Actions

Work Header

Choices

Summary:

One week before the Astronomy Tower, Severus Snape falls through time and finds himself face-to-face with the impossible.

Harry Potter respects him. Ron Weasley trusts him. His house has flowers in it...and Hermione Granger is his wife.

With only two days before he must return to the choice that haunts him, Snape must decide whether the future he has seen is a cruel illusion or a life worth fighting for.

Notes:

This one shot refused to leave me alone. Every time I carved out time to write the next chapters of Kintsugi, I wrote the first scene of this instead. I simply couldn't stop thinking about it.

I wrote this all in one go. It's only been lightly edited as I looked over it to post. Any errors are my own. Enjoy this rabid plot bunny 🐇

Work Text:

The impact knocked the breath from his lungs. 

For one disorienting moment, Snape thought he had misjudged the distance. The battlements should have been closer. The hard ground should not have been polished wood. His wand was in his hand before he had fully risen.

Two wands were already pointed at him.

The first man was tall. Broad-shouldered. The unmistakable hair marked him as a Weasley, though the boyish roundness Snape knew had been replaced by sharper features and a cropped haircut.

The second—

The second was more alarming. Older than James Potter had ever been. Bearded, his dark hair pulled back from his face. Those eyes. There was no mistaking those eyes behind the wire-rimmed glasses.

"...Potter?"

The man's expression shifted from alarm to something far worse. Horror.

"Oh, no."

The redhead stared. "...Harry. Is that— I think that's—"

Potter lowered his wand. "Yeah."

"It can't be."

"It is."

Snape's already thin patience vanished.

"Would someone care to explain why two much-aged students are standing in my sitting room?"

Only then did he properly look around…and stop. This was Spinner's End, and it was not. The threadbare curtains were gone. The cracked plaster had been repaired. The shelves remained filled with books, but the dust and neglect had vanished. There were flowers. Photographs. Children's toys. Evidence of life. 

His eyes narrowed. "...My sitting room."

Potter's expression somehow became more pained.

"What year are you from, sir?"

The respect in Potter's tone was almost more disturbing than the question. Snape found himself answering honestly. 

"Nineteen ninety-seven."

Harry closed his eyes. "Before the thirtieth of June?"

"Yes. One week before."

"Bloody fucking hell," Ron swore. "Is this why Severus asked us to check on the house?"

Harry pinched the bridge of his nose.

"Oh, for God's sake."


Snape sat on a couch far too comfortable for Spinner's End and folded his arms, watching the two men pace before him in increasingly frantic circles. He had faced the Dark Lord with less visible distress than these aged dunderheads were showing. Snape sighed. 

"I see you two remain incapable of independent thought."

"We're thinking!" Weasley protested.

"Without success, clearly," Snape drawled. He watched their exchange with growing irritation. Some things, apparently, had not changed with time. "Where is Miss Granger? I assume she continues to do your thinking for you."

Potter and Weasley exchanged a look of silent communication. Weasley made a strangled sound in his throat, shaking his head at Potter with wide eyes. Potter closed his eyes.

"Oh, for the timeline."

"The war," Weasley hissed. "Mione!"

Potter dragged a hand down his face. "Oh, fuck."

Severus frowned.

"Why, precisely, would Miss Granger prove any more hazardous to your precious timeline than you two?"

Potter opened his mouth. 

The front door opened.

"Boys?" The woman's voice carried from the hallway. "I'm home. Severus has been behaving so oddly all morning. He insisted on taking the girls to Minerva's himself so I could meet you here first—"

The room went still. Snape's mind caught on individual words.

Severus. His name, spoken casually. Familiar.

Home. Not Spinner's End. Not the house he had inherited from a father he despised. A home.

Girls.

His fingers tightened slightly around his wand. Potter closed his eyes.

Weasley whispered, "We're dead. She's gonna lose it."

Potter glanced at Snape.

"Whatever happens next..." A grin tugged at his mouth despite the situation. "...be nice to her."

Snape's lip curled. "I beg your pardon?"

Weasley leaned closer. "Her husband is terrifying."

Harry nodded. "Very protective."

Snape stared at them. "...You are describing me? But who?"

A pretty witch with a riot of brown curls rounded the doorway, still smiling.

"Boys, honestly, if Severus is planning some type of surprise for our anniversary—"

She stopped. The smile vanished. Every trace of color drained from her face. For one suspended heartbeat, she simply stared.

Then her suitcase slipped from nerveless fingers. It struck the floor with a dull thud. Her wand was in her hand before it stopped bouncing.

"Harry, what the hell! Ron! Riddik—"

She never finished. 

Potter moved first. Weasley a heartbeat later. To Snape's astonishment, they stepped between him and Miss Granger. Shielding...him. From her. The absurdity of it was almost enough to make him laugh.

Almost.

"Hermione." Potter's voice had gone impossibly gentle. She didn't seem to hear her friend. Her eyes remained fixed on him. Snape frowned.

Miss Granger. Older, certainly. The years had softened the sharp angles of adolescence into beauty, but there was no mistaking the intelligent brown eyes now wide with...terror?

Not fear of attack, something else. Something far more personal. An unpleasant weight settled low in his stomach. She was looking at him as though his mere existence had wounded her.

"Hermione," Harry said. "He's not a boggart."

Her eyes squeezed shut. A sharp breath escaped her. Weasley spoke just as quietly.

"Something time-turnery's going on, Mione."

She opened her eyes again. Still looking only at Severus.

"…He's..." Her voice broke. Her gaze swept over him. Too thin. Shoulders bowed beneath invisible weight. Skin stretched tight across sharp cheekbones. Eyes that had forgotten what uninterrupted sleep looked like. Recognition gave way to something perilously close to grief. The thought was absurd. Miss Granger had no reason to grieve him. 

"...From the Shack?"

"No," Potter answered softly. "The year before…Right before Dumbledore."

The door banged open hard enough to rattle the photographs on the mantel. Black robes swept into the room. For one irrational moment, Severus thought he was looking into a mirror. Then the illusion fractured.

The man was older. He had to be. Silver threaded through his dark hair at the temples. Lines marked his face that had not yet been earned by the man Snape was now.

And yet...

The hollows beneath his cheekbones were gone. The constant tension that pulled at his shoulders had eased. He looked older, but not worn. His face bore the evidence of years, but not the weight of them. Strength where Severus knew only endurance.

The impossible man did not look at Potter or Weasley. Did not even look at him. His attention went immediately to Miss Granger. He took her face in his hands.

"I am so sorry, my love."

For perhaps the first time in years, Snape failed to control his expression. His mouth fell open.

My love?

The words were absurd, and yet Miss Granger did not recoil.

"I couldn't tell you when it would happen."

Miss Granger gripped the front of his robes. Her face was a storm of anger, fear, and something far more painful.

"You knew it was today?"

Snape felt the instinctive urge to look away. The moment was too intimate. Too personal, and yet he remained rooted in place. His future self—inconceivable though the thought remained—brushed the tears from Miss Granger's face with his thumbs. Gently.

"I knew." 

The answer was quiet. Certain.

"You let me walk into this?" Her voice cracked. 

"I needed you to." He rested his forehead against hers. "I needed him to see."

He drew her closer, one hand settling into her hair as though the gesture was familiar. Practiced. As though he had done it a thousand times. Miss Granger rested her cheek against his chest. Her eyes never left Snape. 

That was the strangest part, the way she looked at him. As though she was seeing someone she loved and someone she had lost at the same time.

"Harry. Ron." Future Severus finally looked away from her. "Thank you for being here."

The gratitude was genuine. Not the forced politeness of an ally or the reluctant acknowledgment of a useful soldier.

"I know this is quite the surprise, I would have warned you if I could have without risking a change in the timeline."

Harry waved a hand. "You don't have to—"

"I do."

The interruption was quiet. Final. Snape recognized the tone. He had used it himself countless times. 

The man finally looked at him. Really looked at him. For a long moment, neither spoke. Snape waited for something. A smug remark. A warning. Perhaps even pity.

He received none.

Only a look of unsettling familiarity. As though the man before him remembered exactly what it felt like to stand where Snape stood now. As though he remembered the exhaustion, the sleepless nights. The weight of every choice pressing down until breathing itself felt like a burden.

"You are fifteen years in the future." The words were quiet, almost rehearsed. "A future that cost more than you can presently imagine. One that exists only because of the choices you are about to make."

Then, with the same authority Snape had used on students for years: "Sit down."

Snape's eyes narrowed. "I have no intention—"

"You look as though you've forgotten to eat." The interruption was immediate. Annoyingly familiar. "It is upsetting my wife to see you like this."

"I fail to see—"

"Sit."

The word cracked through the room with unmistakable authority. Snape's spine stiffened. There was something deeply unsettling about hearing his own voice—his own command—delivered by a man who looked like him. 

Hermione let out a quiet breath. 

"Severus." He glanced toward her. "Stop."

Slowly, she put her wand away. Snape watched as she forced herself to take a breath. To gather the pieces of herself. The terror did not vanish, but it was carefully folded away. Then she turned back to him.

"I'm so sorry, sir." Her voice was softer now. "Please excuse my husband. He has a habit of slipping into professor mode when stressed."

The corner of Future Severus' mouth twitched. As though this apology was both unnecessary and completely expected. Hermione offered Snape a small, strained smile.

"Welcome to our home." She gestured toward the sofa. "Please, have a seat, sir. Severus, put the kettle on, please."

"Of course."

Snape's fingers tightened. He had never imagined there existed a version of himself who could be ordered into domestic service and somehow look neither insulted nor defeated.

Ron leaned toward Harry and muttered under his breath, "Still can't believe that works."

Harry grinned. "Works every time. You're a bit soft in our time, sir."

"Severus is happy, not soft." Hermione rolled her eyes, though there was still a trace of strain around them. Then she turned back to Snape. 

"You hate when I apologize on your behalf," she said quietly, "but I am sorry, sir."

The words caught him off guard.

"Not for him," she continued, glancing briefly toward her husband. "For this. For you being brought here without warning. For being forced to see things you were never meant to see." Her expression softened. "I imagine it is rather a lot to take in. I know it is for me, to see you like this again."

Snape had no answer for that. Because she was right, and somehow that was worse. After a long, suspicious pause, he sat. His eyes continued their relentless survey of the room.

The polished floorboards. The repaired walls. The toys.

The warmth.

His older self emerged from the kitchen carrying a tea tray. Without asking, he placed one cup into Hermione's waiting hands before setting the others around the room. As he passed behind her chair, his fingers settled briefly against her shoulders.

She leaned back into the touch without even looking. A gesture practiced. Familiar.

Harry and Ron exchanged a glance before shrugging and taking their seats. Snape stared at them all for a long moment. At the ease, the affection. The impossible normality of it.

Finally, very quietly, he muttered, "I'm in hell."

Potter laughed. Then he looked around the bright, comfortable sitting room. At Hermione and Future Severus. Then back at Snape.

"...Really? This is your hell, Professor?"

Snape's gaze moved away. He meant it as a dismissal. A dry remark. An attempt to make sense of a situation that had become increasingly impossible. Instead, his eyes caught on the mantel. Photographs. His attention narrowed despite himself. A wedding. 

His wedding. The man in the photograph was unmistakably him, though the expression on his face was one Snape had never seen reflected back at him in a mirror.

Another image. Minerva McGonagall holding a tiny infant, her usually stern face softened by something dangerously close to tears.

Another. Two young girls perched on Severus' shoulders, both laughing while he wore an expression of long-suffering resignation that fooled no one. The girls smiled at him and waved. 

His throat tightened. He looked away immediately. As though refusing to observe something could make it less real.The reaction disgusted him. He had spent decades training himself to distrust sentiment, yet a single image of himself smiling had unsettled him more than any prophecy, curse, or threat the Dark Lord had ever offered.

Then Hermione laughed softly. His head turned before he could stop himself. Future Severus had said something too quiet for him to hear. She smiled at him, not as though she were tolerating him but with complete and effortless affection.

Snape frowned as he watched himself and saw a man who was loved.

"...Purgatory, perhaps."


"Don't let Hermione cook for you, Professor," Harry said with a grin. 

"Or Severus grill," Ron added. "Last time he cremated the sausages." 

Severus rolled his eyes. "One time, seven years ago." 

Harry embraced Hermione tightly as he left. She laughed, then she kissed his cheek. Ron followed with his own embrace, earning another laugh before pressing a quick kiss to her other cheek.

Something unpleasant twisted low in Snape's chest. He did not know what it was. Or perhaps he did, and disliked the implication. His gaze moved to his older self.

This future Severus had seen it. He had watched another man put his hands on his wife, and he had not moved. Had not reacted. Did not even appear concerned.

"You permit that?"

The words escaped before he had considered whether they should. Severus looked up from collecting the teacups.

"Obviously."

Snape's eyes narrowed. "She is your wife."

For a moment, Severus simply regarded him. Then, quietly: "You still believe love is a thing to be won." 

The words struck harder than they should have. Snape's expression hardened.

"I have no idea what you mean."

"Of course you don't. She has yet to teach you."

Severus glanced toward the door where Harry and Ron had disappeared.

"Hermione has never made me feel she loves me less because she loves others. Love is not a competition."

The words were spoken with the certainty of someone who had once believed the opposite. Someone who had been wrong.

"It took us rather a long time to learn that."

Snape said nothing.

Because the answer that came to mind was not a rebuttal. It was a memory. A red-haired girl, a boy with glasses. The unbearable realization that perhaps he had spent his entire life believing love was something someone else could win from him. That perhaps he was wrong. 


Snape sat stiffly at the kitchen table, the plate before him untouched. He was hungry. He simply found the notion of eating in the middle of this inconceivable day faintly absurd.

Time travel. Himself with grey at his temples. Potter bearded and Weasley broad as a wardrobe.

Hermione Granger—

He stopped the thought before it could finish. None of this could be real. Perhaps this was some elaborate piece of magic. A curse. A hallucination born of exhaustion.

His gaze flicked briefly toward the window. Or perhaps he had simply fallen hard enough this time, finally fallen faster than his magic could stop. The thought was oddly comforting. 

Dumbledore had always possessed an irritating talent for manipulating the improbable. Perhaps he had finally managed to break Snape's mind. A small, humorless laugh escaped him.

No.

Even Dumbledore's imagination would have lacked the audacity to invent a future in which Hermione Granger looked at him with unconcealed love...or in which he returned it so effortlessly.

Across the table, Severus waited until the silence settled. 

"I'm sure you have questions." He folded his hands loosely before him. "You may ask them." His mouth twitched almost imperceptibly. "I remember which ones I answered. I believe the timeline will survive the conversation."

Dark eyes met his own.

"What do you know?"

Snape inclined his head.

"If this is indeed the future—and I am not lying unconscious somewhere under the effects of an unusually elaborate curse—I can safely conclude the Light prevails."

His gaze shifted to Hermione.

"From Miss Granger's—"

"Hermione," she corrected gently. A small smile touched her lips, tinged amusement. "I haven't been Miss Granger for quite some time, Professor. Unless you prefer Mrs. Snape?"

He cleared his throat. "...Hermione."

The name felt unfamiliar on his tongue. Wrong. Or perhaps merely unpracticed. He looked between her and the man who wore his face.

"This..." He searched for a word equal to the absurdity before him. "...marriage is considerably more difficult to comprehend than my surviving the war."

His eyes settled on Severus.

"And you...we..." The correction caught in his throat. "...have children?"

Hermione smiled. "Yes. Two little girls."

Something fierce and wholly unexpected twisted through Snape's chest. Protective. Possessive. It vanished almost as quickly as it had come, leaving him disturbed by its very existence.

They were not his daughters. Not yet. Perhaps not ever. They belonged to the man across the table. He kept his expression carefully blank, refusing to meet the eyes of the only person in the room who would undoubtedly remember feeling exactly the same thing.

"How are they?" A heartbeat. He corrected himself. "Where are they?"

Severus regarded him steadily. "Safely elsewhere."

Snape's eyes narrowed. "You distrust yourself that much?"

"I distrust desperation."

The words were quiet. Matter-of-fact.As though he had spent years arriving at precisely that conclusion. Snape held his gaze.

"You believe I would endeavor to take your place?"

"I know," Severus said evenly, "that you have just been shown everything you've spent a lifetime believing you would never have."

Silence.

"A home. A family." His eyes flicked briefly toward Hermione before returning to Snape. "Hope."

The word settled over the room. Heavy. Dangerous.

"I remember standing where you are and believing that was the closest I would ever come."

Snape looked away first. The sharp, familiar ache of seeing something beautiful and knowing it could never belong to him clawing through his chest.

Hermione reached across the table and rested her hand lightly over Snape's. He flinched at the warmth, but did not move away. 

"You would never hurt our girls, sir." The certainty in her voice startled him. "You've spent years protecting children who never knew you were protecting them. You are trusted in this home."

She smiled sadly. Snape couldn't meet her eyes.

"I know you, Severus Snape. My husband is right, though. Desperation makes good people consider unreasonable things."

Severus nodded once.

"It does," Then, after a pause that seemed to stretch between two versions of the same man, he added dryly, "Which is why you're fortunate I'm permitting you anywhere near my wife."

Snape's head snapped up. "I beg your pardon?"

"The thought crossed your mind," Severus smirked. "You wondered whether you could stay."

The denial died on Snape's tongue. Because for one terrible, shameful instant... He had.

Severus's expression softened. "I know. I remember."

Something inside Snape snapped.

"If you remember so well, then tell me." His voice sharpened. "Tell me what we become."

Severus did not move.

"Do we become a murderer? Do we tear our own soul apart for the cause?"

Hermione went still. Snape saw it, the flicker of pain, and hated that he had caused it.

"Does your beloved little wife know?" he demanded. "Does she know what you've done? What you have been asked to do?"

He shoved himself to his feet, hands gripping the edge of the table.

"How dare you sit there and accuse me of wanting my student!" The words came out harsher than intended. More desperate.

"What did you do?" His voice cracked. "What did you have to become to claw your way into this?"

He gestured around the room.

"What did you sacrifice to earn this?"

Severus did not flinch. Hermione did, only slightly. Then she looked at Snape.

"You already know the answer, don't you?"

He stiffened.

"You should never have been asked to carry such a burden."

Her voice was so soft. 

"Not by Dumbledore. Not by anyone. But without what you have done—and what you will do—our world falls."

The words settled heavily. His composure faltered. She knew.

"Hermione—"

Severus' warning was quiet. She turned sharply.

"No, Severus."

The force in her voice silenced them both. Her eyes moved between the two versions of the same man.

"Enough of Dumbledore's secrets. Enough of half-spoken warnings and expecting people to survive horrible tasks without ever being told the truth."

Her gaze returned to Severus. 

"Look at him! He needs to know."

Severus went still. Snape's fingers tightened against the table.

"Know what?"

His voice was low.

"Tell me why I am here." A bitter laugh escaped him. "Tell me what ridiculous, tangled thread Fate has woven and why I have been forced to witness a life I am apparently expected to earn with blood."

Silence. Then Severus spoke. Firmly.

"You already know what you must do."

Snape's expression hardened. "Do I?"

"Yes." The answer was immediate. "You are simply hoping someone will tell you there is another way. Stop running from the choice in front of you." His voice lowered. "Do your job."

Snape's eyes flashed. "You make it sound simple."

"I will not let the actions of a desperate man destroy the life we fought to reach."

The word hit harder than coward would have. Desperate. Because that was what Snape feared most. That he was not noble. Not brave. Just a man clinging to the ounce of honor he had left.

Hermione stood abruptly. "Enough."

Both men looked at her. She moved between them, one hand pressing lightly against Severus' chest.

"This isn't working. You're both impossible. Severus," she said, quieter now. "Go."

His eyes narrowed. "Hermione—"

"Go brew something. Read. Take a nap. Be as dramatically miserable as you like somewhere else. I'm far more capable of handling the professor than you are and you know it, so go."

A tiny flicker of amusement crossed his face despite himself. Then she turned to Snape.

"And I will explain."

Severus remained silent for several moments. Then he exhaled quietly. Not a sigh, something closer to surrender. He leaned toward Hermione and murmured something too low for Snape to hear. Her expression changed immediately. A small smile touched her mouth. Was she blushing?

"Severus."

A warning. An affectionate one. The older man looked entirely unmoved.

"Fifteen minutes, wife."

"He's literally you."

"Then clearly you understand the importance of the request."

Hermione rolled her eyes and smiled. Snape watched, unable to look away. Severus gave her hand one brief squeeze before stepping away. Then he left.

Snape remained silent. He found himself watching Hermione as she watched her husband disappear down the hallway. The expression on her face was...

He struggled to name it. 

Fondness. Affection. Something warmer. Something that made his chest tighten unpleasantly. He had seen people look at him with disgust. Respect. Fear. Even desire.

But this? This obvious affection? He could not remember anyone ever looking at him that way.

"I've seen you argue with yourself before." Hermione's voice broke the silence. A faint smile played on her lips. "But this is quite the experience." 

"How?" Snape asked. "How do I find myself alive in the future, married to a former student? How do I get back?" 

"Severus told me about a year ago you would come. He didn't say from when, but we did discuss what would happen. Your future self leaves out your arrival, as I'm sure you picked up on." 

"I'm your boggart? Surely a witch who survived a war has more to fear than her Defense professor?" 

Her eyes softened. 

"You look very much like you do now in one year's time. During the Final battle, Nagini is ordered to kill you. I thought I watched you die that day. Your death is my boggart, Professor." 

"Will it not affect the timeline for me to know this?" 

Hermione shook her head. "I will only tell you what Severus has shown me in his memories. We talk about us next. You only half believe me. I show you the room you'll be staying in for two days. After that, you go back to your time." 

"I see you remain incapable of subtlety, Miss…Hermione. You and I, we are… happy together?" 

"Obviously," Hermione droned in a playful imitation of his slow cadence.

"How?"

"Don't worry," Hermione said with a smile. "I'm the one who seduces you. Though I'll tell you between us, I do believe you were interested far sooner than you claim." 

"I assure you," he said coldly, "I have never desired a student."

Hermione's expression softened.

"Good to know," she said with a laugh. "I was your apprentice for two years, you swear you didn't desire me then either." 

"You doubt your husband?" 

"I doubt his ability to recognize his own feelings, and to admit them. He did marry me after all," she rested her hand on her flat stomach and grinned. "I have quite a few reasons to know you desire me, then and now. Don't look so alarmed, you're very subtle… until you weren't. If you do change anything, try to remember to lock the door when you confront me over the pictures you see of my summer vacation in the Prophet. Septima still teases us over that one." 


Miss Granger—Hermione, he corrected silently, though the name still felt strangely intimate on his tongue—led him to a guestroom that had never existed in his time. It was clean. Warm. Comfortable. Three words that had never once described anything belonging to Severus Snape.

She had provided clothing for him, apologizing that it might be too large for his frame. His future self had dismissed the concern with an irritated roll of his eyes, claiming she was being dramatic.

Standing before the mirror now, Snape wondered if the man had merely been attempting to spare his wife's feelings.

Because Hermione had not been dramatic.

The reflection staring back at him was not one he recognized as a man who would survive. His robes and layers of fabric had concealed the truth well enough, but stripped of them there was no hiding what years of exhaustion, hunger, and war had taken. He looked less like a man preparing for battle and more like something that had crawled out of one.

His fingers traced the scars crossing his chest and torso. Old wounds. New wounds. Proof of every battle he had endured and every punishment he had accepted.

His mouth twisted.

Even his body appeared to be evidence against him. This could not be his future. It was impossible.

He had spent his entire life building himself into someone undeserving of mercy, and yet this version of himself had somehow acquired everything he had never allowed himself to want.

A home.

A wife.

Children.

Love.

Snape looked away from the mirror. He could not even take comfort in the one thing he had always believed he could claim.

Death. Even that, apparently, had refused to have him. With a quiet sigh, Snape lowered himself onto the bed. It was too comfortable. That was his first thought. Simply wrong. A guest bed had no business being softer than his own at Hogwarts.

His eyes moved across the room, cataloging details he had no desire to notice. The quality of the furniture. The warmth of the lighting. The absence of anything broken, neglected, or temporary. The entire house seemed to contradict everything he knew about himself.

Was he wealthy in the future?

Perhaps.

The evidence certainly suggested comfort beyond anything he had ever expected to possess. But wealth alone did not explain this. Money could purchase books, furniture, clothing.

It could not purchase this.

After an hour spent staring at the ceiling and failing to sleep, Snape abandoned the attempt. He had never been skilled at resting, and apparently being thrown fifteen years into the future had not corrected that particular flaw.

He rose silently and made his way toward the kitchen, intending only to find something to occupy his mind. Then he heard voices. He stopped immediately.

Old habits and curiosity combined. Snape moved without thought, stepping behind the wall and listening.

 "—going to be just fine, love."

Snape went still.

It was his own voice. Or rather, it was a voice that belonged to him and yet seemed impossibly foreign. Softer. Warmer. A voice that did not cut, command, or conceal. There was something deeply unsettling about hearing himself speak with such effortless tenderness. He had spent a lifetime mastering every expression except that one.

A quiet laugh followed, muffled as though Hermione's face was pressed against his chest.

"When I said I wanted a weekend without the girls before I started showing," she said, amusement and exasperation woven together, "this is not what I had in mind."

Snape remained motionless behind the wall.

"Perhaps," his future self replied, "you should have been more specific, wife."

The teasing warmth in his voice was almost more disturbing than the affection.

A chair scraped against the floor. Something was placed upon the table.

Snape's mind supplied the image before he could stop it. His future self lifting her onto the surface with the casual familiarity of someone who had done so many times before.

The thought was unwelcome. Worse, it was not difficult to imagine. A sound escaped from the kitchen. A laugh. Then the unmistakable sound of kissing.

Snape's eyes snapped toward the staircase.

Escape. The instinct was immediate. Surely he could manage fleeing a room without being discovered by himself.

"Severus," Hermione moaned, her voice breathless with amusement, "we have a guest…"

"I know precisely where our guest is, Hermione."

Snape froze. The calm certainty in his future self's voice sent a chill through him.

"Precisely what he is doing..."

More kissing. 

"...as we speak.

Snape remained utterly still. His eyes widened. 

"Exactly what he will see. What he must see this weekend."

Snape's brows lifted. The words settled slowly. Not an accidental discovery, then. His future self had chosen this. A strange, uncomfortable thought followed: he had chosen it because he knew Snape would never believe anything he was told.

With a slow breath, Snape stepped forward and looked around the corner. He had been correct but that did not make the sight any less startling.

Hermione sat on the edge of the kitchen table, her legs wrapped around her husband's waist. Future Severus held her with a familiarity that made something in Snape's chest tighten unpleasantly—not possessiveness, exactly, but the shock of seeing himself trusted so completely.

His hand rested in her hair, guiding her gently as he kissed her neck. And Hermione...

His wife looked happy. Not nervous. Not uncertain. Not as though she were tolerating something she had chosen to endure.

Happy.

Her eyes were closed, a small smile touching her mouth. Snape looked away.

It was somehow easier to face a curse.

Just as Snape was about to duck out of sight, Severus lifted Hermione from the table and sat in a kitchen chair settling her onto his lap. Snape's mouth went dry at the sight of a beautiful woman straddling him, willingly threading her hands through his hair to press her mouth to his. Snape pulled himself away. He moved quickly and silently back toward the staircase, every instinct urging him to put distance between himself and this impossible glimpse of a life he could not understand.

He had nearly reached the bedroom door when a voice stopped him. A voice he knew far too well.

"Severus?" 

Snape turned sharply. The portrait hanging on the wall regarded him with familiar blue eyes.

Albus Dumbledore.

The same man whose office he had left only that morning. The same man whose death he had already agreed to cause. The old wizard's expression softened.

"Your future self warned me you might arrive soon. How are you, my boy?"

The words struck harder than they should have. Snape's expression twisted.

"You want me to kill you."

Silence.

"You have arranged every detail. Every contingency. You have decided the manner of your own death and handed the burden to me. How do you imagine I am?"

Dumbledore's portrait had the good grace to flinch.

"I am sorry it must be you, Severus. I asked you for more than any man should have been expected to bear, and yet you did it. You did more than any of us. More than anyone will ever know. I am profoundly proud of you."

The answer was gentle. Infuriatingly gentle. Snape stared at the portrait, waiting for the familiar irritation to come. Waiting for the anger. It was far easier to endure Dumbledore's manipulation than his kindness.

Pride was a dangerous thing coming from this man. Because pride meant Dumbledore saw him. If Dumbledore saw him, then he had no excuse left to pretend he was merely a tool being used.

"You should not say such things."

The words came out colder than he intended. Dumbledore's expression softened.

"Why?"

"Because they are unnecessary."

"That is not the same as saying they are untrue."

Snape turned and entered the room, choosing at the last moment to make sure the door shut silently instead of slamming. 


The next morning, Snape left the borrowed room in his own home and heard the shower running. An image of Hermione's naked body pressed against his own under the water flashed through his mind. 

The thought was so startlingly inappropriate that he nearly missed the final step on the staircase. He forced the image away with the same discipline he applied to any unwanted thought. Occlumency had served him well for years. It would serve him now.

He entered the kitchen. Hermione sat at the table, a book floating before her as she ate breakfast. The domesticity of it was somehow more disorienting than anything else he had witnessed.

"Good morning," she said brightly. 

"I'm not him," Snape said abruptly. Her smile broadened. 

"Yes, I'm aware. Severus made breakfast, if you're hungry. Minerva is bringing the girls home this morning. She knows you're here." 

"Is she going to kill me?" Snape asked as he sat. His eyes narrowed on the dark wood laying casually on the table. He palmed his own wand in his hand. Hermione noticed. 

"Ah," she said, sliding a coffee mug towards him. "He doesn't always leave it laying about. Only when we're home alone. It took years before he stopped reacting to every unexpected sound as though he were about to be attacked. I'm very proud of him. Of you." 

Snape scowled at his coffee. "I only drink it black."

"Sir, I know this is difficult but this truly is the future. I am your wife, and I know you only drink it black to seem unbothered. Now, drink your sweet coffee and try to get yourself together. Our daughters will be home soon and they think their father hung the moon. I would prefer they do not meet a version of him who is dramatically unpleasant."


 Snape felt the familiar shudder of someone approaching the front door through wards that were unmistakably his own and yet older, deeper. It was a peculiar sensation, feeling a future version of his magic recognize friend from foe before he did.

The wards yielded without hesitation. The front door flew open.

Two little girls burst into the house.

For a moment, Snape thought they were miniature Hermione Grangers, all wild brown curls and determined energy. Then one lifted her head as she ran, and he caught the familiar dark eyes that met her father's with absolute certainty.

Neither child slowed.

They ran straight into Severus' waiting arms, laughing as he caught them with the easy confidence of someone who had done so a thousand times before. The younger buried her face into her father's shoulder as if it were the safest place in the world. Snape felt himself tense at the effortless affection.

"Severus?"

Snape turned.

Professor McGonagall stood in the doorway, scarcely older than the witch he had left at Hogwarts only the day before. Time had silvered her hair a little more, softened the lines about her eyes, but she remained unmistakably Minerva McGonagall.

He instinctively straightened.

Should he explain? Apologize? Draw his wand and prepare for an attack?

Before he could settle on any course of action, she crossed the room in three brisk strides and wrapped her arms tightly around him. Snape went utterly still. He could not remember the last time another person had embraced him. If anyone ever had.

Across the room, Hermione's hand flew to her mouth. Whether to stifle a laugh or a sob, Snape could not tell.

After a long, uncertain moment, he managed, "Hello, Minerva."

Minerva drew back just far enough to study him, her hands remaining firmly on his shoulders as though she feared he might disappear. Her gaze traveled over the sharp lines of his face, the hollows beneath his eyes, the weight carried in every rigid line of his posture. Her expression crumpled.

"Oh, Severus..." The words were barely more than a whisper. "How did we miss it?"

Snape gave a faint, humorless smile.

"You were meant to."

She closed her eyes briefly, the answer seeming to pain her all the more.

"You shouldn't have had to carry all of that alone."

"No," he said quietly. "You were never meant to know. Do you know now, Minerva?" His voice dropped lower. "Do you know what Albus has asked of me?"

 Minerva's expression softened with grief.

"I know what happened. I know why it had to be done." Her fingers tightened slightly against his shoulders. "And I know you should have told me."

Snape went still.

"Severus, the year you were Headmaster—"

"Minerva."

The firm voice came from behind them. They turned. Future Severus stood in the doorway, his youngest daughter resting comfortably against his shoulder. Hermione stood beside him with their other child tucked safely in her arms.

For a moment, Snape was struck by the absurdity of the sight. Himself, holding a child. Being trusted with something so fragile. Then his future self's expression hardened.

"He cannot tell you." The words were not cruel. They were protective. "It would risk too much. The timeline—"

"Damn the timeline."

Minerva's voice cracked through the room. Both versions of him turned toward her.

"And damn Albus Dumbledore, Severus Snape." Her eyes shone with anger and pain. "You were alone. Alone!"

The word landed harder than any accusation could have.

Hermione flinched. It was a small movement. Barely noticeable, but Snape saw. The reminder of what he would endure had struck her harder than he expected. Her throat worked as she swallowed, her eyes shining with the effort of holding herself together.

Something unfamiliar tightened in his chest. An impulse. A need to reach for her. To ease whatever pain had crossed her face. The thought unsettled him. Before he could move, however, Severus was already there. Already drawing her against him with the ease of someone who knew exactly how to hold her together. He whispered something into her ear, too quiet for Snape to hear.

Hermione closed her eyes and leaned into him. The sight was strangely intimate. When would he become a comfort to her? Two years? Five? Snape looked away.

"Do you forgive me, then?"

"Of course I forgive you, Severus." Minerva's voice was firm. "You saved our world. You protected everyone, even when it cost you everything."

Her expression softened.

"I am immensely proud of you and I am beyond thankful."

Snape looked away. Praise was easier to endure when it came from people who did not know the truth. She knew, and she still looked at him as though he had done something worthy. His voice lowered.

"Tell me something, Minerva. Am I truly a good father?"

The question felt foreign the moment it left his mouth. He had faced death without hesitation. He had stood before the Dark Lord and lied. He had carried secrets that would have broken most men. Yet this was the question he could barely ask.

"Is this marriage..." He paused, forcing the words out. "Is it truly as happy as it appears?"

Minerva did not answer immediately. Instead, she pulled him into another embrace. Over her shoulder, his gaze found Hermione. 

She stood beside his future self, his arm wrapped securely around her waist. Their daughters were safe between them, healthy and smiling, completely unaware of the impossible weight of the conversation around them.

A family. His family.

The thought was almost too much to bear.

"Yes, Severus," Minerva whispered. Her arms tightened around him. "You and Hermione have a wonderful marriage. Your daughters adore you."

Snape looked past her shoulder.

At Hermione. At the woman who had looked at him as though he was something precious instead of something damaged. At the woman who loved him. 

Then his gaze moved to the man beside her. To himself. Future Severus stood silently, one hand resting at Hermione's waist, his daughters safe between them. He looked older. Softer. Not untouched by suffering, but no longer defined by it.

Their eyes met. For a long moment, neither spoke. Future Severus knew the question Snape had not asked.

Was it worth it?

"This life is worth it," Minerva whispered.

Snape closed his eyes.

He had spent years preparing himself for an ending. A death he believed he deserved. Now, standing in this house surrounded by proof that something survived beyond the pain, he found himself wondering if perhaps he had mistaken sacrifice for destruction.

When he opened his eyes, he met the gaze of the man he would become. The man who knew. The man who had lived.

"Severus," his future self said softly. "Please."


The Astronomy Tower was exactly as he remembered. The same cold wind. The same ancient stones. The same terrible silence before everything would change. Only he was not the same man who had climbed those stairs a week before.

Death Eaters at his back, his mentor and friend before him. A choice between them. Snape closed his eyes. His time in the future flashed through his mind. When he opened his eyes Dumbledore gave him a small, knowing smile. One of victory.

"Severus…please…" 

Severus Snape raised his wand, and made the first step towards his future.