Actions

Work Header

Regular people (made us who we were)

Summary:

“John Rose,” he said, offering her a handshake, here at his party. He behaved like someone who wore a suit to work.

“Moira Callahan.”

Notes:

Thanks for the prompt, Aelia_Weasley! The request:

 

In the Girl's Night episode we heard a little bit about how Moira got Johnny's attention. I'd love a fic about their first meeting!

 

You also requested a Gen fic, and this is Teen, so I wanted to let you know that the chapters of the fic that specifically fill your prompt are Gen (or anything in them that might not be is mentioned in the episode, like it takes place in a bar and there’s some non-specific discussion of hooking up with John Cougar Mellencamp in the corner). That’s chapters 1, 4, and 7. Chapters 3 and 6 are also quite Gen; 2 and 5 have (low-key, Teen-rated) vague drug use and mentions of sex.

Thanks to deathbysandblk for beta reading. (Any errors or things you don't like are on me, obviously.)

Chapter 1: 1980

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Making friends with Sharon had been worth the trouble, no question about that. If only Moira could get her makeup right, this would be the sort of party she’d imagined when she thought about New York. She’d never even been into the Carlyle before: when she’d first come here, she’d been sure that they would recognize her immediately as someone who didn’t belong, and she’d been right. And since then, well, she’d learned to live alongside that kind of glamour. But tonight she had a reason to go. She’d been invited.

Moira had been spending most of her nights out at the Mudd Club lately, hoping to catch a glimpse of Debbie Harry. And there were plenty of nights out; after all, the alternative was a night in. Partying at the Mudd Club, she basked in the self-assuredness of the punks and the artists who came out to be seen in all their strangeness. Twenty-six—twenty, if anyone asked—felt so horrifically old to be where she was, never sure of the next job, living in an apartment with one bedroom and five other girls so that she waited until the buses all got back on their morning schedules before she even tried to make it home. She'd been in the city ten years, and while it was a thrill to find herself acting, the job was no more reliable than any of her others. Technically she could move out now, but there was nothing to say she wouldn't be crawling back in a few months. The way the people talked at the Mudd Club made her hunger feel glamorous, like if she was struggling, at least it might be worth something. Moira had never been especially drawn to art for art’s sake, which seemed demanding, but it made her feel better, like going into a church did if she missed her aunt Mary, and no matter that since she came here she hadn’t given a single thought to God.

But as much as her usual nightly crowd might look down on it, Moira couldn’t say no to luxe. Someone had invited Sharon’s boyfriend to the bar at the Carlyle, and he had invited Sharon, and Sharon had invited her. Someone else, someone who knew the boyfriend, would buy Moira’s $10 cocktails. Sharon had laughed about it the way they’d always made fun of rich people, He’s hosting a party at the Carlyle, can you even imagine, the sort of thing you said to remember that the absurdity of the wealthy was off-limits to you. But Moira was getting better and better at pretending she deserved that kind of access, the kind that followed from recognizable glamour. Moira had ended up at all sorts of fancy gatherings in New York, though after all of them she’d ended up in her room with the two abutting bunk beds. When she went to the Mudd Club and other real art scene events, she always kept her eye out for shifts in trend, a new look on someone else that might flatter her, a style falling out of favor; likewise, at upscale gatherings, she kept an eye out for looks she could mimic cheaply, hairstyles the other guests admired, mannerisms gaining prominence. The work had paid off, she knew it had. Tonight—and having finished applying her makeup, she looked it over critically, but it was perfect—she would look just like she belonged at Bemelmans.

There were enough coins in her handbag; she added tonight’s lipstick. It was two buses and a train to the Carlyle, where she would meet Sharon and go in together.

 

Sharon left her almost immediately. The boyfriend, whose name Moira hadn’t chosen to catch—Aaron or Eric, something with a vowel, she was pretty sure—was surrounded by friends, and he politely introduced one of them—Dan? Don?—to Moira before carting Sharon off to be displayed to the rest. Sharon would be engaged soon: the way she was dressed tonight, she had every intention of it.

Dennis traded securities, which was all Moira needed to know about him; she looked around. It was a small enough party that there was no question of who was hosting: the one with the eyebrows looked practically as though he belonged here, but he was keeping a paternal eye on everyone else, making sure their drinks were full, stepping in if anyone was alone too long. He wasn’t exactly gregarious, but he seemed to know everyone and to watch out for them. In a different world, he’d have made a good hostess. When Moira caught his eye, he offered a lift of those eyebrows and a faint smile, a look of nonrecognition but also of welcome.

She’d have gone to introduce herself—Duane would keep talking at the place where she’d been standing and remain none the wiser, probably—but another woman fit herself in beside the host before Moira could get up from the table.  Her clothes were all-black, like Moira’s, but they were clearly real silk velvet, and Moira could guess from three tables over that all the chains on her neck were proper gold. Still, no need to waste time here: Moira went to the bar for another martini on the man with the face, fished out a quarter for a tip, and surveyed.

She made eye contact with a few—she made eye contact with plenty—but no one made her want to hold it. When she noticed John Cougar Mellencamp, well. He looked all right, artist enough, but he wasn’t as handsome as you’d have thought from the fame. In a bigger space, she would have ignored him, but there weren’t enough strangers like her in their party, and it would be the funniest thing she could tell Sharon about this evening—you’ll never guess who I met in a dark corner. She maintained the casual look at him until he looked back, and—oh, that was the kind of look that meant business, and she was in. He was more attractive when he made eye contact; it was harder to focus on everything else. Moira never responded to anything else like she did being wanted, and the want was plain. She didn’t put her drink down at first, but she figured Eyebrows could afford to buy her a new one later. So she walked up behind Mellencamp, put a finger on his back, and traced it slowly down.

Notes:

Moira mentions the Mudd Club in Girls’ Night. It was open from 1978 to 1983 and was an Arty spot – Keith Haring art upstairs, Basquiat a regular.

Bemelmans is the bar at the Carlyle Hotel, so, heckin’ fancy – and decorated with murals by Ludwig Bemelmans, of Madeline fame, in an art deco style otherwise. I imagine that Moira in her early days in New York would have thought of the Carlyle as the absolute height. $10 in 1981, the price Moira imagines for a cocktail, is almost $30 today; the most recent Bemelmans menu I found had the house cocktails at $21 and wine at $14-40 a glass, and I figured $10 was an amount Moira would think of as an extravagant, absurd price for a drink.

Wikipedia tells me John Cougar Mellencamp has been “active” since 1976.

I’ve chosen, for the purposes of this fic, to take Moira at her word when she talks about her past (except her age in 1979—she says she was 17 and David immediately says she wasn’t, and O’Hara would have been around 25 then), whether that’s reasonable or not. So I’m accepting that she used to be a Competent, Functioning Person and that Johnny was with someone else when they met (rather than that being something she just said to make Alexis feel better). And I'm accepting that she moved to New York at 16 with her driving instructor, did some hand modeling, worked at "a charming gas station deli," etc, and started acting at 25, in 1979. I have her meeting Johnny in 1980, and per canon, they'll get together after a year, and David will be born in 1983.

The one conflict in canon that I've resolved by ignoring some of it is that Johnny somehow only had $2000 to start Rose Video, but he also had enough money to buy the drinks at a party nice enough to be colocated with John Cougar Mellencamp when he was famous enough to recognize on the night Moira met him (and when Moira says "then I met your father and suddenly I had people to do all those things for me" it definitely implies that he was well-off when they met if not soon after), and he couldn't likely have started Rose Video by then because it wasn't until the mid-80s (after David was born! he and Moira had for sure met!) that video rental really became a thing (VHS wasn't even released in the USA until 1977). But if Johnny had lost all his money before, you'd think we'd have heard about it. So Johnny is doing well when Moira meets him, and he hasn't started Rose Video yet, and he's working for someone else (he says when he goes to file for unemployment that he's worked for himself "all his life," but I'm figuring it's okay for that to just mean "over 30 years").