Work Text:
The gym was feverish— a cage of sound and heat. Bodies moved with a kind of desperate precision; sneakers struck the floor like gunfire, voices rose in a single, trembling pitch. I could feel my pulse in my throat. The ball spun in the air, bright and merciless.
Cleo’s toss arced high— perfect, deliberate. I leapt. My hand met the ball with all the strength I could summon, the sound of the spike cutting through the noise like a verdict. The crowd roared. Victory. Ecstasy. All of it felt… foreign.
Applause surrounded me, but none of it reached the place where feeling once lived. My teammates crowded in, their joy spilling over me like water over stone. I smiled, because that was what was expected— because the body obeys long after the heart has forgotten how.
And then I saw her.
Pearl.
Blue eyes gleaming under the white lights— soft, trembling, alive. Even now, they looked at me the way the ocean might look at a drowning thing; curious, distant, unbothered. I could read no cruelty there, only the cruel indifference of beauty itself.
Beside her stood Cleo. My friend, my mirror, my Judas. She leaned in, said something that made Pearl laugh— that low, ringing sound that once belonged to me. Their laughter rose above the crowd, a melody I could not join.
It’s strange how swiftly joy curdles into grief. Someone called my name. A voice clear and trembling.
‘Gem! That was perfect!’
Etho.
He stood near the bleachers, his hands still raised, his smile unguarded— a quiet, faithful light in a room full of noise. For a moment, I almost looked back. Almost. But my gaze slipped past him, back to the blue that had already condemned me.
Etho’s voice faded into the applause, unnoticed, unreturned. He kept smiling— as if belief alone could bridge the distance between us.
The whistle blew again, long and sharp. The crowd dissolved into motion. I should have felt something— pride, relief, the dull ache of triumph. Instead, I felt only the echo of my own heartbeat, steady and hollow, like the ticking of a clock counting down to nothing.
Pearl turned toward Cleo, her hand brushing against hers— a gesture so gentle it could kill. I looked at them and understood; love, when unreturned, becomes devotion’s cruel parody.
And still, I smiled. Because even in humiliation, one must keep playing the part.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
The match pressed on. The scoreboard flickered, cruelly indifferent, its red digits bleeding into the noise. Every serve, every cheer, every breath— all of it collapsed into a single, unbearable rhythm. I moved without thought now, driven by something mechanical, something hollow.
Cleo’s voice rang out — sharp, commanding.
‘Left side! Gem, go!’
I obeyed. My legs hit the floor; my body rose. The ball came spinning toward me, white and flawless. For an instant, the world stilled— the hum of the crowd, the glare of the lights, the dull ache in my chest— all swallowed by that suspended second before impact.
Then I struck.
A clean spike. Perfect.
The kind of perfection that means nothing.
Applause followed, rising and falling like a tide I could no longer feel. My teammates shouted my name, their faces bright with something I couldn’t share.
I looked to the sidelines. Pearl stood there— her posture soft, her expression unreadable. Those blue eyes were fixed on the court, but not on me. They searched for Cleo. I saw it in the tilt of her head, in the way her lips parted when Cleo served, in the quiet anticipation that belonged to someone watching the person they love. It is remarkable, isn’t it, how the heart recognizes its own replacement long before the mind does.
Etho’s voice broke through the noise again— earnest, clumsy.
‘You’ve got this, Gem!’
He was standing just beyond the bench, the hem of his jacket tugged by the wind from the open doors. His eyes held something I once thought impossible— unselfish warmth. He was there for me, and yet, I did not have the mercy to look back.
Because all my attention was fixed on her— the girl with the blue eyes, who smiled only when Cleo spoke.
The rally began again. My arms ached. Sweat slipped into my eyes. The court became a battlefield of blurred figures and echoing voices. Cleo set; I spiked. Again and again. Each hit perfect, precise— each one emptier than the last.
When we scored, Cleo turned, grinning. I should have felt proud. Instead, I followed the path of her gaze as it landed— not on me, but on Pearl. Their eyes met, and Pearl’s hands came together in applause meant for her.
That was when I knew— victory could wound deeper than loss.
Etho’s cheer faltered, drowned beneath the roar of others. I think he kept watching, though. He always did. Watching me fight, excel, unravel— all in the same breath.
I wonder if he ever realized that I wasn’t playing to win anymore.
I was playing to be seen.
And the one I played for had already looked away.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
In my eyes, I see hers— that cyan light, trembling like something alive. Pearl. Even her name feels like a mercy I was never meant to touch. There was a time she’d sit beside me after practice, her laughter soft, her hands warm from the game. I thought that warmth was mine. How foolish.
Now she stands beside Cleo. My friend. My reflection, even. The setter to my spiker, the one who used to call my name with pride. Cleo, who knew my every weakness— and used it. She didn’t take Pearl for cruelty. No, she took her because she could. Because love, when left unspoken, becomes a gift the world gives to someone else.
People say high school heartbreaks are small. Childish. But tell me, what could be more tragic than loving for the first time— and realizing that love is not holy, but humiliating?
They call me perfect. ‘Gem’s great.’ ‘Gem’s brilliant.’ I wear the compliments like armor, but every word feels like a confession I didn’t mean to make. Because beneath all that— beneath the trophies, the clean grades, the fake smiles— there’s only this; a girl who keeps mistaking admiration for affection.
And still, I would forgive them both. That’s the part that disgusts me the most.
If they asked, I would step aside, let them have their happiness, even hand it to them like an offering. Because the heart, once it loves, no longer serves reason. It only kneels.
Sometimes I wonder if this is what it means to be human— to crave what destroys us, to return to the fire even after being burned. I watch them together, and I feel both hatred and gratitude. Hatred, because they remind me that I was never enough. Gratitude, because at least I once believed I could be.
When practice ends, I stay behind. The court is empty now. The air still smells like sweat and varnish, the sound of laughter fading down the hall. I pick up the volleyball, trace its worn seams, and I think— this, too, is love. A thing that hurts when it’s gone, but still asks to be held.
I tell myself I’m fine. That I’ve grown above it. But that’s the lie we all tell, isn’t it? That heartbreak is just a phase, when in truth, it’s a mirror. It shows us everything we are too afraid to see.
And maybe that’s why I can’t stop loving her. Because somewhere in that unbearable ache, I still feel alive.
The gym is almost silent now. Only the hum of the lights remains, a low, nervous sound that fills the space between my thoughts. I sit on the bleachers, still in uniform, still pretending the ache in my chest is just muscle fatigue. Then the door opens. Pearl’s voice enters first — soft, hesitant. Cleo follows, her laughter echoing off the walls like the bounce of a ball that won’t die. I don’t move. I just watch.
Pearl’s carrying Cleo’s jacket. Cleo reaches for it, their fingers brushing, and in that tiny motion, I see everything I’ve lost. It’s not dramatic, not cinematic — just two people existing easily in each other’s orbit. And it’s unbearable. They don’t notice me at first. Maybe they wouldn’t have noticed at all if Cleo hadn’t said my name.
‘Gem. You’re still here.'
Her tone is casual, like we didn’t share a decade of friendship, like she didn’t steal the only person who ever made my heart feel real.
’Yeah,’ I say, and my voice sounds strange, foreign, as though it belongs to someone else.
'Just cooling down.'
Pearl gives a small smile — polite, distant. The kind you give to strangers. She looks tired, her hair tied up in that messy bun I used to tease her about. I used to think I had the right to notice small things like that. Cleo wraps an arm around her shoulders, light, protective. The gesture is so gentle it could kill me. I want to ask her if she’s happy. I want to ask if she ever thinks of me when the gym lights fade and the air smells like dust and sweat. But I don’t. Because I already know the answer. So instead, I force a smile — the same practiced one I use when reporters shove microphones in my face.
‘Good game earlier.’
‘Thanks,’ Cleo says. She looks at me the way people look at old photographs — fond, but already detached.
‘You played amazing, by the way.’
Pearl nods, murmurs something about getting dinner, and they start walking away. Something inside me stirs, sharp and quiet. Maybe it’s pride, or maybe it’s the last gasp of a dying love.
‘Hey, Pearl,’ I call out.
She turns, and for a second, I think I see it — the ghost of the girl who used to stay after practice just to talk. But it’s gone as quickly as it comes.
‘Take care,’ I say. That’s all. Two useless words.
She smiles again, that same kind, unreachable smile, and then she’s gone.
The door closes, and the silence rushes back in. I stay there for a long time, staring at the place where she stood. The air feels heavier now, thick with everything I didn’t say. And yet, I don’t cry. I just sit there, hollow and awake, realizing that this — this quiet undoing — is what love becomes when it’s no longer returned. It doesn’t explode. It decays. And still, even as the lights flicker and the world moves on, I can’t help but think:If she turned around — just once more — I would forgive her.
Every time, I would forgive her.