Work Text:
The Olive Garden sign was exactly the same as they remembered.
Johnny stopped walking a few steps before the entrance, hands in his jacket pockets, eyes fixed on the glowing green lettering like it might start talking back to him.
“You notice how it hasn’t changed at all?” Gyro said beside him, like it was funny. Like it wasn’t anything.
Johnny didn’t answer right away. “That’s the problem.”
For a second, neither of them moved. Traffic hummed behind them, a bus hissed at the curb, and through the glass doors they could see the warm yellow lighting, the neatly set tables, the endless breadsticks waiting like nothing bad had ever happened inside those walls.
That was the lie, though.
Because both of them remembered.
Not in the clean, simple way memories usually sat. This one came back in fragments.
“Last time we were here,” Johnny said quietly, “we didn’t talk for an hour after we left.”
Gyro gave a small shrug, but it didn’t reach his face. “We talked. Just not to each other.”
That earned a short, humorless breath from Johnny. Almost a laugh. Almost.
The door opened and a wave of warm air spilled out, carrying garlic and baked bread and something sugary underneath it that made the whole place feel a little too comforting to be real.
Johnny shifted his weight. “We don’t have to go in.”
Gyro glanced at him then, properly this time. Not joking. Not deflecting.
“Yeah,” he said. “We do.”
That was the thing about them. Neither of them liked unfinished loops.
Inside, the noise hit first - cutlery clinking, low conversation, the soft shuffle of servers moving too quickly between tables. A hostess greeted them with practiced cheer, and Gyro answered for both of them before Johnny could decide how his voice should sound in this place.
Same booth as before, somehow. Or it felt like it. Memory liked repeating patterns like that.
Johnny sat down slowly, fingers brushing the edge of the table. “Do you think they remember us?”
Gyro snorted under his breath. “Why would they?”
“I don’t know,” Johnny said. “Feels like… places remember things anyway.”
That got quieter. Gyro looked down at the menu like it might contain an answer that didn’t involve him looking at Johnny directly.
For a while, it was just paper rustling and the distant kitchen noise. No dramatic moment. No sudden revelation. Just two people sitting in a restaurant they both disliked for reasons they couldn’t fully explain without reopening everything.
Then Gyro said, “We ordered the same thing last time.”
Johnny blinked. “We did?”
“Yeah,” Gyro said. “And you hated it, but you said you were fine.”
Johnny stared at him for a moment, then leaned back in the booth with a slow exhale. “That sounds like me.”
A pause.
Then, softer: “I don’t want a repeat of that.”
Gyro finally looked up. “Neither do I.”
The server came back, pen ready, smiling like the world was uncomplicated. They ordered differently this time - on purpose, like it mattered. Like small changes could rewrite older versions of themselves.
When the breadsticks arrived, Johnny didn’t touch them right away.
“You know what’s weird?” he said after a while.
Gyro raised an eyebrow.
“I thought coming back here would feel like getting stuck in it again,” Johnny said. “But it doesn’t.”
Gyro leaned back, arms folded loosely. “Because we’re not the same idiots we were.”
Johnny huffed a quiet laugh at that. “Speak for yourself.”
“Hey,” Gyro said, mock offended, but there was warmth under it now. “I’ve upgraded slightly.”
Johnny finally picked up a breadstick, turning it in his fingers before taking a bite. He chewed, then nodded once.
“…Okay,” he admitted. “Still better than last time. Not shoving it anywhere again.”
Gyro smiled at that, small, real. “See? Progress.”
And for the first time since they walked past the Olive Garden sign, the place didn’t feel like a trap.
Just a restaurant.
With bad memories in the past tense.