Gah, you're done. There is no reasoning with you. You're wrong, 100%, but you're also one of those people who believe that Rogers can do no wrong and Tony can do nothing right, regardless of proof and evidence to the contrary. And that's fine; that's your opinion and beliefs, and they are yours to have.
But WHY read a story that you **know** isn't going to be even a little friendly to your side? Unless your purpose is to harass Tony Stark/Team Iron Man fans, what's the point? There is no way you'll enjoy the story, so I really want to know, to understand, why you do it. What do you get out of it? And if your purpose is just to harass us, then . . . God, I feel so sorry for you, that you actually have nothing else to do with your time. That's just pitiful, and pitiable.
These are not opinions or beliefs; they are canon facts shown on the screen. In the scene you cite as "non heroic" action by Steve, Steve did not throw the shield at Tony. Tony was not under threat when he shot Steve, so by your own definition Tony's action was decidedly "non heroic." If you believe the clip mentioned does not contain these facts, please point out where they do not. I am trying to understand how you can view this scene and make the claim you did. It does not follow.
I read this work because you claimed you were not being cliche and that you were presenting truths. As your third chapter imagines scenarios that never happen outside of stories like yours, I would say that you failed in your mission. Unless you can explain how I am "100% wrong" about actual video evidence, we are indeed done.
There's no point whatsoever in trying to debate with you, is the problem. You've decided that what you see onscreen is point a, while I think it's point b. We are never going to reconcile those beliefs, which is fine, but again: you can claim that I wasn't going to be cliche and presenting truths, but you somehow managed to miss the not Rogers friendly tags right next to them? You managed to miss the part where I specified that I'm presenting stories that are different to the prevalent **fic** plots I keep seeing. Not the movies so much, though I have issues with virtually all of them, but fic.
You . . . refuse to understand that. And that's fine; your life, your opinion. But you've gone way, way past 'opinion' and straight into harassment mode here, and I'm done with that. It has been made abundantly clear to you that your attempts to educate us on how stupid and wrong we are for our interpretation of things that differ from yours are not welcome. So please, go away. Find and read stories that are clearly marked to your liking. Because commenting on a story like this, one that is so blatantly the opposite of your personal opinion, is not constructive criticism. I've gotten some of that and it's been helpful and insightful, but not from you. I've gotten nothing but stubborn refusal to concede any point that you don't like, even if I agree that Tony did something wrong. You are determined to make sure that I -- we -- understand that you and only you are right and correct in how you see things, and I'm done. I don't want to block you, because I think that's childish, but to be blunt: you are not welcome to comment on this fic anymore, as long as this harassment is what you're going to say. Post something like this again and I *will* block you.
Comment on Did I Do That?
xfphile on Chapter 1 Sun 29 Sep 2024 03:33PM UTC
Comment Actions
Rebuttal on Chapter 1 Sun 29 Sep 2024 08:39PM UTC
Comment Actions
xfphile on Chapter 1 Sun 29 Sep 2024 09:24PM UTC
Comment Actions