Adult Content Warning

This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.

• Yes, Continue
• No, Go Back

If you accept cookies from our site and you choose "Yes, Continue", you will not be asked again during this session (that is, until you close your browser). If you log in you can store your preference and never be asked again.

1. Witches, Give me a Sign by Anonymous

   Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

   • Mature
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • M/M
   • Complete Work

   20 Aug 2026

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
   • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
   • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
   • Alternate Universe - Modern: No Powers
   • Shadow Milk is a serial killer
   • Pure Vanilla is just a guy
   • he doesn’t know that Shadow Milk is a serial killer
   • Thoughts of Violence
   • Intrusive Thoughts
   • Possessive Behavior
   • Shadow Milk Cookie is Bad at Feelings (Cookie Run)
   • Implied religious trauma
   • Shadow Milk hates the witches
   • but also wants their attention
   • Shadow Milk is kind of creepy
   • nothing bad happens
   • We’re in Shadow Milks point of view so things are a little complicated
   • Pure Vanilla Cookie Has a Savior Complex (Cookie Run)
   • Mentioned White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
   • She’s technically Veil of Mourning in this
   • Alternate Universe - Flower Shop
   • Cookie Run Characters Are Ambiguously Cookies or Human
   • Pure Vanilla Cookie is Bad at Feelings (Cookie Run)
   • Implied/Referenced Suicide
   • Just the topic of suicide
   • Misunderstandings
   • Shadow Milk internally refers to Pure Vanilla as ‘His Angel’ for a lot of this
   • Implied Murder
   • Falling In Love
   • but they’re both bad at it
   • Awkward Flirting
   • They’re into each other but they don’t know it yet
   • Somehow inspired by that one image of the guy going ‘Nooo don’t kill yourself your so sexy aha’
   • Shadow Milk is scared of feeling things

   Summary

   Still. Shadow Milk gives Them a chance. Yes, if the Witches are truly the kind creators that he and his peers were taught to worship, then They will send Shadow Milk a sign. If Shadow Milk is meant to stop killing, then the Witches will surely, surely send a sign. If They don’t, Shadow Milk can always kill again, and again, and again until he proves They don’t exist or proves They do.

   There’s a short ruckus that comes from the back of the shop, and a moment later— “I’m so very sorry, you caught me with my hands full. I’m Pure Vanilla, how can I help you, sir?” An angel. The Witches sent him an angel.

   Or: Shadow Milk is a serial killer who likes to use poisonous plants for his kills. Pure Vanilla is very reluctant to sell any poisonous plant to Shadow Milk, because he assumes Shadow Milk is trying to poison himself.

   Series

   • Part 4 of ClownDownTown’s CRK Fics

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   7,473

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Collections:

   1

   Comments:

   37

   Kudos:

   162

   Bookmarks:

   17

   Hits:

   1,149