Archive of Our Own

Recent works

• Benny's "Mystery Girl" by DianaPaxerva

  Fandoms: The Sandlot (1993)  

  • General Audiences
  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • M/M
  • Complete Work

  22 Apr 2026

  Tags

  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • Benjamin Franklin Rodriguez/Scotty Smalls
  • Scotty Smalls
  • Benjamin Franklin Rodriguez
  • Hamilton "Ham" Porter
  • Micheal "Squints" Palledorous
  • Alan "Yeah-Yeah" McClennan
  • Kenny DeNunez
  • Timmy Timmons
  • Tommy "Repeat" Timmons
  • Bertram Grover Weeks
  • Mr Mertle
  • Hercules the dog
  • Post-Canon
  • Aged-Up Character(s)
  • Secret Crush
  • Baseball
  • Mutual Pining
  • References to Ancient Greek Religion & Lore
  • Racism

  Summary

  Benny won't stop talking about this girl that he is obsessed with. The issue is that everyone seems to know who she is, except Smalls. Mr Mertle helps out along the way.

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  1,524

  Chapters:

  1/1

  Comments:

  3

  Kudos:

  37

  Hits:

  243