NotTheOnly
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
After the chaos in St. Louis, Colter insists on seeing - Reenie safely back to her hotel. One night of shared quiet, bruises, and unspoken history forces them to face what neither has said since their first night together — and what it might mean if Colter finally stopped running.
(A missing scene from Season 1, Episode 5: St. Louis)Bookmarked by NotTheOnly
27 Aug 2026
-
Tags
Summary
After a harrowing case, Colter ends up at Reenie's door, distraught and in need of comfort.
Bookmarked by NotTheOnly
27 Aug 2026
-
Tags
Summary
When a photo of Dory arrives with a threat attached, Colter decides not to tell anyone. It doesn't stay that simple.
Bookmarked by NotTheOnly
27 Aug 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Episode tag s2.ep.5 "Preternatural". Once again Colter seems very badly hurt and has just shrugged off the physical and mental trauma by the next episode. This explores what happens if it wasn't quite so easy, that there are complications about leaving trails of blood and bodies. Maybe Colter needs more help than he realised.
A/N everyone was so lovely with the last story, thankyou so much for your comments and kudos! Writing again some Colter / Reenie hurt comfort because I think the show needs more of it! Also, I am British, i've tried to keep the wording as American as possible but also apologies if my details of US police procedure isn't right, it's pretty different over here!
Bookmarked by NotTheOnly
14 Aug 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Episode tag s1.ep.5 "St Louis". What happened between the rooftop and the hospital? Colter had taken a lot of hits in the last couple of days and needs to recover and, as always, his instinct is to go it alone. Sometimes, maybe even the great Colter Shaw needs a little help.
Mainly canon compliant, written just after it aired so no knowledge of later developments, also took some liberties with background of characters. A/N. This is my first ever fanfiction so any thoughts, comments or encouragement very welcome! Also, apologies I am British, so since it's an American show I have tried to use American words ("sidewalk" for "pavement", "Tylenol" for paracetamol, "sweater" for "jumper" etc) but I may have missed some, plus i couldn't bear to fully go for American spellings, so sorry if you have to cope with what feel like extra vowels in random places!
Bookmarked by NotTheOnly
14 Aug 2026