Adult Content Warning

This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.

• Yes, Continue
• No, Go Back

If you accept cookies from our site and you choose "Yes, Continue", you will not be asked again during this session (that is, until you close your browser). If you log in you can store your preference and never be asked again.

1. It Was Always You by odaatlover

   Fandoms: Wynonna Earp (TV)  

   • Explicit
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • F/F
   • Complete Work

   07 Aug 2026

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Waverly Earp/Nicole Haught
   • Waverly Earp & Wynonna Earp
   • Wynonna Earp & Nicole Haught
   • Waverly Earp & Chrissy Nedley
   • Waverly Earp
   • Nicole Haught
   • Wynonna Earp
   • Chrissy Nedley
   • Perry Crofte
   • Mattie Perley | The Blacksmith
   • James "Champ" Hardy
   • Rosita Bustillos
   • Alternate Universe
   • Best Friends to Lovers
   • Friends with Benefits
   • Friends with Benefits to Lovers
   • Smut
   • Fluff
   • Angst
   • Queer awakening
   • Miscommunication
   • Waverly thinks Nicole is inviting her over to have sex
   • She was very wrong
   • Inspired by On The Same Page by Haley Cass
   • Oral Sex
   • Vaginal Fingering
   • Strap-Ons
   • Casual Sex
   • First time with a woman
   • Bisexual Waverly Earp
   • Love Confessions
   • Multiple Orgasms
   • Aftercare
   • Light Bondage
   • Slow Burn
   • Jealousy
   • Alternate Universe - No Curse
   • Alternate Universe - Modern Setting

   Summary

   Waverly is stuck in a dating rut when a ridiculous misunderstanding with Nicole, her best friend that she's known for a decade, changes everything. What starts as Waverly thinking Nicole invited her over for casual sex accidentally exposes a mutual attraction, leaves Waverly questioning her sexuality, and forces her to realize that she’s falling for her best friend.

   **This story is inspired by On The Same Page by Haley Cass. Go give it a read if you haven't already!

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   56,186

   Chapters:

   16/16

   Comments:

   90

   Kudos:

   415

   Bookmarks:

   46

   Hits:

   9,583