Adult Content Warning

This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.

• Yes, Continue
• No, Go Back

If you accept cookies from our site and you choose "Yes, Continue", you will not be asked again during this session (that is, until you close your browser). If you log in you can store your preference and never be asked again.

1. I tried to be good, am I no good? (Ticci Toby x male reader) by rosaryyonthenightstand

   Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom  

   • Explicit
   • Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Major Character Death
   • M/M
   • Work in Progress

   02 Apr 2026

   Tags

   • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
   • Major Character Death
   • Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby/Reader
   • Eventual Smut
   • Religious Guilt
   • Internalized Homophobia
   • Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby Stutters
   • Insane Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby
   • Christian Themes
   • Suggestive Themes
   • My First Fanfic
   • Constructive Criticism Welcome
   • Advice
   • Mental Instability
   • Mental Health Issues
   • Stockholm Syndrome
   • I'm Bad at Tagging
   • Song: Strangers (Ethel Cain)
   • Strangers to Lovers
   • Reader-Insert is Bad at Feelings
   • Wet Dream
   • Car Sex
   • How Do I Tag
   • BDSM Switch Reader-Insert
   • Grinding
   • Clothed Masturbation
   • Non-Consensual Voyeurism
   • First Meetings
   • Murder
   • Dead People
   • Spit as Lube
   • No Lube

   Summary

   A pastors son, you, has had a recent run-in with some.. cryptic looking guy, at your local church where your father attends and works at. Ever since that, he's started to make his way into your life, despite your own protests.

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   5,745

   Chapters:

   9/?

   Comments:

   65

   Kudos:

   93

   Bookmarks:

   9

   Hits:

   1,132