Work Text:
Agatha was not spiraling.
She wasn’t.
Not like the first time, anyway.
This time, there were no frantic outfit changes. No compulsive floor scrubbing or dramatic rereads of every message Rio had ever sent her. She hadn’t rewritten a grocery list five times.
This time was different.
She was calm.
Totally.
Mostly.
She stood in the kitchen with her arms crossed, staring down at the pot of pasta sauce simmering gently on the stove like it had personally offended her. It was a simple meal. Intentionally simple. Comforting, even. Not a “first date” meal. Not something designed to impress. Something that said I do this all the time. Something casual. Chill. No pressure.
Nothing to spiral about.
Agatha tapped her fingers against the counter, then stopped.
She wasn’t overthinking. She was being thorough. That was different.
It felt different.
Mostly because now she knew what this was.
This wasn’t two people navigating something ambiguous.
This wasn’t the complicated, unspoken maybe they had been dancing around before.
This was a second date.
An official one.
Rio had called it that. Explicitly. Without hesitation.
Which meant it was real.
And Agatha was terrible at real.
She glanced at the table—already set, but not too neatly. Two plates. Two forks. No candles. No centerpiece. Nothing overly curated. She’d agonized over every part of it and then intentionally made it look like she hadn’t.
Which was insane.
But also necessary.
She wanted Rio to feel comfortable. Relaxed.
Wanted her to feel like this was normal. Easy. Wanted to prove—somehow—that Agatha could do this. That she could exist in this soft, strange space between them without falling apart.
Too late for that, probably.
She sighed and moved to the mirror by the door, checking her reflection for the fourth time. Her hair was fine. Her sweater was fine. Casual. Comfortable. Nothing about her screamed date night. Nothing about her said this is a test I am desperate to pass.
Still, her chest felt tight.
Not in a bad way.
Just… full.
With awareness. With anticipation.
With the knowledge that Rio would be here in less than fifteen minutes and that Agatha had not stopped thinking about their kiss since the moment it happened.
And now they were doing this again.
With the weight of knowing.
She stared at her own reflection, exhaled slowly, and said, “Get it together.”
The doorbell rang.
She jumped.
Of course it was on time. Rio was always on time. Probably standing exactly six feet from the door, phone tucked away, arms folded neatly behind her back while she waited the precise amount of time before ringing the bell.
This wasn’t spiraling.
It was just the second date.
Totally normal.
Completely fine.
No emotional collapse in sight.
She opened the door, and there was Rio—standing exactly where Agatha had imagined she’d be, posture straight, hands tucked behind her back like she’d been waiting for inspection.
“Hi,” Agatha said, already trying not to smile.
Rio nodded once. “Good evening.”
And then, without preamble, she produced a small box from behind her back.
Agatha blinked.
“What’s this?”
Rio held it out, entirely unbothered. “You mentioned, during our fourth conversation, that lemon tarts are your preferred dessert.”
Agatha stared at the box like it might explode.
“I—what?”
Rio tilted her head slightly. “Was that incorrect?”
“No,” Agatha said slowly, taking the box. “It’s just—how do you even remember that?”
Rio frowned, as if confused by the question. “It was relevant.”
Agatha opened the box.
Two perfectly arranged lemon tarts. Handmade, from the looks of it—definitely not store-bought. The crust was golden, the filling smooth and pale yellow, with a light dusting of powdered sugar on top.
“I didn’t even remember saying that,” Agatha muttered.
Rio shrugged slightly. “You were eating something with raspberry filling and said it was inferior.”
Agatha blinked. “I—what?”
“You said, and I quote,” Rio continued, completely deadpan, “‘If it’s not lemon, why even bother?’”
Agatha stared at her.
“That… does sound like me."
Rio nodded. “So I brought lemon.”
Simple. Blunt. Like it was the most logical thing in the world.
Agatha looked up sharply.
Rio’s expression hadn’t changed. No embarrassment. No grand gesture. Just calm observation, like she was stating any other fact.
That made it worse, somehow.
Because she hadn’t meant anything by it.
She hadn’t brought dessert to impress her.
She’d brought it because she listened.
Because she remembered.
Because something Agatha said weeks ago had mattered enough to stick.
“Thanks,” she said, softer now. “You didn’t have to.”
“I know.”
She didn’t say anything else. She didn’t explain or downplay or turn it into a joke.
Just stood there like she hadn’t just rearranged the architecture of Agatha’s entire brain.
Agatha stepped aside, heart thudding. “Come in.”
Rio entered, eyes scanning the apartment like she was noting structural updates. She paused near the bookshelf—reorganized, not that she would say anything about it—and gave a subtle nod of approval.
Agatha placed the dessert on the kitchen counter, suddenly hyper-aware of every breath she took.
They hadn’t even eaten dinner yet.
And already, she felt like this night was going to destroy her.
In the nicest possible way.
“So,” she said, in a voice that was slightly too high. “You remembered a throwaway comment I made a month ago and brought me dessert. No big deal.”
Rio looked at her. “It was not a throwaway comment.”
Agatha blinked. “Oh.”
Rio said nothing else.
She didn’t have to.
And Agatha didn’t know what to do with that, either.
Agatha’s apartment wasn’t small. Not by any reasonable standard.
But with Rio in it?
It felt like the walls had closed in by a few inches.
Not in a bad way. Just… noticeable.
Everything felt more present with Rio around. Every quiet breath, every movement, every shift of air. She didn’t make noise—she barely even rustled—but Agatha felt her. Like Rio’s entire presence had its own gravity, quiet and dense and inescapably magnetic.
Agatha moved to the kitchen to stir the pasta sauce, trying to breathe normally.
Rio stood maybe four feet away, examining the spice rack like it held ancient secrets.
That shouldn’t have been a big deal.
Except Agatha could feel her there. Could sense her body heat like an invisible hum in the air. She was hyperaware of every inch of distance between them—how close Rio was, how close she wasn’t, and how ridiculous it was that Agatha could chart the space between them like she was trying to solve an equation.
She glanced over her shoulder—just for a second.
Rio was holding a jar of oregano like she was reviewing its entire production history.
Agatha turned back to the stove, lips twitching.
She was being ridiculous. It was just a dinner date. A casual one. They had already survived their first kiss. They had survived Rio’s meltdown and the fact that Agatha had stayed overnight. They had talked about things. Real things.
This should be easier now.
So why did it feel like every second was quietly killing her?
“Do you need help with anything?” Rio asked from behind her.
Agatha’s breath hitched—just for a second. She masked it by stirring more aggressively.
“Nope,” she said. “Got it all under control.”
There was a small pause. Then, footsteps—quiet and purposeful.
Too quiet.
Agatha felt the shift in air before she heard her speak again.
“Your stovetop is inefficiently laid out,” Rio observed, now standing close enough that Agatha could feel her at her back.
“Okay,” Agatha said, tone deliberately flat. “Don’t insult my stove while I’m cooking for you.”
Rio didn’t move. “It’s not an insult. It’s an observation.”
“Same difference.”
Another pause. Then Rio said, still entirely calmly: “I like the way your apartment smells.”
Agatha froze.
Just a second.
Then stirred again, slower now.
“Oh?” she asked. Casual. So casual. Like her heart wasn’t trying to elbow its way through her ribs.
“Yes,” Rio said, still close. “Like citrus. And cinnamon.”
Agatha swallowed. “That’s just the dish soap and the air freshener.”
“I know.”
Agatha didn’t answer.
Because her brain was no longer supplying responses.
Rio hadn’t moved. She wasn’t hovering, not really. But her presence was there, solid and steady and making it incredibly difficult to focus on marinara sauce.
“I’m just gonna—” Agatha gestured vaguely. “Plate things.”
Rio stepped back immediately.
Respectful. Efficient.
Agatha nearly collapsed with relief.
And disappointment.
She didn’t know what to do with that, either.
It was just dinner.
Just a second date.
Totally fine.
Except she kept catching herself leaning toward Rio without realizing it. Tracking her in her periphery. Wanting—
Well.
Things she wasn’t about to say out loud.
Especially not while holding a serving spoon.
“You’re overthinking,” Rio said mildly.
Agatha jumped. “I am not.”
“You are,” Rio replied, like it was obvious.
Agatha turned around slowly. “And what exactly am I overthinking?”
Rio blinked. “I don’t know. You haven’t said anything.”
Rio tilted her head. “You’re making that face again.”
Agatha squinted. “What face?”
“The one where you are debating the appropriate amount of emotional vulnerability for the situation.”
Agatha opened her mouth. Closed it.
“I hate how accurate that was.”
Rio offered the faintest hint of a smile. “I know.”
And just like that, the walls felt like they were closing in again.
Not in a bad way.
Just…
Close.
After dinner they sat on the couch with a small, reasonable amount of space between them.
Not touching.
Not technically.
But Agatha could still feel Rio’s presence like a pulse beneath her skin.
There was something about this version of closeness that was worse than full-on kissing. Worse than the slow, careful confessions. Worse than sleeping in the same bed, half-tangled under a blanket, pretending they weren’t both awake and thinking too loudly.
Because this—
This was quiet.
Intentional.
Soft in a way that lingered.
The TV flickered in the background—some nature documentary neither of them were really watching. Agatha’s legs were curled beneath her. Rio was sitting upright, as always, but more relaxed than usual, her arm draped along the back of the couch. Not quite touching Agatha’s shoulders, but close.
Too close.
But not close enough.
Agatha let her head tilt slightly in Rio’s direction. She didn’t lean. Didn’t cross the line. Just hovered near it. That invisible point where awareness turned into contact.
Her pulse was steady, but slow—like it was holding its breath.
This wasn’t like the first kiss. Or the second. Or even the more recent moments where touch had felt like inevitability.
This wasn’t about kissing.
This was sitting.
Being.
Existing next to each other, in the quiet space where nothing had to happen.
And that was what made it dangerous.
Because nothing had to happen, and Agatha still wanted something.
Not more, necessarily. Just continued.
Continued warmth. Continued presence. Continued proximity that asked for nothing but offered everything.
She let herself glance sideways.
Rio was watching the screen, expression calm. Neutral.
But her fingers were curled faintly along the back of the couch, like she was aware—acutely aware—of how close they were.
Agatha’s shoulder itched with the phantom feeling of contact that hadn’t even happened yet.
She cleared her throat quietly. “You comfortable?”
Rio blinked. “Yes.”
Agatha smiled faintly. “Just checking. You look like you’re concentrating on the meaning of life.”
“I’m trying to identify the thematic structure of this documentary.”
“…It’s about sloths.”
“They are structurally fascinating animals.”
Agatha let her head fall back with a soft groan. “God, you’re such a dork.”
She didn’t expect Rio to respond.
But then—
“I know,” Rio said.
Soft. Almost warm.
And just slightly smug.
Agatha glanced at her again.
Their eyes met.
And it was like someone had pressed pause on the entire world.
There was no dramatic music. No fireworks. No sweeping emotional crescendo.
Just…
Stillness.
Familiar and new. Steady and fraught.
A tension that wasn’t about escalation—it was about presence.
Rio didn’t move. Didn’t close the gap.
And neither did Agatha.
Because they didn’t need to.
It was already there.
The intimacy. The weight of everything unsaid. The quiet ache of wanting that didn’t demand resolution.
Agatha exhaled slowly.
And leaned just a little closer.
Just enough for her arm to brush against Rio’s.
No comment.
No reaction.
Just a soft breath—just audible enough to count.
And that?
That was enough.
It was late.
The quiet kind of late. The kind that settled into the walls and softened the edges of everything. Agatha’s apartment had gone still, the empty plates stacked neatly by the sink, the leftover wine forgotten on the counter.
Rio stood by the door, coat on, eyes steady.
Agatha leaned against the frame, arms crossed, doing her best not to look like she was stalling.
“You sure you don’t want to stay?” she asked, voice light.
Rio blinked at her. “I didn’t bring anything.”
Agatha shrugged. “I have blankets. Toothbrushes. The works.”
“That’s not the issue.”
Agatha tilted her head. “Then what is?”
Rio hesitated for just a breath.
“If I stay,” she said quietly, “I might not want to leave.”
Agatha’s heart did something completely unreasonable in her chest.
She didn’t answer right away.
Just reached for the door and opened it slowly, letting the cooler hallway air drift in.
Rio stepped into the threshold but didn’t move past it. She turned to face her again, still lingering like she was running one last diagnostic before committing to the night.
“Thank you,” she said softly. “For tonight.”
Agatha’s voice came out gentler than she meant it to. “Don’t thank me yet. You haven’t seen how I load a dishwasher.”
Rio’s lips twitched. Almost a smile.
Neither of them moved.
Agatha’s fingers brushed the edge of the doorframe. “You’ll text me when you get home?”
Rio nodded. “Of course.”
Agatha hesitated.
And then—
Like it was the most natural thing in the world—
She leaned in.
Just a little.
Just enough.
And Rio met her halfway.
The kiss was brief. Gentle. A soft brush of mouths, warm and unhurried. Not a grand gesture. Not a declaration.
Just a quiet promise.
When they pulled apart, Rio’s eyes lingered on her face.
“Goodnight, Agatha.”
Agatha’s voice was barely a whisper. “Goodnight.”
Rio stepped out of the door. This time, she did walk away.
And Agatha closed the door slowly behind her, fingers brushing her own lips.
Already thinking about the next time.