Chapter Text
“So...tell me Prudence. What do you guys do out of the Academy?”
Weird Sisters, four of them were sitting on couches whilst they waited for their next class. Dorcas was passing time by braiding Agatha’s hair and Prudence was peeking at a warlock boy that Sabrina had yet to be introduced to.
“We? Huh...you know the answer, Sabrina. After all, you were a participant once, don’t you remember?”
Sabrina couldn’t hide her smirk as the memory became clearer, “Ah yes. Tormenting mortal boys, how could I forget? I was just thinking, we should do something out of here. Doesn’t it sound like a nice idea?”
With this, Sabrina caught and held all of Prudence’s interest as the taller girl straightened on the couch that she was laying so that she could get a better look at Sabrina.
“Very interesting offers from you I must say, but we never say no to such an entertainment like this. What do you say girls? “ she directed her question to Dorcas and Agatha who by this times were already looking intrigued.
Dorcas smiled with joy and nodded, “It has been a long time. The last time was the Baxter mudbloods with Sabrina.”
Agatha suddenly turned them with a coy smirk and a glint in her eyes, “Since this is Sabrina’s full offical torment, let’s make it kinda special. I haven’t eat some mortal meat for a long time. And also Father Blackhood told it is good for a witch’s health.”
Prudence’s smile widened with Agatha’s words, “And as you know Sabrina, your sister Agatha was a wreck not that long ago. Some mortal flesh would do her well. What do you say?”
Sabrina could feel the challenge behind the words but there was also something else. This was their way of showing that they would accept her. Sabrina was reminded once more that they were not like Roz, Susie or Harvey and that they had their own ways to show their acceptance. Evidently, that acceptance was a meal centred around a mortal main course. So Sabrina would take their hand.
“You know what, girls...” she continued, “aunt Zelda always says the most delicious part of a human body is...heart.”
——————————————————
“Guys...Why Riverdale?”
“So much happened lately in our town.”
“If heartless, ” Prudence seized the word and Dorcas laughed, “boys appears suddenly, our existence may be in danger. Out of Greendale is better...for now.”
Sabrina shrugged. There was no difference for her.
While four was walking, center of the town appeared with all those lights. There were people around the place called Pop’s Chock’lit Shoppe.
“A chocolate shop?”
“Nope. Just a local diner. But milkshakes are great,” Agatha answered.
Sabrina had never been in Riverdale before. She wasn’t sure that was exactly a bad thing either, she decided as she looked around and took in the sights.
“The honour is yours if you would like it. After all Sabrina, this is your first supper..”
Sabrina turned her head to Pop’s with a one sided smile, “Yeah...I’d love to.”
The bell above the door rang as the four girls entered the diner. They carried themselves like the powerful beings that they were, creating an aura as they walked together. This aura was so captivaitng that it held the attention of everyone in the modest diner, just the thing they intended to do. They made their way to the bar and occupied 4 of the high chairs. An old man with a ridiculous white hat appeared in front of them, in the other saide of the bar.
“How can I help you misses?”
“One vanilla,”
“One chocolate,”
“One banana,”
“One strawberry.”
They each relayed their order in the matter that Sabina had grown accustomed to. İn fact, she rather enjoyed how in sync they were. They were always synchronised in their own badass way. After their order, they turned to each other once more before a group of jocks wearing yellow and blue jackers with a huge R letter printed on it came in, bringing with them their loud laughters and noise. The boys made their way to the counter where one placed their order, raising his voice unnecessarily.
“Hi, Pop’s! Same for all of us! Chocolate!”
The boys made their way to a table, the laughter never ceasing. Sabrina gazed at them before she turned to Sisters. They all nodded with a slight head shake. She picked up her strawberry milkshake and made her way to the boys’ table.
When four boys realized Sabrina was there, they stopped chatting and looked at the witch. Sabrina held her glass for them to see and then she slackened her hand, leaving the glass at the hands of gravity.
With a deafening noise, glass hit the floor and she watched as her milkshake spread through the spaces between the tiled floo, leaving a pink foamy puddle at her feet.
“Oops,” she said, directing the boys’ attention to her once more.
“Now I should buy another one.” she said with a pleased voice, never once beaking the eye contact she held with the one jock who placed the group’s initial order.
She assumed that he was their leader of sorts. He was also the first to snap out of the trance like state whereas the other boys were still very much captivated by the witch.
“Let me buy one for you. On me, for a beautiful lady like you who I never seen in the town before.”
The Spellman girl smirked before responding.
“That would be sweet. Thank you...” she waited a second for letting him fill the silence.
“It’s Chuck. Chuck Clayton.”
“Well, Charles. Maybe you have some friends to accompany my friends and myself?”
Chuck let his eyes drift past Sabrina to the other three girls who were sat atop their high chairs at the bar.
“Of course, I do,” he says as he angles his body in the direction of the boys he came in with.
“Fellas...there are some ladies who need our company.”
“We hav always wanted to see Sweetwater River. I’ve seen the billboards and signs about it. Will you boys do us the honour of taking us there?”
They smiled each other playfully.
“Of course we will. İt will be our pleasure.”
“Well in that case, what are we waiting for? There is no need to wait I think. My friends are really excited. We can just have the milkshake another time, Charles.”
——————————————
The group made their way through the woods, and when they all paused at the riverbank, Sabrina made her way to Pudence, voicing the thought she’d held on to for the longest while.
“Pru, do we really need kill them all?”
“What do you mean Sabrina, this was all your idea.”
“I know and I am still eager to torment them all but maybe we should hold back on the killing. Perhaps we can do two yeah? İf we kill the lot of them, it might look a bit too suspicious.”
“Believe me sweetheart, Riverdale is right under Greendale on the whole weirdness scale. What’s a couple muders?” Prudence’s lips lifted in a smirk.
“Still...” Sabrina insisted.
“Alright. İf you’d really like. We’ll torment the four but we’ll kill two. İs that a deal? At least they’re footballers. That means we can share their hearts. We never share our kills otherwise.”
Sabrina couldn’t argue with that and she had to be the slightest bit proud of her negotiating skills. She agreed with Prudence and told the taller girl as much, also telling her that she will be the one to do the actual killing. Once that had been agreed upon, Sabrina made her way back to the boys who were being guided by Dorcas and Agatha
A little further on, Sarbina was psyching herself up for what was about to come. Minutes late, she stopped and pointed beyond a wall of trees, an excited grin on her face as she said, “I think I saw something in there. Let’s go Charles. It may be a deer!”
“Umm... I don’t see anything. Are you sure you saw something? İt is kind of dark.”
“ Oh don’t be such a spoil spot. C’mon! I haven’t ever seen a deer before!”
She grabbed his hand tighter and pulled him along, passing the barrier of trees to where she was pointing earlier. Before passing through the trees she glanced back at her sisters and Sabrina saw Pru, Dorcas and Agatha taking the boys into other parts of the woods just like she was doing with Chuck. She turned back to Chuck and they continued moving forward. Whilst they were walking, Sabrina wondeed how she would cast her spell. This spell in particular was designed to play a trick on the mundane mind, making them see the trees as monsters and decaying corpses. She whispered the words very quickly.
“Mortuum arbor sollicitus somnum exterreri.”
Sabrina kissed Chuck suddenly. He closed his eyes while spell was activating. Chuck held her waist and pulled her closer and started to try to deepen the kiss. Sabrina responded until she was sure that the spell was ready and then she pushed him to the ground. As he was caught up in the kiss, he was distracted, and fell down. Once on the ground, he began to look around and upon realising the trees, he started screaming. He jumped to his feet in orde to get away from a bush but he jumped directly into a tree and that was how Sabrina made a mortal cry. This should have pleased the witch but Sabrina had to admit that a part of her still had compassion for mortals. She also knew that this part of her would soon be destroyed.
“I’m sorry Chuck. The only thing I can do for you is to give you a quick death. You’re unlucky, that you accepted my offer. You are lucky that you are with me because if my sister would have you, she was going to give you a painful death. I really am sorry.”
Since Sabrina signed her name on the Book of Beast, she had some weird symptoms. Especially this drive for blood and pain. Her drive to blood was quickly erasing this compassion and affection she once held for the mortals. In one smooth motion, Sabrina tore into his shirt and dug her nail into his skin, and kept digging until she felt her fingers gasp the had bone after the soft flesh. İn that moment, a black mist appeared just like an aura and surrounded Sabrina.
She twisted the hand that held his rib, effectively breaking it and allowing her entrance to his heart. She held Chuck’s beating heart, feeling the muscle contract and expand as it tried to bleed life into him. Then she ripped it off from his chest. When she extracted the heart, a fountain of blood sprayed out onto her red dress and platinum colored hair. She looked down at the heart that was laying in her hand and then she looked at the body that lay at her feet. Walking away, she snapped her fingers and Chuck’s body went up in flames.
By the time she returned to her sisters, they were done. Sabrina gave the heart to Prudence.
“I have no apetite, sis. Enjoy your meal.”