Work Text:
Tim died on a Tuesday, on a mission he'd gone into alone the way he always went into things alone when he'd decided the risk was his to carry and no one else's. Alead on a smuggling operation running out of a warehouse outside the city, no backup requested, no backup sent, and by the time anyone got a signal on him the structure had already come down around whatever he'd found there. That was the whole of it, in the end. A building that wasn't rated for what came through it, and Tim underneath, and hours before anyone even knew to look.
It had been three days, and Kon still hadn't slept anywhere that felt like sleeping. He'd stayed at the manor because leaving felt like a decision he didn't have the strength to make, and because Smallville—four hundred miles and a whole ordinary life away—seemed built for a version of him that didn't exist anymore. The house had gone quiet around midnight, Bruce shut away somewhere below, Dick not due back until morning, and Kon lay in the guest room listening to the place settle and creak around him the way old houses do, and at some point, without deciding to, he got up and walked down the hall and found himself standing in front of a door he hadn't let himself open since he'd arrived.
He went in.
The room was exactly the way Tim had left it, which meant it was almost unbearably tidy: the bed made with corners nobody had taught him except maybe Alfred, a stack of case files squared off on the desk, a jacket hung with the collar straightened on the back of the chair, a mug that had once held an energy drink sitting exactly where he'd left it, because nobody yet had had the heart to come in and treat the room like it needed clearing instead of preserving. Tucked into the corner of the mirror above the dresser was a photograph Kon hadn't seen before; he two of them on some rooftop, mid-laugh, neither of them looking at the camera— the kind of picture that only exists because someone else took it without either subject noticing until after— and he stood in front of it a long moment before he could make himself look away.
Kon sat down on the edge of the bed. He hadn't turned on the overhead light, just the small lamp on the desk, and the room held itself in that low gold light the way rooms do at night, ordinary objects gone soft-edged and strange, and he sat there a long time doing nothing at all except being in a space that still smelled, faintly, like Tim.
He wasn't looking for anything. He wanted that understood, later, if it ever mattered to anyone besides himself. He hadn't come into the room hunting for secrets, hadn't had any reason to suspect there were secrets to find. He was just sitting there, working his thumb along the underside of the desk drawer the way you touch things without meaning to when your hands need somewhere to be, and the drawer had swollen with age the way old wood does, stuck fast, and Kon— not thinking, not paying any attention at all to what his own strength could do when he wasn't paying attention to it— pulled.
The drawer came free all at once, with a crack loud enough in the quiet room to make him flinch, wood splitting cleanly along a seam he hadn't known was there, and underneath the drawer's false bottom, in a shallow compartment built into the desk itself, sat a small, dented tin box, the kind of thing that might once have held tea or tobacco and had clearly been repurposed for something else entirely.
He stared at it a long moment before he understood what he was looking at.
He hadn't meant to break anything. He thought, distantly, that he should feel worse about that than he did— should feel guilty, breaking something of Tim's this soon, this raw— but some instinct, the same one that had walked him to this door without his permission, told him the breaking wasn't really the point tonight, and he set the broken drawer piece aside, careful even in his carelessness, and lifted the box out.
He opened it, because the alternative— sitting alone in Tim's room with an unopened box in his hands, forever— was somehow worse than whatever it contained.
Inside were letters.
Not one. Not two. A stack of them, folded in various ways, on various kinds of paper— a few on the manor's heavy cream stationery, one on the back of a printed case file, several on plain lined paper torn from a legal pad— spanning, Kon understood almost immediately from the differences in the handwriting alone, years. Tim's handwriting at nineteen was tighter and smaller and more controlled than Tim's handwriting at twenty-one, which had loosened, had started to slant, had started— Kon noticed this with a private ache— to look more like the handwriting he remembered from case notes passed between them a hundred times, familiar in a way that hurt before he'd read a single word.
None of the envelopes were sealed. None were addressed, not really— no name on any of them, no stamp, nothing suggesting Tim had ever seriously meant to put these in a mailbox the way Kon had once put his own letter in a mailbox and walked away without looking back. These had been written and folded and kept. Written, apparently, across years, and never sent, and never— as far as Kon could tell from the box's dents and the softened edges of the oldest pages— even reread often.
Written, and then put away, the way you put away a thing you can't bring yourself to destroy and can't bring yourself to look at either.
Something cold moved through him as the shape of it became clear— not shock exactly, grief didn't leave much room for shock anymore, but a kind of vertiginous recalibration, the sense of a floor he'd been standing on turning out to be built from something other than what he'd assumed. However many letters there were, they spanned more of their history than Kon had ever fully accounted for in his own head, more than half the years he'd known Tim at all, and he sat there with that arithmetic settling into him like weight before he let himself pick anything up.
He sat with the box a long time before he picked up the first letter.
It was the oldest, he could tell, the paper slightly yellowed, the ink a cheap ballpoint blue faded at the folds, the handwriting cramped and young and trying hard to be controlled. His hands weren't quite steady when he finally reached in. The paper was cool against his fingers, edges gone soft with age, and he became aware of his own pulse in a way he rarely was, a fast, uneven thing in his throat that had nothing to do with exertion. He made himself breathe. He made himself unfold it.
Kon,
I don't know why I'm writing this. I'm not going to give it to you. I want to be clear with myself about that before I write anything else, because if I don't say it now I'll talk myself into believing this is something other than what it is— a way of saying a true thing without having to watch your face while I say it.
You almost died Tuesday. I know you know that. I was there. I ran the extraction numbers three times and each time the margin was smaller than I wanted, and I did it anyway because there wasn't a version where I didn't, and it worked, and you're fine. You're downstairs right now eating cereal like nothing happened, and I am up here writing a letter I'm never going to send because I can't stop thinking about the four seconds where the numbers said it might not work.
I don't have a good name for what I felt in those four seconds. I've tried several. None of them are adequate, and I've decided that's meaningful— that the failure of my vocabulary here is itself data. I am nineteen years old and apparently the kind of person who deals with catastrophic feeling by trying to name it correctly instead of just having it, and I don't know what that says about me except that it says a lot.
I keep replaying it. The four seconds. I don't know why my brain decided that's the unit of measurement, why it isn't the whole mission or the whole day, just those four seconds, over and over— your signal flickering, the extraction window closing, and me standing in the command room unable to do anything except watch numbers update on a screen. I rarely feel that kind of helplessness anymore. I want to say I hope I never feel it again, but I think that's probably naïve, given what we do, given who we both are.
I'm going to stop here.
The letter ended there, mid-thought, no signature, the pen strokes trailing off like Tim had simply set it down and never picked it back up.
Kon read it twice. Then he sat with it, something in his chest reorganizing itself around a fact he hadn't had access to before. That nineteen-year-old Tim, in some room in this house, had come within four seconds of losing him on a mission neither of them had ever really talked about afterward, had gone upstairs and written this instead of saying any of it aloud, and had folded it up and never mentioned it again for the rest of that year, or the one after, or any of the years that followed.
His hands weren't steady— he noticed that distantly— the page trembling slightly where he held it, not from any weakness in his grip, he could crush steel without trying, but from something underneath the grip that had nothing to do with strength. His throat had gone tight sometime in the last minute without his permission. He pressed the heel of one hand briefly against his sternum, a gesture that did nothing, fixed nothing, just gave his body somewhere to put the pressure building there, and made himself keep breathing in the slow, deliberate way you breathe when your lungs have started doing something involuntary and you need them to stop.
He picked up the next one.
Written maybe a year later, judging by the handwriting — looser now, more confident, but with the same habit of trailing off when the feeling outran the sentence.
Kon,
You came to Gotham today. You didn't have to. There was no mission, no reason, you just showed up because you said you were in the area, which we both know isn't true, and I didn't call you on the lie, because I didn't want you to stop doing it.
We sat on the roof of the clocktower for three hours and didn't talk about anything important. You told me a story about a cow. I don't even remember the details, I remember you told it badly and that I was laughing so hard I had to put my drink down, and I remember thinking, somewhere around the second hour, that I would rather be on this roof failing to follow the plot of a story about a cow than doing almost anything else available to me on Earth, and that this should probably alarm me more than it does.
You had a blanket in your car— an old flannel one, Ma’s, you said, though I suspect it was really yours and you just credited it to her because admitting you kept a blanket in your car for cold rooftops felt like admitting too much— and at some point you put it around both our shoulders without asking, some casual gesture you probably don't even remember making, and I sat there for the rest of the night with your arm against mine under that blanket, memorizing the warmth of it like it was going to be tested on later.
It doesn't alarm me. That might be the problem.
I keep telling myself there's a version of this where I say something. I keep constructing the scenario, I'm good at that, and every time I run it forward I get to the part where I'd have to open my mouth and something in the words breaks down. I don't know how to do it without changing the shape of what we have, and I like the shape of what we have. I like it enough that I'm apparently willing to sit on the rest of it indefinitely rather than risk it.
I don't think that's brave. I want to be honest, even here, even where no one's going to read it. I don't think staying quiet is brave. I think it's just easier, and I've built a whole personality around not choosing the easier thing, and this is apparently the one place I do it anyway.
Anyway. The stars were good tonight. You'd have liked them more than the cow story, probably, though you didn't seem to notice them at all— you just kept talking, and I kept not stopping you, because I wanted it to keep going as long as it could.
Kon had to put that one down for a minute.
His stomach had dropped somewhere around the blanket, a lurching, falling sensation like missing a step in the dark, and he sat there on the floor of Tim's room with his elbows braced on his knees and his head bowed, waiting for something in his chest to stop moving before he trusted himself to pick the page back up.
He remembered the roof.
He remembered the blanket— he did remember it, now that it had been named, a detail he hadn't thought about in years suddenly vivid and total, the rough scratch of old flannel and the warmth of Tim's arm and how neither of them had said anything about it, how it had just been a thing that happened, unremarked, the way so much between them had been unremarked. He remembered the cow story— a heifer that got loose during a thunderstorm and ended up three farms over, thoroughly unbothered, chewing grass in someone's flower bed like nothing had happened— and he remembered telling it badly on purpose because Tim's real laugh, the unguarded one Tim almost never let out in front of anyone, was worth working for.
He had not, until this exact moment, three days after Tim's death, had any idea that Tim had been sitting beside him on that roof running some private calculation about whether to say something that might have changed the shape of both their lives, and had decided, quietly enough that Kon never even suspected, not to.
The next was written on a different kind of paper entirely, thicker, cream-colored, the kind Tim used for nothing but official correspondence, which made the contents feel stranger for the mismatch.
Kon,
We had to pose as a couple this week. You remember— the fundraiser, the guest list Oracle needed eyes on, the two of us walking arm-in-arm because a lone Red Robin and a lone Superboy would have drawn more attention than a couple clearly enjoying an evening out. It was tactically sound. I signed off on the plan myself. I want that on the record, because everything that happened afterward was, strictly speaking, my own fault for not running the second-order consequences before I agreed to it.
You were good at it. Too good, maybe— you had your hand at the small of my back all night like it belonged there, and you kept finding small, unnecessary reasons to lean in and say something in my ear, and I kept telling myself it was for the cover, and some of it probably was—you've always had good instincts for a role— and some of it, I think, wasn't performance at all, and I have spent the four days since the mission trying to figure out which parts were which and getting nowhere useful.
There was a moment on the dance floor where you pulled me in a little closer than the choreography required and said something about the mark near the bar, purely operational, completely in character, and I heard the words and understood the content yet simultaneously could not, for several full seconds, remember how to make my own voice work in response. I covered it. I don't think you noticed. I have thought about those several seconds more than I have thought about the actual outcome of the mission, which by any professional measure should embarrass me.
I keep telling myself it doesn't count if it was a job. I don't think I believe that anymore.
Kon had gone completely still reading that one, something hot and strange moving up through his chest that had nothing to do with grief and everything to do with a memory suddenly recontextualized. He remembered that fundraiser, remembered the mark near the bar, remembered his own hand at the small of Tim's back and thinking, at the time, that it was easy, natural, the kind of thing his body did without asking permission first, and he'd never once considered that it might have landed on Tim's side of things as anything other than easy competence. He pressed his palm briefly against his eyes, hard enough to see stars behind the lids, and made himself keep reading.
The next was shorter, the paper a scrap torn from something else, the handwriting hurried.
Kon,
You mentioned someone tonight. Wonder Girl's friend, the one from the mixer in Central City. You didn't say much, just that you'd gotten coffee with her twice, but there was an energy to it, the good kind, the kind you get when something's going well, and I want to be honest and say I spent the rest of that conversation running a kind of controlled damage assessment on myself that I'm not proud of.
I told you I was happy for you. I meant it, mostly. The mostly is the part I'm writing down here instead of saying aloud, because the mostly doesn't get a vote in how I actually treat you, and I've decided that if I can't be fully happy for you, I can at least be quiet about the rest.
I ran into her once, afterward, at some gala Bruce made me attend. She asked how you were doing. I told her you were good, which was true, and I felt an ugly little flicker of relief that she'd asked about you and not the other way around, like your happiness with someone else was a thing I still got to be the custodian of information about, which is a possessive and small way to feel about someone else's dating life and I'm aware of that even as I keep feeling it.
It didn't last, the coffee thing— you told me a month later, offhand, that it "wasn't really going anywhere," and I want it on record, here, in the only place I let myself keep records like this, that I felt something when you said it that I am deeply unwilling to examine, and that I hate, a little, that I felt it at all. You deserved for it to go somewhere if you wanted it to. My own feelings were never supposed to be relevant.
I don't know how to stop having them anyway.
Kon felt something twist low in his gut. An old, complicated feeling he didn't have a clean name for either— guilt, maybe, for a thing he hadn't known he was doing at the time; something else too, warmer and worse, at the thought of Tim sitting through some gala running a controlled damage assessment on himself over a woman Kon barely remembered. He tried to remember her name and couldn't, which felt, suddenly, like its own small tragedy— that an entire evening of Tim's careful private suffering had attached itself to a person so unmemorable to Kon that her name had simply evaporated, while Tim, apparently, had kept the whole of that night stored away for years.
The next was barely a year old, the paper still crisp, no visible wear.
Kon,
I almost told you tonight. I want that written somewhere, even if you never know it, because I think if I don't write it down I'll convince myself later that I imagined the moment, softened it into something smaller than it was.
You'd come by my apartment with takeout, unannounced, which you do more than you probably realize, and we were sitting on my floor because I still haven't bought a second chair, eating out of the containers, and you said something— I don't even remember what, something small and stupid about the takeout place's terrible music— and I looked at you and the sentence was right there. Right at the front of my mouth. I felt it arrive, fully formed, ready to be said, in a way it had never quite arrived before.
And then my phone rang. A case, obviously, it's always a case, and I answered it because that's what I do, that's the whole of my life, the phone rings and I answer it and whatever was about to happen gets postponed indefinitely in favor of whatever's on the other end of the line, and by the time the call ended you'd finished eating and the moment had gone somewhere I couldn't get it back from.
I keep wondering what would have happened if I'd let it ring.
Kon made a sound low in his throat, something between a laugh and something much worse, because he remembered that night too— remembered the terrible music, remembered his own phone habitually silenced but Tim's never was, remembered thinking nothing of it when Tim picked up, because why would he have thought anything of it, there had been no way to know a whole future had been sitting right there in the room with them, close enough to touch, and had simply rung itself into nonexistence.
The next was written on manor stationery, the hand steadier but pressed harder into the page than usual, like it had been written fast and without much revision. It was undated, slightly crumpled, Kon could tell it hadn’t been in order in the stack, pulled out and read over again, knowing Tim to try and make sense of his own words.
Kon,
Bruce has been gone three weeks. I don't call it "presumed dead" out loud, not even to Dick, because saying it out loud makes it a category I'd have to build response protocols around, and I'm not ready to build those yet. I keep running searches instead. I keep telling myself the next lead will be the one that resolves it.
Dick keeps telling me to sleep. Alfred keeps making food I don't eat. I know they're worried about me on top of everything else they're carrying grief about Bruce, and I hate that. I hate being one more thing anyone has to manage right now, and you're the only person I've let see how bad it actually is, because somehow with you it doesn't feel like a burden I'm handing over. It just feels like the truth, said out loud to a person who can hold it without flinching.
You’re dead. You’re gone. I know you cannot comeback; I tried. I tried so hard, Kon. The shape of my effort was in those tubes. I couldn’t do it. You will never read these letters, they will never find their way into your soft, loving hands. I can’t allow myself to fall into this grief, I am sorry.
Bruce is not dead. I can bring him back. I'll find him.
I’m sorry I can’t do the same for you.
Kon had to set that one down too. His eyes were stinging in a way that had nothing to do with tiredness, and he pressed the back of his wrist against them, hard, an old reflex from a childhood spent trying not to cry in front of anyone who might see it as weakness, though there was no one here to see anything, just him and the lamp and the letters and the enormous quiet of a house that didn't know yet what he'd found.
He read two more after that, each written in a hand a little less controlled than the last, each a little more devastating in its content.
The first was written after a mission that had put Tim in the infirmary for three days— the hand noticeably unsteady, pressed hard enough into some lines that the pen had nearly gone through the paper.
Kon,
I'm writing this from a hospital bed, which feels like it should be a metaphor for something, except it isn't, it's just where I am. Three cracked ribs, a concussion the doctors are calling "moderate," and enough time lying here doing nothing that my brain has had no choice but to catch up with itself.
I keep doing the math on what it would mean to lose you again. I don't know why my brain went there instead of somewhere useful, somewhere about my own recovery timeline or the case I was working, but it went there and it's stayed there for six hours now, running the same numbers over and over, and the math doesn't resolve. I've never had a variable that doesn't resolve. Everything resolves, eventually, if you run it long enough— Oracle taught me that— and this doesn't. I don't know what to do with a variable that refuses to resolve except write it down and put it away, so that's what I'm doing.
The nurse keeps asking if there's someone she should call. I keep telling her Alfred already knows. I don't tell her there's a different someone I'd want here, if I let myself want things like that out loud, because that would require explaining who, and I'm not ready to explain who, not even to a stranger who'll forget my name by her next shift.
The second was written the same week Kon himself had once nearly died on a mission of his own, and this one was barely legible, ink pressed hard enough in places to almost tear the paper.
Kon,
You're going to be fine. Bart says you're going to be fine. Cassie says you're going to be fine. I've asked four different people in the last two hours to tell me you're going to be fine and I don't think I've believed any of them— not really, not underneath the part of me that keeps running the same catastrophic projection no matter how much good data comes in to contradict it.
I keep needing someone to say it again. I don't know how to need something this much and never once ask for it out loud— I've been standing in this hallway for two hours refusing a chair, refusing coffee, refusing every kind gesture Bart's tried to make because sitting down feels like giving up the vigil, like the vigil itself is doing something useful, which it isn't, I know it isn't, I know standing here isn't keeping you alive any more than sitting would, but I can't make myself stop.
I think I forgot how to ask for things a long time ago. I think I forgot on purpose, actually, somewhere around when I decided that needing things out loud made you a liability in this line of work, and I've spent so long being unassailable that I don't remember how to admit I'm scared. I'm scared right now. I've never written that down before. I'm scared, and I don't know how to be anything except quiet about it, even here, even in a hallway where no one but me can hear the sentence.
Kon had to stop entirely for a moment, both hands pressed flat against the floor on either side of him like he needed the physical contact with something solid to keep from tipping over. He remembered that hallway— remembered coming out of surgery groggy and half-conscious and someone's hand gripping his before he'd even opened his eyes, and he'd always assumed, in the hazy unreliable way you assume things about moments you weren't fully present for, that it had been Bart's hand, or Cassie's. He hadn't known it was Tim's. He hadn't known Tim had stood in that hallway for two hours refusing to sit down. Something about that fact, small and enormous at once, undid him more thoroughly than either of the letters he'd just read.
The next was written on plain paper, the ink darker, the hand oddly formal, like Tim had made himself slow down on purpose.
Kon
You told me tonight you'd been thinking about walking away from all of this. Not forever, you said, just stepping back. Living in Kansas full time. A regular life, whatever that means for a person who can lift a car over his head, and I sat there and nodded and told you that sounded healthy, that you deserved to want an ordinary life if you wanted one, and I meant every word of it, and underneath every word of it I was doing the math on how often I'd actually see you if you weren't in the field anymore, and the number frightened me more than almost anything has in a long time.
I didn't say that. Obviously I didn't say that— you were talking about your own wellbeing, your own exhaustion, and the correct response to that is support, not some selfish accounting of how your choices affect my access to you, and I know that, I know the difference between the right response and the true one, and I gave you the right one because it was also, mostly, true. I do want you to have whatever life makes you happy.
I just also want to be in it. I have never figured out how to say both of those things at once without the second one sounding like a condition on the first, so I don't say the second one at all, and I write it here instead, where it can be both true and safely unheard.
Kon remembered that conversation with a jolt that went all the way down into his stomach — remembered sitting on Tim's fire escape almost three years ago, talking through the exhaustion that had been building in him for months, and remembered Tim's steady, supportive nods, had taken them at face value, had never once suspected there was an entire second conversation happening underneath the one they were having out loud. He wondered, with a fresh stab of something between grief and fury, how many of their conversations had secretly been two conversations. He suspected, reading this, that the answer was most of them.
One more of the newer letters remained before the steadier one, and this was the hardest one yet, the paper worn soft at every fold like it had been taken out and put away more times than any of the others despite everything Kon had assumed about how rarely they were reread.
Kon,
I don't talk about it. You don't either, not really, not beyond the occasional joke about coming back from the dead like it's a funny personal quirk instead of the single worst thing that has ever happened to either of us. I think we've both decided, independently, that talking about it seriously would require admitting how much it changed things, and neither of us wants to do the admitting, so we joke instead, and the joking works, mostly, except on this one day every year when I sit somewhere quiet and let myself actually remember.
I remember where I was when I found out you were gone. I remember exactly how long it took me to stop believing it. I have never told you how long that was, because the number is embarrassing, professionally, given everything I claim to believe about data and probability and letting evidence lead— I believed I could bring you back, the science would back me up, I believed it could work, and I was wrong, in the end, and I have never once let myself accept that I was wrong because I got you back regardless and I'm still not sure I've forgiven the universe for the version of the math where I might not have.
Kon had to stop reading entirely for a long moment, his whole chest gone tight and airless, because he did remember that gap— five months, from his own accounting, though apparently four of Tim's— and he had always assumed, the handful of times he'd thought about it at all, that the team had simply mourned efficiently and moved forward the way heroes are trained to, that grief in that world ran on a schedule dictated by operational necessity. He pressed the heel of his hand hard against his sternum, the same gesture from hours ago, except now it wasn't helping at all.
The last of the older letters, written more recently than any of the others, had a steadiness to it the earlier ones lacked, as if some argument Tim had been having with himself for a decade had finally, quietly, resolved in a direction he hadn't expected:
Kon,
I turned twenty-one this week. You flew out with a cake that said the wrong age on it— you'd gotten the math wrong on purpose, I think, some joke I never entirely understood— and I keep coming back to how easy it was. The whole evening. How little effort it took to be happy in a room with you in it, and I've started to wonder if easy is actually the tell I've been looking for all this time and just refused to read correctly.
You'd brought the cake up from Smallville on the red-eye, still half-frozen in a cooler, and you'd been so proud of yourself for remembering the flight schedule that you didn't notice until Alfred pointed it out that you'd written "21" as "71" in blue icing, and when I laughed at it you looked so wounded that I told you it was perfect, actually. That I'd rather be seventy-one with you in the room than twenty-one without you in it, and you didn't understand what I meant by that, and I didn't explain, and some part of me has been turning that non-explanation over ever since.
I don't have a plan yet. I want to say that clearly, so future-me reading this back has an accurate record: I don't have a plan. But I think I'm getting closer to one. I think, for the first time, I can imagine a version of a conversation with you that doesn't end in breaking down.
I'm not ready tonight. I'm writing this instead of being ready, which I recognize as its own kind of pattern by now. But I wanted it on record that something is shifting. That I noticed it shifting. That I'm not going to let this be another year of letters if I can help it.
Kon exhaled something that wasn't quite a laugh and wasn't quite a sob, some collapsed hybrid of both that hurt his chest on the way out. He remembered the cake. He remembered the wrong number, remembered Tim's face doing something complicated when Kon pointed it out and laughed, and he understood now, with the terrible clarity of information arriving months too late.
By the time Kon reached the bottom of the stack, the lamp on the desk was the only light left in the house he could sense at all, and he had not moved from the floor in what must have been hours, and there was one letter left.
It was different from the others in almost every visible way. The paper was newer— clean, unyellowed, a single sheet of the plain printer stock Tim used for case notes, folded into precise thirds with a corner crease sharp enough to have been ironed. The handwriting was the most recent version of Tim's hand Kon had ever seen, looser than the earliest letters, more slanted, faster, worn loose by a decade spent wearing down the careful control he'd started with into something more fluent and less guarded.
And unlike every other letter in the box, this one had a date written in the corner, the way you'd date a piece of evidence.
Kon looked at the date a long time before he made himself read anything else.
It was the night before the warehouse.
His heart was doing something strange and heavy in his chest, a slow, dragging thud that felt entirely disconnected from its usual rhythm, and his hands, when he finally unfolded the page, were not steady at all— he had to set it down flat on his knee and smooth it twice before the words would hold still long enough to read.
He understood, underneath the part of him that was simply grieving, that this letter was going to be different from the others— not only because of the date, though the date was doing something to his chest he didn't have a name for yet, but because of the care in the fold, the fact that Tim had dated it at all when he hadn't bothered to date a single one of the others across ten years of writing them. Something about this one had been meant, in a way the others hadn't quite managed to be. Something about this one had come close to being finished.
He read it.
Kon,
I want to start by telling you that I know exactly what I'm doing, writing this tonight instead of any other night, and I want you to know I've thought about it clearly, the way I think about things once I've stopped letting myself pretend I don't already know the answer.
I'm leaving for the warehouse district in four hours. I've run the risk assessment twice and I don't love the numbers. I'm not telling you this because I think something is going to happen— most operations with numbers like these resolve fine, I've run worse odds a hundred times and walked away from all of them— I'm telling you because I've developed a habit, over the last several years, of writing one of these before anything with elevated risk, and I've never examined that habit closely enough to explain it to myself, and tonight, for whatever reason, I'd like to try.
I think I write these because I'm afraid of dying without having said this, and I think I've been afraid of that for longer than I've let myself admit, and I think the fact that I keep writing the fear down instead of addressing it is its own small tragedy that I'm aware of even as I keep doing it. I am aware, Kon. I want that on the record. I know I've had years and I know I've spent most of them finding increasingly sophisticated ways not to use them, and I am not writing this because I've suddenly become braver. I'm writing it because it's midnight and I'm tired of my own cowardice in a way I don't usually let myself be tired of anything, and there's something about the quiet of a house before a mission that makes honesty feel less dangerous than it does in daylight, even though I know, logically, the honesty itself hasn't changed at all.
So. Here is what I haven't said.
I have loved you for as long as I've had a word for loving anyone. I don't know the exact date it started because I don't think it started on a date— I think it accumulated, the way most true things about me have accumulated, slowly, underneath whatever else was happening, until one day I looked up and understood it had been there long enough to count as foundational. I was a kid the first time I tried to write it down. I've been trying, on and off, in this exact useless way, for a decade. There are eleven other letters in this box that say some version of this, in various states of unfinished, and I am ashamed of that, a little, the way you're ashamed of any evidence of your own avoidance once you finally hold all of it at once.
I want to tell you what it's been like, because I don't think I've ever told you anything true about this, and if tonight goes the way the numbers say it might not, I don't want the last few years to have been entirely unspoken.
It has been like watching you tell a bad story about a cow on a rooftop and understanding, somewhere around the second hour, that I would rather be there than anywhere else available to me, including several places I was technically supposed to be that night.
It has been like running extraction numbers with your name in the variable column and finding that I check that number more times than I check anyone else's, more times than is professionally necessary by any reasonable standard, and telling myself for years that it's just thoroughness, when I think we both know, if I'm honest, it isn't only that.
It has been like the relief I feel when you land somewhere I can see you— not hear about later, not confirm through comms, but actually watch come down out of the sky in one piece— a relief that is different in kind from what I feel about anyone else's safety, sharper, more physical, something that used to embarrass me and eventually just became a fact I stopped fighting, even if I never said it.
It has been like every time you've called just to talk about nothing— a tractor, a cow, a team meeting that went sideways— and I've let myself stay on the phone longer than I needed to because I wasn't ready for the call to end, and I've told myself that's just what friends do, and some of it was, and some of it was never only that.
It has been like standing next to you at more funerals than either of us should have had to attend by this age, and finding, every time, that the only hand I wanted to reach for in the receiving line was yours, and reaching for it anyway, disguising it as solidarity, as teammates closing ranks, when it was never only that either.
It has been like the fundraiser four years ago now, the two of us posing as something we weren't for the sake of a mission, except some of it wasn't posing, not on my end, and I never told you that either, one more entry in a very long list of things I decided you didn't need to know.
It has been like the take-out on my floor years ago, the sentence sitting right at the front of my mouth before my phone rang and I let it ring itself into silence instead of saying it, because some part of me has always been more comfortable letting the world interrupt me than admitting I was the one choosing not to speak.
It has been like knowing exactly how you take your coffee even though you've never once asked me to make it for you, like keeping a second toothbrush in my bathroom for no reason at all. Like a hundred other small unremarkable facts I've accumulated about you and stored without ever asking myself why I was storing them.
I don't know how to tell you this without also telling you that I don't know what I would have done with it, if I'd said it while I was still around to find out. I think about that more than I should. I think I would have kept finding reasons not to— the mission, the timing, the fear that saying it would cost us the thing we already had, which was real, and good, and which I valued too much to risk carelessly. I don't think that fear was wrong, exactly. I think it was incomplete. I think I let it make a decision that should have belonged to both of us, and I'm sorry for that. I've been sorry for it, quietly, for years, the way I'm sorry for things I've decided not to fix.
I used to imagine it sometimes, late, when I couldn't sleep — a version where I actually said it, out loud, in real time, with your actual face in front of me instead of a blank page. I could never get the imagined version of you to react in a way that felt true. My brain kept defaulting to the safest outcome, you laughing it off gently, both of us deciding it didn't have to change anything, because that was the version that let me keep imagining it without it costing me the rest of what we had. I never let myself imagine the other version. I think that tells you something about me too.
If you're reading this, it means I ran out of time to fix it. I want to be plain about what that means, because I think plainness is the only thing I actually owe you at this point. After everything I didn't say when I had the chance. It means I'm gone, and it means the last twelve years of loving you happened almost entirely in a register you never got to hear, and it means I let that happen— not through bad luck but through a long accumulation of small choices, each one individually defensible, that added up to a life where I loved you completely and told you almost nothing. I don't have a way to make that right anymore except this.
So. For the record. In my own hand, dated, so there's no ambiguity about when I meant it:
I love you. I have loved you since before I had good enough language to describe what that meant, and I kept loving you through every year I didn't say it, and I loved you tonight, at two in the morning, writing this instead of sleeping, and if there's a version of me that exists past whatever happens in this warehouse in four hours, that version loves you too, because this isn't the kind of thing that resolves into something smaller. It's just the truest fact I have about myself, and I've spent a decade being a coward about a fact.
I don't know what I want you to do with this. I don't think I get a vote, honestly, given the circumstances that must be true for you to be reading it at all. I think I just wanted, once, for the truest thing about me to exist somewhere outside my own head, in case my own head stopped being a reliable place to keep it.
Don't blame yourself for not knowing. There was nothing to know— I made sure of that, carefully, for twelve years, and if I did my job as well as I usually do, you had no reason to suspect any of this, and that was deliberate, and it was mine to carry, not yours.
Be the version of yourself that tells the truth faster than I did. You're better at that than I am. You always have been.
I keep thinking about my box itself, honestly, in these last few minutes before I have to go get ready. Twelve letters, one drawer. I used to tell myself I was being responsible, keeping this contained, not making you carry something you never asked to carry. I think now that I was mostly being a coward, and I'd like the record— my own record, the only one I apparently trust enough to write anything down in— to reflect that too. I was scared. I stayed scared for years. That's not a flattering thing to know about yourself and I'm writing it here anyway, because if this is the last honest thing I get to say, I'd rather it include the parts that don't make me look good.
I'm going to fold this up and put it in the box with the others now, the way I always do, telling myself I'll deal with it later, that there'll be time to figure out what to do with all of it eventually.
I hope there's time.
If there isn't—
I loved you. All the way through. I'm sorry it took this to say it properly.
Tim
—
Kon sat on the floor of Tim's room a long time after he finished.
His whole body had gone strange and unfamiliar, the way it sometimes did after a fight that had asked more of him than he had to give— a ringing hollowness behind his sternum, his pulse loud enough in his own ears that it took him a moment to register it as his pulse and not some external sound. His hands were shaking. He watched them shake, distantly, the way he'd watched Cass’ blank face in the yard three days ago, some part of him still cataloging even while another part of him had come apart completely.
He was aware, distantly, of the house continuing below him, a pipe somewhere ticking as it cooled, the ordinary machinery of a house at night going on because it didn't know how to stop. He was aware of the letter in his hands, the ink slightly smudged in one corner where his thumb had pressed too hard without his noticing, and he was aware, underneath all of it, of a grief so large it had stopped behaving like an emotion and started behaving like weather instead, something with no edges he could locate, something he was simply inside of now, the way you're inside a season.
His chest hurt. Not figuratively— an actual, physical ache low in his sternum, tight enough that for one disoriented second he genuinely checked whether something had happened to him, whether some injury he hadn't noticed sustaining had finally announced itself, before he understood that this was just what this felt like, apparently, grief with nowhere left to go, converting itself into something his body had decided to treat as an injury because it didn't have a better category to file it under.
He thought about the roof. He thought about the blanket, about Tim's laugh, about a decade of overchecked variables and a box that had sat hidden under a drawer for years, waiting for no one to find it, until grief made him careless enough that he did.
He thought: he was going to tell me.
The thought arrived and then arrived again, looping, insistent, refusing to resolve into anything he could set down. Not might have. Was going to. There had been an intention, a direction, a future in which the sentence got said out loud in daylight with Tim's actual voice instead of ink on a page, and that future had existed, had been real enough to write about, right up until it wasn't.
He thought: he ran out of time.
His breath had gone strange, too fast and too shallow, and he made himself slow it down the way he'd once been taught, in, hold, out, a technique that had never worked especially well on him and worked even worse now, and somewhere in the third or fourth repetition he stopped trying to control it at all.
He thought, and this was the one that broke something loose in his chest that had held since the first terrible hour of this, since every minute of composure he'd been rationing out for other people's sake in a house too full of its own grief to hold his as well: he loved me the whole time, and he never got to watch my face while he said it, and I never got to say it back.
He cried, finally, alone on the floor of Tim's room with the letter still in his hands, the way he hadn't let himself since the first night— not managed, not rationed, not held to some decent size for the benefit of anyone else who also needed holding. It came up out of him in a way that felt almost violent, a full-body thing, his shoulders shaking, some sound leaving his throat he didn't recognize as his own voice, raw and low and entirely involuntary, and he let it, because there was no one there to see it and because some deeper animal part of him had simply run out of the strength it took to hold the shape of composure any longer. It went on a long time, and nobody came to check on him, because nobody in the house knew there was anything to check on.
His body had started to ache in the way exhaustion produces when grief has been running through it for hours without pause— a deep, bone-level tiredness in his shoulders and along his spine, muscles that didn't usually register fatigue at all now heavy and reluctant, and he let himself lean back fully against the side of the bed, the letters gathered loosely against his chest, and simply existed there for a while, not reading, not thinking in any organized way, just being a body in a room that used to have someone else's life happening in it.
He read the earlier letters again after that, all of them, in order this time, watching Tim's handwriting change year over year the way you watch a photograph age, and by the time he reached the last one again it didn't hit any less hard the second time— if anything his body had less resistance built up against it now, no reserve left to soften the blow, so that the second read landed somehow rawer than the first, his eyes stinging before he'd even reached the date in the corner. He understood it probably never would stop landing that way.
—
He didn't leave the room again that night.
He sat with his back against the bed frame and the letters spread around him in the order he'd read them, the box within reach, and he stayed like that long after his own thoughts had stopped arranging themselves into anything as organized as sentences, long after the window had gone from black to the charcoal blue that comes right before a Gotham morning.
Alfred found him there near dawn.
Kon didn't hear the door open— hadn't heard much of anything for hours, the whole world narrowed to the twelve pages spread across the floor around him — and when he looked up Alfred was simply there in the doorway, in his dressing gown, an expression on his face that took in the broken drawer and the letters and Kon's own wrecked, hollowed-out stillness all at once, and seemed to understand, without needing any of it explained, exactly what he was looking at.
He didn't ask. That, in itself, was its own kind of mercy.
"I'll bring you some tea," Alfred said, quietly, and did, and when he came back he set the cup down within reach and settled into the chair by the desk without being invited, the way you settle in beside a person you don't want to leave alone with a thing this size, and didn't say anything else. Kon didn't either. They sat together as the window slowly lightened from black to grey to the deep, cold blue of an early Gotham morning, and neither of them needed the quiet to be filled.
After a while, Alfred spoke, not looking at the letters, looking instead at the broken drawer, the wood split clean along its old seam.
"I always wondered," he said, "why he kept that drawer locked so tight when nothing else in this house ever was." He was quiet a moment. "I never asked him. I told myself it wasn't my business, whatever he was keeping in there, and I think some part of me suspected I already knew the shape of it, even without knowing the details." He glanced, briefly, at Kon, something gentle and unbearably sad in it. "I am sorry I never asked him, Mister Kent. I think, had I asked, he might have told me. He was better at honesty than he ever gave himself credit for, when someone finally made it easy enough."
"He wasn't good at making it easy for himself," Kon said.
"No," Alfred agreed. "He rarely was."
"I would have said it back," Kon said, quietly, mostly to the box in his lap and not really to Alfred at all. "I need you to know that. Whatever else— I would have said it back. Every single time."
Alfred's hand, when he set it briefly on Kon's shoulder, was steadier than his own voice had been a moment before. "I believe you," he said. "I think, in whatever way matters now, he believes you too."
Before he began folding them away, Kon laid all twelve letters out flat across the floor in front of him, side by side, in order, and looked at the whole shape of it at once— a decade of Tim's handwriting evolving letter by letter across the floorboards, tighter to looser, younger to older, an entire silent history laid bare in ink — and something in his chest ached in a way that had gone past sharp into something duller and more permanent, a kind of ache he suspected he was going to be carrying for a very long time.
Eventually, because it was the only thing he had ever really known how to do with grief this size, Kon began folding the letters back into their thirds, one at a time, careful with each the way Tim had been careful, and set them back in the box, and closed the lid.
He didn't know yet what he was going to do with any of it. He only knew that he intended to keep going, the way he always had, and that for the first time in three days, in the grey hour before sunrise, with Alfred quiet beside him and the box closed in his lap, he thought he might actually be able to.