Work Text:
The new camper arrived under a gray sky—typical, Nico thought, for a daughter of Thanatos.
Her name was Lyra, and she wore black like it was armor. Her hair was dark and choppy, her eyes pale silver that didn’t quite belong to the living, and she carried herself like she could see things others couldn’t—and usually did.
Campers gossiped within hours. "She’s a child of Death itself,” they whispered. “Not Hades. Thanatos. The actual guy with wings and chains.”
Nico di Angelo didn’t listen to most of it. He didn’t care. What he did notice was the way she didn’t flinch when shadows moved. How she stood a little too still when someone mentioned the Underworld. How her eyes didn’t look haunted, but familiar—like a mirror.
She reminded him of himself.
And that made him pause.
---
They started talking after dinner, a few nights into her arrival.
She was sitting by the edge of the woods, flipping through a book about ancient death rituals, and Nico—half out of curiosity, half out of habit—sat beside her without saying anything.
After a long moment, she glanced sideways. “Do people always treat you like a ghost here?”
He blinked. “Yeah. They used to, at least.”
Lyra nodded. “I kind of like it. Ghosts are honest.”
That was the beginning.
---
Within a week, they were inseparable in the way two shadows blend in dusk.
They walked through the woods at odd hours, trading stories about spirits and the afterlife. Nico showed her how to summon the mist from the cracks of the earth; Lyra showed him how to listen when the dead didn’t speak. They spent hours in the quiet—sometimes talking, sometimes not—connected by an invisible thread woven through years of solitude.
And one evening, just as the sun was disappearing behind Half-Blood Hill, Lyra said, “Wanna see something?”
Nico, intrigued, nodded.
She closed her eyes and whispered something in Ancient Greek, words soft as breath, and then—
They appeared.
A swirl of butterflies—small, flickering shadows in the shape of delicate wings. They hovered between them, dancing slowly in the twilight. Black and violet, their outlines shimmered like smoke.
Nico watched them in silence.
“They come when I’m calm,” she said softly, her voice almost lost in the breeze. “Or when I’m seen. Thanatos used to tell me that souls often pass as butterflies. Gentle ones. The ones that don't scream.”
Nico reached a hand out, and one landed on his finger, so light he could barely feel it.
“They’re beautiful,” he said. And he meant it.
Lyra didn’t smile often, but she did then.
---
Will Solace had never considered himself jealous. He was confident—about most things. His healing magic, his archery, his place at camp. Even with Nico, who was sometimes difficult and prickly, Will had found his grounding. They balanced each other. They worked.
Until now.
At first, it was small things. Missed breakfasts. Nico zoning out at dinner. Canceling their stargazing nights because Lyra wanted to “walk the border between planes,” whatever that meant.
Will told himself not to be petty. Not to be that boyfriend.
Nico needed friends. Gods, he deserved them. And Lyra understood him in a way few others ever could. Will couldn’t talk about soul travel or bone magic, and he didn’t want to—he was the light, the healer. Nico came to him to rest.
But the distance between them was growing, and Will felt it like a slow-burning fever.
He missed Nico’s silence. He missed being the person Nico wanted to return to.
---
One night, Will found them on the hill overlooking the strawberry fields.
Nico was lying on his back in the grass, hands behind his head, Lyra sitting cross-legged beside him. They were talking softly, both facing the stars.
Will stood at the bottom of the hill, just watching.
Lyra said something that made Nico laugh—a real laugh, low and surprised.
Will didn’t remember the last time Nico had laughed like that with him.
He turned and walked away.
---
Will didn’t bring it up for days. Instead, he worked longer hours in the infirmary, trying to lose himself in healing bones and mending bruises.
But even Kayla noticed.
“You keep wrapping the same bandage over and over,” she said one afternoon. “Want to tell me who broke your heart?”
Will didn’t answer. He didn’t need to.
“You know he loves you, right?” she added gently. “Even if he doesn’t always show it in normal ways.”
“That’s the problem,” Will said quietly. “Lately, he’s showing it to someone else.”
---
It all came to a head a few nights later, when Nico was late—again.
Will was waiting outside the infirmary, a blanket folded in his lap, hot cocoa already lukewarm. Nico had promised to meet him for a quiet night on the porch. They’d been planning it for a week.
He never showed.
Instead, Will saw him hours later near the fire pit, sitting beside Lyra, their heads bent close. She was drawing something in the dirt with a stick—symbols Will didn’t recognize.
Will snapped.
He marched over before he could stop himself. “Hey.”
Nico looked up, surprised. “Will?”
“You forgot,” Will said, holding up the now-cold cocoa.
Nico blinked, confused. “Oh—gods. I—”
“You forgot, Nico. Again.”
Lyra stood slowly, picking up her cloak. “I’ll... give you two a moment.”
Will didn’t acknowledge her. His gaze was locked on Nico.
“I’ve been waiting for you all week,” Will said. “And every time, you’ve chosen her.”
Nico stiffened. “It’s not about choosing.”
“Then what is it about?” Will asked, voice shaking. “Because I’ve been patient. I get it—she’s like you. She sees you. And maybe you need that. But I’m standing here, trying to be your partner, and I feel like a ghost in your life.”
Nico flinched.
Will exhaled sharply, turning away. “I know you struggle. I know this isn’t easy. But I can’t be the only one trying.”
There was a pause.
Then Nico’s voice, low and cracked. “You’re not.”
Will turned back.
Nico looked wrecked. “I didn’t mean to shut you out. I just—I’ve never had someone like Lyra. Someone who understands the darkness without needing it translated. With you... I always feel like I have to try to be more. Not in a bad way. Just... brighter.”
Will stepped closer. “Nico. You don’t have to be brighter for me. You just have to show up. That’s it.”
“I’m sorry,” Nico whispered.
Will hesitated... then pulled him in.
Nico clung to him, arms around his waist, forehead against Will’s collarbone.
“I missed you,” Will murmured. “Even when you were right there.”
---
From behind the trees, Lyra wiped a tear and whispered something under her breath.
A small storm of butterflies rose from her fingertips—black and violet, wings glinting in the moonlight.
She smiled, watching them dance above the couple in the clearing, before turning and quietly slipping away.
---
Later that night, Will and Nico sat together under the stars again—this time alone.
Nico reached for Will’s hand without hesitation.
“You know,” Will said, “Lyra’s probably writing fanfiction about us.”
“She already offered to stage a dramatic retelling,” Nico muttered.
Will laughed. “She’s staying forever, isn’t she?”
“Unfortunately,” Nico said. Then added, more softly: “I’m glad she’s here. But I’m gladder that you are.”
Will leaned in.
They kissed—soft, sure, slow.
Not an ending.
A beginning.