Secrets better left in the dark

Series Metadata

Listing Series

• Can you keep a secret by MidnightBlue66

  Fandoms: Five Nights at Freddy's, Five Nights At Freddy's (Movies 2023-2025)  

  • Mature
  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • Gen, M/M
  • Complete Work

  13 Jul 2026

  Tags

  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • William Afton | Dave Miller & Mike Schmidt
  • William Afton | Dave Miller/Mike Schmidt
  • Mike Schmidt & Mike Schmidt's Father (Five Nights at Freddy's Movies)
  • William Afton | Dave Miller
  • Mike Schmidt (Five Nights at Freddy's)
  • Vanessa Shelly (Five Nights at Freddy's Movies)
  • Mike Schmidt's Father (Five Nights at Freddy's Movies)
  • Digital Art
  • Comic
  • Creep William Afton | Dave Miller
  • Michael Afton and Mike Schmidt are the Same Person
  • Grooming
  • Secrets
  • Good Sibling Mike Schmidt (Five Nights at Freddy's)
  • Henry Emily is Mike Schmidt's Father
  • Set in 1980s
  • alternative universe
  • Dead Dove: Do Not Eat
  • Blackmail
  • mike is 16 years old
  • Emotional Manipulation
  • Hurt No Comfort

  Summary

  It was unfortunate that William discovered one of Mike's secrets. It was even more unfortunate that Mike in turn discovered William's secret.

  Series

  • Part 1 of Secrets better left in the dark

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  0

  Chapters:

  5/5

  Comments:

  28

  Kudos:

  59

  Bookmarks:

  10

  Hits:

  752

• Where nightmares breathe by MidnightBlue66

  Fandoms: Five Nights at Freddy's  

  • Explicit
  • Rape/Non-Con, Underage Sex
  • M/M
  • Work in Progress

  06 Aug 2026

  Tags

  • Rape/Non-Con
  • Underage Sex
  • William Afton | Dave Miller/Mike Schmidt
  • William Afton | Dave Miller & Mike Schmidt
  • Henry Emily & Mike Schmidt
  • Mike Schmidt (Five Nights at Freddy's)
  • Henry Emily
  • William Afton | Dave Miller
  • Creep William Afton | Dave Miller
  • Dead Dove: Do Not Eat
  • mike schmidt is 17
  • Mike needs a hug
  • William is NOT a good person
  • Implied Sexual Content
  • Dubious Consent
  • Blackmail
  • Rape/Non-con Elements
  • heed the warnings
  • Don't Like Don't Read
  • AU
  • set in the 80s
  • henry emily is mike's father
  • Digital Art
  • Comic

  Summary

  Mike discovers the weight of William's secret
  Continuation of "Can you keep a secret"

  Series

  • Part 2 of Secrets better left in the dark

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  0

  Chapters:

  2/?

  Comments:

  4

  Kudos:

  65

  Bookmarks:

  4

  Hits:

  493