Work Text:
It had been four long years since their date, which hadn't gone well at all. Every night, Luke finds himself replaying that evening over and over in his mind. He keeps wondering how he could have made things better, how he could have made their time together more interesting, and most of all, how he could have made Penelope fall in love with him.
Now, Luke has to watch as Penelope falls in love with someone else, someone who is not the version of him he had imagined for her. Tyler is a good guy, but he isn’t who Luke had pictured Penelope ending up with. The person Luke had always envisioned her being with was, well, himself.
It's hard for Luke to accept this reality. He’s trapped in a cycle of introspection, struggling to understand where he went wrong. Why didn’t things turn out the way he had envisioned? What did he miss, and how could he have been different? Every moment of self-reflection seems to deepen his sense of loss, making it even harder to move forward. Watching Penelope with Tyler only makes it harder for him to let go of the past and move on.
He knew he had to move on, not just for his own sake but for Penelope’s. It wasn’t fair for him to cling to these emotions when she had clearly moved on. Maybe it was time for him to dip his toes back into the dating scene and give himself a chance to heal.
Luke sighed and glanced at his watch. It was 7 PM, time to clock out and head home. As he walked out of the office, he couldn't shake the feeling that, despite knowing Penelope was no longer a part of his future, a small part of him still wished things were different. He couldn't help but think about how much he still wanted to be with her, even if she could never see herself with him again.
Determined to take a step forward, Luke decided to stop by a bar on his way home. It was a place he’d frequented occasionally, a local spot where he could unwind. As he settled onto a bar stool, he struck up a conversation with Teresa, a familiar face from an old case at the FBI. Their conversation started out casually, catching up on old times and sharing a few laughs. Teresa had a way of making him feel at ease, and her presence reminded him that life still held moments of connection and comfort.
“Does she know you still have these feelings for her, Luke?” Teresa asked, taking another sip of her drink.
Luke scoffed and shook his head. “She knows I love her, Teresa. We’ve already had that conversation.” He set his drink down with a heavy sigh.
Teresa put her drink aside and reached out, gently placing her hand on his. “Sometimes, when you love someone, the best thing you can do is let them go. It might not be what you want, but it might be what you both need.”
Luke met her gaze, and her words struck a chord. “Maybe it is time to let her go. I mean, it’s been four years, right?”
Teresa nodded in agreement.
“I don’t want to give up on her. I’ll never fully give up,” Luke said, his voice laced with sadness. “But maybe what I need to do is face her and be honest about how I’m feeling.” He sighed deeply, the weight of his emotions evident. He wished sometimes that things had worked out differently, and that he could have found a way to make it alright.
Talking to Teresa, he felt a shift in perspective. He understood that holding onto his feelings for Penelope wasn’t just keeping him from moving on; it was also unfair to her. He couldn't continue to let his unresolved feelings dictate his actions, especially when she had clearly moved forward with her life.
It became clear that if he was ever going to truly move on, he needed to confront Penelope directly about how he felt. It was time to have an honest conversation and, more importantly, to find closure for both of them.
He let out another heavy sigh. “I think I know what I need to do.” He set his empty glass down on the table and stood up. “I will text you to let you know how things go.”
Teresa nodded. “Go let her know how you feel, wolfman.”
As he finished his goodbyes to Teresa he let out a small chuckle, however, he also felt a newfound sense of resolve. He knew what he had to do next.. Face Penelope and finally address the feelings that had been holding him back for so long.
-
As Luke drove towards Penelope's apartment, the hum of the engine and the rhythmic flicker of streetlights outside the window provided a backdrop to his swirling thoughts. The city lights blurred by in a streak of colors, mirroring the whirlwind of emotions within him.
He kept replaying the conversation in his mind, trying to find the right words. What exactly was he going to say?
The song “Say Something” by A Great Big World and Christina Aguilera played softly on the radio, its melancholic notes resonating with his mood. The lyrics, “Say something, I’m giving up on you,” seemed to echo his own feelings of vulnerability and longing.
What if she doesn’t understand? What if I can’t find the right words? Luke thought, gripping the steering wheel tighter. I need to be honest, but I also need to be clear. I don’t want to make things harder for her, but I can’t keep these feelings locked away.
He practiced his opening lines quietly, trying to steady his nerves. “Penelope, I know it’s been a long time, but there are things I need to say. I’ve been holding on to these feelings, and it’s not fair to either of us. I need you to know how I feel, even if it’s painful for me to admit.”
The drive seemed to stretch on forever, each minute heightening his anxiety. He thought about the past, how things had started out a little rocky, and then finally they got closer, only to falter during their date. I can’t change what happened, but I can’t keep pretending that I’ve moved on when I haven’t. I owe it to myself and to her to be honest.
But how will she react? Will she even want to hear what I have to say? These questions looped in his mind, adding to his unease. It’s time to let go, whether it’s for her benefit or mine. Maybe hearing me out will give us both the closure we need.
The familiar streets leading to her apartment seemed both comforting and daunting. Luke took a deep breath, trying to calm the storm inside him. I’m doing this because I need to move forward, and so does she. This is the only way to find peace.
He pulled up to Penelope’s building and parked the car. The finality of the moment hit him as he sat there, staring at the entrance. Okay, Luke. This is it. Just be honest, and don’t hold back. No matter what happens, you’ll be okay.
With one last deep breath, he got out of the car, feeling a mix of worry and determination. As he walked toward the building, he knew that this conversation, however it turned out, was a crucial step towards finding closure and, hopefully, moving forward.
He raised his hand slowly, hesitating before knocking on the door. His fingers grazed the surface, trembling slightly as he tried to calm the storm of anxiety coursing through his veins. “Here goes nothing,” he whispered to himself, drawing a deep breath to steady his nerves before he finally knocked.
It was only 9 PM, so she should still be awake, Luke reassured himself as he stood in the hallway, the weight of the moment pressing down on him. The quiet of the evening only heightened his sense of unease, making the upcoming conversation feel even more stressful.
He was jolted from his thoughts by the sound of the door creaking open. Penelope stood there, a mix of surprise and sleepiness in her eyes. “Luke, what are you doing here at this hour?” she asked, stifling a yawn.
Luke felt a pang of vulnerability as he took in her disheveled, yet still remarkable, appearance. How do I even begin? he wondered. The song “Say Something” played softly in his mind, its lyrics haunting him with their melancholy. Say something, I’m giving up on you... The lyrics seemed to perfectly capture the bittersweet emotions he was feeling right now.
“Penelope,” Luke began, his voice unsteady, “I know it’s late, and I’m sorry for showing up like this. I’ve been thinking a lot about us, about everything that happened. I don’t want to keep these feelings bottled up any longer. I need to tell you what’s been on my mind.”
Penelope’s expression shifted from confusion to concern, and she stepped aside to let him in. “Alright, come in,” she said, opening the door wider. “Let’s talk.”
As he walked past her into the familiar space of her living room, Luke felt a mix of nostalgia and nervous anticipation. The room was cozy, a comforting contrast to the storm raging inside him. Penelope gestured for him to sit on the couch, and he lowered himself onto it, feeling a wave of uncertainty.
Penelope settled down in a chair across from him, her gaze attentive. Luke took a deep breath, trying to gather his thoughts. The soft hum of a nearby lamp and the faint glow of city lights filtering through the window created an intimate atmosphere, which made the moment feel even more significant.
“I’ve been holding onto these feelings for far too long,” Luke began, his voice barely above a whisper. “The truth is, I still care about you a lot, and I’ve been trying to figure out how to let go. But I realize now that the only way to move forward is to be honest about how I feel.”
Penelope looked at him, her expression a mix of surprise and empathy.
Luke continued, his voice trembling slightly. “I know it’s been four years, and things have changed. I understand if you don’t feel the same way anymore. I just needed you to know that I’m still here and that I still care. I needed to say something, even if it’s hard for me to admit.” By the time he finished saying all that he was out of breath. Why in the world couldn’t he breathe right now?
The room fell into a heavy silence, filled with the echoes of his unspoken hopes and fears. The lyrics of “Say Something” played in his mind once more, the weight of their meaning pressing down on him.
Say something, I’m giving up on you... Luke thought, feeling the emotional heaviness of the song in the quiet of the room.
Penelope took a moment before responding, her eyes thoughtful, but there was so much to say and she had to find the way to say it. “Luke, I appreciate your honesty. I really do.” She stopped herself and reached out to hold his hands. “I want you to know that there’s a part of me that still feels like there might be a chance for us, and hearing you say all this has stirred up old feelings.” She paused, taking a deep breath, this was hurting her a lot more than she thought it would. “But, honestly, I really like the way things are between us right now as friends. I’ve come to value our friendship deeply.”
Luke sat there and nodded his head, even though he saw this coming, those words still cut his heart to shreds.
She continued, her voice steady but soft as she held back tears. “I also believe that my person is still out there, even if things with Tyler don’t work out.” Penelope knows that Luke’s relationship with him is very awkward, but it was getting better especially now that Tyler was pretty much a new member of the team. “I’m still figuring things out for myself and trying to understand what I truly want. I think that sometimes what we need most is to be honest with ourselves and with each other, even if it means acknowledging that we might not be on the same path.”
Her words continued to jab at his heart, each one a reminder of the distance between them and the reality he had to face. Luke felt a knot of pain but also a glimmer of understanding. He took a deep breath, trying to steady himself before responding.
“Thank you, Penelope,” he said quietly, his voice sincere despite the lump in his throat. “I really needed this clarity, even if it wasn't the outcome I was hoping for. I appreciate your honesty, and I’m grateful for the chance to hear it from you directly.” He glanced around the cozy room, taking in the familiar surroundings that had once felt so comforting but now seemed like a backdrop to his heartache. “It’s hard to accept, but I understand where you’re coming from. I guess it’s time for me to let go of the hope I’ve been holding onto and find my own way forward.”
Penelope’s expression softened, and she nodded in understanding. “I’m glad we could have this conversation, Luke.” A tear fell from her eye as she looked up at him once more. “I hope you find what you’re looking for, and I hope we both find happiness in the places we’re meant to be.”
Luke managed a small, appreciative smile. “I hope so too. And I’m really grateful for our friendship, no matter where it leads us.” Little did she know, she was what he was looking for, but after this conversation he knew that was going to have to change, no matter how he felt.
As he stood up to leave, he felt a bittersweet sense of relief. The conversation had been difficult, but it had provided the clarity he needed to move on. With a final, heartfelt look, he thanked Penelope once more before giving her a hug. They held each other like that for a few minutes before he finally let her go.
“I think I should go.” He whispered, as he brought his hand up to wipe a tear from her cheek.
Penelope nodded, her eyes glistening. “I think so too.”
As he made his way to the door, every step felt like an echo of the heartache he carried. He could feel the sharp sting of sadness, knowing that what he had hoped for was no longer possible. But amidst the pain, there was a glimmer of hope that shone through the darkness. The clarity he had gained, painful as it was, offered him a path forward.
Stepping out into the cool night air, Luke took a deep breath, trying to calm the turmoil within him. The streetlights cast a soft glow, and the night seemed quieter now, almost as if it was acknowledging his sorrow. He felt a pang of emptiness, his heart aching from the finality of the moment.
Yet, beneath the sadness, there was a sense of resolve. He had faced the truth, and while his heart felt shattered, he also felt a small spark of hope. Maybe this is the beginning of a new chapter , he thought to himself. A chance to heal and find what truly lies ahead.