Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 599 of one-shots , Part 136 of ATLA and LOK one-shots , Part 248 of Therapy stories , Part 444 of Awareness stories , Part 50 of Holiday and Anniversary stories , Part 146 of LGBT Stories , Part 23 of Obsidiana's tales, Part 516 of gift fic , Part 539 of collection stories , Part 117 of Nicktoons One-shots , Part 8 of personal favs
Collections:
2022 - Awareness Challenge, Tales of Avatars Past_ A Prequel Series
Stats:
Published:
2025-05-09
Words:
1,100
Chapters:
1/1
Comments:
14
Kudos:
9
Bookmarks:
2
Hits:
350

The Mothers who Chose Me

Summary:

A heartfelt Mother’s Day story about a little girl with two moms and a grandmother who chose her. As she celebrates her unique family, she learns that love defines family, not blood or tradition, and that no amount of hate can take away the bond they share. A tribute to families in all forms.

Notes:

Kkachi95 owns the fanart.

I wrote The Mothers Who Chose Me because stories like this are long overdue. I wanted to show that families come in all shapes—and that love, not tradition, makes them whole. This is a story for every child with more than one mother, for every survivor of loss or trauma, and for every person who’s ever been told they’re ‘unnatural’ for simply loving or being loved. You are seen. You matter. And you deserve stories that reflect your joy.

 

Please answer these questions in your reviews of the story!

What flowers did Obsidiana choose for each of her moms and grandmother?

What role did her kitten Hope play in the story?

How did you feel during the breakfast scene? Did anything stand out emotionally?

How did the story challenge traditional ideas of what a family “should” look like?

What did you think of how Kyoshi responded to the rude boy at the shrine?

If you could say one thing to Obsidiana, what would it be?

What message or feeling did you take away from this story?

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

 

 

 

Kyoshi and Rangi in Flying Opera Company Makeup

 

 

 

Dawn rose slowly over the modest village Avatar Kyoshi called home. Her six-year-old daughter, Obsidiana, opened the window wide to watch the sun paint the sky with vibrant streaks of gold and rose as she finished her very first Mother’s Day gifts.

After all, not every child had two mothers and a grandmother.

It had never felt strange to her. With no memory of life before the concentration camp, she’d clung to Kyoshi and Rangi with a quiet trust that came from survival. She had accepted them—fiercely, without hesitation. Rangi’s mother, Hei-Ran, had been a more formal presence at first, but Obsidiana had claimed her too.

She paused in her work, mesmerized by the morning sky, then returned to her flower crowns. She had made one for each of them.

Grandmother Hei-Ran’s was woven with pink carnations, pink roses, and a few small sunflowers. For Mommy Rangi, she had chosen daisies and lavender. And for Kyoshi, she’d picked forget-me-nots and peonies. All three were bound together with ivy.

Obsidiana turned to her kitten, who was pawing at a stuffed turtle. “Hope? Do you think they’ll like them?” she asked, holding out the crowns.

Hope sniffed them, then purred in approval. Obsidiana giggled. “Thanks for your opinion,” she said, scooping her up.

She chose a leaf-green sundress with fire lilies embroidered along the skirt, brushed her black hair with one hundred careful strokes, and clipped her emerald headpiece into place. The obsidian pendant on her necklace—another gift from her mothers—caught the sunlight streaming through the window.

“Let’s go, Hope! We don’t want to be late,” she said, hurrying down the stairs, basket in hand.

The scent of warm spices and sweet herbs drifted from the kitchen. Sunlight spilled across the wooden floor in bright stripes.

Rangi was plating fire lily omelets, their petal-shaped edges slightly charred. Hei-Ran stirred a pot of skyberry porridge, her sleeves rolled up, her posture relaxed. Kyoshi sliced jadefruit slowly, each movement deliberate.

Obsidiana stopped in the doorway, her heart thudding. Rangi looked up first and smiled. “There’s our girl.”

Kyoshi turned next, offering that rare, quiet smile Obsidiana loved best.

“I made something,” she said, stepping forward. “Because it’s Mother’s Day. And you’re my mothers. And you’re my grandmother too,” she added, eyes on Hei-Ran.

She placed the basket on the table and gently lifted each flower crown, her small hands trembling.

“For Grandmother,” she said, holding out the crown of pink and gold.

Hei-Ran stilled. Her hands—so steady in battle, so practiced in ceremony—shook slightly as she took it.

“Pink roses,” she murmured. “My mother used to plant them outside our house.”

Obsidiana blinked. “Really?”

The old general’s expression softened. “Yes. And now they remind me of you.” Her voice caught slightly, but she recovered. “Thank you, my little warrior.”

Obsidiana’s smile grew as she turned to Rangi, lifting the daisy and lavender crown. “This one’s yours, Mommy. I wanted it to smell nice like you always do.”

Rangi crouched so Obsidiana could place it on her head. “I love it,” she said, voice warm. “Almost as much as I love you.” She pulled her into a hug.

Finally, Obsidiana turned to Kyoshi. The peony and forget-me-not crown was the one she’d spent the most time on. She stood on tiptoe, and Kyoshi bent down, allowing her to place it gently among her dark waves.

“You look like a queen,” she whispered.

Kyoshi rested her forehead to Obsidiana’s. “And you make me proud every single day.”

Hope mewed. Obsidiana giggled. “She helped. Kind of.”

They sat down to a breakfast of blossom cloud tea, lotus-stuffed buns, honey-glazed jadefruit, and roasted flatcakes. Obsidiana declared it “the best breakfast ever,” and no one disagreed.

For a while, there was only peace.

Later, they left the house together for a walk through the village. Obsidiana, still glowing from the morning, held Kyoshi’s hand. But as they passed the market square, she noticed something shift.

People stared. Whispers followed them. A few turned away with tight mouths. Others didn’t bother hiding their expressions.

Obsidiana looked up at Kyoshi, suddenly uncertain. Kyoshi gave her hand a light squeeze.

At the edge of the village stood a shrine dedicated to Alanna, the White Spirit of Life. It was tradition to leave offerings there on Mother’s Day, to thank the first mother of humankind.

Obsidiana stepped forward with a fourth flower crown—woven from the leftovers of all the others. She placed it gently on the marble head of Alanna, whose stone face smiled with calm serenity.

As they bowed their heads, another woman and her son approached. Obsidiana stepped aside, assuming they were next.

But the boy scoffed. “Do you think that brat even knows people are supposed to have a mom and a dad? Two moms? That’s disgusting.”

His mother’s eyes went wide. “Shinzu! I told you to be respectful—especially in front of the Avatar.”

“But Dad says it’s unnatural!” Shinzu said, loud and defiant. “He says people like them don’t deserve respect!”

The woman’s tone sharpened. “That’s enough.” She turned to Kyoshi and bowed low. “Avatar Kyoshi, please accept my deepest apologies. I bear your family no ill will. My husband’s ignorance clearly rubbed off on our son more than I thought.”

Kyoshi’s expression didn’t change. “You don’t need to apologize for your husband’s views. But your son does owe my daughter one.”

The woman nodded. “Shinzu. Now.”

The boy scowled at Obsidiana. “Sorry for hurting your feelings.”

It wasn’t sincere, but it was said.

Kyoshi’s family left quietly. Back home, no one spoke for a moment. Obsidiana sat curled on the couch, Hope tucked under her chin.

Hei-Ran sat beside her and gently combed her fingers through Obsidiana’s hair. “People will always think their way is the only way. But love isn’t limited by their imagination.”

Rangi crouched beside them. “Families come in all shapes. What matters is how we care for each other.”

Kyoshi knelt in front of her daughter and took her hands. “We chose you because we love you. That’s all the truth we need. And that love makes us the luckiest family in the world.”

Obsidiana’s throat tightened. “Even if people say mean things?”

Kyoshi nodded. “Even then. Especially then.”

Tears shimmered in Obsidiana’s eyes, but she smiled. Kyoshi lifted her and spun her gently through the air as the girl laughed through her tears.

The three mothers embraced her tightly, all wrapped around each other like the ivy in Obsidiana’s crowns.

And this time, no matter what the world said, Obsidiana knew exactly who she belonged to.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Notes:

What Did You Do Right?
Emotional grounding through a child’s perspective: You captured the gentle joy, innocence, and sensitivity of a child navigating love and prejudice for the first time. That’s powerful.

Chose a unique but universal setting: By setting this story in Kyoshi’s world but grounding it in a relatable, modern issue (LGBTQ+ family visibility), you built a bridge between fantasy and reality.

Balanced softness and strength: The family isn’t just loving—they’re dignified, graceful, and resilient in the face of quiet bigotry. That combination is rare and moving.

 

What Stood Out the Most?

The flower crowns.
They’re more than just cute crafts—they symbolize thoughtfulness, memory, care, and unity. Obsidiana making one for Alanna also speaks volumes about her heart and the story’s depth.

Favorite Part:

Kyoshi kneeling and telling Obsidiana, “We chose you because we love you.”
That line hit. It’s simple, but carries generations of pain and healing. The image of this towering, formidable Avatar grounding herself to reassure her child? Beautiful.

What Emotions Did I Feel?

Warmth during the breakfast scene.

Ache when the villagers stared—especially because Obsidiana doesn’t know how to process it initially.

Protectiveness when Shinzu started speaking, and pride at how the mothers handled it.

Hope at the end. It felt healing, not just for Obsidiana, but anyone who's ever felt “othered.”

Was There Realism? How Does It Reflect the Real World?
Yes—deeply so.

LGBTQ+ family dynamics are still scrutinized in many communities, even today. The discomfort of being stared at in public, the hushed comments, the subtle (or not-so-subtle) hostility—it’s all painfully real.

Intergenerational learning is also accurate. The adult apologizing for her son, acknowledging a spouse’s role in his thinking? That’s a real conversation happening in families right now.

Childlike emotional resilience—how kids pick up on tension, even if they don’t understand every word? That’s spot-on.

Character Growth & Development?

Obsidiana: Learns for the first time that not everyone will understand her family, but she’s reassured with truth and love, not platitudes.

Hei-Ran: Softens and opens up emotionally, even briefly. It shows that love is not only given—it can be grown into.

Kyoshi and Rangi: They were already strong, but you showed their maternal depth, not just as protectors but also as nurturers and educators.

Themes & Messages:
Love is a choice.

Family is made, not inherited.

Prejudice doesn’t define you—love does.

There’s no such thing as “normal,” only what’s narrow.

Children carry the heart of the future, and that heart can be kind.