Actions

Work Header

Love, Shane

Summary:

Based off a Tumblr post by rainbow-femme
(They came up with the WHOLE idea, I just turned it into a fic)

Shane Hollander has exactly two modes with greeting cards: "Love, Shane" and emotional devastation. Ilya has watched the damage—Hayden sobbing in the kitchen and Yuna going quiet over the birthday cake. He thought he understood what he was in for.

He did not understand.

Notes:

Yay! 100 Kudos!
I did not realise I bypassed 300 Kudos. Thanks y'all.
Finding bookmarks that have little messages on them really make my dayyy

ALSO the End Notes is the ACTUAL POST with the ideas that OP had. Mine is a stretched out version of it. Feel free to check that out first before reading or check it out later, your call. Also, considering this is 9k+ words and people STILL sat through and read this through?? Standing ovation to y'all.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Shane’s cards had not always been dangerous.

For a long time, they had been exactly what people expected them to be: neat, polite, affectionate in the proper amount, his handwriting clean across the inside of store-bought paper that said Happy Birthday or Merry Christmas or Congratulations in looping silver letters. He had always signed them warmly enough. Love, Shane.

Sometimes a little more if the occasion required it, sometimes a little less if he was writing to someone he liked perfectly well but wasn't very close with. No one ever cried over those cards. No one needed to sit down before opening them. No one looked at the envelope in their hands like they were about to receive life-altering information from a man who, in most ordinary conversations, would rather die than say any of it out loud.

Then, at some point, usually without warning, something changed.

He still gave them cards, but now he wrote in them properly, and that was a very different thing. Shane was careful with his words when he spoke, dry where other people were earnest, private where other people were obvious. On paper, apparently, none of that applied. Once he crossed whatever private line existed in his own head, he became alarmingly sincere. The cards stopped being cards and started being small emotional ambushes.

No one was ever ready for the switch.

That was the problem. Even after people knew it was a possibility, even after they had seen it happen to someone else, they still opened Shane’s cards like they were expecting paper and ink instead of a full account of exactly how much he loved them and why.

Shane had learned, eventually, to give those ones privately. This was not modesty. It was practical. There were only so many times a person could accidentally make a grown man cry in the middle of a birthday dinner before adjustments had to be made.

It became, over time, a strange little pattern in Shane’s life: first the ordinary cards, signed Love, Shane like anyone else in the world, and then, once he loved someone enough to trust them with the full force of it, the other kind. The kind people carried away to read again later. The kind that got folded back into envelopes with shaking hands. Shane never seemed especially embarrassed by the aftermath, which only made it worse.

He would hand over the card, watch a person disintegrate in front of him, and then respond with the calm patience of someone who had merely offered them a glass of water and not a handwritten account of exactly how much they were loved.

The first time anyone in his family began to suspect that Shane’s cards might, in fact, be a public health risk, Hayden was standing in the kitchen with one hand over his mouth and tears already running down his face.

See, Hayden had opened the card expecting a card.

That was the problem, really. He had known Shane long enough by then to expect affection, sincerity even, but not this. Not the particular, devastating precision Shane seemed to reserve for paper, where he could apparently say things he would rather swallow whole than speak aloud.

He had made some stupid joke about hoping there was cash inside. Then he had wandered off toward the kitchen with his drink in one hand and the card in the other, leaving everyone else in the living room with the cake and the noise and the rest of his birthday.

Shane, who had absolutely known what was coming, had let him go.

A minute later, he had gone suspiciously quiet.

I used to think some people were just born knowing how to have a best friend, and maybe I had just missed whatever lesson everyone else got when they were kids.

At first, no one noticed.

Why would they? The apartment was full enough, Jackie halfway through a story on the couch, somebody in the corner arguing about music, David trying to cut the cake with the intense concentration of a man who believed uneven slices were a moral failure. Shane was leaning against the kitchen island with his beer, one ankle crossed over the other, looking as calm as he always did when he had just done something quietly catastrophic and was waiting for the damage to unfold.

Then Jackie paused in the middle of a sentence and looked over toward the kitchen.

“Where’s Hayden?” she asked.

Shane took a sip of his beer. “In the kitchen.”

“That narrows it down.”

He only lifted one shoulder.

Jackie squinted at him for a second. Then she set her plate down on the coffee table and went looking, which was how she found Hayden standing at the far end of the kitchen with one hand braced flat against the counter, his head bent over the open card, and tears already running down his face.

I thought maybe I was too much, or not enough, or some combination of both that meant I was meant to love people from a little further away than everyone else.

“Oh my God,” Jackie said.

Hayden made a strangled sound that might once have been a laugh. “I know.”

Shane, still leaning against the island a few feet away, looked up at the sound of Jackie’s voice but otherwise did not seem especially alarmed. That, more than anything, probably should have warned her this was not a crisis so much as a recurring event. Hayden, meanwhile, was blinking rapidly down at the card as if there were any chance at all that the words might rearrange themselves into something survivable if he gave them enough time.

By the time I got old enough to know better, I had mostly accepted that maybe I just wasn’t going to have that. Not the way other people seemed to. Not the easy, obvious kind. Not the person who just fit.

They did not.

I told myself it was fine. I had good people around me, people I cared about. But there was always this quiet ache underneath, this sense that I was standing just outside a room where everyone else had already found their seat.

Jackie looked from Hayden to Shane and back again, her eyebrows climbing higher with every second. “Did you—”

“Yes,” Shane said.

“Jesus Christ.”

Hayden laughed again, properly this time, but it came apart in the middle and turned into something else. He lowered the card, looked at Shane like he was personally responsible for every emotion currently ruining his birthday, and then covered his eyes with the back of one hand.

And then you showed up and made me feel a little stupid for ever believing I had missed my chance. You made room for me so naturally I didn’t even realise, at first, how badly I had wanted someone like you in my life.

“This is so fucked up,” he said thickly.

Shane’s mouth twitched. “It is birthday card.”

“You cannot say all this to somebody in a birthday card.”

“I already did.”

“That’s not a defence.”

“No?”

“No!"

Jackie, who had apparently decided very quickly that this was the funniest thing she had seen all week provided one did not look too closely at the tears situation, leaned one shoulder against the doorway and folded her arms. “What did he write?”

Hayden made a helpless gesture with the card.

You just... stayed. And then you stayed again. And somewhere between all the staying, I stopped bracing for you to leave. You gave me a kind of friendship I used to think belonged to other people. You made it look easy. You made me feel wanted in ways I didn’t know I was still waiting for.

Hayden lowered the card very slowly, stared at Shane for one raw, disbelieving second, and then crossed the kitchen in three quick steps and grabbed him. Not dignified. Not measured. Just both arms around Shane’s shoulders, face tucked hard against him, the card crushed between them as Hayden finally lost the last of the fight he had been putting up.

Shane made a soft oof sound as the beer bottle got trapped awkwardly between his wrist and Hayden’s side, then set it down on the counter without complaint and put both arms around him.

There he was.

One hand settled between Hayden’s shoulder blades. The other came up to the back of his neck. He rubbed slowly up and down, patient as anything, while Hayden clung to him and laughed wetly into his shoulder in the humiliating, broken way people did when they were crying too hard to be at all charming about it.

Jackie looked at Shane over Hayden’s shoulder.

Shane looked back, entirely composed, and gave her a small OK sign.

That made her snort out a laugh she tried very hard to turn into a cough.

“You absolute menace,” she said.

Hayden, still folded into Shane’s shoulder, lifted one hand blindly and flipped her off.

“See?” Jackie said. “He’s emotional and rude. You’ve really done a number on him.”

“I’m aware,” Shane said.

Hayden pulled back just enough to glare at him with a face already going blotchy. “You wrote me a psychological attack.”

I love everything about being your friend. I love how easy you make it to stay. I love that somewhere along the way you became family to me without asking permission first. I didn’t know, before you, that I could still have this. A best friend. A brother. A person I trust with my whole heart without ever needing to say it like that out loud, because somehow you always knew anyway.

“I wrote you birthday card.”

“You need to stop saying that like this is normal.”

Shane tilted his head, considering. “It is normal for me.”

“That is the least reassuring thing you’ve ever said.”

Jackie held out a hand. “Let me see it.”

Hayden clutched the card to his chest at once. “Absolutely not.”

“Oh, come on.”

“No. I’m serious. I’ll die.”

“You’re already dying.”

“I can die more.”

That got an actual laugh out of Shane, brief and quiet and impossible not to feel rewarded by. Hayden made an offended sound at it and shoved weakly at his shoulder, which only made Shane’s expression soften.

I don't know what I did to deserve you. I don't know what stars aligned or what I did right in a past life to land you in this one. But I am so grateful. I am so, so grateful. And I want you to know that I see you too. I see how hard you work, how much you carry, how quietly you hold things together for everyone around you. I see the person you are when no one is watching, and that is the person I am most proud to know.

“Okay,” Jackie said after a moment, her own voice suspiciously tighter than before. “Maybe don’t let me read it actually.”

Shane glanced at her. “Good instinct.”

She narrowed her eyes. “Have you done this to other people?”

Shane looked thoughtful for exactly long enough to be annoying. “Yes.”

“How many other people?”

“Enough.”

“Shane.”

He smiled into Hayden’s hair and said nothing.

That was answer enough, apparently, because Jackie just shook her head once and pushed away from the doorway, muttering something under her breath that sounded a lot like unbelievable. But she was smiling when she went, and when she passed back through the living room a minute later and David asked where Hayden was, she only said, “Emotionally compromised,” and kept walking.

Hayden stayed where he was for a while.

I still don't know what I did to deserve you. But I'm not going anywhere. And if you ever need someone to make room for you the way you made room for me— I'm already here.

Long enough that the music changed. Long enough that the candles on the cake had to be relit because apparently nobody was willing to drag the birthday boy out of his breakdown until he had finished having it. Shane did not seem to mind. He kept one hand on Hayden’s back and the other at his neck, steady and absentminded, as if this were not the direct and foreseeable result of his own choices.

Eventually Hayden pulled away enough to wipe at his face and look down at the card again. “Friends and brothers,” he said, his voice wrecked all over again. “For the rest of our lives?”

Shane, because he was apparently determined to kill him properly, only said, “Yes.”

Hayden stared at him for a second, then dropped his forehead to Shane’s shoulder with a low groan. “I’m gonna be sick.”

“You’re okay.”

“I’m not okay,” Hayden said into his shirt. “You can’t just— You can’t just write things like that down.”

Shane’s hand moved once, slow over the back of his neck. “Seems like I can.”

“Shut up.”

“Okay.”

Hayden laughed despite himself, which turned into one last broken little hiccup of crying and then, finally, into something he could live with. When he straightened properly, his face was a mess and his dignity was long gone and the card in his hand already looked handled too much to ever lie flat again. He looked at Shane with the dazed, exhausted expression of someone who had just survived a weather event.

“You’re insane,” he said.

Shane considered that. “Maybe.”

“No, like, clinically. Someone should study this.”

“Probably.”

Hayden looked down at the card again, then folded it shut with exaggerated care, like he no longer trusted himself to look directly at it for too long. “I’m keeping this forever, by the way. And if you ever die before me,” Hayden said, still sniffling, “I’m getting buried with it.”

Jackie’s voice floated in from the living room. “Jesus Christ.”

Hayden didn’t even turn around. “Mind your business.”

Shane, infuriatingly calm, rubbed one thumb once over Hayden’s shoulder and said, “That seems little impractical.”

“Don’t start with me.”

“I’m just saying.”

“Well, stop saying.”

Shane’s mouth twitched. “Okay.”

Thank you for being my person.

And that, more or less, was how the family learned that Shane’s cards had become a threat to public safety.

----

By the time Ilya learned about Shane’s cards properly, the people closest to Shane had already developed strategies.

Some of them practical. Some of them emotional. Most of them, as far as Ilya could tell, inadequate.

It was Yuna’s birthday, and the card itself did not look especially alarming. Cream envelope. Shane’s handwriting across the front. Nothing about it to suggest disaster. And yet when Yuna picked it up off the table, she handled it with the careful concentration of someone who knew there was at least a moderate chance this was going to end with her in tears. That, more than anything, was what caught Ilya’s attention.

He looked from the envelope to Yuna, then to Shane.

Shane, noticing the look, only lifted one shoulder.

Interesting.

Yuna opened it slowly. Not suspiciously, exactly. More like a person who had every intention of reading every word properly the first time. The room kept moving around her while she did it — glasses clinking, somebody laughing in the kitchen, Hayden saying something to David that made Jackie snort into her wine — but Ilya’s attention, against his own better judgement, settled and stayed.

Yuna read the first few lines with a small smile.

Then the smile changed.

It did not disappear. It softened. Her mouth pressed together slightly at one corner, the way it did when she was trying very hard not to make a scene over something that had gotten under her skin faster than expected.

She went still after that, eyes moving more slowly over the page, one thumb braced against the fold of the card as if holding it steady had become a task requiring concentration.

Ilya frowned a little.

Across the room, Shane had gone very still too, not tense, just attentive in that quiet way of his.

That was also interesting.

Yuna finished reading and stayed where she was for a second, looking down at the card.

Then she looked up at Shane with tears in her eyes.

Ilya sat up before he could stop himself.

Not in panic. Not exactly. More in confusion. Shane had not said anything. He had given his mother a birthday card, and now she looked like she was trying not to cry in front of the entire family.

Then Yuna crossed the room, put one hand against Shane’s cheek, and pulled him into a long, quiet hug.

No one interrupted.

That, perhaps, was the strangest part. No jokes, no commentary, not even Hayden, who seemed to recognise the moment on sight and wisely kept his mouth shut. The room simply adjusted around them, giving the embrace the sort of respectful space people made instinctively when they knew something meaningful was happening and had no desire to cheapen it by pointing.

Shane folded into the hug at once, one arm around her waist, the other coming up between her shoulder blades.

When she finally let him go, she kissed his cheek and said something too low for Ilya to hear.

Shane answered with that little private smile of his, the one that always looked like he was trying not to be more openly fond than the situation allowed.

And because apparently the entire Hollander family was committed to behaving like this was perfectly ordinary, everyone moved on.

Ilya, naturally, did not.

Later, when he had a chance to see the card — whether Yuna showed him, or Shane left it somewhere, he learned what had been in it.

Happy birthday, Mom.

I know birthday cards are supposed to be shorter than this, but apparently that’s not happening, so you’ll have to live with it.

The last year made me realise again how lucky I am that you’re my mother. I know that isn’t exactly new information, and I’m sure I’ve been aware of it in some form my whole life, but some years make you understand old facts more clearly, and this was one of them.

You’ve always been strong in a way that made hard things feel manageable, even when they weren’t. I think that’s one of the first things you ever taught me without meaning to. Not that life would always be easy, because obviously it wasn’t, but that difficult things could still be lived through. That panic was not the same thing as disaster. That people could keep going. That love could keep a house steady even when everything else felt uncertain.

You’ve always been supportive in a way that never felt performative or conditional. You were just there. Constantly. Quietly, when quiet was what was needed, and loudly when it wasn’t. I think I probably took that for granted when I was younger, which is what children do when they grow up inside something solid. They assume it’s ordinary because they’ve never had to imagine life without it.

The older I get, the more I understand that it wasn’t ordinary at all. Not everyone gets someone as steady as you. Not everyone gets a mother who makes it so easy to believe they are loved that it becomes part of the architecture of their life. I did. I do. And I know how lucky that makes me.

You made home feel safe for me. You made being loved feel normal, and I think that’s one of the best things a parent can do for a child. You gave me a place where I could grow up without having to wonder whether love would still be there when I came back to it. That is a bigger gift than I think I knew how to measure when I was younger, but I can measure it now.

And I think, over the last year especially, I’ve understood again how much of who I am rests on things you gave me so naturally I barely even knew to name them at the time. Patience. Stubbornness, probably. The ability to keep standing up when things are difficult. The certainty that loving people properly is worth the trouble.

I hope one day I can be even half the parent to my own children that you’ve been to me. If I can make them feel even a fraction as safe, as supported, and as loved as you always made me feel, I’ll think I did something right. More than right, actually. I’ll think I was lucky enough to pass on one of the best things I was ever given.

I love you very much. Happy birthday.

Love, Shane

It was, Ilya thought upon reading it, an absolutely deranged thing to hand a woman in a folded piece of paper over birthday cake.

And perhaps worse than that, it was beautiful.

That was the point where Ilya understood two things at once.

First, that the stories about Shane’s cards had not been exaggerated.

Second, with a small, sinking feeling he immediately resented, that eventually one of those cards was going to be his.

The thought arrived whole and unwelcome.

He wondered, against his will, what Shane would write to him.

Then he stopped wondering at once, because that way lay humiliation of a very particular kind, and Ilya had no interest in making himself ridiculous over a hypothetical birthday card months before his birthday. It was paper. Folded paper. That was all.

Still, the thought had lodged itself somewhere inconvenient.

He did his best to forget about it.

It helped that Shane never mentioned it. There was no smugness, no little look across the room, no indication at all that he had noticed Ilya noticing anything. He simply went on as usual, which in some ways made it worse. If he had teased him once, if he had said something dry and unbearable that gave Ilya an excuse to be annoyed, perhaps the whole thing would have settled properly.

Instead it was left alone, which meant it stayed where it was, quiet and unhelpful, surfacing only now and then at moments that made Ilya feel faintly insane.

Shane, months later, signing his name at the bottom of a thank-you note and Ilya, absurdly, having to look away.

Stupid.

He ignored it.

Mostly.

It did not help that Shane kept happening near him. Shane at the kitchen table, pen in hand, writing something with his hair falling forward so Ilya could see the pale nape of his neck. Shane in the doorway of the bedroom, shirt untucked, humming something off-key while he folded laundry with irritating competence.

Shane asleep on the couch one Sunday afternoon, mouth slightly open, one arm dangling off the cushion, and Ilya standing there with a blanket in his hands like an idiot, staring at him for thirty seconds before he draped it over him.

He almost pushed Shane's hair back from his forehead.

He didn't.

He went to the kitchen and made coffee too strong, jaw tight for reasons he refused to name.

---

By the time his birthday came around, Ilya had done an admirable job of not thinking about Shane’s cards.

Shane, infuriatingly, gave no sign of planning anything catastrophic.

He was perfectly normal about the whole thing. Maybe a little too normal, actually, which should have been suspicious, except Shane was also capable of making breakfast with that same flat, innocent expression while concealing any number of terrible intentions.

He kissed Ilya good morning, wished him happy birthday into the side of his mouth like he was not ruining his life by inches, and then went about the rest of the morning with the calm efficiency of a man who had absolutely nothing to hide.

It was a quiet day by design. No dinner out, no family descending on them in waves, no need to sit through a room full of people singing at him while he figured out what to do with his face. Just the two of them at home, which was how Ilya liked most things that mattered.

There were flowers on the counter from Yuna, a bottle of wine already open by the time the food was finished, and the easy sort of peace that settled over the apartment only on nights when neither of them had anywhere else to be.

Shane was in one of those moods that made him impossible to resist.

Not unusually affectionate, exactly. He was always affectionate with Ilya, in the thousand ordinary ways that had long ago become the structure of their life together. But tonight there was something especially soft in him, some extra looseness around the edges, some private satisfaction he was trying not to show too openly and failing at only because Ilya knew him too well to miss it.

He kept touching him in passing. A hand at the small of his back while reaching around him in the kitchen. Fingers brushing his wrist when he handed him a glass. A kiss stolen from the corner of his mouth for no reason except that Shane, apparently, had looked at him and decided he wanted one. 

By the time they finished dinner, Ilya was more interested in getting his hands on Shane than in behaving like a reasonable adult.

This was, in his view, an entirely appropriate use of a birthday.

Shane was rinsing plates when Ilya came up behind him and put both hands on his waist.

“You are very clingy tonight,” Shane said, though he leaned back into him immediately.

“It is my birthday.”

“That is not answer.”

“It is excellent answer.”

Shane laughed softly and turned in his arms, damp hands settling briefly against Ilya’s shirt before he dried them on a dish towel abandoned somewhere over his shoulder. He looked good like this — sleeves pushed up, hair a little messy, mouth still pink from wine, familiar in a way that kept taking Ilya by surprise even now.

Domesticity should have made him less devastating by now. It had not.

Ilya kissed him before he could say anything else irritating.

Shane made a pleased sound into it at once, one hand finding the front of Ilya’s shirt and bunching lightly there while the other came up to his jaw. It started as the sort of kiss they had a hundred times a week, easy and thoughtless and part of the shape of their evenings, but it did not stay that way for long.

It rarely did when Shane had had wine and nowhere to be. He leaned into Ilya more fully after a few seconds, mouth softening, body loosening, the whole of him warm and willing and so familiar that Ilya felt his own chest go quiet with it.

There he was.

He deepened the kiss a little, one hand sliding around Shane’s waist and the other to the back of his neck. Shane let himself be guided without resistance, smiling faintly against his mouth as if he knew exactly where this was going and approved of the route.

When Ilya nudged him backward, Shane went easily. When the backs of his thighs met the counter, he made that same little pleased sound again, and Ilya, because he was only a man and not an especially good one under these circumstances, lifted him up onto it without much ceremony.

Shane opened for him at once, knees parting so Ilya could step in between them, one hand settling at the back of his neck again while the other braced against the counter beside him. The position was familiar enough to make something low and affectionate turn over in Ilya’s chest.

Shane on the counter, warm and a little flushed, kissing him like he had nowhere else in the world he wanted to be.

Very nice birthday, actually.

Ilya kissed him until Shane was smiling helplessly into it. Then along his jaw. Then at the corner of his mouth again because he liked the way Shane giggled softly when he did that, as if being kissed in too many places in quick succession was somehow both ridiculous and deeply satisfactory. Shane’s fingers had found the hair at the nape of his neck by then, scratching lightly in the way that always made it harder for Ilya to think straight.

Manipulative, really.

Very effective.

He put one hand flat on the counter beside Shane’s hip and the other at his waist, thumbs slipping under the hem of his shirt just enough to feel warm skin. Shane shivered for him, immediate and honest, and tipped his head back when Ilya kissed his throat.

“You are spoiled,” Ilya murmured against his skin.

“It’s your birthday,” Shane said, breathless enough to be gratifying. “I’m being generous.”

Ilya smiled into the next kiss. “Is that what this is?”

“Mm.” Shane ran his fingers once through the short curls at the back of his head. “Don’t be ungrateful.”

As if Ilya had ever been capable of that where Shane was concerned.

He kissed him again, slower now, one of those kisses that made time go a little strange around the edges. Not urgent. Not careless. Just the steady, devastating sort of affection that felt too intimate to be shown to anyone else and yet had become so ordinary between them that it now lived in the kitchen between clean plates and half-drunk wine and the quiet hum of the refrigerator.

"There," Ilya said quietly, rubbing slow circles into the hollow of Shane's spine. "Relax."

"I am relaxed."

"You are kissing me like you are trying to climb inside my skin."

Shane pulled back just enough to give him an unimpressed look. "That was one time."

"It was many times."

Shane's face lit up, helpless and delighted, and he dissolved into giggles right there on the kitchen counter, legs tightening around Ilya's waist as if to keep him from escaping the sound. It was undignified and ridiculous and Ilya felt his heart melt so fast it was almost embarrassing.

He kissed the corner of Shane's smile, then the other corner, then his cheek, then his eyebrow for no reason except that Shane's giggles turned softer, breathier, when he did.

Ilya smiled, and kissed him properly. Shane melted into it, smiling against his mouth, fingers scratching at his scalp in that way that made thinking difficult. Ilya let his hand slide higher on Shane's thigh and felt him arch into him with a soft sound.

By the time Shane put a hand flat to his chest and gently pushed him back, Ilya was warm all the way through and in no fit state to discuss anything intelligently.

He frowned a little. “What?”

Shane was smiling at him, soft and pink and kissed senseless enough himself that it took some of the sting out of the interruption. “I have to get your gifts.”

For one dazed second, Ilya only looked at him.

He had, rather embarrassingly, forgotten all about gifts.

Not his finest moment.

Then the meaning of the words reached him properly, and something bright and stupid moved through him all at once. “Ah,” he said, eloquent as ever.

Shane laughed, quick and helpless, and leaned in to kiss him once more before sliding off the counter. “Stay there.”

“I’m not dog.”

“No,” Shane said, already halfway out of the kitchen. “You’re worse. Be good anyway.”

Ilya watched him go.

Then he leaned both hands on the counter behind him and tried, with limited success, to remember how to be a person for the next thirty seconds.

When Shane came back, he was carrying two wrapped boxes.

That, at least, restored some of Ilya’s higher brain function.

He straightened at once. “You wrapped it.”

Shane gave him a look. “Obviously.”

Ilya took them from him with what he felt was commendable restraint, though he was aware Shane was watching him closely enough to find even that amusing. The paper was dark blue, neatly folded at the corners, the tape almost invisible. Of course it was. Shane wrapped gifts the same way he did everything else: with irritating competence and enough care to make the result look effortless.

“What?” Shane said.

“You are very smug.”

“I’m not smug.”

“You wrapped something this neatly and brought it to me with that face. You are definitely smug.”

That made Shane smile, which was more or less an admission.

Ilya put both boxes down and opened the smaller box first.

Inside, nestled in tissue paper, was a stuffed loon. Not a cartoonish one. A proper one, soft grey and black with a white breast and a red eye that looked almost real, the sort of thing found in a museum gift shop rather than a toy store. The tag on its foot said something about conservation funding. Of course it did.

Ilya stared at it.

Then he looked up at Shane, who was watching him with that particular expression — soft around the mouth, trying not to look pleased with himself and failing.

"You are mocking me," Ilya said.

"No."

"You bought me a bird."

"A loon."

"Same thing."

Shane's smile widened slightly. "You cried the first time you heard them at the cottage. You pretended it was allergies, but you were standing on the dock at six in the morning with your coffee and you wiped your eyes twice."

"I did not."

"You did."

Ilya looked back down at the loon. Its eye was glassy and dark and somehow judgemental. "I hate this," he said, and tucked it under his arm lovingly.

Shane laughed, quiet and warm, and reached past him to the next box. "There's more."

He pulled out a flat package, wrapped in the same dark blue paper, and handed it over. Ilya unwrapped it to find a collection of items he didn't immediately recognise. Small packets. A roll-on stick. Something that looked like a miniature heating pad with a USB cord.

"What is this," Ilya said, not really a question.

"You said Icy-Hot patches don't work on you." Shane's voice had gone quieter, more practical, the way it did when he was being careful about something that mattered. "So I found alternatives. The roll-on is menthol and arnica, supposedly better for deep tissue. The heat pad is for your ribs — low setting, you can wear it under your shirt during meetings. The packets are herbal compresses, you microwave them. I don't know if any of it works, but—" He shrugged one shoulder, suddenly almost shy. "You won't admit your ribs still hurt, so I thought I'd try."

Ilya looked at the collection in his hands.

Then at Shane.

Then back at the loon, which he was still holding against his chest without meaning to.

"You researched this," he said.

"Yes."

"For how long?"

Shane's mouth twitched. "A while."

Ilya set the migraine aids down carefully on the counter. He kept the loon. He was, apparently, going to keep the loon.

"You are the worst person I know," he said.

"Okay."

"You make it very difficult to be normal."

"I know."

Ilya looked at the loon again. Its red eye gleamed up at him. He thought of the dock, the mist, the sound of them calling across the water while Shane stood beside him in a sweater that smelled like wood smoke, not saying anything, just there.

He pulled Shane in by the front of his shirt and kissed him. Shane made a surprised sound into it and then softened, one hand coming up to his jaw, the other settling at his waist.

When Ilya pulled back, Shane was smiling properly now, open and pleased and still trying to hide it.

He stepped closer, one hand coming up to rest light at Ilya’s waist, familiar and warm and entirely unhelpful. The touch was so easy by now, so ordinary, that it still had the power to wrong-foot him when he was already feeling too much. Ilya looked down at the gifts once more, then back at Shane, and felt something in his chest go very quiet with it.

He set the boxes aside before he did something embarrassing, like thank him too properly.

Shane watched him do it.

Then, when Ilya straightened again, he was still standing there with that same unreadable little look, one hand at Ilya’s waist, the other hanging loose by his side.

“What?” Ilya said.

Shane shook his head once, almost absently, and looked down for a second as if deciding something. Then he reached behind him to the counter. When he turned back, there was an envelope in his hand.

Ilya went still.

It was ridiculous, how quickly the room seemed to change around one harmless piece of paper. Cream-coloured. His name on the front in Shane’s handwriting. Nothing dramatic about it. Nothing threatening. Just an envelope, held loosely between Shane’s fingers like it weighed nothing at all.

Which, of course, meant absolutely nothing.

Shane looked at him for a moment, and whatever he saw in Ilya’s face made something soften in his own. “This one,” he said, quieter now, “you should probably sit down for.”

Ilya stared at him.

Then at the envelope.

Then back at Shane.

“That is deeply ominous,” he said.

A small smile pulled at Shane’s mouth. “Probably.”

“That is not reassuring.”

“It’s not supposed to be reassuring.”

“Wonderful.”

Shane laughed, brief and helpless, and stepped closer again until the envelope was between them.

For one absurd second, Ilya considered not taking it.

Not because he did not want it. That was, perhaps, the problem. He wanted it too much all at once, with a kind of immediate, humiliating clarity that made him feel about nineteen years old and not at all in control of himself. He had known this was coming, theoretically.

He had known it from the moment he watched Yuna go still over her birthday card, from the moment the thought lodged itself in him and refused, however intermittently, to leave. One day, he had thought then, with the particular resentment reserved for things that are both inevitable and unbearable.

Apparently one day was today.

Shane’s hand shifted slightly. Not pushing. Just waiting.

There was nothing teasing in his face now, nothing smug, nothing dry. Only a kind of steadiness that made the whole thing worse. “Hey,” Shane said, very softly.

Ilya looked up.

Shane’s thumb brushed once against the back of the envelope, almost absentmindedly. “You can open it later, if you want.”

That, more than anything else, nearly undid him.

Because Shane was giving him an out. Of course he was. After all of this, after apparently sitting down and writing whatever was inside in his own impossible handwriting, he was still standing there prepared to make it easy for Ilya if easy was what he needed.

Idiot.

Beautiful idiot.

“No,” Ilya said, and was relieved his voice sounded more or less normal. “I want it now.”

Something in Shane’s expression changed at that. Small. Deep. Not quite relief, exactly, but close enough that Ilya felt it like a touch.

He held the envelope out properly then.

Ilya took it.

It was warm from Shane’s hand.

He slid his thumb under the flap with more care than dignity and opened it, then reached inside.

And paused.

It did not feel like a card.

He frowned slightly and pinched the edge of the paper between two fingers, drawing it out in a single smooth motion that stopped halfway only because his brain took a second too long to understand what he was looking at.

Not a folded card.

Not even a longer note tucked into one.

Just paper.

Several sheets of it.

Ilya stared.

Then he pulled the rest of it free and discovered, with a kind of slow, gathering disbelief, that there was more than he had first thought. A small stack, neatly folded together, edges aligned, Shane’s handwriting visible immediately on the first page and then again through the thin layers underneath.

He looked up. “This,” Ilya said, because he was suddenly not sure he had enough English for the situation, “is not a card.”

“No,” he said.

Ilya looked back down at the pages in his hands.

There were at least four. Maybe five. He did not count properly. He only saw the density of Shane’s writing, the way it filled the page in controlled, deliberate lines, and felt something in his chest shift all at once into a shape much more dangerous than nerves.

Because this was not a card anymore. This was not even a long card.

This was Shane, apparently, abandoning the concept of limited space as a failure of the format and deciding to continue anyway.

Completely insane behaviour.

And because Ilya was himself, because humiliation was alive and well in him even now, his first clear thought was not oh God or he wrote me pages or even Shane.

It was, absurdly: he had more to say than would fit.

He made the mistake of glancing at the top page.

The first line was enough to tell him two things immediately: first, that sitting down had not, in fact, been a suggestion, and second, that if he attempted to read this standing in the middle of the kitchen like a normal person, he was going to end up on the floor for reasons that would not flatter him.

Shane, of course, noticed.

“Told you,” he said quietly.

Ilya laughed once, though there was nothing especially funny in it. More disbelief than humour. More self-defence than either.

“You wrote me pages.”

“Yes.”

“As if this is reasonable.”

“It wasn’t going to fit in a card.”

That was said so simply, so matter-of-factly, that Ilya had to close his eyes for a second. When he opened his eyes again, Shane was still watching him, quieter now than before, his own composure beginning to show its seams in small ways only Ilya would ever notice. The slight tension in his mouth. The stillness. The fact that his hand, resting against the counter, had curled in on itself a little at the fingers.

He looked back down at the pages, then at Shane again.

“You are unbelievable,” he said, and meant it in every possible way.

“Probably,” Shane replied.

Ilya lowered himself onto the nearest chair before his legs embarrassed them both.

The pages trembled once in his hands.

He ignored that completely.

Then he took a breath, flattened the top sheet with his thumb, and began to read.

He read the first line twice.

I am not good at saying things out loud. You know this. You have watched me fail at it for years. So I am writing them instead, which means you will have to live with the fact that I had time to edit, and I still decided this was the best version.

Ilya looked up.

Shane had moved to the sink and was rinsing the wine glasses with his back to him, shoulders loose, as if he had not just handed over a small emotional bomb and was now pretending to be interested in soap.

"You are terrible," Ilya said.

"Mm," Shane agreed, not turning around.

Ilya looked back down.

The second paragraph began with something about Vegas, which was already unfair. He felt his mouth tighten and turned the page too quickly, tearing it slightly at the corner. He stared at the tear with genuine betrayal, as if the paper had personally wronged him, then kept reading.

By the third page he had forgotten he was sitting.

He stood up without deciding to, the chair scraping loudly against the tile, and walked three steps toward the living room before realising he had nowhere to go. Shane glanced over his shoulder, saw him standing there with pages in both hands like a man reading a map in a language he had not quite learned, and smiled.

"Water?" Shane asked.

"I am fine."

"You've been holding your breath."

"I have not."

Shane dried his hands on a towel and leaned against the counter, watching him with that particular patience that always made Ilya want to either kiss him or flee. "Your face is red."

"It is warm in here." Ilya turned his back on him and kept reading.

The first time I heard you laugh—really laugh, not the polite thing you did at parties—was two months in. You were drunk on terrible wine and telling me about your first coach, and your whole face changed. I remember thinking: oh. That's what he looks like when he's not careful. I wanted to be the reason for that always. I'm still trying.

Ilya walked into the living room.

He did not remember deciding to do this. His legs had simply carried him away from the kitchen, from Shane's visible presence, from the unbearable fact of being watched while he was being dismantled. He sat on the couch. Stood up again. Sat back down. The pages rustled in his hands.

He got to the part about the apartment — something absurdly specific about the way Ilya arranged the coffee mugs in the cabinet, handle-out, which Shane had apparently found endearing for years without mentioning it — and laughed once, sharply, before his throat closed over it.

He stood up again.

The room was too small. The apartment was too small. He walked to the window and back, still reading, and walked into the edge of the coffee table hard enough to swear in Russian.

"Everything okay?" Shane called from the kitchen.

"I am reading."

"Sounds violent."

"It is your fault."

"Probably."

Ilya turned another page and discovered there was still more.

This was inhumane.

You still talk in your sleep sometimes. Last week you said "Shane, that's the wrong sauce" at 3am and I laughed for ten minutes without making a sound so I wouldn't wake you. The week before that you said "stay" very quietly, and I did. I always do. Even when you don't say it out loud. Especially then. I'm not going anywhere.

He walked into the kitchen again without looking up, navigating by memory and nearly colliding with the island, and opened the refrigerator. He stared into it without seeing anything, one hand holding the pages flat against his chest, the other reaching blindly for something cold.

His fingers closed around a bottle. He brought it out and discovered it was ketchup.

He put it back.

Shane, still at the counter, was watching him with his chin in his hand, openly delighted now. "Need help?"

"I am fine."

"You put ketchup on the counter."

"I am aware."

"You are not aware of anything right now."

Ilya closed the refrigerator with his hip and walked out again.

He made it to the hallway before he had to stop and lean against the wall, one forearm braced above his head, pages dangling from his other hand. His eyes were stinging. He blamed the hallway light. It was too bright. Everything was too bright, too warm, too full of Shane's handwriting describing things Ilya had not known he remembered.

You once told me, he read, that I was the only person you had ever wanted to stay. I think about that more than I should. I think about it when you are annoying. I think about it when you are perfect. I think about it when you are asleep and I am awake and the apartment is quiet enough that I can hear you breathing. I think: he stayed. He's still here. I don't know what I did to deserve that, but I'm grateful in ways that make me write things like this at 2am while you're sleeping in the next room.

Ilya pressed his forehead against the wall.

The drywall was cool. It helped slightly. Not enough.

He felt warmth at his back before he heard footsteps. Shane's chest pressed against his shoulder blades, not heavy, just there. His chin settled briefly on Ilya's shoulder, reading the same line Ilya had stopped on. His breath stirred the hair at Ilya's temple.

Neither of them spoke.

Shane's hand came up to rest flat against Ilya's stomach, fingers spreading wide as if to feel his breathing.

"Your heart is loud," Shane murmured.

"Shut up," Ilya said, and felt Shane smile against his neck.

"Keep reading," Shane whispered, and pressed a kiss there, just below his ear, soft and brief. "I'm right here."

He didn't retreat. He stayed pressed against Ilya's back, one hand on his stomach, his chin on his shoulder, reading along in silence.

Ilya turned the page with shaking hands.

I know you think you're difficult to love. I know because you've told me, usually at three in the morning when you think I'm asleep. You're wrong. You're the easiest thing I've ever done. Not because you're easy—God, you're not—but because loving you is the most natural thing in my life. Like breathing. Like blinking. Like wanting to touch your hair when you walk past me in the kitchen. I don't decide to do it. I just do.

Shane's hand slid up to cover Ilya's, steadying it.

Shane turned him around gently, one hand at his waist, the other cupping his jaw. He didn't say anything. He just looked at him—at his wet eyes, his blotchy face, the pages crumpled between them—and smiled in that soft, unbearable way.

Ilya kissed him.

It was not a good kiss. His face was wet, his nose was running, he was still holding the papers in one hand and they were crumpling against Shane's shoulder. Shane made a surprised sound into it and then softened, opening for him with the same easy willingness he brought to everything, one hand coming up to cradle the back of his head.

When Ilya pulled back, he was breathing harder and no less emotional. He let Shane guide him back to the kitchen. He sat on the floor this time, back against the cabinets, and Shane sank down beside him, shoulder to shoulder, thigh to thigh. He didn't try to take the pages. He just sat there, one hand resting on his own knee, the other hanging loose between them.

After a moment, Shane's pinky finger brushed against Ilya's.

Then his whole hand turned over, palm up, waiting.

Ilya stared at it.

Then he threaded his fingers through Shane's and held on too tight.

Shane squeezed back. "Okay?"

"No," Ilya said.

"Okay."

Ilya bent his head and kept reading.

I used to think love was supposed to feel like certainty. Like knowing. You make it feel like choosing. Every day. Even when you're annoying. Even when I want to shake you. Even when you're crying on the kitchen floor because I wrote you a letter. Especially then. I would choose this every time. I would choose you every time. I have chosen you every time, even when I didn't know how to say it, even when I was stupid and scared and standing in elevators staring at my phone like an idiot.

Ilya looked up.

Shane was watching him, eyes bright and soft and a little wet now too.

Ilya stared at him. Then he lifted their joined hands and pressed his mouth to Shane's knuckles, not quite a kiss, more like he needed to put his mouth somewhere and Shane's skin was the only thing that made sense.

Shane's breath caught.

Ilya bent his head again.

The first time you said my name in your sleep I thought I had imagined it. The second time I recorded it. I still have the audio. I am not sorry. I listen to it sometimes when you're on road trips. Your voice saying "Shane" like it's a place you want to be. I want to be that place for you always. I want to be home for you in the way you are for me.

Ilya made a sound. He wasn't sure what kind. Something between a laugh and a sob, ugly and unguarded. He pressed the heel of his hand hard against his mouth and kept reading.

You are not a project. You are not a phase. You are not something I am putting up with. You are the person I want to tell when something is funny and the person I want when nothing is. You are the person I reach for in my sleep. You are the person whose shampoo I smell on my pillow when you're gone and don't wash the sheets because I'm ridiculous. You are it for me. I don't know how to say that without sounding like a greeting card so I am writing it instead, and you will have to live with the fact that I had time to edit and this is still what I came up with.

Ilya blinked, hard, and felt tears run down his face without bothering to wipe them. He turned another page, and another, Shane's handwriting swimming and settling.

"You wrote me pages," he said, his voice wrecked.

"Yes," Shane said.

"You cannot just—" He gestured with the papers, which flapped pathetically. "You cannot just write these things and expect me to—"

"To what?"

Ilya stared at him.

Shane was smiling, small and private, his thumb brushing over Ilya's cheekbone to catch a tear. He showed him the wetness on his fingertip with the calm of a scientist presenting findings.

"Oh," Ilya said.

"Yeah."

"I am not—" He stopped again. There was no point. He was crying. Had been for some time.

Shane shifted closer, pressing their shoulders together, his hand finding Ilya's again. "You can keep reading," he said. "Or not. Whatever you need."

Ilya looked down at the pages. At Shane's hand in his. At the tile floor.

He turned his face into Shane's shoulder instead.

Shane made a soft sound and put both arms around him, easy and unhurried. Ilya stiffened automatically—old habit, old pride—then felt it leave him all at once, a door opening somewhere in his chest.

He let his forehead drop to Shane's shoulder.

The pages crumpled slightly between them. He did not care.

"You are the worst person I know," he said into Shane's neck.

"Okay."

"You planned this."

"Obviously."

"You wanted me to—" He gestured vaguely, the papers rustling against Shane's back. "To do this."

"I wanted you to know."

"That is—" Ilya swallowed. "That is not fair."

Shane's hand moved in slow circles at the base of his spine. "Probably not."

"You should have warned me."

"I did. I said sit down."

"That was not sufficient warning."

Shane laughed, warm against his hair. "What would have been sufficient?"

Ilya thought about it. "Nothing," he admitted. "There was no warning that would have been sufficient."

"See?"

"You are unbearable."

"I know."

Ilya pulled back just enough to look at him. Shane's face was close, still smiling, eyes bright with something that looked almost like tears himself.

Ilya kissed him again.

It was still messy. His face was still wet, his nose still running. Shane made a soft sound into it and then smiled, opening for him, his hand sliding back into Ilya's hair to scratch lightly at his scalp.

"There," Shane whispered against his mouth.

Ilya made a broken sound and Shane shushed him, not with words, just with his mouth against Ilya's temple, pressing small kisses there like punctuation. Ilya lifted his head enough to find Shane's mouth again, tasting salt and wine and Shane, messy and uncoordinated because he was still crying, because none of this was dignified.

Shane smiled into it, fond and wrecked, and wiped Ilya's cheek with his thumb.

Ilya caught the thumb in his mouth, kissed it, felt Shane's breath hitch.

"You're disgusting," Shane whispered.

"You love it," Ilya said, voice thick.

"I really, really do."

He turned his face in closer again, hiding there shamelessly, and felt Shane shift to make it easier for him. Shane's hand stayed in his hair, the other arm firm around his shoulders, holding him without any need to make a point of it.

"I hate you," Ilya said.

"I know."

"You planned this."

"Yes."

"You wanted me on the kitchen floor."

Shane squeezed him. "I wanted you to know."

Ilya turned his head. Shane was looking at him, close enough to see every tear track, every blotchy mark. He didn't look away. He never looked away.

"I knew," Ilya said, quieter.

"I know." Shane smiled, small and wrecked and fond. "But now you have it in writing."

Ilya stared at him.

Then he leaned forward, forehead dropping to Shane's shoulder, pages crumpling between them, and let himself be held.

Shane's hand resumed its slow path through his hair, scratching lightly, the other arm wrapped firm around his back. They sat there for a long moment, breathing together, Shane's chin resting on top of Ilya's head.

"I can't feel my foot," Shane said eventually.

Ilya laughed, wet and surprised, the sound muffled against Shane's shirt. "Then move."

"Can't. You're heavy."

"I am not heavy."

"You're emotionally heavy. Same thing."

Ilya lifted his head enough to glare at him. Shane was grinning, eyes soft, his thumb brushing over Ilya's cheekbone to catch a stray tear.

"You're ridiculous," Ilya said.

"You're crying on my shoulder."

"I am aware."

"You're also—" Shane stopped, his expression shifting into something even softer. He leaned in and kissed Ilya's cheek, then the corner of his mouth, then his forehead. "You're also very loved," he whispered. "In case that part wasn't clear."

Ilya felt his face crumple again.

Shane saw it and pulled him back in, tucking Ilya's head under his chin, hand resuming its path through his hair. "Okay," he said softly. "Okay. I've got you."

And he did.

Notes:

Edit: AHHH I forgot to thank people!!
1. I want to thank the three people from Tumblr who gave me the birthday gift ideas when I was stressing at 1am. LOVE Y'ALL.
2. That one specific person who messaged me privately telling me how awesome this fic was. THANK YOU SO MUCH. (It was three paragraphs long y'all. THREE!)

Actual post:
Shane is one of those people who will just write “Love, Shane” at the bottom of a card UNTIL he feels comfortable being vulnerable with that person, at which point he writes the most heartbreakingly sweet and earnest notes. And no one is ever ready for the switch, and even after it happens they can never fully prepare themselves for what they’re going to get. Shane has learned that when he’s going to do that he should take them aside to give them the card rather than in front of people

Once Shane feels comfortable with Hayden as a genuinely good friend in his birthday card that year he writes out a whole thing about how he’s always wanted a best friend like other kids had but never had one and had accepted he never would, and then Hayden came into his life and gave him a level of love and friendship he never thought he would get and he loves everything about Hayden and can’t wait to be by his side as friends and brothers for the rest of their lives. Hayden fully breaks down and loses it, Jackie notices they’ve been gone a while and walks into the kitchen to see Hayden hugging Shane and sobbing into his shoulder. She raises her eyebrows at Shane and Shane just gives her the OK sign and goes back to rubbing Hayden’s back

Ilya learns about the card thing when it’s yunas birthday and he notices her opening Shane’s card like she’s deactivating a bomb. She stares silently as she reads it and Ilya starts freaking out a little when she starts to tear up and then pulls Shane in for a long silent hug. He looks at it later and sees that Shane wrote about how the last year made him realize over again how lucky he is to have someone as strong and supportive as her as a mother and he hopes to one day be half the parent to his own kids as she was to him

When it’s their first time having Ilya’s birthday together he’s legitimately nervous because this is his first Shane Card and he doesn’t know what to expect and part of him is afraid he’s built it up too much in his head and Shane won’t have as nice things to say as he did with other people. And then he opens the envelope and there’s no card but instead multiple pieces of paper because Shane couldn’t fit it all into a limited space.

Ilya spends the better part of the next hour walking around the house reading it, taking breaks occasionally to cry or hyperventilate before going back to reading it because holy shit does Shane Hollander love him. Like he knew logically that Shane did but now he’s got pages and pages of Shane walking him through his feelings over the last decade of their life and every moment he remembered and cherished. Shane finally catches up to him and he’s on the floor of the kitchen, face a splotchy red mess, chugging Gatorade because he’s dehydrated from crying.