41 - 60 of 151 Bookmarks by Commanderhearteyes3
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Do You Always Fall in Love with Your Neighbors? by stellebelle
Fandoms: The Wilds (TV 2020)
26 May 2025
Tags
Summary
When Dot asks Toni to catsit for a week, she expects litter boxes and a grumpy tabby—not late-night conversations with the flirty blonde in the apartment across the alley. Especially not while she’s in the shower. But as time goes on, the blonde across the alley becomes harder to ignore, she's charming, nosy, and has interesting taste in lip balm flavors. It’s not like Toni could fall for a girl she’s never actually met... right?
Or,
A one-shot that got out hand, where Shelby flirts with Toni through the bathroom window.Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
25 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Toni has a notoriously one track mind and horrible attention to details. After a breakup over summer break, and a one night stand that was gone by morning, Toni decides to finally move on and ask someone out… on a date she completely forgets about.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
25 Aug 2025
-
if you hold me without hurting me (you'll be the first who ever did) by moonflowerdamie
Fandoms: The Wilds (TV 2020)
28 May 2021
Tags
Summary
Shelby Goodkind had sauntered into her life one sunny morning in September, clinging to Martha’s arm and giggling like she was the funniest fucking person she’d ever met. She’d introduced herself, all flashy smile and sun-kissed skin, her Southern drawl dripping from her lips like honey. Toni had taken one look and immediately felt her metaphorical hackles raise. This girl, with her perfect teeth and drop-dead gorgeous eyes, felt dangerous. Something about her made Toni want to run and run and run, until the horizon caught up with her and the sunset swallowed her whole. Maybe it was her accent, or maybe it was the way her eyes had scanned her up and down, but whatever it was, it was all Toni needed to decide that she did not like Shelby Goodkind.
She didn’t like her at all.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
22 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
5 times Shelby hides herself from the world + 1 time she doesn't
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
22 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Everything clicks into place for Shelby when she sees Toni kissing Regan.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
21 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby's been drowning herself in alcohol and sex since her break-up with Becca.
She meets Toni and learns that sometimes it's okay to be a little bit of a mess.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
21 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby calls you “exuberant” during your second week of AP Lit, and you’re confused to no end.
And yeah, you’re in AP Lit, so of course you know what it means. You’re confused because that’s the last word anyone would use to characterize your whole… deal.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
21 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Toni leans over her shoulder and whispers in her ear, her breath warm, “I still don’t like you. In fact, I may even hate you”
“I still think you’re a total bitch,” Shelby breathes.
“It looks like we've reached something of an agreement.”
or
Shelby and Toni are sent to a 6 week college soccer clinic. The two captains are the perfect rivals their teams need them to be, after all, Shelby couldn’t possibly fall for the competition.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
20 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Toni Shalifoe is rich, famous, and a world-renowned athlete. She's also a complete PR nightmare with a reputation for being the bad girl of soccer. Fresh from a humiliating break-up (like, there is an album about how much she sucks) and a terrible magazine article, Toni is forced to try and generate some good press by volunteering at an elementary school for a charity drive she doesn't care about.
It's just another thing on her celebrity checklist to get over with.
It's not like she's going to instantly fall in love with the kindergarten teacher or anything, is she?
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
19 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby and Becca have a longstanding tradition of betting on anything and everything, and the outcome is always the same: the loser has to complete a dare of the winner’s choosing.
Lately, a certain girl (who just happens to be exactly Shelby’s type) has had a front row seat to all the embarrassment.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
19 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
"So, neither of us has been flirting yet we’ve been getting numbers from people. I wonder what would happen if we did start flirting.”
“Are you suggesting some sort of competition?” Toni asked with a smile.
“Maybe. I know you love competition.”
Toni scoffed, “you’ve known me for three weeks.”
“And yet I see right through you. Come on, tell me I’m wrong.” Shelby nudged Toni lightly in the shoulder.
__Shelby and Toni work at a queer bookstore together and decide to have a little contest to see who's the better flirt.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
16 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
shelby wants a girlfriend. toni sets her up on dates.
it's all gutter balls. until it isn't.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 30,315
- Chapters:
- 7/7
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 144
- Kudos:
- 498
- Bookmarks:
- 60
- Hits:
- 8,654
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
15 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
When Toni picks up a woman at the bar for a one-night stand, she's surprised to find out pretty early on that they can't stand each other. It's cool, though, because it's just for one night. It's not like she's ever going to see her again.
Right?
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
14 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby's a 23-year-old virgin. Toni's a professional she's hired to fix this.
Twelve sessions. Twelve weeks. Twelve opportunities to fall in love.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 70,496
- Chapters:
- 12/12
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 557
- Kudos:
- 2,561
- Bookmarks:
- 319
- Hits:
- 77,284
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
13 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Just before their Senior Year, Shelby Goodkind shocks Fort Travis by coming out. Determined to show everybody that she is still who she has always been, Shelby makes a bid for Prom Queen.
The only issue is she needs a date... and Toni Shalifoe isn't exactly the best choice to be her fake girlfriend and running mate.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 30,297
- Chapters:
- 11/11
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 218
- Kudos:
- 864
- Bookmarks:
- 89
- Hits:
- 18,009
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
13 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Somebody has bought the derelict house opposite Shelby Goodkind in order to flip it and resell it in 4 months. Too bad the new owner is such an asshole. And completely Shelby's type.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
12 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
“I’m sorry, you want me to teach you how to flirt with girls?”
If Toni’s initial reaction to the “I’m gay” confession hadn’t been enough to make Shelby blush, this sure does the trick. She looks around sheepishly as if it had taken every ounce of courage in her goddamn body to ask. “That’s not what I said.”
“Shelby, I can’t say I know you well, but I do know you own a mirror so trust me when I say you are going to have no problem getting a girl to date you.”
or
Shelby needs help flirting with girls. Toni needs to pass liberal arts math. They both harbor oblivious crushes because they're dumb gay babies.
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
11 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby befriends the couple next door. For a while, she knew the sound of her neighbors' voices before she even knew what they look like.
They share the same wall, and they sometimes keep her up at night as a result of it, because Toni and Regan have been dating for six years— which means Shelby can hear when they laugh, and fuck, and sometimes even fight.
And they tend to fight— a lot.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 26,060
- Chapters:
- 5/5
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 89
- Kudos:
- 921
- Bookmarks:
- 111
- Hits:
- 14,810
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
09 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Fatin always said the best way to get over someone is to get under someone else. Shelby never thought she’d take that advice, but then she meets Toni.
. . .
“This is the last time,” Shelby sighs out from underneath Toni.“Sure, Shelby. Whatever you say.” Toni’s heard that one before. It’s never true. She moves her fingers over the metallic button of Shelby’s pants, swiftly popping it open.
“I’m serious.” Shelby has always been a little bit of a liar.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 26,306
- Chapters:
- 9/9
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 139
- Kudos:
- 1,316
- Bookmarks:
- 152
- Hits:
- 37,248
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
04 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Following her first breakup during her sophomore year of college, Shelby picks herself up and meets someone new in Toni along the way.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 8,966
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 25
- Kudos:
- 653
- Bookmarks:
- 70
- Hits:
- 7,565
Bookmarked by Commanderhearteyes3
29 Jul 2025