Comment on The Big Bang, Baby Challenge is Moving to AO3

  1. a snapdragon on a pillow

    definitely not in the foreseeable future, hosting images costs a lot more money than text and fairly paying moderators for moderating images costs even more than that (because whenever you have free image uploads, you'll have people uploading very illegal and disturbing ones, and ao3's current moderation team is a few dozen unpaid volunteers who already take months to process work reports)

    there are smaller fannish image hostings like squidge's, and you can look up how to pay for your own server so that you're in full control of your images

    Comment Actions
    1. Well, you might want to have a look around. People are already uploaded GIF clips of porn, full nudity and sexual content, on here and I've unfortunately come across images with assault involving minors and even babies. Reports have not gotten them taken down, so, me asking for a simpler version to upload an image is hardly going to fix an ongoing issue that's been present for years.

      Comment Actions
      1. a snapdragon on a pillow

        you are asking for something that would make the moderation situation way worse

        People are already uploaded GIF clips of porn, full nudity and sexual content, on here

        you can't upload images on ao3, only embed them, which means images are still stored on another server that ao3 does not control

        sexual content is not forbidden to be embedded here, so if the work it's inside doesn't break the rules otherwise, then reporting it just wastes the policy&abuse volunteers' time and makes it take longer for actual tos violations to get processed. (and when it's just spam then it's in the same situation as non-porn spam and having no image-uploading interface adds more friction preventing people from spamming more)

        if you do encounter CSAM (child sexual abuse materials, meaning sexual photoimagery involving real children), that's something to report to the image host and relevant autorities first, because as i've said ao3's volunteers are already overworked

        if you were just referring to drawings, that's also not forbidden to embed on ao3 and from what i've seen those usually have clear warnings in tags and summaries (but they may or may not be allowed by whatever site is actually hosting them, so check those sites' rules if that's something you're concerned about)

        Comment Actions
        1. I literally just told you that was something I came across.
          I put in the feature request already, so we shall se.

          Comment Actions
        2. beatrice from umineko, looking smug

          "However, photographic or photorealistic images of humans may not be used to illustrate works featuring underage sexual content. This includes (but is not limited to) photographs of children, porn gifs, photo manipulations, photorealistic computer-generated or "AI" images, and other linked or embedded images that could potentially be mistaken for photographs of real humans."

          from: https://archiveofourown.org/tos_faq#underage_images
          Not entirely sure of the context funnygirl is referring to, but it does sound vaguely like what they're talking about is against TOS, so reports should get that taken down.

          Comment Actions
          1. a snapdragon on a pillow

            they could be talking about literally anything

            Comment Actions