Actions

Work Header

21-Night Moves (Baby S11 E4)

Summary:

A funny, warm rewrite of the “Night Moves” scene from Baby S11 E4 in my "Accidentally a Winchester" series alternate universe.
Includes Sam/Reader, Dean, the Impala, classic rock, bad timing, and one extremely awkward morning after.

Notes:

In case you're not already familiar with this series, the Reader is from this universe (reality) where she was a fan of the Supernatural TV series. She now lives in the bunker with Sam and Dean and is Sam's girlfriend.

Part 21of my series Accidentally a Winchester: A Supernatural Reader Series.

I try to stick close to canon facts and keep everyone in character.
Comments welcome. This is my first fanfic, so please be kind. Thanks.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

The Impala’s still parked outside the Roadhouse. Dean stumbles out the door like the floor tries to fight him. His walk says he wins anyway. Behind him, the neon signs blink off one by one, like they read the moment: time to go.

He climbs in with a groan. “Mistakes were made. Uh huh.” He slides down until his head rests on the top of the bench seat, legs stretched out like he’s settling in for sleep.

“Hi, Dean,” you say, popping up from the back seat.

Naked. One arm strategically held over your chest, the other braced on the worn leather.

Your hair is a mess, wild and tangled from hours of abandon. Eyes wide with mischief and fake innocence. A shy smile tries to look sweet and fails on contact.

The words come out like you were trying to be cheerful but sounding more like pure embarrassment. Your face warms. A blush starts to bloom.

“Oh!” Dean sits up fast, shocked by the sound. He looks back at you, then drops his eyes to the back-seat floor for an instant where Sam is wrestling with his clothes.

Sam clears his throat. “Uh, good morning…” 

Dean does one full double-take, a nervous little chuckle stuck in his throat. Then he looks back again at you for a beat too long, eyes widening before his brain catches up with his manners.

He adds a small, awkward “Hi” to you, then snaps forward like the windshield can save him.

“Sorry, Sam. I didn’t... I didn’t realize you guys were… busy.”

“Yeah. Yeah, uh… could you give us a minute?” Sam fumbles with his shirt in the cramped space.

You grab your shirt and pull it on fast.

“Well, I’ll just, uh… I just won’t be here anymore. So you kids take your time,” Dean says. Big-brother amusement. Strategic retreat.

He gets out of the Impala and shuts the door like it’s a blast shield.

A few minutes later, Dean climbs back in. By then, Sam has moved to the passenger seat, dressed, sleeves half-rolled like he’s trying to look normal. It doesn’t work.

Dean pulls out of the Roadhouse parking lot. Gravel crunches under the tires as he eases her onto the empty road. For a minute, nobody talks.

Baby hums steady. The heater wheezes warm air that smells like oil and old cassette plastic. Sam stares out the window like the trees might offer him sanctuary.

You scoot forward to the edge of the back seat and lean in until your head sits between them. Your hands rest on the top of the bench. Leather cool under your palms.

“I just remembered something.”

Dean’s eyes narrow in the rearview mirror, catching yours with that hunter instinct for incoming trouble. “Oh?”

“Yeah. It’s the clearest memory I’ve had.” You bite your lip, not because you’re nervous, but because you’re trying not to laugh. “It’s that scene.”

“Scene?” Dean frowns.

“You know,” you say, sweet as sugar. “From the show? The original scene. Where you walk out of the Roadhouse, get in the car, and see Sam with some random naked chick in the back.”

Sam’s expression goes flat. “What?”

“Yeah. She’s tall, blonde and pretty. Oh, and kind of dumb.”

Dean presses his lips together. He fights a grin that screams, Dude, you are toast.

Sam cringes as he prays for the right words.

You let the silence stretch just long enough to be evil.

Then you grin. Big. Sharp. Pure chaos.

“Relax,” you say, voice turning warm. “It wasn’t her. It was me…” You squeeze his shoulder through the flannel. “And I get to keep you.”

Dean’s shoulders drop in one long exhale. He looks relieved, amused and impressed all at once. He turns his head to look at Sam.

“Oh, she is so cool, man.”

You sit back, pleased with yourself after a second you say loudly, “Hey Dean! Play him the song.”

Dean blinks “Song?”

“Yeah, the one you want to play for him right now.”

Dean’s eyebrows jump. “Yeah?”

You nod, grin widening. “Yeah.”

Dean reaches into the glove box like he knows exactly where everything lives. And of course there’s a tape. Of course it’s ready.

He slides it in with a satisfying click.

The first notes hit, warm and familiar.

Sam sits up straighter. “Dean, we were just researching and...”

“No, no, no. No.” Dean says and holds up a hand like a stop sign. “Shh. Let it wash over you.”

Sam stares. “Really. You’re going to ‘Night Moves’ me?”

He twists just enough to look back at you. Betrayal and resignation. “And you encouraged him?”

You smile. “Yep.”

Dean lip-syncs, dramatic and shameless, his whole face in it. He’s not trying to be cool. He’s trying to be Dean, which is worse.

“This is ridiculous,” Sam mutters as he finishes buttoning his flannel and rolling up his sleeves.

When the song hits the line about the black-haired beauty, Dean looks at you in the rearview mirror and points like the lyrics were written specifically about you.

“One of the greatest rock writers of all time, Samuel,” Dean declares.

“It’s Sam,” Sam says, but there’s no real heat in it.

Sam tries to stay mad. He lasts maybe ten seconds.

You hear the Chevy line coming. You point at Sam from the back seat even knowing he can’t see it.

You and Sam sing the line wrong on purpose: “Out in the back seat of my brother’s ’67 Chevy.”

Dean shakes his head, smiling, and glances out the side window.

Sam points at him, half-serious. “Hey. You started this. You played it.”

Dean turns the volume up. “Here we go. Come on now.”

The chorus hits and you all end up singing anyway. Loud. Off-key. Perfect.

Working on the night moves…

* * *

Miles later, the song comes back around. You pass around greasy paper bags that shine with oil. Something fried. Something salty. The Impala smells like leather, metal, and cheap diner food.

The song sparks another memory and you laugh. “Hey Dean!”

“Yeah?”

“He tried to give her his number. You know what she said?”

Dean grins and answers “We’ve got tonight. Who needs tomorrow?”

You laugh, because that's exactly why you said it. To set him up for it. 

Sam groans. “Is everything a Bob Seger song to you?”

Dean shrugs. “Yes. Well...”

You eat. You joke. You laugh.

For a little while, there’s no case, no monsters, no apocalypse waiting around the bend. It’s just family. The three of you in this car, held together by classic rock and bad timing.

Sam wipes his fingers on a napkin. “Next time, I choose.”

He reaches for the steering wheel.

Dean smacks his hand away without looking. “Hands off the wheel.”

“You’re not even looking at the road!” Sam snaps.

You lean back, settling into the familiar creak of old leather, heart full.

And you do what Dean says.

You let it wash over you.

 

Notes:

I ❤️ comments!
Please let me know what your think, any notes or questions, and what part hits best for you!
COMMENTS=Variable Reinforcement
If you’re enjoying this, you can subscribe to the series for updates, or bookmark it to save it for later. ❤️
Thanks.