Adult Content Warning

This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.

• Yes, Continue
• No, Go Back

If you accept cookies from our site and you choose "Yes, Continue", you will not be asked again during this session (that is, until you close your browser). If you log in you can store your preference and never be asked again.

1. He must take more suffering from the Gods by FireLord1664 for girl_ibuprofen

   Fandoms: Percy Jackson and the Olympians & Related Fandoms - All Media Types, Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan, EPIC - Jorge Rivera-Herrans (Albums)  

   • Mature
   • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
   • F/M, Multi
   • Work in Progress

   29 Sep 2025

   Tags

   • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
   • Athena & Poseidon (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena & Odysseus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena & Penelope (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena & Telemachus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Annabeth Chase/Percy Jackson
   • Percy Jackson & Poseidon (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena (EPIC: The Musical) & Percy Jackson
   • Athena & Nico di Angelo
   • Bianca di Angelo & Nico di Angelo
   • Poseidon (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Poseidon (Percy Jackson)
   • Athena (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Tiresias (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Hermes (Percy Jackson)
   • Hermes (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Diomedes (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Menelaus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Ajax (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Telemachus (Percy Jackson)
   • Telemachus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Penelope (Percy Jackson)
   • Penelope (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Hector (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Percy Jackson
   • Thalia Grace (Percy Jackson)
   • Beryl Grace
   • Sally Jackson (Percy Jackson)
   • Bianca di Angelo
   • Nico di Angelo
   • Minos (Percy Jackson)
   • Odysseus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Odysseus (Percy Jackson)
   • Circe (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Circe (Percy Jackson)
   • Protective Athena (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Poseidon Being an Asshole (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Yet at the same time loving Percy
   • he's a complicated man
   • Protective Hermes (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena Needs a Hug (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Athena Needs a Hug (Percy Jackson)
   • Odysseus Needs A Hug (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Odysseus is Not Okay (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Percy Jackson Needs a Hug
   • Percy Jackson is Not Okay
   • Mental Breakdown
   • Song: No Longer You (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Tiresias really gives the worst news ever
   • Poseidon is based off of Duvetbox's design
   • Because that design rocks
   • Percy Jackson is Odysseus (EPIC: The Musical)
   • Zeus' design is based off of Duvetbox's design
   • Athena's design is based off of Duvetbox's design
   • Because those designs are cool too!
   • Good Parent Zeus (Percy Jackson)
   • Good Uncle Zeus (Percy Jackson)

   Summary

   I recently read Lavender_Hyacinths' AU of what if Percy Jackson is Odysseus reincarnated and I really love it! Read it if you haven't already.

   Therefore, I'm making this what if scenario of how it could play out.

   This is based on Lavender_Hyacinths' AU. I'm just making a what if scenario.

    

   *Start of it*

   "Poseidon, you cruel heartless bastard!" Athena yelled.

   "Ah, so you've figured it out," Poseidon said with a chuckle.

   "Yes, I have! How could you. Odysseus' family and friends have been waiting in the Underworld for literal millennia to come back to them! Penelope grieves everyday, Telemachus just wants to know who his father was, and this is what you do! You take his soul and reincarnate him over and over again so he can never reach them!?"

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   52,013

   Chapters:

   12/?

   Comments:

   37

   Kudos:

   279

   Bookmarks:

   55

   Hits:

   10,899