Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 6 of Tell Me You Met Me In Past Lives (S&B AUs), Part 1 of Monster AU
Stats:
Published:
2026-08-25
Updated:
2026-10-05
Words:
34,351
Chapters:
5/?
Comments:
1
Kudos:
8
Hits:
326

Some Don't Know Why They're Wolves (They Just Howl For The Sound Of It, I Howl For You)

Summary:

Just a fun AU my brain came up with at 3:00AM, as one does

S&B Monster AU

Chapter 1: Our Hometown's In The Dark

Chapter Text

The bell over the shop door hadn’t finished ringing before Judah started talking. 

He’d crossed half the shop floor already, quick in a way that didn’t quite match the easy sprawl of his voice—the kind of speed a body only kept if it had long since stopped needing to pace itself for anyone else’s comfort.

“You’re going to want to see this,” he said, reaching the counter before Michelle had gotten two steps past the threshold. “Absolutely you are. Michelle. You are going to want to see this.” 

“I am extremely capable of continuing not to see it.” She hadn’t moved from just inside the doorway, well back from the strip of window-light spilling gold across the floorboards—not urgent about it, just habitual, the kind of small calculation she made without thinking anymore, the way another woman might avoid standing in a draft. She pulled her gloves off finger by finger, unhurried. “Whatever it is.” 

“It’s fabric.” 

“Riveting.” 

“It’s fabric,” he said again, holding up a bolt of deep green silk like it had personally wronged her by existing, “that would look extraordinary on you, and I refuse to let you walk past this shop for the third week running pretending you haven’t noticed it in the window.” 

“I hadn’t noticed it in the window.” 

“Lies. You slowed down. I felt you slow down.” 

“You felt nothing. You were three steps ahead of me, talking.” 

“I am always three steps ahead of you, that’s not new information.” He draped the silk over his arm, turning it toward the light, and Madame Verrick—who had weathered enough of Judah Nelson’s opinions on fabric to have long since stopped looking up from her ledger for them—made a small sound of agreement from behind the counter without being asked. 

“He’s not wrong about the color, dear.” 

“I did not ask for a second opinion.” 

“You never do,” Judah said, “and I give you one anyway, that’s the whole arrangement.” He set the bolt down with more care than his tone suggested, smoothing a hand over it once. “It’s for the Ravensmoor dinner. You need something that isn’t the grey one.” 

“There’s nothing wrong with the grey one.” 

“There’s nothing wrong with the grey one the way there’s nothing wrong with a serviceable umbrella. It does the job. It isn’t the point.” Something in his face eased, just slightly, out of performance, and  he continued in a lower register, just for her, “You’re going to be in a room with the whole Guild council. Half of them still whisper about how you were turned, and the other half whisper about who your family used to be before you were, and none of them have the nerve to say either to your face. Let them look at you and see someone who decided to be looked at, for once, instead of someone just enduring it.” 

She didn’t answer right away. It wasn’t the fabric that had gone quiet in her—it was the rest of it, the part he hadn’t meant as an accusation and she hadn’t quite braced for hearing said plainly.

The whispering had never stopped, not really, not since the year she’d been turned in circumstances the Guild still discussed in careful half-sentences whenever they thought she wasn’t in the room. She’d learned to walk through it the way you learned to walk through weather—chin level, expression unreadable, giving them nothing new to repeat. 

She reached out and touched the edge of the silk herself, thumb dragging once over the weave. Her hand, brushing his sleeve as she did, was cool enough that he didn’t so much as flinch—long past noticing it, the way you stopped noticing the temperature of your own skin. 

“I’ll think about it,” she said. 

“You’ll take it,” Judah said, already turning back to Verrick before she could argue, “and you’ll wear it, and you’ll let one room in this city see you the way the rest of us already do.” 

She didn’t answer that either. But she didn’t tell him to put it back. 

He walked her the two streets home himself, the silk wrapped and tucked under his arm, and by the time they reached the Agency gate, Patience was already visible through the workroom window, sleeves rolled, some tangle of dried herbs spread across the table in front of her.

Judah’s whole posture changed before he’d even reached the door—not less of himself, exactly, just less performed, the volume he kept turned up for guild shops and council rooms dialing down to something that didn’t need an audience anymore. 

“You’ve been gone three hours,” Patience said, without looking up from the herbs, “and you’ve come back smug. I can feel it from here.” 

“I have come back triumphant. There’s a difference.” He set the parcel down and dropped a kiss against her temple on his way past, unhurried, the kind of gesture that had long since stopped needing to be commented on by either of them. “Michelle’s wearing green to the Ravensmoor dinner.” 

“You didn’t.” 

“I absolutely did.” 

“She let you?” 

“She didn’t tell me no fast enough, which in Michelle is practically a proposal.” He dropped into the chair across from her, watching her hands move through the herbs with the same unhurried certainty she brought to most things—nothing wasted, nothing rushed, the quiet competence that had never once needed to raise its voice to be noticed. “You smell like the Circle’s back garden.” 

“I was in the Circle’s back garden.” 

“I like it.” He said it plainly, without any of the performance he’d spent the last hour wearing for Verrick’s benefit, and Patience glanced up at that—just briefly, just long enough to catch whatever was under it—before going back to her work, satisfied enough with what she’d found there not to need him to say anything more. 

 


 

The Agency’s kitchen smelled like burnt toast, which meant Phineas had gotten to the stove before he’d fully woken. 

“It’s fine,” he said before Shiloh could say anything about it. He scraped the worst of it into the bin, unbothered, sleeves pushed up past his elbows. “Second one’s better. Give it a minute.” 

“I didn’t say anything.” 

“You were going to.” 

“I was going to say it smells like the roof is on fire, which is different from criticism.” She said it from the doorway, arms loosely crossed, not quite awake herself—the house still held that particular hush it kept before the rest of the household surfaced, the fire in the front room not yet built back to a proper blaze.

She watched him work. The deliberate, unhurried way he moved around a kitchen that hadn’t been his to begin with, like he’d long since decided which cupboard held what and simply never doubted himself on it again. It was, she’d come to think, close to the whole shape of how he loved anyone—quietly, functionally, by making sure the ground underneath them didn’t shift without warning. 

“There’s a shipment coming in this afternoon,” he said, setting the pan back over the flame. “Verdine’s supplier. The one who’s always three days later than he promises. I want to be at the yard before he has the chance to blame the roads again.” 

“You could send someone.” 

“I could.” He didn’t look up. “I like going myself.” 

She knew that already. It wasn’t really a question, not from him—he liked knowing exactly where things stood, liked being the one who made sure they landed where they were meant to rather than trusting the shape of a plan to hold on its own without him checking the seams.

She came further into the kitchen and reached past him for the kettle, and for a moment their hands crossed without either of them stepping back to make room for the other. He didn’t comment on it. Neither did she. It had stopped being the kind of thing either of them needed to remark on months ago. 

Something caught at the edge of her, faint and formless, gone again before she could turn her attention toward it properly—a thread of wrongness, the kind she’d learned to recognize the way you recognized a draft under a door before you found the gap.

She let it pass. Chasing every flicker before breakfast was a good way to spend the whole day paying for a headache that hadn’t earned itself yet, and there would be time enough later, if it mattered, to go looking. 

“You slept,” Phineas said. Not quite a question either. 

“Some.” 

“Some’s not nothing.” He glanced over, just briefly, taking her in the way he did most mornings—not searching for anything alarming, just checking, the way you’d check a door was properly latched before you stopped thinking about it. Whatever he found seemed to satisfy him well enough. He didn’t ask what had crossed her face a moment ago. He rarely did, not straightaway—he’d learned, same as she had, that some things settled better if you let her come to them in her own time rather than naming them for her. “Toast’s good this time. I promise.” 

It wasn’t, particularly. She ate it anyway and let the quiet of the kitchen do the rest of what neither of them needed to say out loud. 

 


 

The notice was new. Micah was fairly sure of that—he’d walked this same stretch of the Marches two days ago and hadn’t seen it, and it wasn’t the kind of thing a person missed twice. 

BY ORDER OF LOCAL WATCH — UNGUILDED PERSONS OF LYCANTHROPIC STANDING SUBJECT TO CURFEW FROM DUSK THREE NIGHTS PRECEDING THE FULL MOON THROUGH ONE NIGHT FOLLOWING. VIOLATIONS SUBJECT TO DETENTION AND FINE. 

Someone had scrawled something underneath it in charcoal, half-rubbed away by rain or by a passing sleeve. He didn’t bother trying to read what was left of it. He’d read enough versions of that particular sentiment over the years to fill in whatever was missing himself, and none of the versions had ever surprised him. 

He stood in front of it a beat longer than he needed to, long enough to feel the particular tightness settle into his shoulders that always came with these—not quite anger, not quite anything he let himself name outright, just a kind of bracing, the same motion his whole body made whenever the world put its assessment of him up in ink where he could read it plainly. Then he kept walking, because standing there wasn’t going to change the wording, and there was work waiting that didn’t care what mood he arrived in. 

“You planning on standing there all day, or you actually here for the delivery?” 

Halloway was already hauling a crate toward the door by the time Micah reached the shop—the only supplier in three streets who dealt with the Agency without tacking on a surcharge for the trouble of it. Micah took the other end without being asked. 

“Here for the delivery,” he said. 

“Good. Didn’t figure you for a man who reads notices for fun.” 

“Wouldn’t call it fun.” 

“No,” Halloway agreed, settling his end of the crate against the cart with a grunt. “Wouldn’t figure that either.” 

They worked in a companionable sort of quiet after that, crate after crate, the kind of quiet Micah generally preferred to conversation—nothing that needed managing, nothing that needed to be read twice for what wasn’t being said outright.

He caught the rain before either of them mentioned it, that faint mineral sharpness in the air an hour or better ahead of the clouds actually deciding to open, and adjusted the order of the crates without thinking much about how he’d known—the kind of thing that had stopped being remarkable to him a long time ago, and that he’d learned not to explain unless someone asked. 

Out here, nobody asked. That was most of what he liked about the Marches, if he was honest with himself, which he tried not to be too often before noon.

There was no guild standing to fall short of out here, no polished council room to feel too large or too careful inside of. Just work, and hands, and a crate that needed carrying, and a notice on a wall that would be there tomorrow whether he looked at it again or not. 

He thought, unbidden, of the way Michelle had looked at him across a guild function last month—not unkind, never unkind, but careful in a way that had nothing to do with fear and everything to do with the fact that she understood exactly what a room like that cost him, better than most people who’d never been on the wrong side of one of these notices themselves.

He hadn’t needed to say anything to her about it afterward. She’d simply steered them both toward the door twenty minutes earlier than the evening called for, hand light at his elbow, then cool fingers slipping down to link properly through his the moment they were past the guild’s front steps and back on a street that didn’t belong to anyone’s council. 

Neither of them had needed to name what she was doing for either of them to understand it. That was mostly how it went, still, even now—she said the true things with her hands more often than her mouth, and he’d learned to listen for them there instead of waiting on words that didn’t come as easily to her. 

“Tell your sister the roads out past the mill are worse than they were,” Halloway said once the cart was loaded. “Axle-breakers, some of them. She’ll want to route around if she’s sending anyone through this week.” 

“I’ll tell her.” 

“Good lad.” Halloway clapped him once on the shoulder, easy, unthinking, the kind of contact that would have read as an accusation from half of Rothgard and read as nothing at all from him. “Get on, then. Don’t want you caught out past dark on my account.” 

Micah didn’t point out that dark was still hours off. He just nodded, took up the cart handle, and started back, the notice already fading behind him into the shape of every other notice he’d learned to walk past without letting it slow his feet. 

 


 

Elijah had been wearing his own face for exactly as long as it took Lila to get bored of the ledger he was pretending to read, which by his count was somewhere under ten minutes.

He’d spent the better part of the afternoon in someone else’s—a courier’s, borrowed for an hour to move through a part of the Marches that wouldn’t have spoken freely to a Nelson—and the business of settling back into his own bones afterward always left him quieter than usual, like a coat that needed time to remember the shape of the person wearing it. 

“You’re not actually reading that,” she said. 

“I am.” 

“You’ve been on the same page since I sat down.” She was curled into the window seat with her knees drawn up, entirely unbothered by the cold coming off the glass at her back—she never seemed to feel weather the way he did, or feel it at all, really, the way a person might not feel water while standing in a river they’d simply always lived in. “You’ve got that look. The one where you’re deciding whether something’s worth saying.” 

He didn’t answer that right away, which was its own kind of answer, and she knew him well enough by now not to push past it. 

“You could just ask me,” he said eventually. “Instead of watching.” 

“I did ask. You said you were reading.” She tipped her head, and something in her stilled in a way that had nothing to do with boredom—an old, unhurried quiet that didn’t belong to anyone raised on solid ground, patient in the particular way of something that had never once needed to worry about running out of time. “You’re allowed to just say the thing, you know. I won’t repeat it wrong. I can’t, actually. Not on purpose.” 

“I know.” That much he trusted absolutely—whatever else was strange about loving something that wasn’t quite bound by the same rules he was, her word was never in question.

She couldn’t lie to him outright even if she’d wanted to; the words simply wouldn’t come out shaped that way. It was the rest of her that stayed unreadable—the things she left unsaid, the truths she folded into riddles instead of handing over plainly, because that was closer to how her kind spoke when they meant to be careful with something. 

“Then say it,” she said, “or don’t, and I’ll sit here being patient at you until you do. I’ve got time.” 

That, at least, made something in his face loosen, just slightly—not quite a smile, but close enough to one that she noticed and didn’t say anything about noticing, which was its own kind of gift from someone who noticed everything. 

“Later,” he said. 

“I’ll hold you to it.” She said it lightly, but there was no glamour in it, no trick—with Lila, a promise held whether she wanted it to or not, the words themselves binding in a way his own never quite managed to. She unfolded from the window seat and crossed to him instead, settling against his side without asking, the way she did most things, patient and unbothered and entirely certain of her welcome. 

He let her stay there. He didn’t say anything about that either. 

 


 

By the time Michelle let herself in, the house had already settled into itself for the evening, and she stood in the doorway a moment longer than she needed to, letting her eyes adjust—not to the dark, which had never troubled her, but to the particular brightness of a room lit for people who needed the extra help of it. 

The fire had been built up properly, closer to a blaze than the modest thing Phineas usually allowed it to be, and she kept to the far side of the room out of old habit, near enough to feel the warmth reach her without sitting close enough to have it settle into her skin the way it clearly had for everyone else.

Judah had claimed the chair nearest it, predictably, Patience tucked against his side with her feet drawn up and a cup of something herbal steaming between her hands—the whole room faintly threaded through with the green, bitter smell of whatever the Circle had sent her home with, the kind of scent that clung to Patience the way woodsmoke clung to anyone who spent enough time near a hearth. 

Across from them, Josiah was still turning some small mechanism over in his hands, more out of habit than purpose at this hour, ink and machine oil worked so deep into the creases of his knuckles by now that Michelle doubted a proper scrubbing would ever fully lift it.

Gala sat close beside him, posture too straight for the room even now, years of a different upbringing not quite worn off her no matter how many evenings she spent with her sleeves rolled up in this house instead of the ones her mother would have chosen for her. She was laughing at something Josiah had said, low and unguarded, in a way Michelle suspected her mother had never once heard. 

Elijah sat nearest the window, still and watchful in the particular way that made most people forget he was in the room at all until he chose to remind them—Lila draped half against him, her presence a faint hum at the edge of Michelle’s senses, something that never quite settled into an ordinary heartbeat no matter how long Michelle had known her.

It was one of the few things about this house that still, after all this time, made the old instinct in her rise briefly to attention. Something in the room that didn’t read the way everything else did, old and unplaceable, gone again the moment Lila laughed at whatever Elijah had murmured too low for anyone else to catch. 

Shiloh and Phineas had taken the settee nearest the center of the room, Phineas’s arm along the back of it, not quite around her, close enough that it hardly mattered. Michelle could hear Shiloh’s heartbeat from here, the way she could hear everyone’s if she let herself listen for it, and there was something faintly uneven about it tonight—not alarming, just present, the way it sometimes was when whatever Shiloh carried in her had stirred without quite surfacing.

Phineas didn’t seem to notice, or didn’t let on that he had, which came to the same thing most nights. Mary sat nearby with a book open and mostly unread in her lap, watching the room the way she watched most rooms—a healer’s habit, cataloguing without meaning to, the kind of attention that never fully switched off even at rest. 

Micah arrived not long after Michelle had settled, quieter than the rest of them, and didn’t so much announce himself as simply appear in the doorway and cross straight to her instead of the fire—dropping down beside her without asking, close enough that his shoulder settled against hers, the tension still sitting in him after a day she hadn’t yet heard about.

She didn’t ask him to explain it.

She reached over and found his hand instead, lacing her fingers loosely through his where it rested against his knee, and felt some of what he was carrying ease out of him by degrees, the way it usually did once he stopped having to hold himself upright for anyone else’s benefit. 

David and Britney came in last, still faintly cold from outside, the smell of the fence line and turned earth following them in through the door before Britney had even gotten it shut behind her—Patience glancing up at her arrival with the particular brightness of someone already planning tomorrow’s errand before tonight’s had properly ended. 

Nothing had happened today. Nothing that would make it into any record anyone kept. 

Michelle let her eyes move once more around the room—the warmth she couldn’t quite let herself sit inside of, the low steady hum of hearts beating at every register of tired and content, Judah’s laugh rising over someone’s half-finished sentence, Lila’s quiet not-quite-heartbeat threaded underneath all of it—and found, without much surprise, that she didn’t especially want to be anywhere else. 

The room settled the way it always did once the worst of the noise had burned itself out—not into silence, but into something quieter and more deliberate, everyone finding whatever version of rest actually suited them.

Judah had pulled his chair close enough to the hearth that the light caught gold in his eyes when he laughed, entirely unbothered by the heat that had Britney fanning herself two seats down; Michelle stayed well back from it instead, half in shadow by choice, the warmth of the fire a pleasant enough thing to look at and not a thing she had any use for herself.

Patience worked a fresh sprig of something green between her fingers without seeming to notice she was doing it, the smell of it settling the room in a way nobody could have named outright, the way the air always seemed to ease a little wherever she sat long enough. 

Micah had gone still in the particular way he did once a day’s tension finally let go of him, listening more than speaking, catching threads of conversation from clear across the room that nobody else in it could have followed at that distance—Mary beside him not needing to ask if he was all right, just watching, the same low attentiveness she brought to anyone in the house who’d had a harder day than they’d admit to.

Across from them, Elijah had gone quiet in a different way entirely, unreadable even now, even here, though Lila curled into his side seemed to need nothing more from him than his presence—patient in a way that had nothing to do with waiting, the particular ease of something that measured evenings like this one differently than the rest of them did, in years rather than hours. 

Josiah had his hands still moving even at rest, turning some small piece of scrap metal over between his fingers out of habit more than purpose, Gala watching him do it with open, unhidden fondness that would have scandalized a mother who’d wanted better for her than oil-stained hands and an unglamorous house.

David sat solid and unremarkable beside Britney in the best possible way, the two of them the plainest thing in a room full of old magic and older blood, and none the less loved for it.

And Shiloh, at the head of the table, let the last of the day’s faint wrongness she’d felt that morning settle somewhere she didn’t have to chase it—not gone, never quite gone, but small enough tonight to set down, with Phineas steady and warm and entirely unmagical beside her, the one thing in the room that asked nothing of her at all.