Actions

Work Header

To Love Without Witness

Notes:

CW:
Emotional vulnerability
Low self-esteem

Work Text:

Compassionate, amiable, and gentle—such are the words they use to define her, yet they are but fragile shadows of what she truly is. To me, she embodies a quiet strength that has no need for proclamation. She listens when others clamor to be heard; she forgives when forgiveness is undeserved. Her grace is not of this world—it is the kind that bleeds silently, and still chooses to smile.

 

There exists an infinitude of words that might strive to capture her essence, yet all would fall short, for she is not something to be described—only felt. Even when the world burdens her with darkness, she carries light in her eyes, a fragile and stubborn flame that refuses to be extinguished. She is kind, not because the world has been kind to her, but because she refuses to become like it.

 

In an age where cruelty parades as power, she reminds me that gentleness is not frailty—it is defiance. To remain soft amidst ruin is an act of rebellion; to love, despite pain, is a form of strength the cruel will never comprehend. And she, in all her quiet, unassuming ways, stands as proof that the purest strength is often silent.

 

Even now, she waits in the other room—unaware, perhaps, that her mere existence humbles me. She waits for me and her brother to finish our conversation so she may rest, and yet it is I who find no rest, haunted by the unbearable simplicity of her goodness.

⋆˖⁺‧₊☽◯☾₊‧⁺˖⋆

The room was dim, the only light coming from Grian’s desk lamp— soft, amber, and flickering every few seconds like it was just as tired as they were. The floor was a mess of blankets and chip bags, a half-finished soda between them.

‘You’re way too quiet for someone who just beat the other team’s setter to death on court today,’ Grian said, half-grinning as he tossed a chip at her.

Gem shrugged, her knees pulled to her chest. 

‘Yeah, well. Guess I ran out of things to yell about.’

‘Since when?’

‘Since I stopped winning the things that matter,’ she muttered.

Grian frowned. ‘What’s that supposed to mean?’

‘Nothing,’ she said quickly. Then, quieter, ‘Everything.’

He didn’t push. That was one of the things she liked about him— he knew when to shut up. They sat there for a while, the sound of the fan humming over the silence.

‘It’s about Pearl, isn’t it?’ Grian finally said.

Gem froze. The air felt thicker suddenly, like the world itself was holding its breath. ‘You don’t have to—’

‘You don’t have to lie, either,’ he said, voice soft. ‘I’m her brother, not blind.’

She let out a shaky laugh, trying to sound okay and failing miserably. ‘Yeah. Guess it’s kind of obvious, huh?’

‘You’ve been looking at her like she’s the moon or something,’ Grian said, chuckling a little. ‘And Cleo… I don’t know. That whole thing just… happened.’

‘Yeah,’ Gem whispered. ‘Happened.’

She stared down at her hands. Her fingernails were chipped, still faintly red from the ball burns. ‘I keep telling myself I’m happy for her. That she deserves it. But it’s like— every time I see them together, it’s like something in me just… folds in on itself.’

Grian sighed. ‘I get it. You can love someone and still hate how much it hurts.’

‘Do you?’ she asked quietly.

He looked away, smiling a little too sadly. ‘Maybe more than I’d like to admit.’

That made her laugh— a small, real laugh this time. It faded fast, but it was something.

‘Scar, I assume?’

‘You’d be right.’

She sighs,

‘I don’t know how to stop,’ she said. ‘It’s stupid, right? Still holding on when she’s already gone.’

‘Not stupid,’ Grian said. ‘Just human.’

Gem leaned her head against the side of the bed, closing her eyes. The exhaustion finally caught up to her, heavy and hollow.

‘Thanks, Grian,’ she murmured.

‘For what?’

‘For not making it weird.’

He smiled faintly. ‘You’re crying over my sister at my sleepover. It’s already weird.’

Gem laughed again— quiet, fractured, but achingly sincere. The sound barely existed, a fragile tremor in the dim air, as if the room itself might shatter beneath the weight of it. For a fleeting moment, it almost felt bearable — the ache, the loss, the cruel tenderness of still being alive.

Outside, the crickets wept their monotonous hymn, a reminder that the world continues its gentle cruelty no matter who lies awake. In the next room, Pearl was likely asleep— untouched, unburdened, her dreams untainted by the chaos she left behind.

Gem wished she could envy her, but envy required energy, and all Gem had left was the dull ache of remembering. Still, there was a strange mercy in this— in sitting beneath the flickering lamplight beside someone who asked for nothing, who didn’t demand she smile or explain.

⋆˖⁺‧₊☽◯☾₊‧⁺˖⋆

The night had grown thick— that kind of silence that feels almost sentient, watching, breathing. The lamp on Grian’s desk burned weakly, a trembling halo of amber that cast their shadows against the walls like ghosts in conversation.

 

Gem sat cross-legged on the floor, her back against the bedframe, the air between them heavy with words unsaid. She thought she had run out of things to feel, but pain has a way of inventing new shapes for itself.

 

Grian spoke first, voice quiet, deliberate.

‘You know, Pearl isn’t as gentle as people think.’

 

Gem turned to him. ‘She’s kind.’

 

‘Kind,’ he echoed, almost bitterly. ‘Yes. But kindness isn’t always mercy, is it? Sometimes it’s just blindness dressed in virtue.’

 

Gem said nothing. Her throat felt tight.

 

‘She doesn’t mean to hurt anyone,’ Grian went on, ‘but she does. All the time. She walks through the world like it belongs to her, and people follow— not because she asks them to, but because she shines. And when you get too close to the light, you burn. She never looks back long enough to see the ashes.’

 

Gem wanted to protest, but her voice betrayed her. ‘You make her sound cruel.’

 

‘No,’ he said. ‘Cruelty requires intent. She just… doesn’t see the ruins she leaves behind.’

 

The words fell between them, heavy and unforgiving. The fan hummed overhead, steady and tired— the only witness to their shared confession.

 

Grian leaned back, eyes fixed on the ceiling. ‘When we were kids, she used to cry over stray cats. Said every lost thing deserved to be found. Maybe that’s why she loves people like Cleo. People who make her feel like she’s saving something. She never realized that sometimes, saving one soul means breaking another.’

 

Gem’s fingers tightened around the hem of the blanket. ‘You sound like you pity her.’

 

‘I do,’ he said. ‘Because she doesn’t understand what she’s taken from you. Or from herself.’

 

Silence settled again, raw and fragile. It hurt to breathe.

 

‘You ever get tired of it?’ Gem whispered. ‘Loving someone who doesn’t know what they’ve done?’

 

Grian smiled faintly, though there was no joy in it. ‘Love doesn’t ask to be reasonable. It only asks to endure.’

 

Gem looked at him then— really looked— and saw the same exhaustion reflected in his eyes. Different wounds, same ache. Two souls bound by the same impossible tenderness.

 

She let out a sound that might have been a laugh, or a sob. ‘Guess we’re both fools.’

 

‘Maybe,’ he murmured. ‘But fools are the only ones who truly love.’

 

The lamp flickered again, its light softening until everything was a haze— their faces half-shadow, half-glow.

 

Gem’s head sank against the bedframe. Her voice was barely a whisper. ‘If I sleep, I’ll dream about her.’

 

‘Then dream,’ Grian said, his tone almost reverent. ‘Better to dream of her than to wake and feel nothing at all.’

 

Outside, the world remained indifferent— the moon hanging pale and patient, the crickets murmuring their hymns of sorrow. Somewhere beyond the walls, Pearl slept soundly, untouched by the quiet undoing happening a few rooms away.

 

And there, in the dim light, Gem realized that love was not a flame but an infection— slow, incurable, and sacred in its suffering

⋆˖⁺‧₊☽◯☾₊‧⁺˖⋆

The night had deepened. The hum of the ceiling fan was the only thing filling the pauses between words. Grian lay on the floor, idly tossing a pillow in the air, while Gem sat cross-legged on the edge of the bed, still clutching the blanket like it anchored her.

‘You know,’ Grian said, voice half-lazy, half-serious, ‘I think Etho would be good for you.’

Gem snorted softly. ‘Don’t start.’

‘No, really,’ he continued, unfazed. ‘He listens. He actually… sees people. He doesn’t talk much, but when he does, he means it. That’s rare.’

Gem shook her head, her hair falling like a curtain between them. ‘You’re reading too much into it. He’s just— nice to everyone.’

‘Not like that,’ Grian said quietly.

She looked up, something flickering in her eyes — fear, maybe, or disbelief. ‘He doesn’t like me,’ she murmured. ‘People like him don’t.’

The words fell like glass on tile — soft, but sharp. Grian didn’t rush to fix it. He just watched her, thoughtful, before saying, ‘Maybe people like him are exactly the ones who do.’

Gem laughed — a fragile thing trying to sound brave. ‘You’re too poetic for your own good.’

‘And you’re too cruel to yourself,’ he countered.

For a moment, silence reclaimed the room. The crickets outside kept time with their breaths. Gem drew her knees closer, head resting against them, and whispered, almost to herself, ‘It’s easier to think he doesn’t care. That way, it won’t hurt when he doesn’t.’

Grian looked at her then — really looked — and understood what she didn’t say. So he didn’t argue. He just sat there, letting the quiet hold what words couldn’t.

‘You deserve someone who looks at you the way you look at everyone else,’ he said finally.

Gem smiled faintly, eyes distant. ‘That’s kind, Grian. But maybe not true.’

‘And even if he did, what would I do with someone who actually stayed?’

Series this work belongs to: