Creepy Pasta
Just my favorite Creepy Pasta Fanfics...
(Closed, Moderated)
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
You’re just a waitress at Pop’s Diner, living a quiet life no one notices. Then four masked killers forcefully take you in one night, claiming their eldritch master has plans for you. They call themselves Proxies. You were meant to serve the Operator’s will. But something changes. They were never supposed to feel anything. Especially not for you.
-
All These Things That I've Done by FreddyFazbearPizzeriaVoicemail
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
03 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
Y/n is still trying to figure out how to be a normal person, something that never came easily to her. After a get away weekend trip turns to murder, she discovers that her life will never be the same. A newfound bloodlust brings her to three (maybe not so) psycho killers and an age old creature hell bent on using her to further his legacy.
Maybe she can stop The Operator with the power of love, but a Ka-bar works so much better.
Basically just your typical Creepypasta fic.
Y/n and Female pronouns used.
Toby/Tim/Brian/Reader -
Tags
Summary
When your name appears in your late great-uncle’s will, you sell your house and move out to the Estate. A victorian manor, an endless garden, and too many candles to keep up with now belong to you—and so do the groundskeepers that come with it. But behind all the intricate furniture and shiny tile, you find that all things have secrets—even the handsome ones.
-
'Till the Ground Holds Me in It's Arms by Maley
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
20 Jul 2024
Tags
Summary
One year ago you had scrapped together enough funds to move from your hometown. Normally anti-social and dramatically emo, the only thing you've found to do with your time is going to see live music and getting drunk with your only friend in this small town. That was until your path crossed with three men while all of you were on the job. Unfortunately for you, they're hot. And unfortunately for them, you're also hot. Surely falling in love will have zero negative consequences.
Series
- Part 2 of Loving Them is Like Breathing
-
Tags
Summary
Trying to outrun her past and start over, a young woman finds herself in a quiet new town, juggling college, work, and the effort to stay afloat. But when a strange boy appears in her life, and unsettling things begin happening around her, she’s pulled into something far darker than she ever expected.
[this is a slowburn so bear with me, will also likely be a proxies x reader as it goes on cuz im self indulgent and cringe]