Adult Content Warning
This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.
-
With Great Pretending Comes Great Feelings by foreverparkers
Fandoms: Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Punisher (TV 2017)
05 Oct 2026
Tags
Summary
You've been crushing on Peter Parker for a few months now, but there's one small problem. You've noticed that his heart seems to belong to someone else.
So when the opportunity to fake a relationship with him comes along, you convince Peter Parker to date you. After all, if you can't actually have Peter Parker, maybe pretending to be his girlfriend is the next best thing, and maybe somewhere along the way, you'll realize you don't actually like him.
It's supposed to be simple. Fake dates. Fake kisses. Fake feelings.
But somewhere between the pretending, the late-night conversations, and the moments that start feeling a little too real, you realize you may have gotten herself into something you can't fake your way out of.
And Peter? He might be starting to realize that the girl he thought was only pretending to like him... is the girl he can't imagine living without.