Actions

Work Header

Pizzagate: Buddie Divorce 4.0

Summary:

Eddie: Buck I have never paid that much attention to how I eat pizza. I just…eat it.

Buck: k well we're all sitting down eating pizza rn so i'm gonna doordash some to you and you NEED to tell me if you fold it to eat it or not

Eddie: Why is this so important to you?

Buck: it's for science
also i need to prove a point
and win a bet
and decide how much i love you

Eddie: WAIT is there somehow a correct answer here??

Buck: well yes

or; Eddie eats his pizza wrong. Buck has feelings about it.

Notes:

i may or may not have said that i was only ever going to write the one fic. i may or may not be a lying liar who lies.

i'm in a discord server that has been having this argument about pizza for over a year now so for some reason my brain decided to write this. special thanks to @CaptainSaphfics on twt for going over this and encouraging me, BethAnne for help with the title, and Carrie/Cody for the inspo for a section of this!

i guess also thanks to the discurt for arguing about pizza for so long that it rotted my brain xo

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

[Private Messaging: Maddie and Buck]

Buck: maddie stop what you're doing this is so important

 

Maddie: I'm feeding my child

 

Buck: ok fine do that first

 

Maddie: What do you need?

 

Buck: how do you eat your pizza?

 

Maddie: Oh Jesus not this

Chim already texted me

 

Buck: gdi chimney

how could he 😩

 

Maddie: Well you're gonna like my answer just as much as he did

 

Buck: MADDIE 

NO

ET TU BRUTE??

i thought you were my sister 

i thought we were in this together 

 

Maddie: Evan relax, the way I eat my pizza does not change the fact that you are my brother and I love you 

 

Buck: but WHY

 

Maddie: Why do I fold my pizza?

 

Buck: yes

 

Maddie: Because it's too floppy otherwise

 

Buck: so you just support it with your other hand!

 

Maddie: And get TWO hands greasy??

 

Buck: the grease isn’t on the bottom of the pizza???

wtf kinda pizza are you eating mads??

 

Maddie: The normal kind?

Like when you’re in New York and you’re running around, you can’t use two hands

I’m pretty sure you’re actually *supposed* to eat New York Style pizza folded

 

Buck: ...

lemme do some research brb

 

5 minutes later

 

Buck: ……ok so you may be right

turns out you ARE supposed to fold new york style pizza bc the pieces are so wide and thin and floppy. i guess it also keeps the toppings from falling off

whatever

doesn’t mean i like it

also i refuse bc if you fold your pizza before eating it then all your mouth feels is crust and that’s icky

 

Maddie: I’m sorry Evan

Sending you my thoughts and prayers during this difficult time

 

Buck: 🖕

 

Maddie: 👼

 

Buck: ya know, at least it’s better than whatever the fuck your husband’s doing right now

 

Maddie: Oh

Yeah

The upside-down thing?

 

Buck: yeah

why tf does he do that?

 

Maddie: I dunno he says it tastes better that way?

I try not to ask too many questions

 

Buck: …i fear your husband may be broken

 

Maddie: *sigh*

I fear you may be right


 

[Private Messaging: Buck and Eddie]

Buck: hey

so

i have a question

 

Eddie: I may have an answer.

 

Buck: how do you eat your pizza?

 

Eddie: With…my hands?

 

Buck: no no 

like

do you fold your pizza?

 

Eddie: Pizza isn't laundry Buck.

Also you've seen me eat pizza a million times. 

 

Buck: ok but consider i don't remember *how* you eat your pizza 

kinda have more important things to look at when i'm with you

 

Eddie:

 

Buck: i never should've taught you about memes

ANYWAY

do you

eduardio diaz

 

Eddie: Not my name.

 

Buck: fold your pizza

 

Eddie: Buck I have never paid that much attention to how I eat pizza. I just…eat it. 

 

Buck: k well we're all sitting down eating pizza rn so i'm gonna doordash some to you and you NEED to tell me if you fold it to eat it or not

 

Eddie: Why is this so important to you?

 

Buck: it's for science

also i need to prove a point

and win a bet

and decide how much i love you 

 

Eddie: WAIT is there somehow a correct answer here??

 

Buck: well yes 

 

Eddie: Buck…

 

Buck: eddie…

whoops gotta go - we have a call, text me when you get your pizza!!

 

30 minutes later

 

Eddie: I got the pizza. 

 

Buck: great! eat it!

 

Eddie: This isn't the kind we normally get.

 

Buck: i know! it's new york style

 

Eddie: Why?

 

Buck: because that style of pizza originated in new york city 

actually, the first pizzeria in the US was opened in new york city 

it's called Lombardi's 

if we ever go to new york we should go there

 

Eddie: Buck -

No.

I love you.

But that's not what I meant.

Why did you send me THIS type of pizza?

 

Buck: oh

well that's the kind we were eating when this whole debate started 

so

pls just eat a slice before it gets cold and show me how you eat it

it's for science 

Eddie:  

 

Buck: i'm divorcing you 

 

Eddie: We're not married???

 

Buck: we're getting married tomorrow so that i can divorce you 

 

Eddie: Over pizza???


 

[Group Chat - 118 bitches!!]

Buck:   

Hen: …what

 

Chim: ooooh can Jee be the flower girl??

wait

 

Eddie: You have GOT to be kidding me. 

 

Bobby: Buck, please stop changing the group chat name. - Bobby Nash

 

Ravi: wait…were you two not already married??

 

Chim: ravioli you've been here for four years, keep up

 

Hen: I'm guessing this means you did not in fact find someone who eats their pizza like an animal like you

 

Buck: how dare you

i eat like a human being

 

Hen:   

whatever, enjoy my latrine duty pretty boy

 

Buck: ugh 🙄

 

Chim: I still think my method is superior

 

Hen: No

 

Ravi: no

 

Buck: no

 

Bobby: No. - Bobby Nash

 

Eddie: I dunno what your method is but I'm gonna say no.

 


 

[Private Messaging: Buck and Eddie]

Eddie: Hey babe?

 

Buck: don't babe me when i'm divorcing you 

 

Eddie: Buck

 

Buck: ok fine

yes, sweetheart?

apple of my eye?

my reason for living?

the air that i breathe?

my better half?

the reason why i have to do extra nasty shit for the next two weeks?

 

Eddie: Well okay then.

Anyway.

I was thinking...what exactly were the terms of the bet?

 

Buck: so basically i bet hen that i could find at least one other person who didn't fold their pizza when they eat it

bc like dude that's so unnecessary

if it's too floppy to eat with one hand you just cradle it with a second

give it a lil extra support

plus when it's folded all you get in your mouth is crust and that feels weird

…maybe chim was onto something with the whole eating-pizza-upside-down thing

then you just get a bunch of gooey cheese on your tongue 🤔

 

Eddie: First of all, don’t “dude” me I've been inside you.

 

Buck: 😏🫦

 

Eddie: 🙄

SECOND, I can't believe you couldn't find ONE person that doesn't fold their pizza?

Third, are we sure Chimney wasn't dropped on his head as a child?

 

Buck: unclear

and tbf the only people i asked were you and maddie

bc i couldn't think of anyone else to ask

and you both failed me

 

Eddie: Babe that's sad. 

 

Buck: hey??

 

Eddie: I'm sure you could've asked so many more people.

Luckily for you, I shared my pizza with someone who just so happens to eat it just like you.

 

Buck: carla? i can’t believe i didn’t even think to ask her!

 

Eddie: What? No, I’m home, Carla’s off today.

 

Buck: oh my god is meth lab jim back???

 

Eddie: Oh dear lord I’m in love with an idiot.

 

Buck: ouch??

 

Eddie: Buck, who is the one person you love more than me who also literally lives with us?

 

Buck: OMG CHRISTOPHER!!

MY SAVIOR!!

i knew he was my favorite diaz for a reason

 

Eddie: I would pretend to be offended if I didn’t already know.

 

Buck: i can’t wait to rub it in hen’s face

 

Eddie: It really is amazing how much he takes after you. Like he just picked up the piece, put the pointer finger of his other hand under the tip of the slice so it wouldn’t flop onto his wrist, and ate it.

Which is exactly how you eat your pizza.

 

Buck: 🥹🥹🥹

man i love that kid

please tell him that

 

Eddie: He rolled his eyes and said he loves you too.

So, about that wedding invite…

 

Buck: oh yeah i should probably tell the team the wedding’s off

and the divorce

 

Eddie: Yeah, definitely want to let them know that divorce ceremony is NOT happening, not on my watch.

That wedding invite though…

 

Buck: yeah, sorry, it was stupid and silly and i just threw it together on my phone on our way back from a call

i’ll make sure i delete it

 

Eddie: Well -

I don’t think you need to delete the whole thing.

I just think some changes need to be made.

 

Buck: what do you mean?

 

Eddie: Well we can’t exactly plan a proper wedding in a day, right? So we’ll need to figure out a different date. Honestly I also don’t think our house is the best place to hold a wedding. Wouldn’t Bobby and Athena’s new house be better? So we’ll need to change the address.

 

Buck: oh my god

eddie

are you seriously proposing to me over TEXT?!?!?!?

 

Eddie: Hey, you’re the one that said we should get married AND made a wedding invitation!

 

Buck: it was a JOKE!

 

Eddie: Yeah, okay, but what if it wasn’t?

 

Buck: oh my god

stop texting me, i’m on my way home

 

Eddie: I love you 💚

 

Buck: i said stop texting me!

I love you too 💙


 

[Group Chat: fam bam thank you ma'am]

Buck:     

for real this time

 

Chim: ahhhh congrats!! ok so, for real this time, can Jee be the flower girl?

 

Eddie: Of course.

 

Karen: Congratulations! 🎉

 

Maddie: I'm so good at keeping secrets 👼 congrats you two!

 

Buck: i literally told you five minutes ago

 

Maddie: Well -

 

Hen: Congrats, I’m real happy for you both, but I'm gonna need this gc name changed immediately

 

Buck: no

 

Karen: Buck -

 

Bobby: Unfortunately this is a thing he does. We're working on it. - Bobby Nash

 

Athena: Oh I'm so happy for you two! And also confused. Why does the location say TBD?

 

Buck: welllll we were kinda hoping to have it at your place?

 

Eddie: Only if that's okay!

 

Athena: Of course you can have it here, our backyard would be perfect!

 

Buck: thanks athena 😊

 

Eddie: Thank you!

 

Ravi: i'm so confused

are you still getting divorced

so that you can then get married again???

 

Chim: oh ravi…

 

Ravi:   

literally what's the point…

 

Hen: I'll explain it all to you later

 

Bobby: In all sincerity, congratulations Buck and Eddie, I'm so proud of both of you. ❤️ - Bobby Nash

Notes:

you're welcome or i'm sorry

come yap with me on twitter @beat_the_bees!

p.s. it is indeed canon that chimney han eats his pizza upside down chimney wtf

Series this work belongs to: