Work Text:
By the time the world narrowed down to just four players, Scar’s hands wouldn’t stop shaking. Not from fear, not exactly, but from the sheer effort of restraint.
Thirty hearts. That was what they all started with, every time. It was a full bar at the beginning of each life, generous on paper and merciless in practice. Thirty hearts that looked like safety, until you learned how quickly they could be chipped away. Damage in Secret Life wasn’t cinematic. It didn’t come with swelling music or heroic last stands, it was cumulative in a quieter way—a missed jump here, a careless sprint there, a moment of distraction that cost you far more than it ever should have.
Scar learnt that lesson early.
Now he stood with two and a half rows of hearts, his health bar grotesque and stitched together from completed red life tasks and kills and escapes that should’ve failed. It was obscene, really—a buffer so thick it felt unreal, like the world itself was daring him to squander it.
His body, however, didn’t feel invincible. It felt tired, heavy, and every muscle ached with the weight of weeks spent never quite relaxing or letting his guard down.
The terrain around him bore the scars of the season. Grass trampled into mud, stone broken and rebuilt and broken again, the remnants of traps long since sprung with TNT holes to prove it. The sun hung high, and the air was too still.
Even the mobs seemed to know better than to intrude.
Gem stood a short distance away, sword lowered but not sheathed, shoulders tight with coiled tension. She was breathing too fast, chest rising and falling in shallow bursts, and Scar could see the way she favoured one leg. Her hearts were low. Dangerously so.
Pearl lingered closer to Scar, light on her feet despite the exhaustion that had to be burning through her. Her eyes flicked constantly to Gem, Scar, cliffs—cataloguing angles and exits, measuring distances like this was just another puzzle to solve.
And Scott—
Scott was smiling.
It was the smile Scar hated most. It was soft, resigned, and the smile of someone who had already decided how this would end and wasn’t planning to argue with it.
“No,” Scar said immediately, before Scott could open his mouth. “Nope. Absolutely not, don’t even start.”
Scott tilted his head, his familiar calm settling over Scar like frost. “Scar. Listen.”
Gem’s eyes flicked between them, brow furrowing. “What’s going on?”
“I’m just saying,” Scott continued, voice gentle and infuriatingly reasonable, “Gem’s low. She’s played well, and she’s my ally. If anyone deserves—”
Scar barked out a laugh before he could even finish. “Oh come on. Is this where we start getting very serious and meaningful? Because I didn’t dress for a tragedy.”
Gem continued to look between them in confusion as her grip tightened on her sword. “Scott,” she said carefully, “what are you planning?”
Scott ignored Gem and met Scar’s gaze. “It’s the smartest move.”
Scar tilted his head, studying him like a puzzle he didn’t particularly care to solve. “Smart,” he echoed. “Sure. Boring, though.”
Behind him, Pearl snorted softly.
Scar paced in a slow circle, boots crunching against stone. “You know, if you’re determined to go, you could at least make it interesting, like going out in a fight. Give us something to clap for.”
Scott didn’t rise to the bait. “This isn’t about you.”
“That’s a shame,” Scar replied lightly. “I’m very compelling.”
Gem went very still as she realised. “Scott. You’re not serious.”
Scott turned to her, voice gentle. “You can win this.”
Scar stopped pacing. For a moment, his smile faltered. Then he exhaled and shrugged, the villain slipping back into place like a well-worn coat. “Alright,” he said. “If you’re determined to be generous, I won't stop you.” He leaned closer, lowering his voice. “But don't pretend it's noble. You're just playing the numbers. “
Scott smiled faintly. “Aren't we all?”
Scar looked away first. “Quick then. I’ve got places to be.”
He focused on the horizon, on the jagged lines of stone and sky, on anything that wasn’t the sound behind him. He told himself it would be loud, and that there would be shouting or hesitation or something he could latch onto.
The sound was worse than he expected, not because it was violent, but because it ended too fast. One strike was all it took for Scott to go.
When Scar finally forced himself to turn around, Scott’s body was already gone. Gem stood frozen where he’d been, staring at her own hands as her health surged upward. Ten hearts flooded her system all at once, the unnatural rush making her stagger. She swayed, catching herself on instinct, and for a moment Scar thought she might throw up.
Pearl stood beside Scar, exhaling slowly through her nose, like she was holding herself together by sheer force of will. Her shoulders were tight, her jaw locked, but when she spoke her voice was even. “Okay. Now, it’s us.”
Gem swallowed. Her knuckles were white as her grip tightened around her sword again, and it looked like she was going to say something, but she paused, and all that came out was “I didn’t want it like that.”
Scar let out a laugh that scraped its way out of his chest, sharp and brittle, and dragged a hand through his hair. “Nobody ever does.”
They didn’t give Gem time to recover. It wasn’t cruelty. It was necessity.
Pearl moved first, darting in from the side, forcing Gem to retreat. Scar circled wide, bow already in hand, his movements careful despite the chaos roaring in his head.
Gem fought like hell.
Scar would remember that later—the way she adapted on instinct, the way she never begged or froze, the way exhaustion never once turned into hesitation. She landed a few hits on Scar, and a clean one on Pearl that made Scar hiss in sympathy, Pearl’s health dipping low before she rolled clear.
Then Gem turned on him. Her sword came too close, grazing his arm, pain flaring bright and sharp. Scar stumbled back, heart slamming against his ribs.
For one terrifying moment, he thought this could all go wrong.
Pearl distracted Gem just long enough, and Scar took out his bow.
The arrow stuck true. Gem fell without a sound, vanishing soon immediately, leaving behind scorched grass and silence. Ten hearts surged into Scar, stacking atop what he already had, and the rush nearly knocked him off balance.
Pearl turned to him. “You ready?”
Scar swallowed. This was it.
She grinned, feral and familiar. “Don’t hold back.”
“As if I ever do,” Scar said, forcing a smile.
Scar kept his distance where he could, bow singing in his hands as his arrows flew in careful arcs. Pearl darted and vanished into blind spots, reappearing where he least expected her.
She nearly got him twice. Once, she slammed into him from the side, sending them both skidding dangerously close to a drop. Scar windmilled, barely catching himself on a jut of stone, laughter bursting out of him wild and breathless.
“Careful!” he said. “I bruise easily!”
Pearl laughed back, sharp and delighted.
Then came the ravine. Scar remembered thinking that it smelled like autumn. Rot and dry leaves and something ending.
Pearl’s voice cut through the noise, sharp with sudden urgency. “Scar, behind you—!”
Scar didn’t turn. He laughed instead, breathless and bright, already moving and lining his next shot as he pressed the advantage. “Oh, come on, Pearl,” he called back, voice light and teasing. “Now is not the time for fake-outs.”
He surged forward, boots skidding on loose stone, the ravine yawning wide at their sides. Pearl twisted away from him, eyes flicking past his shoulder again—not calculating this time, or playful. Just desperate.
“Scar—!”
He fired. The arrow flew clean and true, muscle memory guiding the shot without conscious thought. It struck Pearl squarely, the impact knocking the breath from her chest and stealing the ground from beneath her feet in the same instant.
She stumbled. It wasn’t dramatic. No flailing, no scream—just a single misstep, balance slipping where she expected solid ground. Her fingers scraped uselessly against stone as gravity claimed her.
The ravine swallowed her whole, sound and motion vanishing into depth and shadow.
Scar froze, bow still raised, lungs burning as he dragged in sharp, uneven breaths. He stared down into the dark, heart hammering, waiting for the inevitable—a shout, a laugh, or even a furious insult hurled back up at him from some narrow ledge.
He shifted his weight, peering closer, heart beginning to thud just a little harder against his ribs. The ravine remained stubbornly empty, offering no movement, no sound — just stone and shadow and the slow drip of water somewhere far below.
“Pearl?” he called, voice echoing thinly against the stone. “Pearlie?”
Nothing answered.
A slow prickle crept up his spine.
Reluctantly, Scar turned. The zombie lurched from the shadows behind him, leather cap pulled low, arms outstretched as it groaned softly and shambled forward. Scar stared at it for a long second. Then he barked out a laugh, brittle at the edges. “Oh. That’s what you were yelling about.” He glanced back toward the ravine again. “Pearl! You good? Tell me you didn’t just take fall damage for that.”
The zombie drew closer, uncaring.
Still no response.
Scar shifted his weight, unease settling in his chest like a stone. “Pearl?” he called again, louder this time. “Hey. You still with me?”
The silence stretched.
Then the whisper slipped into place, intimate and undeniable. She’s dead. You’ve won. The words didn’t sound like Pearl. Or Gem. Or anyone he could picture.
Scar flinched, breath catching sharply in his throat. “No,” he said, a little too fast. “No, hang on. She had hearts left. She always does.”
The whispers didn’t argue. They didn’t need to.
You won.
The truth settled anyway.
Pearl wasn’t coming back.
Scar’s breath stuttered as the realisation finally sank in. The fight was over. The game was done.
He was alone.
He laughed until his chest hurt, the sound echoing uselessly against the stone.
He didn’t feel like a winner.
Scar stayed where he was long after Pearl fell.
The ravine stretched out beneath him, dark and quiet, its depths swallowing sound the way it swallowed everything else. There were no death particles blooming at the bottom. No furious reappearance scrambling up the stone. No voice—laughing, or swearing, or furious—came drifting back up to meet him.
Scar swallowed. “Well,” he said, forcing a laugh that rang hollow even to his own ears, “she’s survived worse.”
He straightened, rolling his shoulders like he could shake the moment off.
That was when something bumped into his side. Scar startled, jumping back as the zombie lurched against him, its groan low and confused. He shoved it away reflexively, irritation flaring hot and sudden.
“Oh—hey! Hey, personal space,” he snapped. “Didn’t you see? The dramatic part’s over.”
The zombie didn’t care. It never did. Scar cut it down with more force than necessary, blade crunching through rotted bone and leather.
Then his reward came. The familiar surge followed immediately—ten hearts flooding into him, hot and invasive, sealing over scrapes and bruises he hadn’t noticed collecting.
His health climbed higher.
And higher.
Scar stared at the bar, something sour twisting in his gut. “Okay,” he muttered. “Okay, that’s… that’s enough now.”
The world didn’t listen.
The air shifted. Not physically—the trees didn’t sway, the light didn’t change—but Scar felt it all the same, a pressure settling in behind his eyes. The whispers threaded through the clearing, soft and layered and wrong, like voices speaking through water.
She’s dead, Scar. You won.
Scar squeezed his eyes shut, pressing the heel of his hand into his forehead as if he could physically push the thought away. “I know,” he said weakly. “You don’t have to keep saying it.”
For a moment, he expected something to happen. Fireworks. Lightning. A blinding light tearing the sky open. That sickening, sideways pull he half-remembered from somewhere else—the moment the world stopped pretending you belonged in it. But none of it came.
The sun continued its slow, indifferent crawl across the sky. Birds chirped. Leaves rustled. Somewhere nearby, a sheep bleated.
The server carried on.
Scar let out a quiet, disbelieving laugh. “Oh,” he said. “Oh, you’ve got to be kidding me.”
He waited.
Nothing happened.
Eventually, with nowhere else to put the feeling crawling under his skin, Scar turned and started walking.
At first, it was aimless—pacing the edges of old battlegrounds, skirting craters and scorched stone where traps had gone off days ago. He stepped carefully, not because he feared falling, but because habit was a hard thing to kill. Even now, with more hearts than he knew what to do with, his body remembered how fragile it had once been.
Every block held a memory.
Here was where Pearl had laughed, fearless and feral and impossible to pin down.
Here was where Scott had stood, calm and maddening, already resigned to an ending Scar hadn’t been ready to accept.
Here was where Gem had hesitated—just for a fraction of a second—before dying.
Scar talked as he walked, because silence pressed too hard against his ears. “Well,” he said, hands waving animatedly as if the world might respond if he gestured correctly, “I suppose this is the part where everyone claps. Or boos. I’m flexible.”
The world did neither.
He built instead. Building had always helped. It gave his hands something to do, something repetitive and reassuring. He expanded the sunflower fields until they stretched wide and golden, petals turning obediently toward the sun. He laid paths and benches and little signs with neat, cheerful lettering that no one would ever read.
Sometimes he talked to the air as he worked. Sometimes the air talked back.
It began so quietly he almost missed it. A laugh, drifting just beyond the edge of hearing—light, breathless, and so familiar.
Scar froze, shovel half-buried in the dirt. “…Pearl?” he called, testing the name like it might sting.
Nothing answered.
He laughed it off, a little too loudly, and went back to work.
But the voice came again the next day. And the day after that. Always when he wasn’t looking directly at it. Always just out of reach.
He started seeing her soon after.
Not a body. Not a ghost in the dramatic sense. Just Pearl—standing at the edge of his vision, arms folded, head tilted, that sharp, knowing smile playing at her lips.
The first time Scar turned fully to face her, she was gone.
The second time, she wasn’t. She stood near the edge of the sunflower field, sunlight catching in her hair, looking infuriatingly solid.
“Well,” Scar said, heart hammering as he forced his voice to stay light, “you took your time.”
Pearl didn’t answer. She just watched him.
Scar swallowed. “You know, I did look behind me. Eventually.”
Her expression didn’t change.
He laughed again, brittle at the edges. “Okay. Tough crowd.”
He kept seeing others after that.
Scott, sitting on a bench Scar didn’t remember building, hands folded neatly in his lap.
Gem, lingering near the paths, eyes following Scar wherever he went.
Grian, once—grinning wide and sharp from behind a tree, and gone the moment Scar blinked.
Scar leaned into it with frightening ease.
“Well hello there!” he chirped one afternoon, waving cheerfully at an empty stretch of grass. “You’re late. Very rude. We had a meeting scheduled.”
Pearl sat at the table he’d built—the long one, with too many chairs—legs kicked up casually as if she’d always belonged there.
Scott stood behind her, calm and quiet as ever.
Gem hovered at the edge, arms crossed, gaze unreadable.
Scar smiled at them, wide and practised. “See? Told you this place needed better seating.”
None of them spoke. Scar talked anyway. He told them stories they already knew. About tasks gone wrong. About near-misses. About the way the game twisted people until they barely recognised themselves.
Sometimes he apologised.
Sometimes he justified it.
Sometimes he laughed and laughed and laughed until his chest hurt.
The Secret Keeper watched it all. Scar avoided it after that—until he couldn’t. Until exhaustion crept back in, until his body sagged and demanded rest it was no longer allowed to have. When he returned, he pressed the button with dull regularity, flinching every time the hearts surged through him like mockery.
“Win Secret Life,” he murmured, over and over. “Win Secret Life. Win Secret Life.”
Pearl watched from the edge of the clearing.
Scott looked away.
Gem’s grip on her sword tightened — then loosened—then tightened again.
Scar stopped laughing eventually.
One night—or day; it was hard to tell nowadays—he collapsed into his bed at Trader Scar’s, limbs heavy and aching in ways the hearts never quite fixed. He didn’t bother to undress. He stared at the ceiling, listening to the distant hum of mobs and the soft creak of wood settling.
“Hey,” he said quietly, to no one and everyone. “I did what you asked.”
The room stayed silent.
Scar closed his eyes.
He dreamt of sunflowers. Endless rows of them, stretching farther than his fields ever had. Their faces were all turned toward him instead of the sky, petals trembling as though caught in a wind he couldn’t feel. He walked between them, boots brushing stems, hands outstretched to trail across the leaves.
“Hey there,” he said softly. “You’re not supposed to do that.”
The flowers didn’t listen. They leaned closer. Their centers darkened, spiralling inward, becoming eyes—too many eyes—layered over one another, blinking out of sync.
Scar stopped walking. “Oh,” he said faintly. “That’s… new.”
The ground tilted. The sun went out like a snuffed candle, and Scar fell.
The world peeled back in layers: sky, dirt, stone, memory. Scar tumbled through it all, weightless and wrong, laughter clawing its way out of his throat before dissolving into a breathless gasp.
He tried to scream. No sound came.
The void caught him gently.
That was the worst part.
He floated, curled slightly inward, limbs heavy and distant, like they belonged to someone else. The darkness wasn’t empty—it pressed in on him, humming softly, alive in a way stone and dirt had never been.
Shapes moved at the edges of his vision, tall and watching.
“Oh,” Scar whispered, or thought he did. “Oh, so this is where you’ve been hiding.”
The voices came next. Layered, rhythmic, and not quite in unison.
Winner crowned, game complete,
little king where sunflowers meet.
Scar squinted, trying to focus, but his eyes wouldn’t cooperate. Everything flickered, his consciousness stuttering like a skipped record. “Hey,” he said weakly. “I did what you asked. I won. You can—you can stop now.”
A pause. Then, softer:
You endured, you amused,
Golden soul, worn and bruised.
Something cold brushed against his ribs, not touching skin so much as passing through, riffling through his thoughts with invasive familiarity. Scar shuddered, curling tighter. “I didn’t mean to,” he murmured. “I didn’t mean for it to be like that.”
Images flooded him—sunflower fields stretching empty, the Secret Keeper’s button beneath his palm, the endless loop of the same crimson words. Win Secret Life.
And yet you pressed.
Again and again.
Scar laughed weakly. “Well, you didn’t really give me a choice.”
The darkness rippled.
Choice is an illusion,
but persistence…
The pressure intensified, squeezing, weighing, dragging him under. Scar’s thoughts scattered, slipping through his fingers like sand.
“I want to go home,” he said, the words barely holding together. “Please.”
The Watchers—for he knew now that that was what they were—leaned closer. Their presence filled everything, overwhelming and vast.
Home, they echoed, almost fond.
Scar’s vision went white.
Scar woke to birdsong. That, in itself, should have been comforting. Instead, it set his nerves on edge.
The sound drifted through open air—not stone corridors or echoing caverns, not the hollow quiet that had followed him for… however long it had been. Scar lay still with his eyes closed, cataloguing sensations the way one might catalogue injuries.
Soft mattress beneath him. Clean linen against his arms. Sunlight pressing warm and gentle through his eyelids.
Not the harsh, judgemental glare of a statue. Not the sickly half-light of a world that refused to let him die.
His chest rose and fell.
He could breathe.
The realisation hit him like ice water. Scar’s eyes flew open.
He was in his bed. His bed.
Scarland surrounded him in warm sandstone and familiar chaos—banners hung just slightly crooked, redstone contraptions paused mid-progress, whimsy embedded in every corner like muscle memory. His boots sat by the door, neatly abandoned. A map hung askew on the wall, scrawled with notes he didn’t remember writing but knew, instinctively, were his.
Scar jolted upright, heart hammering so hard it hurt.
“No,” he breathed. “No, no, no—”
He stared down at his hands. There was no blood under his nails. No phantom ache where wounds should have been screaming. His hearts felt normal and finite. Fragile in the way that meant something could actually end.
That scared him more than anything else.
He swung his legs over the side of the bed and stood, half-expecting the room to ripple or peel away. It didn’t. The floor stayed solid beneath his feet. Outside the window, Scarland basked in the morning sun, sunflowers already turning their faces toward the light.
Sunflowers.
His stomach twisted.
“This isn’t real,” Scar said aloud, voice rough. Saying it felt safer than believing otherwise. “Okay. Alright. New hallucination. Very vivid. Points for effort.”
He took a step forward.
Then another.
Each movement felt like tempting fate.
The front door opened without resistance and Scar stepped outside.
Scarland stretched before him—intact, alive, and unapologetically mundane. Rails gleamed. Little builds waited patiently, untouched by blood or fire. No bodies. No ruins. No towering stone face demanding victory again and again.
Scar laughed, the sound sharp and brittle. “Wow,” he said to the empty street. “You really went all out this time, brain.”
A shadow passed over the ground.
Scar froze, and something hit him with enough force to knock the breath from his lungs.
“SCAR!” Arms wrapped around him—tight and warm—nearly lifting him off his feet. Wings brushed his sides, feathers rustling against his arms. Scar staggered, grabbing instinctively at fabric so he wouldn’t fall.
His heart skipped.
“Oh,” he said faintly. “Oh, that’s… new.”
Grian was holding him. Not standing at a distance. Not staring blankly. Not silent. Grian was here—laughing breathlessly, grip firm like he was afraid Scar might disappear if he let go.
“I knew it!” Grian said, voice bright and cracked all at once. “I knew you’d spawn here—Scar, you scared me half to death!”
Scar stared at him. Really stared.
Grian shifted when Scar shifted. He adjusted his hold, and his wings twitched when Scar’s fingers tightened in his jumper, feathers warm and undeniably real beneath his hands.
Scar’s brain made an awful, screeching sound as it tried to catch up. “Uh,” he said intelligently. “Okay. So. Either I’m still asleep… or I’ve unlocked interactive hallucinations.”
Grian blinked. “What?”
Scar swallowed hard. “You’re… touching me.”
“Yes?” Grian said slowly. “Scar, that’s usually how hugs work.”
Scar let out a shaky laugh. “That’s exactly what you would say.”
Grian pulled back just enough to look at him properly, concern flooding his face. “Scar?”
Scar didn’t let go. His grip tightened instead. His hands shook. “You’re not real,” he said, the words tumbling out too fast. “You can’t be. I saw you. You didn’t move. You didn’t talk. You just—you were just… there.”
His throat closed.
Grian’s expression softened, guilt and grief flickering across it. “Pearl died, Scar. You won.”
Scar went rigid. The world tilted violently, snapping him back to the ravine—crunching leaves, yawning dark, whispers threading through the air like smoke. His vision swam. “Don’t,” he whispered. “Don’t say that.”
Grian flinched. “Scar—I’m sorry, I didn’t—”
Scar tore himself free, stumbling back, hands raised like he was warding off a blow. “You don’t get to say that,” he said, breath hitching. “That’s how it starts. That’s how I knew.”
Silence stretched between them, filled only by distant redstone clicks and the soft rustle of sunflowers.
Grian spoke again carefully, grounding every word. “Scar. You’re home in Hermitcraft. You won Secret Life… and then you didn’t come back right away.”
Scar laughed weakly. “I noticed.”
“You already know about the games,” Grian continued. “About how it works.”
Scar nodded slowly. “Yeah. I remember when you and Pearl told us. Sat us all down and tried to explain it like it was just another weird Hermitcraft horror story.”
Grian nodded. “We hoped it would stick.”
“I know,” Scar said hoarsely. “That’s the worst part.”
A soft landing sounded behind them. Pearl stepped closer, eyes immediately softening as she took in Scar’s shaking hands.
“You weren’t ignorant,” she said gently. “You were just unlucky.”
Scar swallowed. “I knew you’d both won,” he admitted. “Knew you remembered. I just didn’t think I’d be the one who didn’t come back.”
“You weren’t supposed to be,” Grian said quietly.
Something finally gave. Scar folded in on himself, a sob tearing free before he could stop it. Grian caught him instantly, arms firm and sure, holding him as everything he’d been bracing against collapsed.
“I couldn’t die,” Scar choked. “I tried. I tried so many times and it wouldn’t let me. Every time I thought it was over, it just—reset me.”
“I know,” Grian murmured, rubbing slow circles into his back.
“I kept seeing you,” Scar said, words spilling out. “Talking to you. I didn’t know what was real anymore.”
“I’m here,” Grian said firmly. “I’m real.”
Pearl stepped in closer, shoulder brushing Scar’s. “Me too.”
Scar looked at her, really looked. “You won too,” he said quietly.
Pearl nodded. “Yeah.”
“And you remember.”
Her jaw tightened. “Everything.”
Scar sagged between them, exhaustion finally catching up now that the ground beneath him felt solid. “Okay,” he murmured. “Okay. That makes sense. Winners remember,” he added faintly. “You told us. We listened, then forgot.”
Pearl exhaled. “We hoped knowing would help.”
Scar stared out at Scarland—at the sunflowers rolling gently in the breeze, gold and endless and alive. For the first time since waking, the world didn’t feel like it was about to peel away.
“I didn’t think knowing would make it hurt less,” he admitted.
“It doesn’t,” Grian said. “But it makes it survivable.”
Scar let out a shaky breath. “Guess I finally won,” he said, trying—and failing—to joke.
Grian smiled, sad and proud all at once. “Yeah. You did.”
This time, when Scar looked at them, they stayed.