Work Text:
The fluorescent lights of Willington’s Department Store hum softly, casting a stark, sanitized glow over the polished linoleum aisles. Ernie Cumberbatch runs a broad, calloused hand over his chin, his dark eyes scanning the hardware section for a specific set of brass hinges. He shifts his heavy shoulders under his denim jacket, the familiar ache of a hard day’s work as an auto mechanic pulling at his back. Nearby, a security guard in a crisp navy uniform paces with deliberate slowness. The guard’s gaze is heavy, fixed squarely on the back of Ernie’s neck, mirroring his every turn through the store with unyielding scrutiny. Ernie turns down aisle four; the guard follows, hand resting casually near his hip belt.
Ernie pauses, reaching for a box of wood screws, only to hear the squeak of rubber soles right behind him. The guard leans against an endcap display, pretending to inspect a box of drill bits while keeping a sharp, hawkish eye on Ernie’s hands. The silent accusation hangs thick in the air, smothering and unmistakable. Ernie’s jaw tightens, a hot spark of indignity flaring beneath his quiet exterior. He shifts the item in his hands, only for the guard to take a slow, deliberate step closer, invading his personal space with a cold, performative dominance.
Later that afternoon, the front door of 704 Hauser Street slams shut with enough force to rattle the glass windowpanes. Ernie storms into the living room, tossing his heavy keyring onto the side table. His face is flushed, his breathing thick with unspent rage as he paces the floral carpet. His wife, Rose, steps out from the kitchen, wiping her hands on an apron, while their son, Thurgood "Goodie" Cumberbatch, looks up from a stacks-of-paper desk setup where a portable radio plays Thomas Sowell audio commentary at low volume.
"I can't even buy a set of hinges in this neighborhood without some rent-a-cop tracking me like I'm on a wanted poster!" Ernie booms, his hands gesturing wildly toward the ceiling. "Five feet away, staring at my hands the whole damn time! Following me down every single aisle like I'm carrying a crowbar!"
Goodie sighs loudly, leaning back in his chair and adjusting his wire-rimmed glasses. He shakes his head with a cool, intellectual detachment. "Dad, come on. You're completely blowing this out of proportion. The man is just doing his job. Store security has protocols. Retail theft is at an all-time high in Queens, and they have a fiduciary duty to monitor patrons. It isn't personal; it's basic risk management."
"Risk management?!" Ernie’s voice hits a fever pitch, his broad chest heaving as he glares down at his son. "He wasn't managing risk, Goodie, he was managing *me*! He looked at my skin and saw a criminal! And you sit there in your vest and tie, talking about 'fiduciary duty' while your own father gets treated like a thief?!"
"He doesn't know you from Adam, Pop!" Goodie counters, standing up to meet his father's gaze with rigid, stubborn conviction. "You can't expect the system to bend its safety regulations just because it happens to be you. He was following protocol."
The room falls into a heavy, suffocating silence. Rose steps forward, warningly saying, "Ernie, now calm down—" but Ernie has already reached his breaking point.
The absolute lack of solidarity from his own flesh and blood cuts deeper than the insult at the department store. "Just doing his job, huh?" Ernie mutters, his voice dropping into a dangerous, icy register.
He strides over to the built-in bookshelf beside the armchair—a shelf dedicated entirely to Goodie’s prized collection of Black history books, thick hardcovers detailing the Civil Rights movement, biographies of W.E.B. Du Bois, and legal treatises. Ernie grabs a huge stack into his arms.
"Dad! What are you doing?!" Goodie snaps, his composure breaking into panic.
"If you think the system is so fair and everyone's just doing their duty, then you don't need any of these," Ernie growls, sweeping the rest of the volumes into a cardboard box resting by the hall closet. "You don't deserve to read about the fight when you're so damn eager to bow down to the overseer!"
Ignoring Goodie’s frantic protests and Rose’s desperate attempts to intervene, Ernie grabs the box, marches out the front door, and drives off to leave them at the local community center giveaway bin.
By early evening, the heavy tension still lingers in the living room like thick smoke. The front door opens, breaking the uneasy quiet. Cherlyn Markowitz walks in, holding her six-month-old son, Gaara, securely in a front-facing carrier, a large canvas tote bag slung over her shoulder. Her hair is tied back in a loose clip, and her expression is uncharacteristically grim.
"Hey," Cherlyn says softly to Rose, who gives her a tired, grateful smile from the kitchen doorway. Goodie is sitting on the sofa, staring blankly at the floorboards, looking thoroughly defeated. Cherlyn unstraps Gaara, cradling the squirming infant against her shoulder. "My mom called the store owners," Cherlyn announces, her voice steady and deliberate. "Since my parents have known the Willington family for twenty years, I managed to get something."
From her tote bag, she pulls out a black, unlabeled VHS cassette. Ernie enters from the kitchen, holding a mug of dark coffee, his eyes narrowing as he spots the tape in her hand.
"What's that?" Ernie asks gruffly.
"It's the closed-circuit security tape from Willington's," Cherlyn replies, setting it on the coffee table. "From three o'clock today. The exact time you were in the hardware section."
Without waiting for permission, Cherlyn steps over to the wooden cabinet housing the TV and VCR. She pops the cassette into the slot. The VCR whirs to life, high-pitched mechanical clicks filling the room as the television screen flickers from static into a grainy, black-and-white camera angle overlooking the hardware aisle. Cherlyn grabs the remote, hitting fast-forward until the time stamp in the bottom right corner reads *15:12:04*.
She sits down in her designated armchair near the window, unbuttoning her blouse to begin nursing Gaara. The baby settles quietly into her lap, latching on under a light blanket as the rest of the family gathers in a tight semicircle around the glowing screen. The footage plays. The quality is rough, but the scene is indisputably clear. Ernie appears on screen, looking at a shelf of brass hardware. Seconds later, the security guard walks into the frame. The guard does not look at the merchandise; his eyes are locked onto Ernie.
As Ernie moves down the aisle, the guard tailgates him, standing barely two feet behind his shoulder. Meanwhile, directly in the foreground—just inches away from the guard’s back—a young woman in a trench coat walks up to a display. She looks around casually, reaches into her coat, pulls out three expensive power tool boxes, and slides them directly into the storage compartment of a baby stroller parked next to her. She does it slowly, unhurriedly, completely unbothered.
The security guard never turns around. His focus remains entirely, obsessively fixated on Ernie.
"Look at that," Rose breathes, pressing a hand to her mouth. "She's taking half the aisle, and he doesn't even blink."
Ernie stands silently, arms crossed over his chest, his jaw muscles working as he watches his on-screen double realize he is being stalked. On the tape, the black-and-white Ernie turns around, his hands throwing up in righteous fury as he begins yelling at the guard, shouting over the blatant injustice before turning on his heel and storming out of the frame.
"See?" Ernie says softly, his voice heavy with a grim, hollow victory. "Just doing his job, right, Thurgood?"
Goodie looks at the floor, his mouth pressed into a thin line, unable to meet his father's eyes. But the tape isn't finished.
Cherlyn doesn't stop the cassette. "Keep watching," she says quietly, supporting Gaara’s head against her breast.
On the screen, after Ernie storms out of the frame, the camera continues to roll. The security guard stands there, looking ruffled. Then, a younger figure enters the frame—Goodie. The tape captures Goodie stepping up to the guard, putting his hands out in a soothing, placating gesture. Goodie speaks to the guard with an anxious deference, patting the man's shoulder, visibly bowing his head and offering a prolonged, submissive apology on his father's behalf. On screen, the guard nods patronizingly, patting Goodie on the back before Goodie turns and meekly follows his father out the store exit.
A terrible, suffocating silence drops over the living room of 704 Hauser Street.
Ernie stares at the screen, the shadow of disappointment on his face far heavier than the anger he had displayed hours earlier. He looks at his son, says absolutely nothing, and turns his head toward the window, looking out into the dim twilight of Queens. Cherlyn adjusts the blanket over little Gaara, her gaze fixed entirely on her boyfriend.
Her voice, when she speaks, is cut with a sharp, uncompromising clarity. "I called in a favor from my family to get this tape because I wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt, Thurgood," Cherlyn says, her Jewish-New York cadence sharp and laced with profound disappointment. "I thought maybe it was just a misunderstanding. But look at you on that screen."
Goodie shifts uncomfortably, adjusting his collar. "Cherlyn, I was just trying to de-escalate the situation—"
"You were apologizing for your father's humanity!" Cherlyn interrupts, her tone dropping into a firm, intense whisper so as not to startle the nursing baby in her arms. "Your father was being degraded, profiled, and racially targeted while a real crime happened right under that guy's nose. And instead of standing by your dad, you went back and apologized to the man who insulted him!"
Goodie looks between his mother, his father, and Cherlyn, his defensive posture crumbling under the collective weight of their gaze. "I thought... I thought keeping the peace was the mature thing to do," he stammers, his voice barely audible over the hum of the television screen playing static.
"That isn't keeping the peace, Thurgood. That's compliance," Cherlyn says firmly, looking down at tiny Gaara, who has fallen fast asleep against her chest. She gently buttons her shirt and cradles their son close to her heart. "Look at your son. He's biracial. He's going to grow up in this exact same world, facing people who will look at him the exact same way that guard looked at your father today." She looks up, her eyes locking onto Goodie's with fierce, unyielding seriousness. "Is this the lesson you want Gaara to learn from you? That when the world treats him like a suspect for no reason, his own father is going to stand there and apologize to the person holding the collar?"
Goodie sits frozen, the words hanging heavily in the room. He looks at his mother's solemn face, at his father's turned back, and finally down at his sleeping baby son. For the first time all day, the young conservative activist has nothing left to say.