Work Text:
The dim glow of the Mystic Grill cast long shadows across the wooden tables, the chatter of late-night patrons filling the air like a static hum. The scent of whiskey and charred burgers clung to the air, but Elena barely noticed. She had been coming here more often alone.
Once, she would have been surrounded by Stefan and Damon, their protectiveness suffocating yet comforting. Now, they barely looked at her. They spoke to her in clipped tones, their gazes darting away when she turned toward them, as if her presence was too much to bear.
She absently traced the rim of her glass. It wasn’t hard to figure out why.
A witch had come into town looking for vengeance. A woman no older than thirty, with eyes black as coal and a voice that rang like thunder. She had accused Elena of crimes she didn’t commit, believing she was Katerina Petrova. Before Elena could even explain, the spell had been cast.
The pain had been blinding. Like fire crawling over her skin, burning away the soft edges of who she used to be. When she finally saw herself in the mirror, horror clawed at her throat. Her face once smooth and untouched was now marred with scars, twisted as if her skin had been melted away in places.
And Stefan and Damon her Stefan and Damon hadn’t been able to look at her the same way since.
She clenched her fingers into a fist. Was that all she had ever been to them? A beautiful girl to be loved, protected, cherished so long as she remained perfect?
Elena swallowed hard, refusing to let the tears rise.
Then, a voice low, accented, unmistakably familiar broke through her thoughts.
"Drinking alone, love? How tragically poetic."
Her heart skipped, then plummeted. Klaus Mikaelson.
Elena turned her head, half-expecting him to smirk at her misfortune, to revel in her suffering. He had always been a thorn in her side, a constant source of pain and chaos. But when she met his gaze, she saw no amusement there.
Only curiosity.
Klaus slid into the seat across from her, resting his arms on the table as he studied her. Unlike everyone else, he didn’t flinch. He didn’t avert his eyes or hesitate. He simply looked.
"What do you want, Klaus?" she muttered, voice hoarse.
"Can’t a man enjoy a drink in the company of an old acquaintance?" he mused, signaling the bartender. "Though, I admit, I expected a bit more fire from you. You’re usually more… spirited."
She laughed bitterly. "Spirited? What’s the point? It’s not like anything I say or do changes anything."
"That doesn’t sound like the Elena Gilbert I know."
"You don’t know me."
Klaus leaned forward, tilting his head. "Oh, but I do. I know the girl who throws herself into danger for the people she loves. The one who, despite everything, still clings to the foolish notion that people are inherently good." He exhaled softly. "I also know the pain of looking into the mirror and not recognising the face staring back at you."
Elena stiffened. "Don’t compare your life to mine."
"Why not?" he asked, a flicker of something unreadable passing through his expression. "You think I was always like this? That I was always this… monster?"
She faltered, her nails digging into her palm.
"I was human once," Klaus continued, his voice softer now. "More human than you can imagine. There was a time when I knew kindness, when I trusted freely, when I believed my mother loved me, that my father was a great man. That my family was unbreakable."
His words sent a strange shiver down her spine.
"What happened?" she asked before she could stop herself.
Klaus smiled, but it was hollow. "My mother cursed me before I even understood what it meant to be cursed. She turned me into an abomination in my father’s eyes. And Mikael well, he made sure I never forgot it. Every lash of the whip, every broken bone, every whispered insult he carved his hatred into me. He wanted to beat the weakness out of me, the part of me that was different. And when that didn’t work, he hunted me for centuries, never stopping, never relenting."
Elena’s breath hitched. She had always known Klaus was cruel, but she had never thought about why.
"Why are you telling me this?" she asked hesitantly.
Klaus’s gaze bore into hers. "Because you think you’re broken. That without your beauty, you’ve lost something irreplaceable. But beauty, love, isn’t skin deep. It’s who you are. And in all my thousand years, I have never met anyone quite like you."
Her throat tightened.
"You think I’m beautiful?" she whispered, barely able to get the words out.
Klaus’s smile softened. "I think you’re remarkable."
A tear slipped down her cheek before she could stop it. No one had told her that. Not since the witch had cursed her. Not since Stefan and Damon had started looking at her like she was less.
Klaus reached out, brushing his knuckles against the tear-stained path. "I know a warlock
an old friend of mine. He’s coming into town soon. He can break the curse, restore you to how you were before."
Elena’s breath caught. "Why would you help me?"
His expression turned unreadable, and for a long moment, he said nothing. Then, finally, he whispered, "Because once upon a time, I was a boy who wanted to be loved for who he was, not what he looked like. And I think, perhaps, you would have liked that version of me."
Elena’s resolve crumbled.
She surged forward, throwing her arms around him, burying her face into the crook of his neck. He tensed for only a moment before his arms encircled her, holding her as if she were something fragile, something worth protecting.
She pulled back just enough to press a soft kiss to his cheek.
"Klaus," she murmured, "I think I would have really liked that version of you." Her fingers tightened against his jacket. "But… I think I’m starting to like this version, too."
For the first time, Klaus Mikaelson—the Original Hybrid, the immortal king of monsters—looked utterly undone.
And for the first time since she had become a vampire, Elena Gilbert felt seen.