket.
“Yes.”
“Why are we here?”
Jack looked at him.
“Marriage license.”
Robby stared.
The city kept moving around them. A bus exhaled at the curb. Somewhere nearby somebody was swearing at a printer through an open office window. The sunlight bounced hard off glass and concrete and the side of Jack’s face, which remained infuriatingly calm.
“What,” Robby said.
Jack’s brow furrowed very slightly. “You heard the words.”
“I did.”
“Good.”
“That does not mean I understand why they are happening to me.”
Jack started walking.
Robby, because his body had spent two years learning that when Jack moved with this much certainty the safest course was often to remain within arm’s reach, followed automatically.
Then stopped.
Then caught up again because apparently panic still preferred locomotion.
“You cannot,” he said, keeping his voice low with visible effort, “ambush a man with civil commitment.”
Jack pressed the elevator button.
“I’m not ambushing you.”
“You absolutely are.”
“I’m streamlining.”
“That is worse.”
“It’s efficient.”
“It’s psychotic, you haven’t even asked if I want to marry you.”
Jack paused, as if he’d never even considered that. “Do you not?”
“I do, but that’s not the point.”
Jack looked entirely too self-satisfied with that answer. “Say I had asked you and you, obviously would have said yes. Then we’d have to plan a wedding and you’d get all up in your own head about and panic and get three different kinds of stressed and start spiraling. This avoids that and we still get what we both want.”
Robby actually sputtered as the elevator doors opened.
“That’s…you can’t…I wouldn’t…” he trailed off.
“You done?” Jack asked, pulling Robby into the elevator.
“I…”
“Speechless is a good look on you, Robby.” Jack said, grinning.
“Fuck you.”
Jack tsked at that, “let’s save it for the honeymoon.”
Robby stared at the numbers above the doors like they might spell out a legal escape hatch.
“This is insane. You are a problem.”
“No,” Jack said. “This is paperwork.”
“That is not a rebuttal.”
“It is if the problem is paperwork.”
Robby turned to look at him fully then, which was a tactical error, because Jack looked maddeningly good when he was getting his way. Calm, yes. But underneath that Robby could see the telltale signs of nerves, too. The way he kept flexing his left hand. The slight set in his jaw. The effort it was taking to keep this contained.
That nearly undid him.
“You are serious,” Robby said.
Jack looked back at him, no irony left now.
“Very.”
The elevator dinged.
The city clerk’s office was exactly as unromantic as every good civic institution should be. Beige walls. Plastic chairs. Forms. A framed photograph of whoever was currently mayor. A woman behind a counter who had clearly seen every variety of human chaos the city produced and no longer feared any of it.
Jack walked up like a man checking in for routine bloodwork.
Robby followed half a step behind, still feeling like he might leave his body and be found later haunting municipal infrastructure.
The woman behind the counter said, “Can I help you?”
Jack said, “We’re here for a marriage license.”
Robby actually closed his eyes for one second.
When he opened them, the woman was already reaching for paperwork on a clipboard.
“I’ll need identification and documents for both of you,” she said.
Jack held out his hand without looking.
Robby stared at it.
Jack kept his hand there.
The clerk looked between them with the mild, professionally suppressed amusement of a woman who had definitely already decided which one was the problem.
Robby handed over his wallet in silence.
Jack took both IDs, set them neatly on the counter, and slid over a folder that somehow Robby had missed seeing up until now. The problem with Jack being so administratively competent was the he knew where every bit of Robby's paperwork was, because he'd filed most of it. Robby had never had a chance.
Jack smiled at the clerk with the weaponized politeness of a man who had spent his entire adult life getting things done in systems that did not appreciate him enough.
The clerk glanced down, typed something, and said, “How long have you two been together?”
Robby laughed once, almost hysterically.
Jack said, “Depends how strict you’re being with the definition of 'together.'”
That, somehow, made the clerk smile.
The forms took less time than Robby would have liked and more than he could emotionally survive with dignity. By the time they were seated side by side, filling things out in matching black ink, he had progressed from outrage to a kind of stunned administrative dissociation.
Jack, of course, was thriving.
Not visibly. He was too well-trained for visible thriving. But Robby knew him. Knew the difference between relaxed competence and the particular bright stillness of a man who had quietly decided to rearrange the structure of his life and was now watching the machinery click into place.
Robby glared at the line for current address.
Jack leaned over and said, very softly, “You have to write legibly or they’ll make you redo it.”
Robby turned his head.
“This,” he whispered with enormous dignity, “is the least sexually attractive you have ever been.”
Jack’s mouth twitched.
“That’s not what your face says.”
“That is because my face is processing a hostage situation.”
Jack looked down at the form. “Don’t be dramatic. You’re signing voluntarily.”
“You frog-marched me into this office.”
“I drove you downtown.”
“You manipulated me with logistics.”
“That’s called planning.”
Robby set the pen down.
For a second he could not tell if the thing in his chest was panic, joy, grief, or some nauseating alloy of all three.
Jack saw it at once. Of course he did.
His voice changed. Still low. Still private. But stripped of its teasing now.
“Hey.”
Robby looked at him.
Jack held his gaze.
“I’m not doing this because I think you’re going anywhere,” he said. “I’m doing it because I know you’re not.”
That shut him up.
Which, for Robby, was clinically significant
Jack went on, quieter still. “And because I’m done pretending there is a version of my life I’m interested in that doesn’t have you in it. We have already done the hard part. I’m not wasting the easy part on principle.”
Robby’s throat tightened.
The clerk at the desk coughed pointedly in the universal bureaucratic language of keep moving or I will become part of your story against my will.
Jack handed him the pen.
Robby took it.
Signed.
And then, because he was still himself and apparently not even impending legal union could alter that, muttered, “I hate that this worked.”
Jack said, “No, you don’t.”
Robby did not answer because unfortunately that was true.
The clerk took the paperwork back, checked it with the weary efficiency of someone who had seen every possible version of human foolishness play out under fluorescent lights, stamped what needed stamping, and slid a folder toward them.
Jack picked it up before Robby could, because of course he did.
Robby narrowed his eyes immediately.
“You are enjoying this too much.”
“I feel I'm enjoying this just as much as is appropriate.”
The clerk looked between them with the bland endurance of a public servant who had no intention of becoming emotionally involved. “You’re all set.”
Robby exhaled and turned toward the door, already bracing himself for the psychic whiplash of stepping back out into the city as a man who had apparently just agreed to marry Jack through bureaucratic ambush.
Then the clerk added, “Take the elevator to four. Suite 412.”
Robby stopped.
Slowly, he turned back around.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “What.”
The clerk pointed with her pen like this was the most normal thing in the world. “Fourth floor. Officiant’s office.”
There was a beat of silence.
Robby turned his head and looked at Jack.
Jack’s expression went so neutral it circled all the way back around to incriminating.
“You booked an officiant,” Robby said.
Jack took his reading glasses off and hooked them in the collar of his shirt. “I made an appointment.”
“You made an appointment.”
“I believed in us.”
“You built a schedule.”
The clerk, clearly deciding that whatever this was, it was not her emergency, had already looked down at her computer again.
Robby stared at Jack. “You knew the license would be done in time.”
“I estimated.”
“You estimated.”
“I accounted for average wait times, document review, and your tendency to argue just long enough to feel principled without actually walking away.”
Robby blinked at him.
“That is deeply sinister.”
Jack put a hand lightly at the center of Robby’s back and steered him toward the hall. “Come on.”
“I cannot believe you timed my emotional collapse to municipal workflow.”
“And yet,” Jack said, pressing the elevator button, “here we are.”
The elevator ride to the fourth floor felt surreal in the way only government buildings could manage. Beige walls. Bad lighting. A framed poster about civic pride. One elderly man holding a manila envelope and minding his own business while Robby stood there realizing, piece by piece, just how far ahead Jack had thought this through.
Not just the license.
The whole thing.
He had known what papers they needed, where to go, how long it would take, which office came next.
He had built this afternoon like a man laying track.
Not forcing. Not cornering.
Just making it very, very easy for destiny to keep excellent time.
It should have infuriated Robby.
Instead it made something low in his chest go unsteady.
The elevator dinged.
Fourth floor.
Jack stepped out first. Robby followed because apparently that was his life now.
Suite 412 was smaller than Robby expected. Not ceremonial exactly. Just an office with too much carpet, a city seal on the wall, and a woman in a dark blue suit sitting behind a desk with a leather folio in front of her.
She stood when they entered.
“Good afternoon,” she said. “You must be Dr. Robinavich and Dr. Abbot.”
Robby stopped dead.
Jack, damn him, just said, “We are.”
Robby looked at him with the slow horror of a man discovering the trap door had carpeting. “You gave her our names.”
“Generally you do need to give names to book an appointment like this.”
“You pre-registered me for my own wedding.”
The officiant’s mouth twitched, but to her credit she kept her voice perfectly even. “We can keep this very simple.”
“Please,” Robby said instantly.
Jack said at the same time, “Within reason.”
Robby shot him a look. “You do not get to have opinions about simplicity after orchestrating a multi-floor surprise marriage.”
Jack’s mouth twitched. “That feels unfair, we are getting married after all."
“It is not unfair enough.”
The officiant gestured toward the small open space near the window. “Whenever you’re ready.”
And there it was.
No grand room. No flowers. No audience. No dramatic music to warn him that his life was changing shape.
Just an office on the fourth floor, Pittsburgh humming along outside, and Jack standing beside him with the same impossible steadiness that had gotten them all the way here.
Robby stayed where he was for one extra second, still a little shell-shocked, the stamped paperwork suddenly very real in Jack’s hand.
He looked at the folder.
Then at Jack.
Then back at the officiant waiting with patient professionalism.
And with a sick, dizzy flash of comprehension, Robby understood that Jack had arranged this so smoothly because he had believed, all the way through, that Robby would make it to this room.
Not because he could be dragged here.
Because he would choose to come.
Jack must have seen something shift in his face, because his own expression softened.
Quietly, so the moment had somewhere gentle to land, he said, “We don’t have to do this part today.”
Which, of course, made Robby want to do it immediately if only out of spite.
He exhaled through his nose. “I’m going to resent how well you understand me until one of us dies.”
Jack tipped his head toward the officiant. “Good.”
Robby looked at the ceiling for one long second, as if searching it for patience or possibly divine intervention. “I need you to know that this is not how normal people get married.”
“No,” Jack said. “Normal people spend eighteen months arguing about linen colors and whether second cousins can sit near the bar. I saved us.”
That shut him up, which was infuriating.
The officiant opened the folio and began in the gentle, practiced tone of someone who had shepherded the nervous, the euphoric, the reluctant, and the catastrophically underprepared across this threshold before.
“We are gathered here today to witness and celebrate the marriage of Michael Isaac Robinavich and Jonathan Jude Abbot.”
Robby felt his spine go strange and weightless.
It was one thing to sign a form.
It was another to hear his own name said aloud like that, paired with Jack’s in a sentence that made them into a single legal and emotional fact.
When they stepped back out into the afternoon, the city looked exactly the same. Buses. Glass. Light. Pedestrians. Pittsburgh remaining offensively indifferent to the fact that Robby had just let Jack annex him through civil channels.
He stood on the courthouse steps with the folder in his hand and said, “I’m still calling this an ambush.”
Jack adjusted his sunglasses.
“I’ll survive.”
“That remains to be seen.”
They stood there for a second, shoulder to shoulder.
Then Jack said, “You realize we’re going to have to tell people.”
Robby made a face. “Absolutely not today.”
“Dana’s going to be insufferable.”
“She actually might kill us for not inviting her.”
“She can get in line.”
That startled a laugh out of Robby, brief and helpless.
Jack looked over at him, pleased in the most intolerable way. Then, like he had just remembered something minor:
“Right,” he said, and reached into his jacket pocket.
Robby looked over. “What.”
Jack pulled out a small velvet box.
Robby stared at it.
“No,” he said immediately.
Jack glanced at him. “That’s not a no you mean.”
“That is absolutely a no I mean. You do not get to surprise-marry me and then produce rings like you’re remembering you left the stove on.”
Jack opened the box.
Inside were two plain bands. Nothing flashy. Clean, simple, solid.
Robby looked at them and felt something in his chest go soft in a way that was frankly humiliating.
Jack, apparently deciding to make it worse, said, “I had them in my pocket the whole time. Kept forgetting to do this part.”
Robby turned to look at him fully. “You forgot the rings.”
“I was focused.”
“On entrapping me.”
“Entrapment sounds so illegal, I think you’ll find what we just did is legal,” Jack correct. “Very legal and binding in all 50 states, as long as the Supreme Court doesn’t fuck us over anyway.”
Robby made a face, but it had lost some of its force.
Jack took one of the bands out and held it between two fingers, suddenly quieter. Not nervous exactly. Just stripped down a little, all the sharp edges tucked away.
“I know this wasn’t precisely the normal way to go about this,” he said, eyes not quite meeting Robby’s for a moment as he held the ring.
Robby suddenly couldn’t stand the idea of making him doubt this at all, even for a little satisfaction of needling him.
“I have never expected you to do anything in the normal way, Jack,” he said, reaching for Jack’s hand and the ring it held. “But somehow you always do it the way I need.”
Something in Jack’s face changed at that. Softened. Opened.
For once, he did not seem to have a smart answer ready.
Robby took the ring from his fingers, then caught Jack’s left hand and slid it on first, because if Jack was going to ambush him into a courthouse marriage, Robby could at least reclaim a little control over the order of operations.
It fit perfectly.
“Well,” Jack said after a second, voice rougher than before, “that’s annoyingly effective.”
Robby snorted and held out his own hand before he could think too hard about the expression Jack was wearing.
Jack looked down at it like it meant something ruinous. Then he took Robby’s hand carefully, with a gentleness that felt almost at odds with the rest of the day, and slid the other band into place.
The weight of it settled low and certain.
Robby looked at their hands for a moment. At the two rings. At the simple, undeniable fact of them.
“This is still insane,” he said, because someone had to preserve at least a scrap of dignity.
Jack’s mouth curved. “And yet.”
“And yet,” Robby echoed.
Then Jack held out his hand.
Not dramatically. Not a grand gesture for the public. Just there, between them, like the most normal thing in the world.
Robby looked at it.
Looked at Jack.
Then took it.
Because two years into therapy, into survival, into shared bed and groceries and evil clinicians and an espresso machine that had somehow become part of his emotional ecosystem, there was something almost funny about the fact that this was still what undid him: not the idea of forever, but the simple physical fact of Jack reaching and expecting him to be there.
He squeezed once.
Jack squeezed back.
They walked to the car like that.
And if Robby spent the whole drive home alternating between outrage, laughter, and the deeply inconvenient awareness that he was already mentally making room for Jack in ways that had nothing to do with square footage, despite the fact that Jack already lived there and had for a while, well.
Therapy had taught him many things.
Among them: there were worse ways to lose an argument.