Work Text:
The rain did not merely begin; it descended with absolute authority, as though the sky had debated with itself at length before releasing its contents all at once. Water struck the long panes of glass in the foyer like driven silk, forming and reforming in luminous sheets. The lamps lowered out of habit, cast small golden halos that appeared to hover rather than illuminate, revealing dust motes and the subtle tremor of the crystal chandelier as thunder reverberated through the house's structure.
Nick Carraway stood at the door with the distinctive Midwestern resolve that had long amused and unsettled New Yorkers equally. His hat rested beside the umbrella stand, his coat was draped across one forearm, and his black, unadorned, practical umbrella was held in his right hand. He was attired for the day’s professional demands: a crisp collar, a modest tie, and a jacket he had brushed that morning until the wool lay smooth beneath his palm. The storm did not alter his intentions; it rendered the day louder.
Behind him, midway up the grand staircase, Gatsby leaned against the banister casually, only because it was artfully constructed. One hand rested on polished mahogany, and the other held a glass that had been poured and then neglected. His tuxedo coat was absent; he wore shirtsleeves, cufflinks, and an air of impatience, as though it were an invisible monocle. Though no one else might have perceived it, Nick felt its focus directed toward him.
“You are not stepping out in this weather, old sport,” Gatsby observed. His voice was mild and elegant, with its warning interwoven so subtly that it became evident only upon reflection.
Nick did not immediately respond. He tightened his grip on the umbrella handle, peered through the beveled glass set into the door, and watched a branch lash itself against the gateposts. “I shall be fine, Jay. The train operates in rain, snow, and tempests of every kind.”
“This is not simply rain,” Gatsby countered. He descended three steps, the crystal chandelier above ringing faintly under the shift of weight. “It is a deluge, the storm that surpasses headlines.”
“I shall dry,” Nick replied.
“And in drying you may catch your death,” Gatsby returned, accompanied by the faintest trace of laughter that lacked amusement. “Such an outcome would be inconvenient to me personally.”
Nick forced a smile directed only at the doorknob. “People go to work in the rain every day, Jay. You know this.”
“People,” Gatsby repeated, testing the word for its adequacy. “But you are not merely ‘people’ to me.”
That remark drew a glance over Nick’s shoulder. Gatsby’s tie was absent, his throat exposed above the immaculate white of his collar, which lent him a disarming youthfulness in the lamplight. He seemed less composed of rumor and more of a tangible presence. Yet his eyes—an unfathomable and brilliant blue, so striking that one instinctively stepped aside to avoid their full force—remained fixed with the determination of a man who had granted fate an appointment and expected it to arrive.
“Jay,” Nick said, his voice tinged with exasperation and affection. “The storm will pass. The office, however, will not. If I do not leave now, I shall be late.”
Gatsby reached the bottom step and leaned casually against the newel post, turning his neglected glass in his hand. “Permit them to wait in your honor. Allow the weather, for once, to compose your excuse.”
“Do you imagine my employer will perceive poetry in that?” Nick asked while retrieving his hat. “He does not read for pleasure.”
“A tragic deficiency,” Gatsby replied, pausing. “Even a man constitutionally opposed to literature must concede the power of natural forces.”
“Then he will recall that trains exist to overcome those forces,” Nick answered with crisp finality, his practiced smile withdrawn. “You are making this unnecessarily dramatic.”
“Dramatic effect is my specialty,” Gatsby remarked lightly, though his levity faltered before completing its orbit. “You will be drenched within a single block.”
“Then I shall turn back,” Nick responded. “If the storm is as severe as you claim, I shall recognize it myself. I am not entirely a fool.”
A private conflict flickered in Gatsby’s expression, his mouth tilting in an unresolved debate. “You have admirable faith in the rational behavior of the world.”
“And you have none,” Nick returned, disengaging the latch. “Together we form a balanced path.”
“That calculation does not please me, old sport.”
“Few things please you unless you have arranged them,” Nick countered.
“That is where you are mistaken.” Gatsby’s eyes moved deliberately to Nick’s hands—one on the latch, the other on the umbrella—before rising again, steady and intent. “Some things please me precisely because I have not arranged them.”
Nick hesitated, his pulse jolting at once—at nothing and everything: at the rain pressing against the house as though the sky sought to become geography, and at Gatsby’s gaze sharpening with an intensity that was not anger but something both stranger and more tender. He recognized the danger of that moment, when Gatsby’s charm stripped away to reveal the steel that had constructed it, no longer threatening but promising.
“I shall telephone when I reach the station,” Nick said quietly. “And again when I arrive.”
“I do not want your voice transmitted through an instrument,” Gatsby replied. “Not when the storm itself makes a cathedral of the world. I want you here.”
Nick finally turned fully, the umbrella still held in his palm and his hat crooked beneath his arm. The neat geometry of his morning had been unsettled by the heat rising to his face. “Jay.”
Gatsby set the glass upon the marble console with the air of one who had been holding it for another. “It will be an hour at most, two perhaps. We shall sit by the fire. I shall read something dreadful, and you will correct it. Together we shall listen to the storm refine its own argument.”
“That is a charming sentiment,” Nick replied, though it was embarrassingly persuasive. “But I truly must—”
He reached for the knob.
The smirk left Gatsby’s face with the quiet decisiveness of a closing door. He crossed the space between them without theatricality, but with precision—the kind that does not announce itself because it requires no announcement. One moment, Nick felt the cool metal beneath his fingers; the next, he felt Gatsby beside him, hands warm and certain at his waist, moving lower with a confidence that signaled not arrogance but certainty.
“Jay—!” Nick’s protest fractured as Gatsby lifted him, his umbrella clattering to the tiled floor with the resonance of a struck note.
The wall accepted his weight with a muted thud; a framed landscape rattled above his head. Nick’s breath escaped him, then returned too quickly, bringing a white intensity at the edges of his vision. His hands clutched Gatsby instinctively, locating familiar shoulders—shoulders learned over a summer of silences, crowded rooms, and the gradual recognition that some things remain trustworthy even when one cannot trust oneself.
“Put me down,” Nick exclaimed, color rising so suddenly in his face that he felt absurdly young. “Good God, Jay—this is—this is unreasonable—”
“No.” Gatsby’s voice did not rise; it dropped instead, low and deliberate, the tone that carried promises beneath it. He pressed closer—not to crush or to confine, but with a deliberation that required no permission, for it had already been granted in quieter rooms and clockless nights.
“Jay.” Nick swallowed, his hands finding the back of Gatsby’s neck, fingers spread in what seemed to him a treacherous gesture. The warmth there made him dizzier than the sudden lifting. “Jay, put me—”
“If you believe I will allow you to walk into that storm and leave me in this echoing house while the sky rends itself to tatters—then you do not know me at all.” Gatsby’s mouth was only inches away; Nick could feel the words as much as hear them.
Nick’s reply dissolved before it reached articulation. Thunder rolled slowly beyond the windows, satisfied with its own volume. Somewhere in the grounds, a fountain overflowed, its misuse amplifying its sound. The house seemed to lean into the storm; Gatsby leaned into Nick. The line between them, usually maintained by timetables, commuter maps, and the careful rituals of daily life, blurred—not through impulse, but through clarity. Gatsby would never stand idly by while Nick entered danger, and Nick could not pretend to be ignorant.
“Stay,” Gatsby said, the word more confession than command. “Stay with me. For this morning only. Stay.”
Nick felt the ache of truth strike squarely in his chest. The umbrella lay at their feet like an argument already abandoned. He could fabricate a dozen new objections, neat and responsible, but the storm had loosened something that rendered even responsibility slightly foolish.
“Jay,” he said, his voice softened by a gentleness he wished to suppress. “I have to—”
Gatsby kissed him.
It was not the graceful formality with which he greeted guests or bid them farewell. It was immediate, warm, and imperfect with urgency, as though intent on securing something already present. Nick gasped, the sound caught between surrender and laughter; Gatsby followed the sound with his mouth until resistance slipped from Nick’s hands. Those same hands, almost against his will, curved around Gatsby’s shoulders, his legs tightening to hold on.
The world narrowed, not harshly but beautifully, as though a lens had shifted. Gatsby’s breath, faintly citrus on his skin, and the familiar disobedience of his hair beneath Nick’s fingers became the only focus. Outside, the rain raged with jealous intensity; beneath Nick’s palm, Gatsby’s pulse was rapid and steady, synchronizing with something within Nick that had long resisted measurement and was now content to remain unmeasured.
When Nick finally pulled away for breath, the sound was more laughter than air. “You are insufferable,” he managed, his face flushing further because of the unmistakable fondness in his tone.
Gatsby smiled with merciless tenderness. “Insufferably devoted.” He shifted his hold, testing its security. “And you are staying.”
“That is—” Nick began, intending to say “impossible” or “unreasonable,” or one of the soft polysyllabic words that had long been his refuge. Instead, the sentence broke into something less specific. “—That is unwise.”
Gatsby touched his forehead briefly to Nick’s, closing his eyes as though to share the silence. “Then let us be unwise together for an hour.”
“You will destroy my dignity,” Nick said, shivering when Gatsby’s hands adjusted minutely, not to press but to cradle.
“I will preserve it from standing in the rain,” Gatsby replied. He stepped back from the wall without further ceremony, still carrying Nick securely in his arms.
“Jay,” Nick hissed, his face now burning with embarrassment as they crossed the cavernous foyer, the storm rising and falling outside like applause. “Put me down. I can walk. For heaven’s sake, I am not a parcel.”
“You are the only parcel I have ever valued,” Gatsby returned with a sideways grin. “And I have no intention of seeing you abandoned on a doorstep.”
“Do you intend to carry me all the way to West Egg?” Nick demanded, tightening his grip—though the gesture betrayed him—when Gatsby adjusted his hold. “You will ruin your back, and I shall never hear the end of it.”
“If I drop you,” Gatsby said with cheerful menace, “it will only be onto the pillows.”
“Jay.”
“Nick.”
They traversed the vast expanse of marble and carpet, their footsteps echoing in the high space, while the chandelier above chimed faintly in rhythm with the thunder outside. An abandoned maid’s cart stood near the archway, indicating that the storm had unsettled the household’s routine. They passed the music room, where the piano sat open as though about to speak, and a bank of windows through which the gardens dissolved into watercolor. Finally, they reached the corridor leading to the private rooms.
Mortified by his mortification, Nick briefly hid his face against Gatsby’s shoulder. “Put me down. Please. This is precisely how rumors become operas.”
“Operas have never deterred me,” Gatsby said, turning a corner. “I have always believed them to be rumors that dared to sing.”
“Ridiculous man.”
“Admitted,” Gatsby replied, so pleased with the word that Nick was tempted to kiss him to equalize the exchange.
The door to their room opened without resistance. The lamps were already glowing; their habit of leaving a light prepared for evening made the space appear expectant, as though awaiting its occupants. The wind found a seam in the window frame and produced a thin, reedy music. The bed, wide to the point of impracticality, retained the faint impression of the previous night’s rest.
Gatsby paused at the threshold, reluctant to push the moment forward. Sensing the hesitation, Nick softened. “Well?” he asked, intending crispness but producing velvet instead.
Gatsby’s eyes brightened. “Well,” he echoed. He crossed to the bed in deliberate strides that seemed to reduce the size of the house itself. He set Nick down with care, lowering him as one places something valuable that must not bruise. With a soft sigh, the mattress received Nick’s weight; the duvet rose around him like a tide.
“Jay,” Nick warned, aware he had already lost the contest and embarrassed to realize that he did not object to the loss as much as he pretended.
“Yes, old sport?” Gatsby’s tone is innocent and deceives no one, not even Nick.
“If you imagine I shall permit this to become an excuse to remain abed all day—”
“I would never require an excuse,” Gatsby answered smoothly. “I would require only you.”
Gatsby approached the bed and set his hands at Nick’s waist with deliberate gentleness, as though the day itself were a gift wrapped too tightly and intended to undo it properly. He began from the top, loosening the knot of Nick’s tie with a restraint that seemed practiced long before it became tender. He did not tug; he coaxed, sliding the silk free and holding it briefly in his hand before laying it aside with reverence that made Nick’s chest constrict with unexpected heat.
“Jay,” Nick murmured, his voice softened by the storm’s sudden pause. The house seemed to draw a breath with him. “I have—”
“An admirable sense of responsibility,” Gatsby interjected, brushing his thumb lightly against the hollow of Nick’s throat where the collar parted. “Which I cherish and will not permit to be drowned by a flood.”
He opened each button carefully, giving each release its own quiet moment. With every gesture, he confirmed rather than claimed. Nick let his head fall back against the pillows, his fingers gripping Gatsby’s shoulder in a silent plea for balance, while his heartbeat struggled not to alter the room's rhythm.
“You make me ridiculous,” Nick muttered, though his tone betrayed more relief than irritation.
“You make me honest,” Gatsby replied. The words cut through Nick’s resistance like warmth through frost, not wounding but relieving pressure.
The coat went first, then the jacket, Gatsby’s hands sliding beneath him just enough to free the fabric and drape it carefully across the chair where Nick habitually placed it himself. Gatsby handled each garment as though it bore significance, his movements suggesting devotion in their precision. He kissed the ridge of Nick’s collarbone as though signing an invisible document.
“Tell me if you are cold,” Gatsby said, though the room seemed indecently warm. “Tell me if you wish me to stop.”
Nick laughed softly, his breath catching. “You are the one who forbade me from leaving the house in the first place. It would be hypocritical to ask for distance now.”
“I have never claimed not to be a hypocrite,” Gatsby replied with quiet amusement. “But I intend to be heroic until the second cup of coffee.”
“You could be heroic by lighting the fire,” Nick said, fighting back a smile that threatened to overtake his composure. “I refuse to be undressed in a room where the hearth remains idle.”
Gatsby’s answering grin was unexpectedly boyish. “A reasonable request. Stay exactly where you are.” Before crossing quickly to the hearth, he pressed a swift kiss just below Nick’s ear, as if bribing the moment.
The small domestic luxury of a laid fire awaited him. Gatsby struck a match and for a breath his face was all shadow and line, illuminated by the stubborn hope that had made men lean toward him for years without knowing why. The flame caught slowly, then built itself into a steady blaze. Rising before it, Gatsby appeared quietly satisfied—not with orchestras or parties, but with the modest triumph of warmth secured from tinder.
“Better?” he asked, turning back. The fire lit his profile, making him appear larger and softer.
“Yes,” Nick said, the word leaving him before he could restrain it. “Stay there a moment.”
Gatsby stilled, and Nick studied him in the glow, the outline of a man made not of legend but of care. The realization undid him more than the earlier intensity had this, more than the dramatic strength at the door or the unexpected carrying through the corridors, dissolved his argument entirely. He had intended to leave, had dressed in his armor of competence, ready to offer the city his hours. And yet.
“Come back,” Nick said gently, his voice as soft as if calling a loyal animal that had never needed restraint. Gatsby returned at once.
The final buttons came undone, and the shirt eased away. Still warm from the fire, Gatsby's palm settled against Nick’s side, not to guide him anywhere but to anchor him. It was not a directive; it was an invitation to remain.
“This is foolish,” Nick whispered, though his tone carried reverence more than resistance.
“Then we are fools together,” Gatsby replied. “I warned you what I was.”
“You warned me of nothing useful,” Nick answered, his eyes shutting as Gatsby’s mouth traced new territory with careful attention. “You arrived in my life like a headline too compelling to ignore.”
“And I intend to make the front page daily,” Gatsby murmured against his skin, his humor quiet but insistent.
“You menace,” Nick breathed.
“Yours,” Gatsby said, and the word, once spoken, seemed to belong to the room itself. The fire received it and made it warmer.
They remained in that soft geometry—Nick half-undone on the bed, Gatsby leaned above him, both close enough to hear the shifting register of the rain, for long enough that the hour blurred. Outside, the storm argued itself hoarse, then resumed, as though unable to remember its own conclusions. Inside, Gatsby’s hands traced a new map, marked not by conquest but affection. Nick, who had never been conquered except by choice and in silence, allowed it.
Eventually, consistent with his habit of rescuing them from Gatsby’s most extravagant impulses, Nick tugged lightly at the front of Gatsby’s shirt. “Your turn,” he said.
Gatsby’s eyes flashed with mischief and relief, as though undressing himself without invitation had seemed too forward. “At your service,” he murmured, permitting Nick to sit up and slide the buttons open, smooth the fabric aside, feel his warmth, and think recklessly that perhaps the storm had done him a favor.
“Jay?” After several quiet moments, Nick asked when touch rather than language had defined their conversation.
“Yes?”
“I am staying.”
Gatsby stilled, like a conductor had paused a symphony with mercy rather than command. “Yes?” he asked, his voice scarcely above a breath.
“Only until the storm—” Nick began, but the falsehood collapsed before it could take shape.
Gatsby’s smile was unbearable in its softness. “Only until forever,” he corrected, his tone teasing but his meaning anything but. “At least until the coffee.”
“At least until the coffee,” Nick conceded, rolling his eyes to mask how his chest had brightened into something unbearably simple.
Gatsby kissed him in gratitude and in apology for having staged the contest in the first place. When he drew back, his hand came up instinctively to smooth Nick’s hair, a habit formed in such moments when storms of kisses disordered it. For once, he looked like a man whose designs had been overtaken by happiness rather than ambition.
“Tell me the train schedule,” Gatsby whispered, “so I may ignore it with sophistication.”
Nick laughed despite himself. “You are impossible.”
“You repeat that constantly,” Gatsby replied, delighted. “And yet here we are. It seems impossibility is simply the wrong word for us.”
“Then what is the right word?” Nick asked, because he could not resist and knew Gatsby favored truth most when it appeared unadorned.
“Home,” Gatsby said so quietly that the fire leaned closer to hear it.
Nick’s breath caught. The storm softened at the windows as though in courtesy. He reached upward until their foreheads touched, and the laugh building in both escaped at last, unburdening the room.
“All right,” Nick whispered. “You win.”
Gatsby’s eyes brightened. “For now.”
“For now,” Nick agreed, because storms end, trains run, and obligations reassert themselves. But there are mornings when a house fills itself with warmth, when one man lays another down as though the world contained only safe landings, and to argue against such mornings is not duty—it is an error.
Gatsby kissed him again, less fierce now and more grateful, then reached for the blanket at the foot of the bed. He drew it over them with deliberate care as if completing a ceremony. “I will make the coffee,” he said softly against Nick’s temple. “You remain here.”
“I might be persuaded,” Nick murmured, tugging lightly at his wrist. “But it would be selfish to let you go when you have argued convincingly for my staying.”
Gatsby laughed into his skin, the sound carrying the warmth of the fire itself. “Very well,” he replied. “We shall be selfish together.”
“An hour,” Nick said, reassuring himself with the comfort of limits. “Two at the most.”
“Three,” Gatsby countered immediately, transforming the negotiation into something almost celebratory.
Nick sighed with exaggerated defeat, though his eyes betrayed delight. “You are bargaining with the weather.”
“Then I cannot lose,” Gatsby answered, settling beside him while the fire worked slowly against winter’s residue and the storm rehearsed yet another of its endless arguments. “For once, the world agrees with me.”
Nick turned toward him and realized that, despite the day having barely begun, it had already reached its finest hour. He could still imagine the trains running on their schedules and feel the crisp fabric of the jacket he had brushed into order that morning. He had not become a different man by refusing to step outside. He had only decided, for a time, that the wisest act was to accept warmth when offered.
“Go on, then,” he whispered, closing his eyes as Gatsby’s fingers traced him, confirming what had always been true. “Be impossible.”
Gatsby’s answering kiss was steady and sure, perfectly at home, and the storm outside sounded, if only briefly, like applause.