Work Text:
Jack was never one to snoop, but the leather-bound journal caught his eye as it peeked out from under his father's bed. It was a quiet afternoon at the ranch, and John had ridden out to town on some errand or another, leaving Jack with an unusual sense of solitude. The sun slanted through the dusty windowpanes, casting a warm glow across the room. He could hear the distant murmur of cattle and the occasional creak of the floorboards beneath his feet as he approached the bed, curiosity gnawing at him.
With a furtive glance over his shoulder, Jack bent down and pulled out the journal. The leather was worn, the edges frayed from countless thumbings. He knew it was John's, filled with the older man's scribbled thoughts and memories. A part of him felt like he was invading sacred ground, but another part, a part that had always craved the truth about his father's feelings, couldn't resist. He flipped open the cover, revealing pages yellowed with age and time.
Jack's heart thudded in his chest as he skimmed through the entries. The first bulk of entries were from Arthur, his thoughts about the gang, and a little passage about taking Jack fishing when he was a boy. Although Jack had long forgotten his younger years, so this was like new infomation to him.
He continued flipping pages, feeling the weight of each one as if they were years of his life passing by. The handwriting grew shakier, the ink more sparse, as if John had written them with a heavy heart. Finally, Jack stumbled upon an entry with his name at the top. His eyes widened and his breath caught in his throat.
John's words, raw and unfiltered, spilled onto the page. He read about John's fears for him, his hopes, and his regrets. The sentences were short, choppy, as if John had been trying to keep his emotions in check even on paper. "Jack," the entry began, "You're the only thing that keeps me going. Sometimes I think I don't deserve you, but I swear I'll do right by you."
Jack's eyes stung with unshed tears as he took in the words. He had always felt like a burden, a constant reminder of John's past mistakes. But here, in his father's own handwriting, was a declaration of love and a silent promise to be a better man.
The room grew hot, and Jack's hand trembled as he turned the page. There, in stark contrast to the earlier entries, was a full page of apologies and confessions. John had written about his fears of not being enough, of failing Jack as a father. He spoke of his struggles with his own demons, and how Jack's innocence was the only thing that kept him from succumbing to them fully.
Jack's vision blurred as he read on, the words a testament to the silent battles John had been fighting. "I know you think I don't care," the entry continued, "but I do. More than you'll ever know. I just don't know how to show it."
Jack felt a lump form in his throat. He had always longed for this kind of acknowledgment from his Pa, but never dared to hope for it. His eyes scanned the pages, each line revealing a piece of John Marston that he hadn't known before. The words painted a picture of a man torn between his past and his desire to be a good father, and Jack couldn't help but feel a deep connection to the pain etched into the paper.
The sound of the front door creaking open brought Jack back to reality. He quickly slammed the journal shut and shoved it back under the bed, his heart racing. He didn't want John to catch him reading his private thoughts. The footsteps grew closer, and Jack took a deep breath, trying to compose himself. He turned to face the doorway just as John stepped into the room, his eyes weary from the day's travels.
John's gaze fell upon Jack, and for a moment, the silence was deafening. Jack searched his father's eyes for any hint of what he might have discovered, but John's expression remained stoic. "You okay, son?" he asked, his voice gruff as ever.
Jack nodded, swallowing hard. "Yeah, Pa. Just cleaning up a bit." He hoped the lie didn't show on his face. The truth was, he felt like his world had been turned upside down. The man he had always seen as so strong and unyielding had bared his soul in those pages, and Jack wasn't sure how to reconcile the image of his father with the man he had just read about.
John hung his hat on the peg by the door and moved towards the bed, his boots heavy on the floorboards. Jack tensed, expecting him to notice the disturbed dust around the spot where the journal lay hidden. But John's eyes remained focused elsewhere, on the gun belt thrown haphazardly over the chair, on the half-empty whiskey bottle on the dresser.
With a sigh, John sat on the edge of the bed and began to untie his boots. "How was your day?" he asked, his voice tentative. It was a question Jack had heard a thousand times before, but now it felt loaded with meaning.
Jack took a deep breath, deciding to play along for now. "It was fine," he said, trying to keep his voice steady. "Took care of the horses, helped Uncle with some chores." He paused, watching John closely. The urge to tell him what he had found was almost unbearable, but he held back. He wasn't ready to face the storm of emotions that would come with that revelation.
John nodded, a hint of relief in his eyes. "That's good," he murmured, his calloused hands working the knots in his boot laces. He looked up at Jack, his gaze searching. "You know, I ain't always the best at this fatherin' business."
Jack felt his heart clench. He wanted to blurt out that he knew, that he had read the journal, that he understood. But instead, he managed a small smile. "You do alright, Pa," he said, the words feeling both true and like a lie on his tongue.
John's eyes searched Jack's, as if looking for something. "I hope so," he said finally, his voice low. "I just want you to have a better life than I had. Better than what I can give you here."
The tension in the room was palpable, and Jack could feel the weight of the unspoken words between them. He knew he should say something, anything, but his mind was racing with the emotions that John's journal had stirred up. The silence stretched out like a tightrope, threatening to snap at any moment.
Finally, Jack found his voice. "What do you mean, Pa?" he asked, trying to keep the tremor out of his tone.
John sighed heavily, his eyes never leaving Jack's. "I mean that I've made a lot of mistakes, son," he said, his voice filled with a world of pain and regret. "I ain't the best example to follow. I've done things..." He trailed off, shaking his head.
Jack's heart was racing, the words from the journal echoing in his mind. He knew John had a past, but to hear him speak of it so openly was something else entirely. "We all make mistakes, Pa," he said, the words sounding foreign to his own ears. "What matters is that we learn from them."
John looked up, his eyes meeting Jack's with a fierce intensity. "It ain't that simple," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. "Some mistakes can't be undone. Some things can't be forgotten."
Jack took a step closer, his hand reaching out to rest on John's shoulder. The leather of John's vest was warm under his touch, and he could feel the tension in his father's body. "I know, Pa," he said softly. "But maybe we can find a way to live with them."
John's gaze remained on the floor, his jaw clenched tight. "I hope so, Jack," he murmured. "I really do." The air in the room was thick with the unspoken words, the confessions and fears that hung between them.
Jack searched for something to say, something that would bridge the gap that had formed. "You know, Pa," he began, "I've been reading some of those books you got me."
John looked up, his eyes meeting Jack's with surprise. "You have?"
Jack nodded. "Yeah, and there's this one that says that a man's not defined by his past, but by his actions in the present."
John's gaze softened. "That's a fine thought, son," he said, his voice gruff. "But sometimes the past has a way of catching up with you."
Jack knew all too well the weight of the past. He had lived with the shadow of John's history for as long as he could remember. But he also knew that his father had been trying, in his own way, to make amends for his past. "Maybe so, Pa," he said, his voice gentle. "But if you keep running from it, you'll never outrun it. You've changed, I've seen it."
John looked up at him, his eyes searching. "You really believe that?"
Jack nodded firmly. "I do."
John was silent for a long moment, his eyes searching Jack's face as if looking for the truth in his words. "You're a good kid," he said, his voice gruff with emotion. "Better than I ever had any right to hope for."
The words hung in the air, and Jack felt a warmth spread through him that was unfamiliar but welcome. He had always known John loved him, but to hear it so plainly, without the usual gruffness or sarcastic bite, was something he hadn't expected. He opened his mouth to respond, but the words caught in his throat.
Instead, he leaned down and hugged his father, feeling the tension in John's shoulders ease slightly. John wrapped his arms around him, holding him close. The embrace was tight, almost desperate, and Jack realized that maybe John needed this as much as he did.
When they pulled apart, John cleared his throat and gave a small, sad smile. "Thanks, Jack," he said, his eyes shiny with unshed tears. "I reckon I needed to hear that."
Jack nodded, not trusting his voice. He knew he had to tell John about the journal, about the things he had read, but now didn't feel like the right time. There were too many emotions tangled up between them, and he didn't want to ruin this rare moment of vulnerability.