Work Text:
The studio lights of CBS Television City are unforgivingly bright, a sterile, neon-white glow that reflects off the polished floor of the American Idol stage. It is February 20, 2007. The air in the room is thick, partially with the scent of Paula’s floral perfume and the hairspray used to keep the Top 12 men looking like pop stars, and partially with a tension that has been simmering since soundcheck.
Chris Sligh has just finished his performance, a curly-haired burst of personality that has the audience on their feet. Simon Cowell sits at the judges' desk, his signature grey V-neck tight against his chest, his fingers drumming a rhythmic, impatient tattoo against the table. He watches as Ryan Seacrest, the man who has shared his bed and his life for the last seven years, makes his entrance from the wings.
Ryan doesn't just walk; he struts. He has an energy tonight that is almost avian, a flamboyant, high-stepping confidence that reminds Simon of a Quaquaval. It’s a ridiculous comparison, but Simon has been spending too much time on the phone with Ant and Dec lately. The Geordie duo has been obsessed with their Nintendo DS consoles, and Simon, ever the odd sponge for trends, has caught the Pokémon fever. Every time he sees a contestant with a certain hairstyle or a backup dancer with a specific gait, Ryan even sometimes whispers a name like Pikachu or Lucario in Simon’s ear. Right now, as the applause for Sligh dies down, Ryan practically dances to the front of the stage, his frosted tips catching the light, his smile wide and practiced for the millions of viewers at home.
Ryan doesn't wait for the judges to speak. He stands beside Sligh, looking toward the judges' table with a forced, squinty-eyed intensity. "I'll tell you what I thought, Chris," Ryan says, his voice taking on a clipped, mock-British cadence that is clearly a jab at Simon. "It was indulgent. It was messy. It was like watching a poodle in a blender."
The audience, usually supportive of Ryan's banter, lets out a collective, sharp jeer. The "boos" ripple through the bleachers, loud and visceral. It’s a swing and a miss; Ryan is trying to channel his inner Simon, trying to be the "bad cop" for a laugh, but he misses the mark of clever critique and lands squarely in the territory of being mean-spirited. Simon’s jaw tightens. Ryan is stepping on his toes, playing a character he hasn't earned. This is the script—the host vs. the judge, but there's an edge to Ryan’s posture that feels like a challenge, a desperate attempt to prove he can be just as sharp as the man he goes home to.
Simon leans into his microphone, his voice a low, dangerous rumble. "You do the links, sweetheart," he says, the endearment dripping with a condescension that is only half-feigned for the cameras. "I'll do the judging."
The audience lets out a collective "Oooooh," sensing the bite. Ryan turns to him, the smile staying on his face but never reaching his eyes. He lets out a sharp, practiced laugh that sounds like breaking glass.
"Don’t call me sweetheart," Ryan snaps back, waving a hand dismissively as if shooing a fly. The audience goes wild, but Ryan doesn't stop. He doubles down, his voice rising. "We don’t have that kind of relationship. I don’t want that kind of relationship."
The words hang in the air, vibrating against the studio's acoustic foam. For the first time in six seasons, the judges' table goes truly silent. Randy Jackson shifts uncomfortably in his seat, looking down at his "Dawg" notes, while Paula Abdul’s hand flutters to her throat, her eyes darting between the two men. Simon glares. He knows the game. He knows that Ryan is playing the spunky underdog host, fighting back against the big, bad judge. But "I don’t want that kind of relationship" is a phrase they’ve heard in their own kitchen during the rare, quiet moments when the stress of being 'Simon and Ryan' becomes too much to bear. It hurts.
Simon’s eyes narrow, his gaze becoming acerbic, cutting through the stage makeup. "You don’t want that kind of relationship," he repeats, his tone flat, stripping away the theatricality.
Ryan finally looks away, staring out at the sea of flashing cameras and waving signs. He adjusts his cufflink, his movements jerky. "Exactly," he says, his voice hardening. "We’ll just work together, that’s fine with me."
The broadcast continues for two grueling hours, but the atmosphere has shifted. The air feels ionized, like the moments before a lightning strike. As the twelve male singers take their turns, Ryan becomes a relentless needle. Every time Simon opens his mouth to deliver a critique—and tonight, he is particularly brutal, dismissing performances as "karaoke," "dull," and "pointless"—Ryan is there to poke at the bruise.
"Why are you being so negative tonight?" Ryan asks after the eighth performer, leaning against the edge of the judges' desk, far closer to Simon than he needs to be. "I mean, you’ve been very, very negative. Even for you."
Simon doesn't even look at him. He stares straight into the lens of Camera 1, his face a mask of professional disdain. "I’m not being negative," he says, his voice clipped. "Unlike you, I actually respect the audience at home—and I don’t believe in lying to them."
The "unlike you" hits Ryan like a physical blow. He fakes a gasp, playing it up for the "Idol" crowd, but his knuckles are white where he grips his cue cards. Backstage, the tension is palpable. The crew members in the wings are whispering, avoiding eye contact with the stars. Even the contestants, usually vibrating with their own nerves, are watching the monitor with wide, fearful eyes. Paula tries to lean over and whisper something soothing to Simon during a commercial break, but he ignores her, staring at his reflection in the black glass of the desk. Randy tries to catch Ryan’s eye as he walks past to get a touch-up on his powder, but Ryan is buried in his notes, his jaw set in a grim line.
By the time the final notes of the closing theme play, the atmosphere is toxic. Ryan stands at the center stage for the final sign-off. He thanks the viewers. He thanks the band. "Big thanks to Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul!" he shouts, his voice booming with forced enthusiasm. He pauses, his gaze flickering toward the end of the desk where Simon sits. He doesn't say his name. He simply turns his back, the credits rolling over his sharp, tailored shoulders.
The moment the "On Air" light flickers out, the silence is deafening. Simon stands up abruptly, knocking his chair back with a loud thud.
"Simon, honey—" Paula starts, reaching out a hand, but Simon brushes past her.
He doesn't look at Randy, who is standing with his arms crossed, shaking his head. Ryan is walking toward the wings, his head down, the adrenaline of the show evaporating and leaving behind a hollow, shaking exhaustion. He doesn't see Simon coming until they are in the narrow hallway leading to the dressing rooms. Simon doesn't slow down. He delivers a heavy, bodily shove against Ryan’s shoulder, a silent, furious communication of his rage.
Ryan stumbles, his back hitting the temporary plywood wall of the corridor. He looks up, and the 'Ryan Seacrest' persona is gone. His eyes are wide, his lip trembling slightly, his bravado stripped away to reveal the thirty-two-year-old man who is deeply in love with the person who just pushed him. He winces as Simon reaches his dressing room door and slams it shut with a force that makes the light fixtures rattle.
"Yo, man, what was that?" Randy’s voice booms from behind them. He’s caught up, his face contorted in anger. He looks at Ryan, who is still leaning against the wall, looking small. "You can't be doing that on TV, Ry. It was weird. It was uncomfortable for everyone."
"I was just..." Ryan starts, his voice weak, cracking. He clears his throat, trying to find the host again, but fails. "I was trying to play up the antagonism. You know? The 'Simon vs. Ryan' thing. It’s what the fans want. It’s... It’s quite successful for the ratings."
"Success? You looked like you were breaking up in front of thirty million people!" Randy huffs, stepping closer. "You two need to keep your home life off my stage."
Suddenly, a muffled roar comes from behind the heavy oak door of Simon's dressing room. "Your fucking mic's on!"
The shout is punctuated by another bang on the door. Ryan’s heart drops into his stomach. He looks down at the small black pack clipped to his belt. The green light is still glowing. Every word—the weak excuse, the admission of the 'act'—has been broadcast to the audio engineers, the producers in the truck, and anyone else wearing a headset in a five-hundred-foot radius.
Ryan’s face turns a deep, bruised shade of red, the color climbing from his neck to his forehead. He frantically fumbles with the switch, killing the power, his hands shaking so hard he almost drops the unit. He looks at Randy, who just sighs and walks away, leaving Ryan alone in the dim hallway. Ryan slinks to Simon's door. He stands there for a long moment, listening to the silence inside. He raises a hand and knocks, a soft, tentative sound.
"Please let me in, Si," he whispers.
"Thought we broke up," Simon’s voice comes back, sharp and cold as a winter morning in London. "I don't want you in my dressing room."
Ryan winces again, the words echoing his own onstage rejection back at him. He can hear footsteps in the hallway—the cleaning crew, a few straggling contestants from the earlier sets. He knows they are watching. He knows he looks pathetic, the golden boy of E! and FOX, begging at a closed door.
"Simon, come on," Ryan says, his voice gaining a bit of desperate strength. "I went too far. I know. It was the Pokémon thing, the energy, I just... I got caught up in the character."
"Go find a Poké-ball and crawl inside it then," Simon retorts. "Leave me alone."
"Simon, please. People are looking."
There's a long, agonizing pause. Ryan is about to turn away, his chest aching with a familiar, sharp pain, when he hears the lock click. The door doesn't just open; it is ripped inward. Simon stands there, his hair disheveled, his eyes burning with a dark, intense fire. Before Ryan can say a word, Simon reaches out and grabs the front of Ryan’s expensive designer shirt, bunching the fabric in his fist. He yanks Ryan into the room with a force that catches Ryan off guard, pulling him across the threshold. The door slams shut behind them, the sound final and heavy.
Simon doesn't let go of the shirt. He backs Ryan up against the door, his face inches away. The smell of tobacco and expensive tea clings to him, a scent that usually means safety to Ryan, but right now feels like a threat. "You want to talk?" Simon asks, his voice a low, dangerous hiss. "Talk. Explain why you decided to divorce me on national television for the sake of a 'link'."
Ryan looks at him, the red in his cheeks finally fading into a pale, honest terror. "I didn't mean it, Simon. I would never—"
"You said you didn't want this relationship," Simon interrupts, his grip tightening, his knuckles brushing against Ryan’s collarbone. "Quite a bold statement to make when I’m the one who has to go home and sleep in the other half of your bed. So, tell me, Ryan. Is the 'persona' worth it? Or are you actually that tired of me?"
The room is silent, save for the hum of the air conditioning and the frantic beat of Ryan’s heart against Simon’s hand. The glitz of the show is gone, leaving only two men, married for seven years, caught in the gap between who they are for the world and who they are for each other. Ryan reaches up, his fingers trembling as he covers Simon’s fist with his own.
"I'm not tired of you," he says, his voice finally dropping the modulation, becoming the raw, real version of himself. "I'm just an idiot who forgot where the stage ends, and where we begin."
Simon stares at him for a long time, searching for the lie. Slowly, the tension in his arm begins to bleed away, though he doesn't let go of the shirt. He exhales a long, shaky breath. "You are an idiot," he agrees, his voice losing its edge, replaced by a weary, familiar affection. "And if you ever tell thirty million people you don't want to be with me again, I'll make sure you're hosting 'Idol' from the parking lot."
Ryan lets out a small, watery laugh. "Deal."
Simon finally lets go of the fabric, smoothing it out with a lingering, possessive touch. "Now," he says, moving toward his desk where a bottle of Scotch sits waiting. "Sit down. We have to figure out how to fix your mess before the tabloids get the transcript of your fucking mic."
Ryan sinks into the leather chair, feeling the weight of the night finally settle. The show is over, the persona is dead, and in the quiet of the dressing room, they are just Simon and Ryan again.