Ticcijeff Fics
Series Metadata
Listing Series
-
I Kissed A Boy Just To Try It. I Hope My Girlfriend Don't Mind It by luckytwink
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
27 Sep 2024
Tags
Summary
To help Toby stop moping over his girlfriend leaving him on read, Jeff drags him downstairs to watch his favorite movie. Usually Toby's fine being in such close proximity to his best friend, but this time feels... different? Had Jeff's lips always looked that soft?
or: Toby impulsively kissing Jeff because of a sexuality crisis he didn't even know he was having
Series
- Part 1 of Ticcijeff Bullshit
- Part 1 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
Tags
Summary
Toby’s head ticced to the side at his growing anxiety. He’d been hoping that if this conversation ever happened, Jeff would’ve been the one to initiate it. But Toby’s felt this way for awhile, and according to everyone else Jeff has too, so he was getting kind of tired of waiting.
“Do you,” Toby hesitated, swallowing down the lump of anxiety building up his throat, “like me?”
Jeff chuckled. “I mean, yeah of course I like-”
“No,” Toby cut him off, locking eyes with him, “I mean, do you like me? Like, romantically.”
Jeff hesitated, opening his mouth to say something but no words came out. He closed it, eyes darting to the side. Toby could tell he wanted to lie, but lying was never really Jeff’s thing.
“So you do?” he pushed.
“I mean,” Jeff chuckled softly, “I’m not exactly subtle.”Series
- Part 2 of Ticcijeff Bullshit
- Part 2 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
Tags
Summary
Slenderman sends Jeff and Toby on a mission together for the first time.
Series
- Part 3 of Ticcijeff Bullshit
- Part 3 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
Tags
Summary
When the self hatred starts to consume Jeff's thoughts, Toby decides to tell him how pretty he thinks he is in a language he'll understand
Series
- Part 4 of Ticcijeff Bullshit
- Part 4 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
So Come Inside And Be With Me, Alone With Me by luckytwink
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
15 Mar 2025
Tags
Summary
It's December 31st, 2022 and the Slenderman proxies are holding a New Year's Eve party at the mansion. Jeff learns the hard way that being in a secret relationship while your love language is physical touch is NOT a good pairing.
Series
- Part 5 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
If We're Talking Body, You Got A Perfect One So Put It On Me by luckytwink
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
13 Nov 2024
Tags
Summary
Toby toyed with a stray piece of fabric hanging off the blue towel Jeff had set on his bed, his heart going a million miles an hour. He was… anxious, to say the least. He’d never done this before, I mean he had, but before it’d been with a girl. Jeff was not a girl. Not that Jeff being a boy turned him off at all because it definitely didn’t. Toby was starting to think boys actually turned him on more than girls did. But despite all the research he’d done on gay sex to prepare for this, in reality he had no idea what he was doing. And Jeff had so much experience. He’d been having sex with other men on a regular basis for years. But… Toby really wanted this. So despite his anxiety screaming at him to run away and hide, he was going to do this.
Because the part of his brain that wasn’t overwhelmed with anxiety, was extremely horny just thinking about what they were about to do.or: Jeff and Toby fucking for the first time
Series
- Part 5 of Ticcijeff Bullshit
- Part 6 of Ticcijeff Fics
-
I Know This Can't Be Good For Me But God We're Fucking Poetry by luckytwink
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
13 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
What happens in Tim and Brian's car, stays in Tim and Brian's car.
Series
- Part 7 of Ticcijeff Fics