Archive of Our Own

In one of the more successfully concealed major productions of recent years, Elle Fanning has been cast as Jennifer Fischer-Scott in Lake Light, Scarlett Johansson’s film about the folk musician, activist, former first lady and vice president whose life stretched across nearly a century of American cultural and political history.

The casting comes with a considerably bigger surprise. Lake Light is already far into post-production.

The film was formally announced only two weeks ago, when its producers confirmed the title, Johansson’s attachment as director and a May 1, 2026 theatrical release. That announcement contained no cast and offered almost nothing regarding the scope of the picture beyond describing it as a film based on Fischer-Scott’s life. The absence of actors led much of the industry to assume casting was underway and that production would begin later this year or in early 2025.

Instead, multiple sources tell Variety that principal photography quietly concluded months ago. Editing is well advanced, preliminary sound work has begun and a substantial portion of the film’s period reconstruction and visual-effects finishing is already underway. The May 2026 date, unusual for a picture apparently announced so early, is therefore not the long production runway it first appeared to be. The filmmakers have effectively revealed the existence of Lake Light after making most of it.

Fanning, 26, plays Fischer-Scott through the central span of her adult life, with the production using makeup, hair work and subtle digital techniques as the character ages rather than dividing Jennifer among several adult performers. A younger actress portrays her in childhood, but Fanning enters the film well before Fischer-Scott becomes a nationally familiar figure and remains its Jennifer thereafter.

The role is among the largest Fanning has undertaken. Fischer-Scott was only 4-foot-11, but her small physical presence sat strangely beside the enormous cultural footprint she accumulated. Raised in Geneva, Ohio, by April and Brandon, the grandparents she regarded simply as her parents, she grew up in a home defined by music, reading, practical work and a close intimacy that would remain foundational throughout her life. The film is understood to spend considerably more time on that household than might be expected from a conventional cradle-to-grave biographical drama.

That emphasis is reflected in two of the project’s other major castings. Laurie Metcalf plays April, while Richard Jenkins portrays Brandon. Both roles extend well beyond introductory scenes establishing Jennifer’s childhood. Sources who have seen material from the film describe April and Brandon as continuing presences in its emotional architecture even after their deaths, although Lake Light does not use them as ghosts or literal narrators. The picture instead returns repeatedly to remembered gestures, conversations and domestic images from Jennifer’s upbringing as later events acquire different meanings.

Paul Giamatti plays Eddie, the machinist-turned-tavern owner whose modest Geneva establishment became one of the most important recurring places in Fischer-Scott’s musical life. His casting is particularly significant because Eddie has been expanded into one of the film’s principal roles rather than treated as a colorful local figure orbiting the famous subject.

The choice offers one of the first indications of how radically Lake Light departs from the usual biopic structure.

The film does not move dutifully from Fischer-Scott’s birth through childhood, musical discovery, fame, politics and old age. Nor does it frame her life around a single political campaign or concert. Eddie’s tavern — and eventually the House of Song that grows out of it — functions as one of several fixed places through which decades overlap. Characters enter young and return old. A table occupied in one period may be empty in the next. Conversations separated by thirty years have reportedly been cut so that one seems almost to answer another.

Giamatti’s Eddie consequently becomes an unusual kind of co-lead. He watches Jennifer arrive before most of the country knows her name, sees musicians begin traveling to Geneva simply to hear her, watches fame and politics pull her elsewhere and is still there when she comes home. The part is not written as an explanatory observer who tells an audience why Fischer-Scott mattered. Instead, Eddie knows Jennifer before an explanation is necessary.

Oscar Isaac portrays Theodore “Ted” Beale, Jennifer’s husband, whose political career eventually carried him from California to the presidency. His role encompasses their marriage, his rise through public life and his final illness. Fischer-Scott’s transition from an artist who had spent much of her life resisting conventional celebrity into a nationally scrutinized first lady, and later a political figure in her own right, forms one of the film’s major movements.

Maggie Gyllenhaal has been cast as Phoebe Whitford, Beale’s vice president and successor, who later asked Jennifer to serve as her vice president following Beale’s death. Gwendoline Christie plays Lucille Robinson, Whitford’s wife and one of Jennifer’s closest figures within the extraordinary personal circle surrounding the Beale and Whitford administrations.

The picture is not, however, understood to become a Washington movie once Beale reaches the White House. People familiar with the screenplay say Johansson and the film’s writers deliberately resisted allowing the presidency to swallow everything before it. Fischer-Scott’s years near the center of government are presented beside, rather than above, the rest of her existence. A White House room can be followed by a kitchen in Geneva. An election may lead into a nearly silent sequence of Jennifer repairing clothing. A state occasion can give way to a child asking for a song.

That approach mirrors one of the fundamental difficulties involved in making a film about Fischer-Scott: virtually any single portion of her life contains enough material for a feature of its own.

She was a folk musician who became enormously influential without building the conventional recorded catalogue expected of an artist of her stature. She repeatedly resisted attempts to fix her performances into definitive versions, preferring songs to change as they passed between musicians and audiences. She was also a writer, arranger, occasional filmmaker, mentor and activist whose friendships crossed generations of American music.

Then came national politics. Beale’s presidency placed her in the White House, his illness and resignation reshaped her private life, Whitford’s succession changed the political order again, and Fischer-Scott subsequently served as vice president and became the Democratic presidential nominee in the extraordinary 1976 election.

A more conventional production might have selected one of those identities and allowed the others to function as background. Lake Light apparently does the opposite.

Johansson’s film is said to be organized around the idea that Fischer-Scott was experienced differently depending on who encountered her. April and Brandon knew the child. Eddie knew the working musician before mythology gathered around her. Ted knew the woman who could return from a celebrated performance and still worry about whether a garden needed watering. Phoebe knew both the private friend and the reluctant political figure. Younger musicians knew the woman whose reputation seemed impossibly large before they discovered that she wanted to discuss their songs rather than her own.

That perspective also explains a large ensemble whose members sometimes appear for remarkably brief periods.

Riley Keough plays Siena, Jennifer’s birth mother, whose absence hangs over the earliest portion of the film without becoming the psychological master key to everything Jennifer later does. Ethan Hawke plays Pete Seeger. Carrie Coon appears as a senior political adviser during the Beale years, while Scoot McNairy has a smaller role as one of the Ohio figures associated with Jennifer’s early musical circuit. Several musicians and cultural figures who crossed Fischer-Scott’s life are represented, although the production has not yet disclosed the complete list.

The film’s treatment of music may prove its most contentious choice.

Fanning does sing as Fischer-Scott, Variety understands, but Lake Light is emphatically not constructed as a musical showcase. The production recorded substantially more performance material than appears in the current cut. Full concerts were staged during photography, including lengthy recreations of several famous Fischer-Scott appearances, but the film frequently enters or leaves songs midway through them.

In some sequences, the audience hears only tuning, a verse or two and the quiet immediately after a song. In others, music continues off-screen while the camera follows somebody leaving the room.

The decision is in keeping with Fischer-Scott’s own unusually complicated relationship with recording. Her performances existed principally as events experienced in rooms rather than as a fixed commercial discography, leaving the filmmakers without the familiar catalogue that structures most major music biographies. Rather than treating that absence as a problem to be solved, Lake Light has made it central to the film’s form.

Fanning’s casting had been guarded with particular intensity. Johansson’s involvement became public with the film’s announcement earlier this month, but Fanning’s name was deliberately absent even though she had already completed the overwhelming majority of her work.

Sources say the production feared that announcing Fanning too early would immediately expose shooting locations and trigger intense scrutiny around the transformation required for the role. Fischer-Scott lived until 2028, meaning Fanning is portraying the same woman across more than seven decades.

The makeup is not designed to make that transformation the film’s spectacle. People familiar with the footage say the filmmakers avoided large transitional scenes intended merely to demonstrate aging. Instead, years can pass between cuts. Fanning may leave one room in her thirties and appear in the next sequence decades older, with posture, tempo and voice carrying as much of the change as prosthetics.

Johansson was involved with the project well before her directing role became public. Development began quietly after Fischer-Scott’s death in 2028 was ruled out as the start of the film — the project does not open with her funeral, final concert or an elderly Jennifer remembering her youth — and the eventual screenplay went through multiple structural versions before settling into its present form.

The title Lake Light came comparatively late.

It refers to Lake Erie and Geneva without naming either directly, and sources say the phrase appears nowhere as a grand piece of dialogue explaining the title. The lake is nevertheless a recurring visual element, particularly in scenes where Jennifer returns home after increasingly public periods of her life.

Johansson and her team had access to an unusually large body of written material despite Fischer-Scott’s resistance to recording her music. Letters, notebooks, essays, political papers, private correspondence and recollections from people who knew her became the principal foundations of the screenplay. That distinction is important: Lake Light is not adapting a single authorized biography and is not presented as a visual encyclopedia of Fischer-Scott’s documented life.

Some famous episodes are missing entirely.

Others last seconds.

Still others that would occupy a paragraph in most biographies reportedly become extended sequences because they reveal something about how Jennifer behaved when no historical importance appeared to be attached to the moment.

That is especially true of April and Brandon. The two raised Jennifer in circumstances that were materially modest but emotionally close, giving her an education at home built around practical work, books and observation. Johansson’s film appears to treat that domestic formation not as the obligatory childhood prologue before the “real” story begins, but as the grammar through which everything later is understood.

The production itself was built to make secrecy easier.

Much of the interior work was completed on closed stages, including reconstructions of the Fischer-Scott house, Eddie’s tavern in several different decades, portions of the White House and the later House of Song. Exterior photography was divided among several locations and frequently operated under alternate production names. Extras were given heavily restricted pages, while actors whose characters belonged to different periods often worked in separate units.

Even crew members were not always given a complete chronological screenplay.

That secrecy has now produced an unusual situation for the distributor. Rather than announcing a prestigious package and then documenting its progress through casting news, first-look photography and production reports, the studio is effectively introducing a movie that already exists.

There is still a long road to May 1, 2026. The picture remains in an expansive post-production process, and no final runtime has been locked. Sources caution that Johansson is continuing to restructure sections and that entire performance sequences could still move, shrink or disappear.

The current cut is described as long, though not extravagantly so given the amount of life being covered. More notable is its refusal to hurry simply because history becomes crowded. Jennifer’s years adjacent to presidential power do not suddenly accelerate the film into a montage of headlines, nor do the late decades become an epilogue after the electoral drama passes.

The production has also left itself considerable time for music clearance, sound reconstruction and the film’s original score, which is expected to be announced separately.

No footage is expected imminently. The studio has no intention of attaching a teaser to the casting announcement and is understood to be resisting pressure to reveal Fanning’s older transformations before audiences encounter them in context.

That means, for the moment, the first image of Elle Fanning as Jennifer Fischer-Scott remains under lock.

But the casting itself radically changes the understanding of Lake Light. Two weeks ago, the film appeared to be a newly unveiled prestige project with an unusually distant release date. It is now clear that Johansson and her collaborators have spent much longer building it in private.

The cast had not yet been announced because the movie was waiting to be made.

The cast had not been announced because almost nobody outside the production knew it had already been made.