Work Text:
It starts small.
A few minutes late here. A brief, glassy-eyed moment in a briefing there. A hesitation when she’s asked a question.
A few weeks in, Hotch is no longer in doubt: JJ isn’t sleeping.
She’s still JJ: Clothes immaculate, hair perfectly in place, nails manicured, posture military-straight. Her face betrays her, though. Her make-up can’t quite hide the dark circles under her eyes, the fact that her pallor is… terrible, that it strains her more than usual to smile.
Hotch isn’t sure if anyone else can tell, whether anyone sees what he sees. He doesn’t quite know where to turn with his growing concern, doesn’t know how to be professional and appropriate with this bone-deep knowledge he has that something in JJ’s life is breaking apart. It feels heavy and like something he has no idea how to handle. It seems having gone through a marriage collapse yourself doesn’t really help you help others. He ends up keeping it to himself, worried that talking will read as gossiping, and tries to decide how to proceed.
He’s kept his distance for long months now, wary of knocking them off-kilter. Polite. Careful. But now? Now he’s not sure he can anymore.
He catches her alone in the break room late in the afternoon, staring into a cup of coffee she hasn’t touched.
He breathes once, then once more, before plunging in: “You okay?”
JJ glances up, her expression carefully impassive. “I’m fine,” she says automatically, but her voice lacks conviction.
“You’ve been ‘fine’ for three weeks now,” he says, as gently as he’s able.
JJ’s lips press into a thin line, her eyes narrow. She looks down into her coffee mug.
“I can handle it,” she murmurs, but there’s a weariness beneath the words that betrays her.
Hotch nods slowly.
“I know you can,” he replies.
That hangs in the air; heavy, uncertain. JJ finally looks up at him fully, and for a brief moment, her face shows it all: the exhaustion, the strain, and something deeper. Something like fear. She offers a faint, tired smile. The kind people give when they’re too worn out to argue but too proud to accept help.
“Thanks, Hotch,” she says, voice polite, distant. “Really. But I’m fine.”
He knows this is where he’s supposed to nod and walk away. Respect her boundaries. But as he watches her turn back to her untouched coffee, something twists in his chest. It’s a familiar ache he thought he’d buried months ago. He lingers a second longer than he should, then finally retreats, the quiet hum of the vending machine following him out.
---
Hotch’s inbox pings late in the afternoon, routine enough that he barely glances at it. But when he sees the subject line – PTO Approval Notification – Jareau, Jennifer – his focus sharpens instantly. He opens it, scanning the message saying JJ has requested three days off. No explanation. No personal note. Just bureaucracy doing its job.
Hotch leans back in his chair, frowning. His eyes flick in the direction of JJ’s office. She didn’t tell him. Didn’t tell anyone, as far as he can tell. And that silence says more than any conversation could.
For a moment, he debates whether to knock on her door, to offer something, even if it's just a token "If there’s anything I can do..." But he knows JJ. If she wanted him involved, she would’ve said something before now.
Still, he can’t shake the knot in his stomach.
The next morning, her office is dark. Her desk, usually neat and orderly, feels too empty without her behind it.
Garcia pokes her head into Hotch’s office around noon, looking unusually subdued.
“Hey... do you know where JJ is?” she asks, clearly uneasy. “She’s not answering texts.”
Hotch keeps his expression neutral, but his hand tightens slightly on his pen.
“A few days off,” he replies simply.
He doesn’t say anything more. Garcia clearly wants to ask, but she must know he can’t give her details even if he had any, so she just nods and leaves.
When she leaves, Hotch closes his laptop and leans back, staring out in the air for a long moment.
Three days. He knows exactly what kind of things happen in time frames like that. Lawyers. Custody agreements. Moving boxes.
---
JJ walks into the Monday morning briefing at exactly 9:59. She looks sharp, composed, and immaculate, as if the past few weeks hadn’t carved shadows beneath her eyes. She looks like JJ again, and that alone sets Hotch on edge. He knows what that kind of perfection means in a professional woman: It’s armor.
The team falls into their usual rhythm as they discuss their way through a stack of new cases. But Hotch watches them.
She’s focused, attentive, but there’s a stillness to her, a painfully deliberate calm. He notices the absence of her wedding ring. As the hour drags on, he can clock as the others notice it one after another, drawing silent conclusions.
When the meeting wraps, chairs scraping back and files closing, JJ clears her throat softly, barely enough to draw attention, but enough to stop everyone mid-motion.
“If I could just--” she starts, voice even, practiced.
The team looks at her, and if she wasn’t staring down at her notes from the meeting, avoiding their faces, she’d be able to tell that the announcement is moot, but her eyes don’t move from the page.
“I just wanted to let you all know... Will and I are separating.”
The silence hangs for a beat too long.
“It’s amicable,” she adds quickly, before anyone can speak. “Henry’s fine. I’m fine. Just figured it was easier to mention it now before anyone wondered.”
Morgan clears his throat, Garcia moves towards her but falters.
“Nothing’s changing,” JJ finishes, gathering her files. “That’s it.”
And just like that, she walks out—leaving the weight of her words behind her like they were nothing more than a calendar update.
The team exchanges glances. Hotch doesn’t say anything.
---
That afternoon, they’re called to Denver. They work until late, then begrudgingly retreat to the hotel to rest for a few hours.
Hotch wasn’t planning to seek JJ out, but when he passes her room on his way to his own, something tells him she’s not sleeping. He finds her exactly where he suspected: In the dim inner corner of the hotel bar, nursing a vodka soda.
Hotch stands at the entrance for a moment, watching her. There’s no slump to her posture, no visible crack in the armor. But he knows better. The fact that she’s here at all, instead of fast asleep in soft hotel sheets, says enough.
Finally, he moves toward her, with quiet, deliberate steps. He stops beside her table, waiting until she acknowledges him.
JJ glances up, unsurprised. “Couldn’t sleep either?” she asks, her voice low, carrying the faintest trace of exhaustion beneath the calm.
Hotch shakes his head once. “Didn’t try.”
A flicker of something passes between them.He gestures slightly toward the seat across from her, silent question. JJ considers for a beat before nodding.
They sit in silence for a while, the soft hum of conversation and clinking glasses filling the space between them. Hotch doesn’t push. He knows better than to prod JJ before she’s ready.
Finally, she breaks the quiet, fingers tracing the rim of her glass.
“I thought it’d feel different,” she murmurs, eyes fixed on the swirl of her drink. “Signing the papers.”
Hotch watches her carefully, his voice soft when he responds. “Different how?”
Finally, JJ looks up at him. Her eyes are bright and red-rimmed.
“I’m not falling apart, Hotch,” she says, and he doesn’t know whether to believe her.
“I know,” he replies anyway. “But if you do... you don’t have to do it alone.”
JJ looks away, blinking hard. She finishes her drink in one controlled motion and sets the glass down with finality.
“I should get some sleep,” she says, standing smoothly.
Hotch rises too, but he doesn’t stop her. As she turns to leave, she pauses, just for a second.
“Thanks,” she says, without looking back.
---
The next night, case closed but too late to get the jet in the air until the next morning, JJ sits in a couch in the hotel lobby, fingers absently spinning her keycard between them. Hotch spots her as he’s walking past.
“You okay?” he asks quietly.
She doesn’t look up right away, just lets out a breath that’s too heavy to be casual. “Yeah. Just... thinking.”
Hotch hesitates, then sinks down beside her on the couch, resting his elbows on his knees. They sit in silence for a while.
Finally, JJ speaks, voice low, almost like she’s afraid saying it loudly will make it worse.
“I thought I’d feel worse.”
Hotch glances at her, waiting.
JJ keeps her eyes on the floor. “About the divorce. About... everything.” She swallows hard. “But when I walked out of that office, I felt... lighter.”
Her voice wavers on that last word, like it betrays something shameful. Hotch straightens, his response immediate, too quick, because he recognizes that look in her eyes.
“That’s okay,” he says firmly. “It’s normal to feel relief.”
JJ finally looks at him, searching his face. “Did you?”
Hotch feels jaw tightening, lets his gaze drop.
“It was different for me,” he says, willing his voice to remain steady. “Haley left because I couldn’t give her what she needed. I didn’t fight for the right things. And then... I never got the chance to make peace with it.”
JJ’s features soften with understanding, but before she can turn the conversation back to him, he needs to say his piece:
“But that’s not your story, JJ. You did everything you could, up to a point. That’s not failure.”
JJ’s eyes glisten for a moment, but she blinks it away, managing a weak smile.
“You’re really bad at pep talks,” she mutters, but there’s a faint warmth beneath it.
Hotch allows the corner of his mouth to twitch. “One of my many faults.”
They sit quietly after that. JJ’s shoulders relax just enough to show she’s heard him. When she finally stands, she doesn’t look as weighed down as before. Before heading off, she glances back, her voice softer.
“Thanks, Hotch.”
This time, he thinks it’s not dismissal. It feels genuine.
---
He couldn’t feel it at the time, but over time he realizes that something shifted between them in Denver.
Back at Quantico, it starts happening without either of them planning it. Every few days, they both end up lingering after hours. One of them finds the other in the break room or passing in the hallway, and before long, they’re sitting in Hotch’s office or JJ’s, coffee growing cold between them.
Hotch listens more than he speaks, tries to let her fill the space between them, talk through her troubles without clobbering her with his own.
But one night, maybe two weeks later, JJ studies him across his desk, her head tilted slightly, fingers wrapped around a mug.
She asks, finally, with all the caution in the world: “What was it like? With Haley.”
Hotch feels himself freeze, trying to remember how to breathe through the memories. After a pause, he leans back in his chair.
“It was good,” he says quietly. “Until it wasn’t.”
JJ doesn’t interrupt. She knows better. Hotch continues, voice calmer than he feels.
“She was patient for a long time. Longer than I probably deserved.” His eyes drop to the file on his desk. “I remember I told Elle once that this job will eat you up if you let it.” He paused. “And when being at work became less fraught than being at home… I let it.”
JJ’s throat tightens, but she stays silent, letting him speak.
“When she left, I got it. I knew I couldn’t blame her.” He exhales slowly. “Didn’t make it hurt any less.”
There’s a long pause, the quiet hum of the bullpen filling the space between them.
JJ’s voice is soft when she finally asks, “Do you ever stop feeling like you failed?”
Hotch meets her gaze, tries to decide how honest to be.
“No,” he says. “But you learn to live with it. And you learn that failure isn’t the whole story.”
---
The bullpen is nearly empty, the hum of overhead lights and distant printers the only sounds left in the building. It’s past 9 PM, too late for paperwork.
Hotch notices JJ still at her desk when he passes by on his way to his office. She’s staring at her computer screen, but her hands aren’t moving. He hesitates, then circles back.
“You need anything?”
JJ glances up, clearly debating whether to brush him off. But something in her expression shifts, exhaustion overriding pride.
“Company,” she admits with a wry smile.
Hotch nods once, disappearing for a moment before returning with two fresh cups of coffee. He sets one beside her without a word, then pulls a chair over to sit across from her desk.
For a while, they just sit. Finally, JJ speaks, her voice low and flat, like she’s reading from a report. “I spent two hours today negotiating who gets the toaster.”
Hotch’s lips twitch. It’s not quite a smile, but close.
JJ lets out a dry laugh, shaking her head. “We’ve been together for this long, and it comes down to arguing over kitchen appliances.”
Hotch sips his coffee, letting her set the pace.
“It’s stupid,” she mutters, rubbing her temples. “The big stuff’s already settled. Custody, the house… but it’s the little things that make it feel real.”
She doesn’t sound angry, just tired.
Hotch leans back, his voice calm. “It’s never about the toaster.”
JJ huffs a quiet agreement, her gaze dropping.
“How’s Henry handling it?”
“He’s… resilient,” she says, but her voice wavers just enough to betray worry. “We’re keeping it as normal as we can. Two houses, same routine. But he knows.”
Hotch holds her gaze, steady and reassuring. “Kids always do. But he has you. That makes all the difference.”
JJ’s shoulders ease, just a little.
---
The next night, JJ shows up at his door. He doesn’t say anything, just steps aside and lets her in. She sits down at the kitchen table and he brings her a cup of coffee.
After a minute, JJ speaks, her voice quiet. “Henry asked if I was mad at his dad.”
Hotch doesn’t respond right away. He sees the tension in her shoulders, the way she holds herself too tightly.
“What did you tell him?” he asks.
JJ lets out a breath, half a laugh but without humor.
“That I wasn’t. That sometimes grown-ups just… stop being right for each other.” Her fingers tap anxiously against her phone. “He nodded like he understood, but he doesn’t. Not really.”
Hotch nods, leaning back in his chair. “Jack was the same. He accepted it, but… it stays with them. Even if they don’t have the words for it.”
JJ looks up at him, eyes tired but searching. “How do you make sure they don’t blame themselves?”
Hotch’s jaw tightens. “You keep showing up. Every day. You remind them that nothing about them changed. That they’re still loved exactly the same.”
JJ nods slowly, absorbing that, but her expression doesn’t ease.
After a pause, she speaks again, this time her voice thinner. “I keep wondering if staying would’ve been better for him. If I should’ve just… pushed through.”
Hotch’s response is immediate. “Staying in something broken doesn’t protect them. It teaches them that unhappiness is normal.”
JJ looks down, her thumb running over the edge of her phone. “Yeah,” she whispers, but it sounds like she’s still trying to believe it.
---
It’s almost midnight when JJ knocks on his door again two days later.
“I couldn’t sleep,” she says apologetically, and Hotch sets a mug of tea in front of her.
He doesn’t answer. For a minute, she doesn’t speak. Just stares at the edge of the table, like the words are caught somewhere in her throat.
Then, quietly, she asks, “How do you know when it was the right decision?”
Hotch doesn’t have to ask what she means.
JJ keeps her eyes down, her voice steady but fragile.
“Some days, I’m sure I did the right thing. And then… there are nights where I lie awake wondering if I should’ve fought harder. If I quit.”
Hotch leans back in his chair, exhaling slowly. He knows that feeling. He glances toward the stairs, suddenly seized by the urge to check if Jack is sleeping well.
“You didn’t quit,” he says firmly. “You stayed as long as you could. Longer than most would’ve.”
JJ lets out a bitter breath. “Doesn’t feel like that.”
“It never does,” Hotch admits. “We tell ourselves that staying is strength. But sometimes, it’s knowing when to stop fighting a battle that’s already lost.”
After a moment, she asks, “When did you stop second-guessing yourself?”
Hotch hesitates, because the truth isn’t what she wants to hear.
“I’ll let you know when I get there,” he says quietly.
That earns a small, tired smile from JJ, a real one, even if fleeting.
---
It’s another late night—too late for either of them to pretend they’re just finishing work.
JJ sits on the edge of Hotch’s desk, nursing a cup of coffee. Hotch leans back in his chair, sleeves rolled up. They’ve been talking about Henry, custody schedules, the usual. But when the conversation lulls, JJ hesitates, then asks the question that’s been bugging her for weeks.
“Do you ever think… if things had been different, you and Haley would’ve made it?”
Hotch doesn’t answer right away. His gaze drifts to the corner of his office, somewhere far beyond it.
“We met in high school,” he says quietly, a small smile flickering across his face, nostalgic, but bittersweet. “She was a year younger. Smarter than me. Funnier.”
JJ watches him carefully, letting him speak at his own pace.
“We were on and off for a while,” he continues, voice steady. “But the time she went to college, that was it. We were… us.”
He pauses, fingers tapping lightly against the armrest.
“For a long time, it worked. We knew each other better than anyone else could.” His smile fades. “But knowing someone doesn’t mean you grow the same way.”
JJ’s throat tightens.
“When did you know it was over?” she asks softly.
Hotch’s jaw tenses, but he doesn’t shy away.
“Too late. When Gideon left and she couldn’t understand why I would want to go with you just for that one case.”
JJ nods slowly, absorbing that.
“She wanted you to choose,” she says.
Hotch finally looks at her, meeting her gaze.
“She deserved someone who could,” he replies.
After a moment, JJ offers a faint smile. “You’re a good father, Hotch.”
His expression softens, and he nods once. “You’re a good mother.”
JJ pushes off the desk, stretching slightly.
“See you tomorrow,” she murmurs, already heading for the door.
Hotch watches her leave.
---
It’s late—later than usual. The kind of late where even the cleaning staff has gone home, and the only light in the bullpen comes from Hotch’s office.
JJ stands in the doorway, leaning against the frame, watching Hotch finish whatever paperwork is keeping him tethered there. After a moment, he sets his pen down, sensing her gaze.
“You’re here late,” he says quietly.
JJ gives a small shrug, stepping inside. “Could say the same to you.”
“Jessica took Jack to visit her parents for a few days.”
There’s a well-earned familiar ease between them now, but tonight, Hotch doesn’t let the silence settle. He looks at her, really looks at her, and before he can stop himself, the question that’s been gnawing at him finally escapes.
“JJ… did I end your marriage?”
JJ freezes mid-step, caught off guard. She sighs, moving to sit across from him, resting her arms on his desk.
“You’ve been holding onto that for a while,” she says softly.
Hotch doesn’t deny it. His expression is tight, waiting for the blow he thinks he deserves. JJ studies him for a long moment.
“No,” she says firmly. “You didn’t.”
When Hotch’s jaw tightens, like he doesn’t believe her, she continues.
“Will and I…” She exhales, searching for the right words. Her fingers trace the edge of a file absently.
“If I hadn’t gotten pregnant…” She hesitates, then meets Hotch’s eyes. “We probably wouldn’t have ever committed in the first place.”
Hotch’s brow furrows, the weight of that admission sinking in.
JJ offers a faint smile. “Henry gave us a reason to try. And we did, for years. But it wasn’t you, Hotch. It wasn’t that night.”
Hotch’s gaze drops, the tension in his shoulders slowly unwinding.
“I needed to hear that,” he admits quietly.
JJ nods, not unkindly. “I know.”
They sit in silence for a while, the air lighter now. After a moment, JJ stands, smoothing down her jacket.
“We both made mistakes,” she says, pausing at the door. “But ending my marriage wasn’t one of them.”
Hotch looks up, meeting her gaze one last time.
“Thank you,” he says, and this time, it carries weight.
JJ nods once, offering a small smile before stepping out into the darkened bullpen. Hotch watches her go, the ache in his chest finally dulling.
For the first time in a year, the past feels like something they can leave behind