Work Text:
The rhythmic clack-clack of the train on the tracks is a steady heartbeat against the Halloween night. Inside the lavishly decorated car, the air thrums with a mix of excitement and unease, a perfect blend for a ghost train party. The scent of stale popcorn and artificial fog hangs heavy, mingling with the sweeter notes of cheap perfume and the metallic tang of something undefinable. Spencer, as Marie "Slim" Browning, her dark hair impeccably styled, her tailored suit a perfect homage, watches the flickering lights outside. The passing landscape is a blur of distorted shapes and fleeting shadows, each one momentarily resembling something more sinister.
Her gaze drifts to Toby, her Harry "Steve" Morgan, his quiet strength a comforting anchor in the swirling chaos of the party. He’s leaning against the window, his gaze distant, a half-smile playing on his lips as he listens to the muffled strains of jazz music seeping in from another car. Across the aisle, Hanna, a vision in platinum blonde and sparkling white, embodies Marilyn Monroe with an almost unsettling accuracy. Her laughter, a bright, effervescent sound, pierces through the din as she playfully swats at Caleb, who is deep in character as the Phantom of the Opera, his mask adding an air of brooding mystery.
He’s telling her a ghost story, his voice a low rumble, and Hanna, despite her feigned nonchalance, leans in, captivated. The fabric of her dress shimmers under the dim, fluctuating lights, reflecting glints of gold and silver. Every movement is a performance, every gesture a careful study in Hollywood glamor. Emily, transformed into Barbarella, her metallic jumpsuit catching the light in dazzling flashes, looks utterly futuristic and utterly out of place, yet undeniably radiant. She’s talking animatedly with Paige, a striking Marlene Dietrich, their conversation a hushed murmur punctuated by occasional bursts of shared amusement.
Paige’s tuxedo is sharp, her expression enigmatic, a perfect foil to Emily’s open enthusiasm. They’re discussing the bizarre costumes, the over-the-top decorations, and the increasingly eerie atmosphere of the train. The temperature in the car seems to drop and rise sporadically, making the already unsettling ambiance even more so. And then there's Aria, a stunning Daisy Buchanan, her flapper dress swaying with every subtle movement of the train. Her dark hair is bobbed, a glittering headband catching the light, and her eyes, usually so expressive, hold a touch of something distant, almost melancholic, a true echo of her character. She’s nestled beside Ezra, who, as F. Scott Fitzgerald, is diligently scribbling in a small notebook, occasionally glancing up at Aria with an admiring gaze.
The literary power couple, lost in their world of prose and romance, seem almost oblivious to the growing tension in the air. The faint scent of old paper and Ezra’s cologne mingles around them, creating a small, intimate bubble amidst the revelry. Aria reaches out, her manicured finger tracing a swirling pattern on the condensation-laden windowpane. Her name, "Aria," appears in ghostly script, briefly visible before the fog of the window slowly consumes it.
The ghost train continues its journey, each car a tableau of Halloween nightmares and historical figures. Skeletons hang from the ceiling, their bony fingers seeming to reach out to the passengers. Cobwebs, thick and artificially aged, cling to every surface, catching the gleam of the flickering lanterns. The soundtrack shifts from jaunty jazz to a mournful, almost guttural moan, making the hair on the back of Spencer’s neck stand up. A costumed figure, dressed as a weeping ghost, glides silently through the car, its spectral form barely discernible in the pulsating red and green lights.
The occasional loud bang or piercing shriek from the sound system makes everyone jump, a shared nervous energy rippling through the group. The air grows heavy, thick with anticipation and something far more sinister.
Hours melt into a disorienting blend of laughter, screams, and the constant, unsettling rhythm of the train. The initial novelty of the costumes and the party atmosphere begins to wane, replaced by a dull throb of unease that settles in Spencer’s stomach. She glances around, her gaze scanning the car, trying to pinpoint each of her friends. Hanna is chatting with Lucas, their playful banter a steady background noise. Emily and Paige are huddled together, whispering, their expressions more serious now. But where is Aria?
Spencer's brow furrows. She distinctly remembers Aria being next to Ezra just a few minutes ago, but now the seat is empty. A chill, sharper than the air conditioning, snakes up her spine.
"Hey, Han," Spencer calls out, her voice cutting through the remaining chatter. "Have you seen Aria?"
Hanna turns, her Marilyn smile faltering. She scans the car, too, her eyes widening slightly. "No, I thought she was with Ezra," she says, her voice laced with concern. Lucas, sensing the shift in mood, removes his Phantom mask, his usually jovial expression now serious.
"She was," Ezra confirms, looking up from his notebook, a frown creasing his brow. "She just stepped away for a minute. Said she needed some air." He gestures vaguely towards the back of the car.
But Spencer's gut screams otherwise. "How long ago was that?" she presses, her voice tight with a growing sense of dread.
Ezra shrugs, looking uncertain. "Fifteen, maybe twenty minutes? I got engrossed in something."
Twenty minutes. That's too long. A prickle of fear, cold and sharp, begins to spread through Spencer. She and Hanna exchange a look, a silent agreement passing between them. This isn't just Aria wandering off. This feels different.
They begin to search, their eyes darting frantically from face to face, from shadowy corner to shadowy corner. The festive decorations suddenly seem less charming, more like obstacles in their desperate hunt. The garish lights make it harder to see, creating deceptive illusions. They check the restrooms, the small, cramped spaces where the music is muffled and the air feels claustrophobic. They push through other costumed party-goers, murmuring apologies, their pleas for information met with blank stares or shrugs. The unsettling realization that Aria is truly gone settles like a lead weight in Spencer's chest.
They return to the area where Aria and Ezra were sitting. The seat is still empty, a silent testament to her absence. Then, Spencer sees it. On the chair, where Aria’s Daisy Buchanan purse had been, it still is. Her heart leaps with a momentary surge of relief, then plummets as she notices the window. The condensation is still there, but the "Aria" that Aria had traced earlier is almost completely wiped away. All that remains is a single, stark, chilling "A." The cursive flourish that had once formed the rest of her name is gone, erased with a deliberate, malicious stroke.
Hanna’s gasp is sharp, a small, choked sound. "Oh my god," she whispers, her eyes wide with terror. The initial concern has morphed into raw, primal fear.
Just then, a faint chime emanates from Aria’s purse. It’s her phone. Spencer’s hand trembles as she reaches into the purse, her fingers fumbling around the soft lining before finding the device. The screen illuminates, casting an eerie glow on her face. It’s a text message. From an unknown number.
Spencer and Hanna lean in, their heads close together, eyes glued to the screen. The words, simple yet utterly devastating, flash before them: "Guess who won't be making it to the end of the line? - A"
The air is sucked out of the car. The music, the chatter, the clack of the train – it all fades into a distant hum. Only the words, burning on the screen, remain. The terrifying realization hits them with the force of a physical blow. "A" isn't just playing games anymore. "A" has taken Aria.
The confinement is absolute. Aria is in a crate, the rough wood pressing against her back and sides. The air inside is stale and thick, smelling of dust and something metallic, like old tools. The darkness is suffocating, a heavy blanket that presses down on her, stealing her breath. Her mouth is covered by a wide strip of thick duct tape, the adhesive pulling uncomfortably at her skin. Another strip binds her wrists together, crisscrossing tightly, making even the slightest movement an agony.
The rough texture of the tape against her skin is an irritating constant. She can hear the distant, muffled sounds of the train – the rhythmic clack-clack of the wheels, the occasional squeal of brakes, the faint thrum of the engine. She’s somewhere on the train, but where? And how did she get here?
The last thing she remembers is standing by the window, the cool glass against her cheek, watching the blurry lights of the landscape. She had felt a hand on her shoulder, a gentle pressure, and had turned, expecting to see Ezra. Instead, a gloved hand had clamped over her mouth, a sharp, cloying scent filling her nostrils. Then, blackness. Now, she’s here, trapped and helpless, her heart a frantic drum against her ribs. The Daisy Buchanan dress, once so elegant, is now crumpled and restrictive, making her feel even more like a butterfly caught in a net.
Back in the main car, the panic has escalated into full-blown terror. Emily arrives, breathless, her Barbarella costume a stark contrast to her pale, haunted face. "I can't find Aria anywhere!" she gasps, her eyes wide and panicked. "I've checked everywhere, even the other cars!"
Spencer’s voice is hoarse, strained. "We know, Em. We just got a text."
She holds out Aria's phone, the chilling message still glowing on the screen. Emily reads it, her face draining of color, her hand flying to her mouth. A small, choked sob escapes her.
"No," Emily whispers, shaking her head in disbelief. "No, this can't be happening. Not again."
Hanna, tears stinging her eyes, wraps an arm around Emily, offering what little comfort she can. "We have to find her," Hanna insists, her voice trembling but resolute. "We have to tell someone."
"Who?" Spencer retorts, a bitter edge to her voice. "The conductor? 'Excuse me, but our friend was just abducted by an anonymous text message sender on your creepy Halloween train?' They’d think we’re insane." Spencer’s mind is racing, trying to piece together the fragments of this horrifying puzzle. The "A" on the window. The text. Aria’s sudden disappearance. It all points to one undeniable truth.
Then, a memory, sharp and unwelcome, slices through the fog of panic. Garrett. His words, whispered to her during one of their fraught encounters, echo in her mind with terrifying clarity. Garrett said he saw Aria’s dad threatening Alison on that night years ago when Alison was killed. The image of Byron Montgomery, dark and menacing, looms in Spencer’s mind. Could this be connected? Is "A" punishing Aria for her father's past? The thought is chilling, sending another wave of nausea through her.
"Garrett told me something," Spencer says, her voice barely a whisper, drawing the attention of Hanna and Emily. "He said he saw Byron – Aria's dad – threatening Alison the night she died." The revelation hangs in the air, a dark cloud settling over them.
Hanna’s eyes widen. "What? Byron? No way. Aria would never..."
"He said he saw it," Spencer interrupts, her voice gaining strength. "He swore it. He said Byron was furious, shouting at Alison about something. He even mentioned her running off after the confrontation."
The pieces, though fragmented and disturbing, begin to click into place, forming a picture of a far more complex and terrifying game.
Meanwhile, in the darkness of the crate, Aria struggles. The tape is excruciatingly tight, the wood rough against her skin. Every breath is a shallow gasp. She pushes against the sides of the crate with her bound hands, the wood splintering slightly under her desperate attempts. The air is growing thinner, her panic rising with each passing second. She can’t scream, can’t call for help. The silence, broken only by the rhythmic clatter of the train, is deafening.
Her mind races, a chaotic swirl of fear and desperate hope. She remembers the faint, sweet scent of something unfamiliar before the blackness, a scent that now seems to cling to the inside of the crate. A floral, almost sickly sweet aroma, not like any perfume she knows. She tries to leverage her body, twisting and turning, her muscles screaming in protest. The crate is narrow, barely big enough for her to lie flat. She remembers being small, being given a toy pony that was too big for her to carry, and the frustrating helplessness of not being able to move it. This feeling is exponentially worse.
With a surge of adrenaline, fueled by terror and the desperate need to escape, Aria pushes with all her might against the top of the crate. It shifts. A sliver of hope, sharp and exhilarating, shoots through her. She pushes again, straining every muscle in her body, her teeth gritted against the tape on her mouth. The crate creaks, groans under the pressure.
Then, with a lurch that sends her tumbling, the crate tips over. It lands with a dull thud, rocking violently before settling on its side. Aria is now wedged against one of the walls, a sliver of light filtering in from what must be a small crack. The change in position offers a fleeting moment of relief, a precious few inches of space to maneuver. The fall has disoriented her, but the new angle provides a fresh burst of determination. She can feel the cold metal of something against her cheek: perhaps a hinge, or a stray nail. The small victory, however brief, ignites a desperate hope within her. She's not entirely helpless.
The frantic search for Aria continues, the Liars’ initial fear morphing into a cold, hard resolve. Spencer, Hanna, and Emily move through the train like a finely tuned, desperate unit, their costumes now utterly meaningless. The festive atmosphere around them feels like a cruel mockery. Caleb, Toby, and Ezra are alerted to the crisis as they join the search, their faces etched with a shared grim determination.
Hanna, her heart pounding a frantic rhythm against her ribs, pushes open the door to a less crowded car. The lights here are even dimmer, casting long, distorted shadows that dance with the train’s movement. A faint, cloying scent of cheap cologne and something vaguely metallic hangs in the air. Her eyes scan the shadowy figures, her gaze fixed on a figure in the corner, shrouded in the Phantom of the Opera costume. The flowing cape, the distinctive mask; it has to be Caleb.
"Caleb!" she whispers, her voice a desperate plea. She hurries towards him, relief flooding her. "Something's going on! It's Aria! She's gone, and 'A' just texted us!" She reaches out, grabbing his arm, her fingers clutching the thick fabric of his costume. The figure turns, the mask unreadable in the dim light.
But then, Hanna’s blood runs cold. From the opposite end of the car, a familiar voice calls out, "Han? You okay?"
Hanna whirls around, her eyes widening in disbelief and a fresh wave of terror. There, at the other end of the car, stands the real Caleb, his Phantom mask in his hand, his brow furrowed with concern. The figure she’s holding onto isn’t Caleb. A gasp tears from Hanna’s throat. Her grip on the imposter’s arm tightens, her knuckles turning white. This isn't Caleb. This is someone else. Someone is wearing Caleb's costume. Someone who knew they would be looking for him.
The realization hits her with the force of a physical blow. This is "A."
Without thinking, driven by a surge of pure adrenaline and a primal fury, Hanna rips at the impostor’s mask. Her fingers scrabble at the delicate ties, the cheap elastic, desperate to reveal the face beneath. The Phantom mask comes away easily, tearing with a soft rip. But instead of a face, Hanna is met with another mask. A grotesque, smiling mask, crafted to mimic Alison’s face. Her perfectly sculpted features are frozen in a chilling, vacant grin. And beneath the mask, spilling out in tangled waves, is a blonde wig, a perfect replica of Alison’s iconic hair.
The horror is absolute, a cold, suffocating blanket. Hanna recoils, a strangled scream caught in her throat. The figure stands perfectly still, the Alison mask a silent, terrifying taunt. The air crackles with an electric sense of malice. This isn’t just a game anymore. This is personal. And "A" is closer than they ever could have imagined.